News
B'Tselem: IDF broke law by killing wanted Palestinians
Ynet
Published: 27.03.08, 07:49
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
46 Talkbacks for this article
1. killing terrorists
sas ,   israel   (03.27.08)
great. should be a policy - better than having them sit in our jails and then having to release them.
2. HE WHO COMES TO KILL YOU KILL HIM FIRST.
Batya Cohen ,   Jerusalem Israel   (03.27.08)
Betselem members do not have sons at risk in the army. "Here good terrrorist, come here boy, I won't hurt you, let me take you in gently to be interviewed - no what's this, you are going to kill me because I am a Jew who abides by the law and the High Court rules? Good boy, sit." Are you joking? HE WHO COMES TO KILL YOU KILL HIM FIRST. Read your Bible.
3. Why! So Olmert can set them free later?
Boblybo Gilobob ,   USA   (03.27.08)
4. BTSELEM THE OFFICIAL CENTER FOR HELP OF ARAB TERRORISTS
(03.27.08)
5. b'tselem is irrelevant. Ynet the voice of Leftits
(03.27.08)
6. Never talk with islamist terrorists, just finish them off
Johnny ,   Stockholm Sweden   (03.27.08)
This is not ordinary gangsters, this is a folk that is at war with mankind, just finish them off at point blank.
7. B'TSELEM SEEKS THE MORAL HIGH GROUND AGAINST ISRAEL
ROLAND SEENER ,   LONDON ENGLAND   (03.27.08)
IT IS NOT SO WELL REPORTED THE EQUINAMITY THAT B'TSELEM SEEKS ALSO WITH CASES OF INJUSTICE EMANATING FROM ARAB SOURCES.PLEASE PAY ADDED ATTENTION TO THEIR DISPOSITION,WHEN PEOPLE ARE WOUNDED AND KILLED BY YHE ROCKETS AIMED AT CIVILIANS FROM GAZA.I AM SURE THAT THE RATIO OF PROTEST ON THEIR PART MUST BE 95% AGAINST THE GAZANS AND ONLY 5% AT THE VERY MOST AGAINST ISRAEL THIS STATE OF AFFAIRS SHOULD BE MORE CLOSELY MONITORED
8. WHO CARES what this TERRORIST ORGANIZATION, Btzelem, says?
Miriam ,   Israel   (03.27.08)
If we don’t hear from them when the "law is being broken" by the kassam shooting terrorists, there's no reason to report what this terrorist organization say in general. Unless......... Ynet is part of this group.
9. Based on "unbiased Palestinian and family members" witnesses
The Doc ,   Haifa, Israel   (03.27.08)
.... what a farce! B'tselem is nothing but an Anarchist "organization" dressed in "intellectual frocks" looking ofr new ways to facilitate terrorism and murder against Israeli citizens. They cooperate with the Arab and Palestinian propaganda and disinformation mechanisms and promote terrorist "rights" at the expense of their past, current and future victims. I do sincerely and wholeheartedly hope that its members feel physically and psychologically the pain of terror victims and their families and of the citizens of Sderot, Ashkelon and the Israeli villages around Gaza.
10. Whose Human Rights?
Aryeh ,   Israel   (03.27.08)
Why do we never hear that B'Tselem has asked anyone for investigations into the the actions of members of the terrorist groups that kill both Jewish and Arab civilians in the territories?
11. punishing a persion for the acts of another IS illegal
observer   (03.27.08)
but does the Jewish state have a basic law?
12. Have you ever Been in PA area? I have
moti ,   rbs   (03.27.08)
When we used to go into the PA area - we went in - did what we had to do... You dont have time to take chances- its our head or their head-better their head- the area is surrounded by other terrorists and snipers. THere is an expression -when u play in s**t u come out smelling like it... same there- when u go in to these areas - u r going into a craphole and u need to take care of yourself first and worry about the terrorists righs second...these people are killers, why is ynet and btselem so concerened with them..if they killed your brother - would u be so concerned about their rights? they kill our brother and sisters all the time without thought..there cant be any concern for their "rights"
13. YNET: publishing "spin" ? ?
moshe Israel ,   k. yam   (03.27.08)
YNET is becoming a propaganda outlet in the Israel-pal conflict. b'tselem claims against the IDF are a perfect example. On what basis does b'tselem accuse ? YNET gives NO clues, NO traceable facts ...yet YNET publishes such accusations ! Is YNET publishing leftist , pal, or political, "spin" ? (spin: the new word for PROPOGANDA) WHY ? ? moshe Israel
14. IDF did nothing wrong.
Israel   (03.27.08)
They are wanted terrorists - not angels.
15. BETSELEM
MZT ,   PETAH TIKVA   (03.27.08)
THEY WERE ON WAY TO SWEDEN. NOMINATED FOR "NOBEL PRIZE" FOR HUMANITARIAN ACTIONS.
16. YNET: publishing "spin" ? ?
moshe Israel ,   k. yam   (03.27.08)
YNET is becoming a propaganda outlet in the Israel-pal conflict. b'tselem claims against the IDF are a perfect example. On what basis does b'tselem accuse ? YNET gives NO clues, NO traceable facts ...yet YNET publishes such accusations ! Is YNET publishing leftist , pal, or political, "spin" ? (spin: the new word for PROPAGANDA) WHY ? ? moshe Israel
17. You only have to read the fascist talkbacks here...
Chanalau, Tova ,   London, UK   (03.27.08)
.. to understand the disastrous effect Zionism has had on the Jewish people (not to mention the Palestinians and all the other peoples of the area).
18. #11 generally correct but how does it apply here?
The Doc ,   Haifa, Israel   (03.27.08)
... do you have a point or you only chimed in to say "Jewish state" with a derogatory tone? Are you from an "Arab state" or from a "British State" or from a "Chinese state"? Is your knowledge of geography so limited or is it only pure hatred? Last time I looked at the UN official countries list, our country is called Israel but THANK YOU anyway for explaining everybody who is against it, that Israel is, was and indeed will be a Jewish State. As for the "basic law" would you care to explain the question "does Israel have a basic law?" as opposed to what? To the "basic law" present in Iran? Or Syria? Or Sudan? Or Saudi Arabia? Ah - I get it - their "basic law" is Islam - "the religion of peace" in whose name more than 10,000 terrorist acts have been committed and hundreds of thousands of Muslims have been butchered. Then maybe our basic law should be the Torah? But as we do not live in the dark ages anymore, we do have a "basic law" - it is called democracy. This is what allows you to post feely on a Jewish forum belonging to a Jewis/Israeli newspapaer and not having the "Moral Police" banging at your door, or a crazed terrorist murdering your family for being "anti-basic law".
19. Terrorists
David ,   Talpiot   (03.27.08)
Funny how there's no "Liberated Territories Centre for Human Rights in Israel", that take Hamas to court for shooting rockets into schools in S'derot.. I don't think it's a bad thing if terrorists get the message that "planning and perpetrating terror attacks against israel" may well lead to being shot- trial or no trial.
20. Poor, pitiful #17..
Arthur ,   SF, CA   (03.27.08)
21. kill terrorists and volunteering regularly will cease
Sammy ,   J'lem Israel   (03.27.08)
The policies nowadays are too politically correct. If you are thinking of becoming a terrorist then you stand 75% chance of being released in a month or two in a measure of good faith from our dear government. If we killed terrorists and took a serious stance against them then they won't volunteer so easily. This is how you tackle a terrorist. These people are inhumane, why is their such support for them all the time. It often makes you wonder how perverted these political correctness have become. Its shocking how they seem to think they understand justice. What is happening to this country??
22. #17 more fascist talk in Muslim forums! They are masters!
The Doc ,   Haifa, Israel   (03.27.08)
... and that wouild explain I suppose what desastruous effect Islam had on Arabs, Indonesians (who had a proud culture before Islam came). same for Malaysia, Afghanistan, Africa, etc. Not to mention the desatruous effect Islam has on the Jews and other nations in the world! You must be pretty hateful of the Jews to lie through your teeth like that, but we are used to the fact that Muslim impostors masquerading as Jews or other nations do that on Ynet and other talkbacks.
23. IDF and B'Tselem
I.Kemp ,   Nahariya Israel   (03.27.08)
Good for the IDF ! Whether true or not it means that they will not be released from prison in a "goodwill gesture" for Condi and Co only to kill again and being fed and kept by us in the meantime
24. "IDF broke law by killing wanted Palestinians"
H. E. ,   Norway   (03.27.08)
"Human" Rights groups like B'Tselem represent a problem in the war against terror!
25. Good Ridance...!
william ,   Seattle,W,USA   (03.27.08)
They were no suspects but hardened murderers with criminal records... The soldiers that carried the mission are heroes who should be celebrated... Judges, Jury and executioners... more are needed...Taxpayer's money should not be wasted on such scumbags... Israel is a safer place without them... B'Tselem sounds like a bleeding heart liberal organization... On whose side are they anyway ?
26. It is the Law
Avinoam ,   Tel Aviv, Israel   (03.27.08)
"B'Tselem claims that the IDF acted in violation of a High Court ruling, which states that suspects must not be killed when it is possible to arrest them and bring them to trial." 1) Anyone can seek justice. Whether they deserve it or not is for the courts to decide. 2) No matter how much we hate it this is the law. If you believe this law to be wrong then you should petition to get it changed instead of voice your moral outrage which has no effect but to pat yourself on the back for the high quality of your moral outrage. 3) Personally I think we are far too lenient on terrorists. Terrorism is not the same as murder, it is worse, it is murder plus the attempt to undermine the entire society. Terrorists who have without a doubt blood on their hands should be shot. Suspected terrorists should be arrested and then, if guilty, shot. Only cases where guilt seems clear but an iota of doubt remains should they be incarcerated. Note I don't speak of Capital punishment, I see this as something different as terrorism is an act of war.
27. B'Tselem,the terrorists love you
don Saliman ,   Nahal Oz, Israel   (03.27.08)
You encourage the terrorists every time you slam Israel. The blood is on your hands shame on you.
28. sorry
Natan   (03.27.08)
But this is the army , not the police!! And those are terrorits not bank robbers!!!
29. bteselem , beshlemmem...
oded   (03.27.08)
these rmat aviv, bored, confused and frustrated women really need to get a life! these plais got the only justice they deserve!
30. Awww poor terrorists. Lets all huddle together and cry!
AR   (03.27.08)
All they wanted to do was kill Israelis, but the IDF didn't even let them do that! They brutally murdered these innocent murderous terrorists. Shame on the IDF for being SO MEAN!
Next talkbacks
Back to article