News
Rabbi Eliyahu: Life of one yeshiva boy worth more than 1,000 Arabs
Kobi Nahshoni
Published: 03.04.08, 21:03
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
56 Talkbacks for this article
31. Rabbi Eliyahu: Life of one yeshiva boy worth more than 1,000
Yoram Matzkin ,   Canada   (04.04.08)
History will judge Rabbi Eliyahu to be a bigot and evil. Maybe the Canadian press should publish this article to show the kind of hate mongering that exist against the Palestinians.
32. Thousands gathered tonight
Samuel ,   NY   (04.04.08)
Worldwide, thousands of Jews gathered tonight to commemorate the 30 day anniversary of the murder of these teens and young adults, with lectures by Rabbi Frand and Rabbi Gotleib among others.
33. coz it says so in Isaiah Chapter 30/17
Yisraeli   (04.04.08)
"One thousand shall flee at the rebuke of one" and as have been mentioned before even the arabs agree wanting to swap a thousand for one.
34. The terrorists are trying to get us to kill their children.
Dora Ziv ,   Haifa   (04.04.08)
While Israel has built a shelter system in Sderot in order to protect lives, Hizbullah did the opposite in Lebanon in 2006 - because Hizbullah wanted to increase the amount of its civilian deaths. That's because our culture is one of 'choose life', while the Imams encourage them to look at their children as martyrs. This is what makes it so difficult for the democracies, the terrorists are trying to get us to kill their children. We should be prepared to fight them with no other consideration than beat them as explained at : http://tinyurl.com/28w849
35. A state that doesn't value the lives of it's citizens
Ilan ,   Ariel   (04.04.08)
This is a basic principle of the responsibilities of a state. The lives of it's people must be worth much more than the lives of the people of any nation that would dare to attack it. If the current government doesn't understand that then it has no legitimacy.
36. wow!
Nikos ,   London   (04.04.08)
What amazes me more is not that some religious lunatic thinks his cult followers' lives are worth more than those of infidels, but the number of people in the talk back that are sympathetic of such views...
37. How many Jews beheaded?
Concerned US Citizen ,   Phila, PA   (04.04.08)
So, you are not counting the countless killed in the Gaza strip or those sick people who were refused medical treatment or entry into Isreal for treatment?
38. A Rabbi
Ian ,   London, England   (04.04.08)
All life is sacred. How a Rabbi can say that the life of one Jewish boy is worth a thousand lives of Arabs is beyond me. I do not note any spiritual wisdom in the Rabbi's words. What is wrong with the man? He talks like a Nazi and not a man of god!
39. Life of Jew is worth life of 1000 Arabs
Mannstein ,   USA   (04.04.08)
A few years ago when a certain Jewish terrorist gunned down Arabs praying in the mosque on the temple mound and was finally killed a rabbi proclaimed the small finger nail of a Jew is worth more than 1000 Arab lives. Now the world hears another similar outrageous comment by another good rabbi. Has any one asked themselves in the Jewish community why anti semitism is on the rise?
40. To Israel, Jews are cannon fodder
andrew r   (04.05.08)
Anyone who places a relative value on life based on ethnicity has no respect for life.
41. Idotic ranting dangerous for Jews
Robert Biggs ,   Fort Wort,TX,USA   (04.05.08)
Anti-Semits worldwide thrive on remarks like this. This idiot and his followers make Jews look just as Nazis portraited us in their propaganda.
42. This "person" is really sick
Advocate4Liberty ,   Chicago, USQ   (04.05.08)
I don't know what sewer this cockroach crawled out of, but if the posters on this board, like Jane, represent the Israeli mainstream, Israel needs to be excised like any cancer - a boil on the buttocks of humanity.
43. Of Rabbis and Imams
michael mazur ,   brunswick australia   (04.05.08)
Although i see people proffer as equivalent the Arab position which says that Arabs are willing to trade one Jewish prisoner for 1,000 Arab prisoners, no one has quoted an Imam saying that an Arab is worth 1,000 Jews. Consider, 50,000 Jewish babies aborted in Israel per annum, so says an advertisement by a charitable organization which manages to save a further 1700 from that fate. And having read all the comments, and no one has noticed this obscenely contrasting anomaly of how is it that a Jewish life is worth 1,000 Arab lives, but, before it is born can be indifferently scraped out and flushed down the sink if tiny, or burnt in the incinerator if larger ? Should someone rush out and kill 1,000 Arabs every time that happens ? Somehow, i think that were you to save these million Jewish kids over the next 20 years, you would survive as a nation, but the `price` you would pay is that in the act of saving all these Jewish kids, you would realise every baby is just as precious, and you would then accept Palestinians as equal to you, in a land once again called Palestine.
44. did anyone ask why?
Ash ,   Palestine   (04.06.08)
did anyone ask why that attack in Jerusalem happened? did anyone mention the 63 Palestinians (16 kids and 12 women) who were killed in Gaza just 3 days before the attack? can we call that a terrorist attack too?!
45. What Hypocrites!!
Tim ,   USA   (04.06.08)
"Even when we seek revenge, it is important to make one thing clear – the life of one yeshiva boy is worth more than the lives of 1,000 Arabs" When whites in America want racial separation from blacks, mainstream Jewish groups (The ADL, American Jewish Committee) call them Nazis. Funny, the policies Jewish groups promote for us in the U.S. (e.g. racial integration, cultural pluralism) they demand the exact opposite for their own people in Israel (e.g. racial separation, separate schools, separate roads, law of return only for Jews) Don't tell me Jews are exposed to Palestinian terrorists. Blacks assault, rob, rape and murders tens of thousands of white Americans every year. This tells me that this is what Jewish groups want, to ethnically cleanse Americans of European descent making it easier for them to take over. That's probably why Jewish groups in European promote the same poison there too.
46. Rabbi Eliyahu
Dale ,   Eveleth ,U.S.A.   (04.06.08)
I wonder if the good Rabbi would trade places with one of the well treared Palistineans for a day with a I9sraeli boot on his neck
47. What a moron!
Alan Heath ,   Warszawa, Poland   (04.07.08)
It is talk like this that leads to continued bloodshed and there will never be peace for normal people until the likes of Hezbollah, Hamas and Rabbi Eliyah are wiped out. Oh dear, I am beginning to sound like him now.
48. Value of one single human life
James Ralston ,   Augusta, Ga, USA   (04.07.08)
It would be priceless, meaning that it is so great, one could not put a money price upon it.
49. ironic
halherta ,   Kingston, ON, Canada   (04.07.08)
Kind of ironic really seeing as how the chances that the Palestinians are descendants of the ancient Judaic people are much greater than the chances that present Israeli jews are its descendents. http://www.haaretz.com/hasen/spages/966952.html
50. 1000 ?
michael ross ,   ohio   (04.07.08)
the talmud may say this but the torah is GODS word and he never mentioned it.
51. Wow!
Edson ,   Brazil   (04.07.08)
The cream of racism, and hate. Fanatic lunatic, what more can i say?
52. Pfft
Crank ,   Los Angeles   (04.08.08)
My life, worth more than all of you put together.
53. Sick People
Patriot ,   NYC   (04.08.08)
And he is considered a religious leader? He is more like a racist leader. There is something definitely wrong and evil with people like this. What sort of religion supports such thinking?
54. crazy rabbi
Dan ,   LA, USA   (04.09.08)
This dude is unfit to serve in any clerical position. Either that, or the jewish faith is spiritually insane.
55. THANK YOU TIM
heath ,   Houston/USA   (04.09.08)
I was scared that I was the only one that recognized that!
56. Terrorists are not HUMAN
Sam ,   Canada   (07.19.09)
Of course 1000 terrorists are not worth even a single HUMAN soul! This Rabbi got it right on.
Previous talkbacks
Back to article