News
Peace with Syria suicidal, MKs say
Amnon Meranda
Published: 23.04.08, 14:35
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
40 Talkbacks for this article
1. what does that mean?
robert ,   usa   (04.23.08)
The Prime Minister's Office declined official comment on the report saying "we will not comment on the said report but we can refer everyone to the prime minister's holiday interviews saying that we know what the Syrians want of us, and they know what we want of them."
2. OLMERT IN JAIL NOW !!!!
(04.23.08)
3. NOT NOW OLMERT!!!
Akram ,   Paris / Beirut   (04.23.08)
I really don't understand Israel! From one side, the Syrians support without any limit Hezbollah and Iran, the ultimate enemy to Israel, and Israel is responding in favor to the Syrian demands! On the other hand, Israel knows very well the peaceful intentions of most of the Lebanese, people and government (anti-Hezbollah), and they don't say a word to seed the tiny, still occupied, Lebanese land of Shebaa farms! I really tend to believe now Hezbollah that Israel only understand the language of force and power, rather than the language of peace! At the end, I think the Hezbollah point of view is winning, unfortunately!
4. Never give up Golan
Y ,   N   (04.23.08)
5. to akram
fish   (04.23.08)
You're absolutely right and it makes me sad... our PM is tired of winning... he's into making money and playing games... he doesn't have time for standing up for this country... It's a pitiful picture, and sorry for letting you guys down////
6. After Spy Scandal, Olmert gives up Golan
Mark ,   Boston   (04.23.08)
There is a connection between the spy scandal and Olmert's decision to give up the entire Golan Heights.
7. Olmer u r a TRAITOR
vicky ,   Ashkelon Israel   (04.23.08)
8. Olmert irresponsible only?
Daniele ,   Amsterdam NL   (04.23.08)
9. Give back what?
Nora ,   Tel Aviv   (04.23.08)
Mr. Olmert, if you want to give back your mandate it`s OK, but giving back the Golan? Never.
10. to 3
tFighterPilot   (04.23.08)
Most Lebanese oppose the HA, but only a few want peace with Israel. The ones who do want will not suffice in the Sheba Farms (which never belonged to Lebanon in the first place) but also demand the transfer of the "Palestinian refugees" who live in Lebanon to Israel.
11. Olmert give away your home, not mine!
Judah ,   Golan Heights,ISRAEL   (04.23.08)
We all need to remember that Shas and Lieberman's party are keeping Olmert afloat.
12. So what, Golan is not Israel's?
Aron ,   Europe   (04.23.08)
You conquered it. So give it back. And don't pull your "Yeah, it's Bible promised" thingy, since Spain is promised to Isalm, and we would not give it eather. I was promised a Heavenly Jerusalem on shores of Haifa in New Testament, and yet I don't clame it. So get out of Golan. It's not yours.
13. Olmert: sneaky, disgusting, incompetant liar....
Andy ,   ramat hasharon   (04.23.08)
and those are his good qualities.
14. re: 12, No more do-overs
Greg ,   USA   (04.23.08)
No the Arabs can't have land back so they can try to destroy Israel for the 6th time. If the Golan was so important to Syria they should have entered a military pact with Egypt with the stated goal of soon destroying Israel.
15. #12. Syria attacked 3 times
Jake   (04.23.08)
Israel didn't "conquer" anything; Israel retaliated. Syria had opened up a front against Israel during the 1967 war that previously was quiet. It attacked the "Upper Galilee finger" in the Tel Dan region, and bombarded the Galillee with aircraft and artillery. I do not know what kind of topsy-turvy world you live on, but clearly you apply to Israel different standards than you would apply to yourself. The entire history of Europe, until this very day, is predicated on the principle that "To the victor goes the spoils". The spoils are the Golan, and they are Israel's as of right, whether you like it or not.
16. Surrender of Golan will NOT achieve peace
Kyle ,   Southpark, CO, USA   (04.23.08)
Jews bought this land with blood and treasure, planted vineyards, built homes and industries, raised families. Giving it away will NOT bring peace but will cause bombardment of Galilee communities.
17. Golan
Millicent ,   Israel   (04.23.08)
Give it back with the understanding that it is to be demilitarized totally, and only farming allowed on the land.After all most of the Syrian mines still litter the landscape in the Golan anyway, but donot give an inch of the Kinneret shore line to them because then they could use the water that we drink as leverage for further compromises on Israel's part. However make it clear to Syria that the golan will be returned slowly and small parts at a time, to ensure thatSyria doesn't go back on any peace agreementwith Israel. Also make it clear that any attack from the Golan once it is returned to Syria will be considered an act of war and Syria will be carpet bombed into the stoneage!
18. What is wrong with the people of Israel?
Sidney ,   USA   (04.23.08)
If Olmert did in fact offer to return the Golan Heights to Syria they have an absolute right to know. Given his utter failure as a leader, they should have taken to the streets to force the Knesset to remove him from office. Now, offers to Arabs which certainly affects their security and may affect national survival, are being kept from them.
19. sounds like treason
alan ,   texas   (04.23.08)
Golan has been israel since biblical times. First century synagogues and villages on the ground there. Syria attacked and lost. Must have uprising and get rid of olmert and kadima mks. also get rid of arab traitorous mks.
20. #17 What naivety
Righteous Zionist ,   Israel   (04.23.08)
to think that giving the Arab enemy can easily be reversed, and that we can clobber them if they are naughty boys. This pathetic thinking was that of the cloud-cuckooland supporters of the Oslo Accords in 1993 and we all know what happens when you cede land to Arabs (terrorists in most cases). So Millicent get real sweetie - we must not give one inch of land - if anything we should take land, which is what THEY would do!!!
21. Olmert: "I'm willing to cede the Golan"
Am Yisrael   (04.23.08)
Who the hell does he think he is?! He was never really elected; if not for Sharon's misfortune, he would NEVER have become PM. He was no. 30 on the Likud list, of no consequence (just a meddling and coniving MK) and now his "highness" is "willing" to give away land. The delusional fool also thinks he will get a second term! We all can't wait to get rid of the fool. Olmert GO HOME!!! GET OUT OF OUR LIVE, NOW! You are the most pathetic PM Israel has ever had. If Kadima does not get rid of him Kadima will fall.
22. #15 No, syria was attacked more than 3 times
(04.23.08)
23. Better do it before the govt collapses
Juan ,   Spain   (04.23.08)
I can't quote the figures but: ... is this a prime minister with support of 20% of the population giving away land which 90% want him to hang on to?
24. Give it all back
Josh ,   MI, USA   (04.23.08)
The only true road to peace for Israel is to give back all the land they stole in 1967. The sooner they realize and accept this, the sooner their neighbors will agree to live in peace with them.
25. Another lie by Olmert
Richard R. ,   Buckeye USA   (04.23.08)
How long is the Israeli people going to allow P. M. Olmert to destroy israel. Are they waiting for the big war where the P. M. will surrender and say we have had enough. In America we have what you call impeachment, The president can be impeached for disobeying the law of the land by our Congress. Look what happen to Richard M. Nixon. Why doesn't the kinnesit do something before we lose all of Israel. Something has to be done now or there is no sence in us Jews giving money to a dead Country and that what going to happen to Israel. People of Israel, go onto the streets and protest with all your might or by this time next year there will be nomore Israel. P.M. Olmert could be a clone Thats just a thought ! I find it hard to believe P. M Olmert who saids he loves Israel Can do what he doing to destroy Israel. You can charge him with working for the Arabs because thats what he is doing. Any way wake up Israel.
26. So, Jake, #15
Aron ,   Europe   (04.23.08)
So tell me loud and clear: if hypothetically Arabs would attack Israel, and USA would do nothing in fear of retaliation from Russia and Iran, and others would stand and watch and if Israel would be stopped to use its nuclear weapon (for it's use would mean the end of the world, cause all other arab nations would respond similarly, including Pakistan) and if Israel would be conquered, and Arab nations would ask UN o recognize that state of conquest... would you recognize it like that? As new Arab state, based on conquest? I wouldn't, we are not in middle ages! Or, by your logic, there is no reason not to declare Iraq - USA colony!
27. Josh, you're sloshed...
David ,   Hartford USA   (04.23.08)
"Give back all the land they stole..." Israel has more a right to exist than any of the Arab countries created in the 20th century. At least the UN decided it and not a couple of drunken British and French 'statesmen' over some whiskey. As for the Arab 'states,' you conveniently forget that Islam spread by the sword and not by the ballot. When Islam crawls back to its native home in Saudi Arabia and allows millions upon millions of people to think for themselves and have personal freedoms, then you can talk about what Israel 'stole'. Ask the poor Darfurans why they are being slaughtered by the 'peaceful neighborly' Arabs. No stolen land there, Josh. Wake up. Until you do, shaddupayoumouth.
28. Treasonous move
Brod ,   USA   (04.23.08)
The Leftist government seems to do away with Israel's national security interests. Begin would never have made such a move had Sadat not flown to Israel and made peace with the Jewish State. To compromise Israel's liberated biblical and historic homeland of Golan to Israel's enemies is a strategic and moral blunder. The Golan was used by Syria to bombard Israel's villages, farms, towns and cities in the valleys. Syria is a tentacle of Israel's pernicious enemy-the fanatical Islamist-Jihadist state of Iran that is hellbent on the destruction of Israel. Syria is also a strong supporter and sponsor of Hezbollah in Lebanon that has ravaged Lebanon and attacked Israel with 4000 rockets. Syria is the main butcher of Lebanese politicians including the late PM Hariri. Is this the kind of entity that Olmert is willing to give away Israel's liberated biblical and historic homeland of Golan? Israel should ensure that such naive proposal exists only in fantasyland.
29. #24 Josh
Tamir ,   Los Angeles   (04.23.08)
Hey josh I assume the MI in your location refers to Michigan. This along with all the other land that is now the United States was at one time belonging to another country/people. We as Americans "stole" this land through our own conquest and have no intention of giving it back. In fact what is the idea behind "manifest destiny?" is that not the single most obscure/theologan thought on land grabbing that has ever existed? Israel is the only country that has time and time again willingly given back land it has captured after being attacked in order to achieve piece. If we had the same mentality as America or most other imperialistic nations Israel would stretch from Damascus through Cairo!
30. #12, How is it that.....
TheWatchman777 ,   USA or once WAS   (04.23.08)
MORONs are able to get through the screeners and have their idiotic comments posted? The heights DO belong to Israel and MUCH more land that is being occupied by Arab squatters. Todays Israel is but a FRACTION of what THE ANCIENT OF DAYS GAVE THEM! NO, We DON'T care if you do or do NOT want to hear about the "Bible promised THINGY" as you so eloquently put it-facts are FACTS, get over it. Now go eat a crumpet or "somethingy!" LOL
Next talkbacks
Back to article