News
Hizbullah: Winograd report confirms IDF was defeated in Lebanon
AFP and Ynet
Published: 30.01.08, 22:12
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
41 Talkbacks for this article
31. 14 - you lost 1/3 of your fighters
mike ,   israel (formerly usa   (01.31.08)
the rest were your human shields (which helps explain why hizbullah is called a terrorist group).
32. Hizbollah is thier to stay.
George Saliba ,   Canada   (01.31.08)
Hizbollah become a part of geopolitical map of the Middle East .It is their to stay as long as the Israelo-Arab conflict exist . Hizbollah most likely get supplied with chemical long range rackets from Syria and Iran .They will not hesitate to use them if they feel their existence is in danger.Next war if it happen will be decisive and Hizbollah not allowed o loose it in all mean O Syria and Iran. So for all hot head war supporter Hizbollah will comes as usual with surprise for you guys ,cool down and step down from the tree.
33. Winograd calls for deterrent
Charles Oren ,   Givatayim, Israel   (01.31.08)
Winograd stated that Israel can survive only if our neighbors realize that it is not worth their while to attack Israel. Olmert’s past, present and future policies are no deterrent! He is not able to stop Kassams nor to prevent Hamas from preparing a major attack on Israel. Olmert has learnt nothing from past mistakes and is rushing to make more. He must be stopped before it is too late.
34. To George Saliba.... the "Canadian"
Franklin ,   Paris   (01.31.08)
Comemorating the "victory" of Hezbollah, Syria and Iran....over his own escape to Canada like a majority of Christians..... Over the destruction of Lebanon .... Bravo !!!! Mr Saliba... What a nice perspective of self-destruction ....without surprise for you
35. The Hizbullah
Harold Lane ,   Tel Aviv   (01.31.08)
The Hizbullah, (or shall we say the unit of the Syrian armee specialized in launching rockets on Israeli civilian and hiding in mosques and hospitals or using Lebanese civilians as human shields) exist only because it is supported by the dictatorship of Syria and the fanatic Islam regim of Iran. In order to destroy the Hizbullah Israel should not hesitate to attack Syria and inflict the country severe damages. If you want to know more about Syria and El Assad just open : http://israelagainstterror.blogspot.com/2007/12/truth-about-syria.html
36. Who asked you? Go back to your rat hole
Tim - Brighton ,   UK   (01.31.08)
37. Don't be so happy, it only points out to short comings.
Daniel ,   Israel   (01.31.08)
38. #26 didn't you see the pictuers..
Mamud ,   Lebanon   (01.31.08)
Sorry didn't know that I'm in english class :P, at least you understood what I said and it's fair enough for me. I like to say you the one who is dearming I don't know if you can prove your information. for the guys asking about pictures, we saw many times isreali solders pulling a killed palestinian gunman in the streets and taking pictures with them, and when the IDF hacked almaner tv all what they could show is one killed hizbollah fighter only!! even your meadia couldn't show the number of prisoners that your army was claiming that they captured. understanding the victory is easy just see the number of IDF (so called) solders the weapon the merkva 4 loool the poor tank the sea force and air force. and look at hizbollah and their numbers and weapons you may understand that what happened in lebanon is more that a meracle. The army that used to defeat any nation in few hour couldn't achieve any thing in 34 days agains small group as the report says.hope my englis is a bit better this time #26
39. #1 HAS IT RIGHT, ISRAEL DESTROYED HIZBULLAH'S INFRASTRUCTURE
HAL TRIPP ,   LA PAZ BOLIVIA   (01.31.08)
ISRAEL HAS DAMAGED THE HIZBULLAH'S STROGHOLD IN THE SOUTH FOR 10 YEARS, KILLED THOUSANDS OF THEIR FOLLOWERS,HOUSES AND ROADS WILL TAKE ANOTHER 10 YEARS TO REBUILD,ALL THEIR ARAB BROTHERS THAT WERE TO SEND MONEY HAVE QUIETLY DISAPPEARED,TRUE120 JEWISH BOYS DIED BUT THATS THE COST OF WAR, AM YISROEL CHAI
40. the political message
Sal Perez ,   Kib. Ein Hashofet   (02.01.08)
Winograd obviously was warned not to hit Olmert hard. The sad truth is Israel's "democratic" system is ruled from abroad, and Israelis don't get it. The system can't change no matter how it needs to. The next war will see Tel Aviv hit with thousands of missiles on the first day and Israel will cease to exist within less than a week.
41. What difference does it make ?
Chadi ,   Lebanon   (02.03.08)
I am not sure whether Hizbollah has won or lost the war. I actually don't care. I know one thing, we lost more than 1000 innocent people, men ,women and children. and this is to me a very heavy price to a victory. I wish Lebanon had an investigation (a la vinograd), ...for some must at least hold the moral responsibility of the catastrophic consequence of this distructive war.
Previous talkbacks
Back to article