News
Al-Jazeera apologizes over 'Barbarian Muslims' remark
Roee Nahmias
Published: 09.03.08, 12:31
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
58 Talkbacks for this article
31. BottomLine::There is need to makeit livable for 21st century
KMR ,   Overseas   (03.09.08)
many muslims realize this need but too much afraid to talk on this issue because of beheading-punishment on blasphemy grounds!!
32. LOL. Do you actually think the leftists would allow
JJstar ,   Israel   (03.09.08)
a truth speaker on the airwaves - their last bastion and domain? Not bloody likely. All I can say is THANK GOD for the internet - where anyone can speak the Truth and the clueless fear mongers are left panting in the dark.
33. #8 - a paid talkback in service of Al-Jazeera
Tahl ,   Israel   (03.09.08)
Any network who apologizes to its audience for giving stage for someone's opinions - as unpopular as they may be - is hardly a "rational voice", or "brave and realistic", as #8response (most likely a paid TB for Al-Jazeera) asserted. Especially given the fact that it never apologizes after it offends Jewish or Christian beliefs. It is not brave, it is simply biased, albeit a lesser bias than most other Arab networks. Kudos to that. In contrast, Israeli and other western media never apologize after interviewing militant Arabs who call for the destruction of Israel, or that Jews are sinners. Al Jazeera has plenty to learn about objectiveness, especially toward Israel. Still, it's in a good company with the BBC, France2, and ARTE in that respect.
34. why this news only available in English solely?
ygalg   (03.09.08)
israelies have no right to know what's going on in the world? are they subject to ignorance?
35. do not you read the Torah & Talmud?
Ibin Nablis ,   nablus   (03.09.08)
it seems that w@#* from the USA (at Al Jazeera) and many on this forum did not read the Torah and the Talmud on the savagery of such religion....read them and talk to me:) LOL, if your house is made of glass, do not throw stones at neighbors windows.....dudes!
36. the muslims need their own reformation
john ,   cincinnati   (03.09.08)
The muslims can't handle the truth. They have evolved to the point at where christians were before the reformation. God willing their will be a muslim reformation.
37. So just to clarify: they think beheading is a bad thing?
Global Citizen ,   Israel & USA   (03.09.08)
Here's a solution: don't do it. In fact, try not doing any of the things you don't like being busted for.
38. Only Arabs think that apologies are required for the truth
Gee ,   Zikron Yaakov   (03.09.08)
Did she actually state anything that isn't factual? No she was telling the truth and Arabs can't seem to handle the truth very well. TFB
39. To Ibin Nablis
Pastaneta ,   NYC   (03.09.08)
Idiot! Contrarily to what is written in the Koran and Hadit, the OT has been reinterpreted and nobody murders in its name. Muslims, following their false prophet do everyday of the week!
40. a very brave woman
david ,   new york   (03.09.08)
41. how did she dare? behead her!!!!
jorge ,   argentina   (03.09.08)
42. wafa sultan=a voice of reason!
oded   (03.09.08)
bravo and hats off to this brave , sincere, and sane woman , who calls it like it is!
43. It's like a sitcom
(03.09.08)
i can imagine how the conversation would go if it was a sitcom Sultan: Islamists are the only ones that behead their enemies. Host: That's not true! *Awkward silence* Sultan: you're thinking about beheading me right now, aren't you?! Host: YES!! DEATH TO THE INFIDELS!!!! *recorded laughter*
44. She told them the world doesn't revolve around Islam!
Steven Wilson ,   Anchorage, Alaska   (03.09.08)
What a moment in these sheeps brainwashed minds. They can't for a moment believe the world doesn't revolve around a nutty religion, which tells everyone to blow themselves up for Allah. It's about time someone clued them in. As far as insulting.....it's insulting that the muslims think we have to accept their philosophy of life, religion,and backwards morals, that justify killing humans for insignificant reasons, justified by their own religious prejudices. The truth will set you free!
45. Another worthy woman
gabriela ben ari ,   jerusalem   (03.09.08)
On the Jerusalem Friday Massacre http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qftK5ROBVH4&feature=related
46. Impressive, and then some
Cameron ,   USA   (03.09.08)
Madam, you carry a much bigger pair than your male counterparts rolling along in that religion/culture. You are a true voice of blunt reasoning coming out of the sandpit
47. To 36 / Islam Reformation
Vince P ,   Chicago   (03.09.08)
They already have had their Reformation.. It's called Wahabbism and Khomeinism
48. Israelies,this woman is nobody on the arab world and opinion
Ahmed ,   Egypt   (03.09.08)
you are too happy with nothing.
49. #48 And you're too threatened by EVERYTHING
(03.09.08)
50. to #33 Who's paid to talk!
steve ,   london, england   (03.09.08)
You are wrong about me. Firtly I am a Jew and secondly I act alone. You are biased in your own interest as much as you say Al-Jazeera are biased. Have you considered how difficult it is for them to exercise free and progressively liberal opinion in the Arab world? Have you any real perception how expensive free speech is in the Arab World! Al-Jazeera are doing a great job for the Arabs and for Muslims. But they are not biased in favour of Arabs and Muslims. They are trying to help this world get its head around its daily problems and its massive global problems. All mof which require the sort of intellect the BBC has abandoned in favour of quiz shows and soft porn dramas. Israel should pitch a news channel on satellite too. Its about time a jewish voice spoke out as loudly as this company does for the world. Television has had its day in the sun and its setting in the west in favour of the internet which has taken the place of intellectual exchange that television once had. But in the Arab World there is more diversity and many more problems of political affairs to be sorted out by the means offered through Al-Jazeera. That is reasonable debate. GOOD LUCK TO THEM.
51. Alas, you're probably right, Ahmed
Cameron ,   USA   (03.09.08)
The fact that people like her are so unusual & exceptional in the Islamic World helps explain why it is such an economic, social, and political basketcase.
52. Mrs. W. Sultan is The Real WELL-WISHER Of The
Maansingh ,   The Netherlands   (03.09.08)
Mrs. Wafa Sultan told the Islamic World the proper, just and correct things -- namely, to honor the other's right to live ; to preach love, peace and coexistence to your children. IF the Islamic World will listen to Mrs. Sultan -- a new and fresh air will BLOW through the Islamic World. IF the Islamic World continues to listen to Mr. Tala'at Ramih -- the old path of BLOWING oneself up will just continue. The Islamic World should NOT listen to Mr. Ramih -- because he sounds like an unbalanced, IRRATIONAL and confused person. Mrs. Sultan is the real WELL-WISHER of the Islamic World -- although the Islamic World may not be able to see THAT at the present moment.
53. a whore can make better stories
(03.09.08)
54. To # 48
Woww ,   LA   (03.10.08)
Ahmed, she might be "nobody" today but 100 years from now she will be remebered as one of the few real arab heros.
55. #3
Braha ,   UK   (03.10.08)
This woman is indeed very couragious and may G-d indeed bless her. However you are really a men-hater and you need councelling as probably someone didn't treat you nicely. You need councelling sister. Unfortunately, there are men and women who do not behave nicely, but most men and women are just great! I also request that Ynet does not publish such hating talkbacks whether they are against men or women, Jews or Arabs. The discussion should be civilised
56. Glad I live to see the day when Muslim media must appease
Wafa is RIGHT ,   USA   (03.10.08)
and apologize for presenting more than one perspective concerning Islam. The Jyllands-Posten has a lot more courage and integrity than Al-Jazeera. Sultan is right: Islam could use a little self-reflection. It needs people like her to remind it that living in the dark ages keeps people ignorant and fearful while giving the power and control to a few corrupt individuals.
57. palestinians et al
jerome ,   vancouver ,canada   (03.10.08)
When will Muslims stop glorifying death.When will life be worth living. Until life has more meaning than being a mobile bomb and mothers speak out against the madness,Palestinian and Arab women will continue to live miserable lives of hate and futility.
58. Wafa Sultan and expression in the West
Stan ,   Dayton USA   (03.11.08)
The program's host, Faisal al-Qasim, asked her, "Why is the freedom of expression in the West holy only when it comes to humiliating Muslims? Can they talk about the Holocaust? Can they talk about Christianity? Cinemas have been torched in the West for talking about Christianity." Freedom of expression is not universally popular in the West. Certainly we talk about the holocaust. The fact that it happened is undisputed, but why it happened and what should have been done to prevent it, and what its legacy should be today are talked about frequently. Cinemas have not been burned that I have heard of, but conservative Christians have gotten upset over films like Life of Brian, the Last Temptation of Christ and the Golden Compass, and tried to suppress them. Mostly the films were not nearly as hostile to their views as they expected, and mostly the opponents just created interest in seeing the films. However no one ever tried to kill someone about them. Books by atheists sell many copies in the West, and their lives are not threatened. Most of these works, much like Salman Rushdie's Satanic Verses, are reverent toward the core values of religion but critical of what people do with it. Other books examine the Biblical texts and ask when they were written and why. Many were written in the forms we have them years or even centuries after the events they describe. No one is killed for doing this. Much of the Muslim reaction may reflect the history of colonialism that gave us Western domination over the Middle East. People who feel dominated and subjugated feel offended more easily than people who are on top. "If you want to change things, you must reexamine your terror studies; honor the other's right to live; preach love, peace and coexistence to your children. When you do that, the world will respect you, see you differently and portray you differently." This sounds like what all religions should be about.
Previous talkbacks
Back to article