Opinion
Hamas countdown has begun
Yigal Walt
Published: 07.03.08, 11:54
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
52 Talkbacks for this article
1. Let's see if Olmert knows how to count down!
Ram ,   London   (03.07.08)
2. Nothing will happen with Olmert as PM.
Terry ,   Eilat, Israel   (03.07.08)
Until we get rid of Olmert, Livni, & Barak, attacks against us will have few real consequences. But the analysis of the Arab mentality is correct - appeasement only fuels more violence, demands for new concessions, & the illusion that victory is close at hand.
3. Hamas, Philadelphia.
Marc ,   Nice, France   (03.07.08)
It's in fact about time to re-establish deterrence and give back Sderot & Ashkelon residents to a normal life. If we still live in a normal world, what happened these last weeks in the South, and yesterday in J'lem means : End of Hamas, eradication of its chiefs, and Philadelphia back to Tsahal control. Nothing less, whatever the scores of virgins implied... Thank you, Ygal & Ynet, for this article.
4. hamas countdown
sergi ,   australia   (03.07.08)
What a GREAT opinion THANK YOU, Would you please write once more from different site view,as each coin has two sites so each problem. Opinion about people who lost their land,livelihood and live 60 years in camps,where 3 generation of children has been brought up in hate instead of love to each other,why it has to come to this dreadful situation...please THANK YOU!.
5. Olmert???
Yessir Ibn Badkarma ,   Kanwait   (03.07.08)
Will Olmert wake from his nap, get off the couch and reach critical mass? Nah, just pass the popcorn!
6. Well put Yigal!
Ines ,   Bangok, Thailand   (03.07.08)
It's time for the kid gloves to come off!! What a shame, if only Gaza Palestinians could see the error of their ways by looking to their brothers in the West Bank. The ball has been in their court for so long! What alternative do we have after this massacre?
7. mistake?
Israel Israeli ,   tel aviv   (03.07.08)
The author has it wrong. The Arab terror war is an enormous success. Before Oslo there was an Israeli consensus that Jerusalem would never be divided, that the territories including Golan were Israeli forever, and that a solution would be found to give the Arabs autonomy. Due to the highly successful Arab terror war, Israel is being defeated. Israel is retreating on all fronts. Israeli civilians have not been less safe since 1948. Arab territory is expanding, while Israeli territory is shrinking. Even on the "leftist" side of the Green line Jews are being driven out of Sderot, Pki'in, Lod and Nahal Iron. Jerusalem is being divided. As for "Homat Magen", what did it achieve? A few dead Arab fighters who have become legends and the blood libel of "Jeningrad", while the Netanya hotel has been forgotten.
8. Just Do It Already!
Bill Foonman ,   Jacksonville, USA   (03.07.08)
Stop talking and start doing already! The world no longer cares what happens to Hamas (or the Palestinians for that matter) and expects Israel to do what it must to destroy this cancer. No civilized country would standby and allow terrorists to attack their citizens on a daily basis.
9. Olmert's countdown
Shimshon ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (03.07.08)
Before the countdown for Hamas starts, the countdown for Olmert has to finish. Being unable to protect Israeli citizens we need a new Prime Minister! http://www.shimshon9.com
10. Yeah. More BS Spin and Momentus Rhetoric
YS ,   Yehudah   (03.07.08)
ENOUGH!!!!!!!!
11. How long will Israel keep quiet ??
Sachin Kunjikoran ,   Mumbai, India   (03.07.08)
How long will Israel keep quiet ?? They did a stupid thing by coming out of Gaza and now u see the results. Israel shud go in for an all out attack. U can't debate, talk or compromise with terrorists and liars. They have no morals and ethics nor any right to Judeo land. I hope Israel stops listening to the the useless UN and do what is best for their own country.
12. Right ...
Gerry ,   Los Angeles USA   (03.07.08)
Nice fairy tale!
13. Let's oust Olmert and give them a real holy war
Texas Matt   (03.07.08)
Send the Arabs back to Jordan and Egypt. If they can't live in peace then they can't live at all.
14. OLMERT AND BARAK WILL DO WHAT BUSH TELLS THEM.
naro ,   nyc   (03.07.08)
These two clowns are in the pocket of the USA. They are corrupt buffoons. They will not act without getting the go ahead from Bush.
15. Trying to make Hamass bad guy/ Fatah good guy
3Jay3 ,   Israel   (03.07.08)
As i understand, the terrorists from this latest attack came from east Jerusalem, not Gazza,,,,,,,,,Olmert is trying to create a fairy tale that Fatah are the good guys/ Hamass the bad guys but both use the same Palastinian Charter that calls for Israels destruction. They both want to achieve this result. yet the fool Olmert ignores the facts! Elections NOW!
16. Israel Government Unhealthy for Jews
JS ,   NEGEV   (03.07.08)
17. Arabs....
Chance ,   Mesa, AZ   (03.07.08)
Go get 'em Israel. Stop playing pussy-foot and get it done. Time to teach your enemies what God does to people who come up against Israel. Be done with it. You gave peace the chance it deserves, but now it is not time for peace, it is time for war. Finish it.
18. Isarel
John ,   Brazil   (03.07.08)
My heart goes out to all the victims and their families of yesterdays attack. Isarel has a right to defend itself from people who want to see it destroyed. I love Israel and the Jews people who gave me the God of Abraham,Isaac and Jacob to worship. God bless Israel and protect it from the Philistines.
19. Are Israelis thoroughly familiar with Palestinian realities?
hamuda ,   Gaza   (03.07.08)
I think If Palestinians are the world’s worst decision-makers, surely Israelis are the seconds.
20. Olmer this is time to remove the gloves
Ben gurion   (03.07.08)
21. From Yigal's keyboard to God's eyes.
Murray of Montreal   (03.07.08)
22. #19
boris ,   nyc, us   (03.08.08)
it is why you and your friend arabs survive, hamuda.
23. Walt doesn't understand this is not a misjudgement
David ,   Los Angeles   (03.07.08)
Even a cursory reading of the basic theories of terrorism (from the Red Army Faction and PFLP in the olden days through to Al Quaida) would inform Mr. Walt that it is PRECISELY the aim of terrorism to provoke a massive reaction from the government. The idea being that this massive reaction will discredit the government in the eyes of the people and the world. Wait and see if they are right.
24. palestinians are safe with olmert and his pals
david ,   new york   (03.07.08)
25. Arabs dont understand that TOO GOOD IS NO GOOD
Alan ,   SA   (03.07.08)
26. Destroy the terrorists.
Jean Van Daem   (03.07.08)
The West should not be the only one to respect the Geneva convention. As has been proven since 60 years, unfortunately, peace is not an option in this part of the world. The Muslims in general and the Arabs in particular do not make a lasting peace. The maximum that Israel can aim for is a temporary limited ceasefire or an armistice. We should not accept a limited ceasefire or an armistice, but fight the terrorists, defeat them and destroy them. We should stop them with a clear cut victory as explained at : http://israelagainstterror.blogspot.com/2008/01/stop-them-with-clear-cut-victory-part-i.html
27. Hamas(& Muslim brotherhood) bring death to their own people.
KMR ,   Overseas   (03.07.08)
28. Question for the israelis
Christian ,   Norway   (03.08.08)
I notice that Olmert, Livni and Barak are not very popular among israelis. Who do you israelis prefair to be in charge in time ahead of us? My personal meaning is that Olmert seems to be a week leader in times like this, but i don't know the political "system" good enough to see who could me the right man/woman for the job right now? Can some of you israelis give some comments on who is the right person to be i charge now? (hope my english is not to bad)
29. Israel Is Too Jewish for It's Own Good
Dave Levy ,   Burbank. CAUSA   (03.08.08)
I ask, what if Olmert and Ptr were actually replaced by a hardliner, such as Bibi, with Lieberman as P.M.? Would the results be any different for Israel? Those who say Bush (through Condi) is running the show are correct. 30b in military aid, and other forms of aid by the US, dictates that Israel Kowtow to US. Will McCain or Hillary or Obama be better? That is the 6m dollar question? But now is now. Israel is adhering to it's lords in Washington and talking..talking, talking..to it's peace ptr, who has no authority. Hamas, Syria and Iran are ruling this waste of time. Iran is 10 months from the bomb, and Syria is arming to the teeth. Hamas will fire long (er) range rockets soon into Jerusalem and Tel Aviv., that is a surety. The US will say to Israel, "Think of the consequences" (yeah sure, like another massacre going unpunished). Nothing has changed since 48, cept the players. Israel beat 5 Arab armies then..and cannot defeat a bunch of disorganized thugs. The Arab mafia rules the day..they covet Israel's wealth, malls, factories, homes, and factories, sans it's Jews. That is their goal, and they say so...Israel is hearing but not listening. We can expect more massacres..next time, maybe a secular high school. shoot em up cowboy style. Where was the security for that hapless yeshive. Again Jews unprepared..afraid of the world..while people die.
30. ha ha ha .. abyss
Jalal ,   Gaza   (03.08.08)
what is abyss we have no food no medical service no .. no .. nothing at all so what is the abyss for me killing me ?? please do it .. as soon as possible heeeeeeeeeeey mister we donnt have economy or state or anything to worry about we donnt have anything to lose you do so you make a jock when you try to sing this tone go back to your Gov and try solve this issue with peace
Next talkbacks
Back to article