News
Livni: Advance compensation to West Bank evacuees
Roni Sofer
Published: 30.03.08, 09:13
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
19 Talkbacks for this article
1. Where's the Compensation for those 10,000 Jews brutally
Joseph P. ,   Jerusalem   (03.30.08)
expelled from their homes in 2005???? These Jews ARE STILL WAITING FOR THEIR COMPENSATION! Most of them are still without homes and financial income. The Israeli corrupt government is NEVER to be trusted.
2. Ready to compensate all of Israel?
A right & left Jew ,   Yesha Israel   (03.30.08)
Tel Avivians & Coastal Strippers...your lives are in serious danger if we are forcibly removed from our homes in the hill country overlooking 'your' settlements, your lives will be a disaster. Try and explain the present mess facing Israelis living near the Gaza border after the last forced retreat. Even Ashkelon is becoming more like a war zone! Our homes in the Shomron hills are prime launching sites for attacking the narrow coastal strip including the airport. Who will be next for special 'compensation' treatment from this defeated government of cowards? They recently invited the Germans here; war compensation was possibly on their agenda? If we can't defend Israel, where else? You will 'Not get Peace' from evicting Jews from our country...you know it...so speak out against it... whilst you still have any brains left.
3. Fools Day
Asher ,   Jerusalem   (03.30.08)
Day after day, we see & feel what is happening around us. You blinded fools called Politicians, act & go on as if everything is normal on the streets. Israel left gaza, and got in return daily rockets. The world won't give up until Israel is wiped off the map, and it doesn't when they have the help of Israel. Israel has never had a real Jewish direction. Thereby believing that they did steal the land. These Israelis think they can defy reality. The World has seen the hand of God. It is only a matter of time that the inevitable will happen. The REAL JEWS will be redeemed & be allowed to live in peace in the Holy Land.
4. Where will the money come from?
Terry ,   Eilat, Israel   (03.30.08)
It costs money to "assist" Jews out of their homes. We're not talking about a couple of shekels here. Yet, we have no money to improve education, we have no money for decent pensions, we have no money for Holocaust survivors, we have no money to fund Ulpan classes for immigrants, we have no money for improved medical care, we have no money for infrastructure projects, we have no money for job training & adult education, & we have no money to compensate Sderot residents for the economic ruin which this gov't. allowed to happen. But we do have money to evict Jews.
5. Palestinian national vision is to destroy Israel
Esther ,   Raanana, Israel   (03.30.08)
not "territorial compromises and security for Israel". The Israeli government is suffering from cognitive dissonance and if Israel's citizens don't cry out a WAKE UP call soon, they will be on a path towards that end.
6. answer for terry #4
no money? they gave ,   it all to shas   (03.30.08)
7. it is rather simple. Those that offer money are....Traitors
jack bauer ,   plain and simple   (03.30.08)
they act to release terrorists they act to arm terrorists they act to destroy Judaism and its roots they are corrupt they are not acting on behalf of the Jewish people..... they are active in the moves against the interests of the Jewish people They spit on Hashem and ignore all of his instructions these corrupt traitors that act daily to destroy Israel from within, will reap their just reward. According to them it is racist to compensate an arab to get him to move off of (arab occupied) the land. But low and behold It is ok to bribe jews it is ok to make a judenrien state where every jew is forcibly removed..... but not ok to kick arabs out? this world is seriously twisted when the terror masters(crybaby hypocrites) get what they want for nothing because of the appeasing traitors A house divided against itself will not stand This govt.......MUST GO
8. Diplomacy, then violence
Dora Ziv ,   Haifa   (03.30.08)
On the last Friday before the Sharm A-Sheikh peace summit between then-Israeli Prime Minister Arial Sharon and Palestinian Authority Chairman Mahmoud Abbas in February 2005, PA TV broadcast an official sermon which made clear to Palestinians the role, in Palestinian eyes, of peace talks. Ibrahim Mudayris, on February 4, 2005, delivered the sermon in which he called for Palestinians to use diplomacy to return to the 1967 lines, but violence to destroy Israel. The way to deal with these people : http://tinyurl.com/2y59qw
9. TERRY, YOU DID IT AGAIN !
AVROHOM BILGREI   (03.30.08)
PERFECTLY !
10. If wishes were horses then beggars would ride
Kent   (03.30.08)
Rice, Livni, Olmert - living in dangerous dream world - and Israelis are doing nothing about it. Thousands more young people doomed to destruction because of these evil clowns.
11. It is frightening how Terry (#4) hit the nail on the head
Chaim ,   Israel   (03.30.08)
12. You didn't like my first post?
Terry ,   Eilat, Israel   (03.30.08)
OK, I'll excercise a little self-censorship & tone it down. But I have to say that the issue is important enough for some blunt talk regardless of your editorial agenda. There is an unusual principle underlying this compensation idea. That principle is that a future Palestinian state must be Judenrein while the State of Israel should host a large Arab population which generally considers itself Palestinian. Isn't reciprocity a fundemental principle? Isn't fairness the basis of any solid agreement? In what way does the presence of Jews impede a Palestinian state when the presence of Arabs does not impede the Jewish state? What are the implications of this idea? Some might compare this to apartheid, to some form of racism. Would Ms Rice like to explain why Jews cannot live in a future Palestinian state if Palestinians can live in Israel? Could she relate this to the black experience in America - that blacks should not live among whites? Is there not something very wrong underlying all the assumptions about two states living side by side in peace? What does this say about our supposed partners in peace?
13. END THE CONFLICT NOW!!
yoni ,   jerusalem   (03.30.08)
COMPENSATE ALL ARABS WHO WISH TO EMMIGRATE FROM ISRAEL THIS IS THE ONLY SLOUTION. ALL ARABS HAVE FAMILY OUT OF ISRAEL THEY SHOULD BE HELPED TO LEAVE THIS COUNTRY JUST AS WE HELP JEWS MAKE ALIYAH THIS IS THE ONLY AND FINAL SOLUTION
14. Livni: You must be blind, deaf and dumb if you don't realize
Miriam ,   Israel   (03.30.08)
what happened to Gaza after it was made Judenrein and how many thousands of rockets are fired from there daily. If you believe that the Arabs will be satisfied with the West Bank you're nothing but a first class fool. After the West Bank and Jerusalem you're so anxious to give away, comes Tel-Aviv and other cities. Rice – just like the Arabs – doesn’t care about Joooos and would love to see them all thown into the sea. Don’t be fooled by this woman. Why don't you foolish politicians who don't care for Israel, move out of this country? You'll be happy there and we will be even more happy to get rid of you.
15. It's kind of strange
Andras Bereny ,   Kfar Tapuah, Ephraim   (03.30.08)
It's kind of strange to see how 63 years after the end of WWII and 60 years after the foundation of the so called "Jewish" state there are still people around, not to mention main streem politicians, who think that any question can be resolved by forcedly moving Jews, only Jews and no one else but Jews. William R. Perl in his book "Four Faced War" documents how the Jewish leadership of the time did nothing to save the Jews. Is history repeating itself? See www.jewishyisrael.org
16. Get paid to leave our land............
Wise Saba ,   Western Negev   (03.30.08)
I think NOT!
17. Terry both posts #4 & # 12 are excellently
rich ,   raanana & NYC   (03.30.08)
stated points that you made. Although GW may be Israel's "best friend" if thats possible he's lettng rice do his dirty work for him. Your exactly right that while arabs can and do live in Israel, jews will not be allowed to live in this new magical, glorious, disneyland-esque shining perfect model of democracy that the palestinians will create whereas they absolutely no historical precedent for creating a successfull arab democracy. They fought tooth and nail usuing terror with jewish blood for 60 years or more to get "their land back". This stark reality of judenrein will be shown to rice and the world this phony state when or if this state ever gets off the ground. The whole thing's almost laughable if it werent so close by.
18. Nice idea
Osama ,   Dark, Cave   (03.30.08)
If Condi thinks arab hatred of Western democarcies will end by caving in to terror, giving up land, and paying off people to further that fantasy, she should suggest that Mr. Bush kick all Texans, and Californians out of there homes (compensation will be provided). Mr Bush should also be made to shake Osama's hand, declare him a partner in peace, give him weapons (to protect the US for the extremists), and declare more than half of the US is to be made into an independant, peaceful state for the terrorist. WHAT? haven't we seen that kicking Jews out of their homes doesn't work. How peaceful is it in Sderot? Who in their right mind would kick more Jews out and hand even a centimeter of Eretz Yisrael to the terrorists?
21. Use the money to expel arabs
hymie zoltsveis ,   NYC, NY, USA   (03.30.08)
No need to use the money to pay off Jews, to flee Israel. Use the money to buy out arabs.
Back to article