News
Suleiman: Major IDF op expected if Shalit isn't released
Roee Nahmias
Published: 17.05.08, 13:33
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
38 Talkbacks for this article
1. Release him or face the terrible consequences
petra ,   usa   (05.17.08)
of your own cowardice. Kipnapped soldiers are not legal, Hamas will bring down a bloodbath on their own pals over one innocent Israeli soldier who should be home with his loved ones.Talk a bout stubborn. What corrupt sick party' would do this unless they can't win any battle any time? They better listen or many pals will die.
2. Why release prisoners at all?
Jay3 ,   Israel   (05.17.08)
Releasing prisoners?? I cannot understand this logic. Israel has the ability to wipe Hamass off the face of this Earth so why bow down to terrorists demands? We should be showing strength and not weakness as the Arabs see it. Release no prisoners, hit Gazza hard and wipe out the scum! To get Shallit released is easy.....just target the Hamass leadership including Haniyeh and Mashall!
3. Why should they believe it?
Terry ,   Eilat, Israel   (05.17.08)
We hear nothing but idle threats from Israeli politicians but never any follow-up action. If I were Hamas, I wouldn't believe it Anyway, the whole idea of a truce is a mistake. But, of course, we should be used to mistakes - it seems that's all we do since Oslo - make mistakes.
4. 3 Israeli prisoners value
Dr D ,   Jerusalem   (05.17.08)
Take ALL the Arab prisoners to the borders with Gaza and Lebanon and exchange them with our 3 boys. After that, if we are so powerful we should not fear any new act of aggression toward us. Make the Arab pay with land and high number of casualties. Loosing time in sterile negotiations proved already their uselessness. We will be respected again only if we reverse the situation. Let the Arab be terrorized by the consequences of their acts . They should be the one to implore for peace. They should be the one to judge their rulers for corruption. They should be the one to arrest and imprison their terrorists. They should be the one to fight for education budgets . They should be the one to fight for them self for food, energy, medical care.
5. #2 What are you talking about?
Aharon   (05.17.08)
Do you even understand what you are talking about? The minute Israel kills the Hamas leadership the new leadership will make an example of Shalit and have him executed. The government has to show the people that the lives of our soldiers are NOT expendable, and we will do ANYTHING to get them back. If we throw away our soldiers' lives like dirt, how can we complain when people begin to lose faith in the army and dodge their service?
6. Israel in control of the Egypt-Gaza border crossing.
Robert Bernier ,   Tel Aviv   (05.17.08)
Israel should make no concessions to Hamas. The Egypt-Gaza border crossing should be exclusively under the control of Israel. The only second possibility should be the free choice of the inhabitant of Gaza to emigrat to other Arab countries (most of these countries are not very populated and can easily integrate them). The time has come for these people to stop with politics and terrorism and search for a solution for their families based on well-being and peace. That is the real solution as explained at : http://xrl.us/bi5c8
7. Subborness? STUBBORNESS???
The Doc ,   Haifa, Israel   (05.17.08)
Hamas claims that Israel's refusal to capitulate to its terms is "stuborness". Well, judging by the many ouvertures for Peace that Israel has made with the Palestinians, only to be stabbed in the back and have all the agreements trampled with impunity by terrorists, I suggest Israel is entitled to a certain "stubborness" and suspicion. Add to that the fact that Hamas is a terrorist organization which has gained power in Gaza following a terrorist coup, and you get the idea that when dealing with terrorists, stubborness is a must. Hamas AGAIN is missing an oportunity to save itself and instead is inviting Israel to destroy it and reduce all its arsenal and terrorist forces it has ammassed during the last two years. But this has been the story of the Palestinians: they've never failed to refuse Peace and opportunity to build a state. They have been misled by their terrorist leaders with the promise that their state will raise with the destruction of Israel. Since Israel is quite hard to destroy, Palestinians have been living in poverty and desperation - both a result of terrorist activities and funds being transferred to private coffers of Terror Lords and for buying weapons. Their "struggle" is deemed to fail and in the process they will destroy generations upon generations of young palestinians. When eventually they will have a state, they will not have any doctors, engineers or teachers to develop it - only a pathetic bunch of jobless terrorists who know only how to murder, rape and lie, and a gang of crazed, analphabet, fanatical clerics who know only to incite. Not the best foundation for a young state.
8. GAZA OFFENSIVE UNAVOIDABLE, ISRAEL MUST RETAKE STRIP
David P. ,   Santa Cruz, USA   (05.17.08)
it is impossible to secure Israel without securing Gaza
9. Hamas mus go
AlbertoGa ,   Houston, USA   (05.17.08)
Hamas has no intention to release Shalit. Actualy they would like to get more Israelis for their Jails. Gaza is like a gangrine to Israel and the Palestinians. It is a question of time to amputate. But I wonder if Mr. Olmert and Livni are serious about a permanent solution.
10. Give us Shalit
Matityahu ,   Slovenia   (05.17.08)
or face the concequences, you savages...
11. #8 David - Israel was not secure when it had troops in Gaza
A Bethlehemite   (05.17.08)
Militants still fired rockets into Israel before Israel withdrew its troops. What we need is a just solution; one state one vote or 2 states. no one is going anywhere. Almighty sharon and is occupational forces for years couldnt stop the resistance in the WB or Gaza. The situation will never change unless that just solution is in place
12. Get Shalit Back, then Blast Hamas
Joe Kaufman ,   Formerly Jerusalem   (05.17.08)
We owe Hamas nothing. Get Shalit back. Then blast Hamas. Negotiating a lull for them to strengthen is utter stupidity. I can understand this tactic to get Shalit back, but not as a policy that restrains our actions. When, not if, we confront Iran, Hamas will explode opening another front. Best wipe them out now when we have the strength and they don't. Unless of course, our leaders are lying (duh) and we don't have the strength.
13. broker's advice to Hamas:
observer   (05.17.08)
try to get a couple more Shalits and every thing will be easy for EVERYBODY.
14. #6 why can't Israel take controle of Egypt-Gaza border
observer   (05.17.08)
-during the second intifada, Israel, in a bid to have stronghold the Philadelphia root, demolished tens of Palestinians' homes which brought a world-wide condemnation. In spite of that, soldiers were being killed and tanks blown up. - the few semi-militarize settlements in the occupied Gaza were viewed as legitimate targets. Keeping those settlements was simply costly. -Israel was there in Gaza's heart and borders when Qassams were launched, in fact the rate reached its lower part after the disengagement and surged when Israel resumed incursion. -do Israel really trust its Intelligence about the fighting capabilities in Gaza?; Israel lost the war on Lebanon because of.
15. a reminder
observer   (05.17.08)
will it be better that way? that is like an inauguration of kidnapping dead bodies of soldiers; instead of alive ones. Remember the second Intifada in Gaza!
16. Time for Disengagement Part 2 Epilogue
Squalid Ibn Harman ,   Qtir   (05.17.08)
Now that the Israelis that were in Gaza are no longer in Harm's Way, it is time for Disengagement Part 2: Epilogue where we disengage the PAL Terrorists and their supporters from Gaza.
17. Can we give Olmert to Hamas as part of the trade?
Squalid Ibn Harman ,   Qtir   (05.17.08)
18. # 4 Dr. D
Ali ,   Gaza prison   (05.17.08)
You always look to one side of the fact .. why Israel retain this huge no. of palestinians in jails ? are they all have blood in hands !!..what about the Israelies with blood in Hands ??.. Shalit was kidnapped during a battle for a simple reason, to exchange prisoners.. but why you retain and kidnap Palestinians .. most of them are civilians some are women, the lady parliment member kidnapped last month from her house !!! is she a terrorist ??..and you have to reconsider thedefinition of terror ..Palestinians are victims, this is a fact , I am a palestinan live among the palestinians in Gaza and see the suffering resulted due to Israeli agression since 1948 .resistance to restore rights and prisoners is terror !!! As for corruption..it is not a palestinain case ..inIsrael Olmert is now accused and the ex -president was involved in sexual harrasment !!!
19. Hamas is in control
shaul ,   Israel   (05.17.08)
This is ridiculus! Why should we bow down to what the terrorists say!
20. A quetion????
Ali ,   Ramallah-Falasteen   (05.17.08)
How about the 3.5 million people whom countrymen are kidnapped in the Palestine? There is one gate for peace in the middle east: Full Freedom and Just deal for the Palestinian issue. Otherwise, keep dreaming.
21. gaza
Doron   (05.17.08)
israel must divide the strip into 4-5 segments and take control of gaza/egypt border. no freedom of movement between these two areas. no lull or ceasefire, these are ways that hamas can squirm out of harms way to lower the pressure when it needs to and raise it later.
22. Best Idea yet
Dan ,   Titusville, FL USA   (05.17.08)
23. #11 ISRAEL NOT ESTABLISHED TO INCORPORATE ARAB STATE
David P. ,   Santa Cruz, USA   (05.17.08)
democracy does not work for Islam, because so many are arabs are muslim, they cannot possibly have a vote, because they will only vote by Islamic law. Israel can incorporate some muslims, but only a minority. If its democracy you arabs seek, go establish it in the 20 other arab countries that surround Israel. Bethlehem is in Israel, if you want equality demand it from Jordan, that is the country of your previous origin. You can continue to live under Israeli rule or move somewhere else in the 99.9% of the land the arabs occupy throughout the middle east.
24. to no 20
fish ,   tel-aviv   (05.17.08)
you're not ready to have a state. You should quit dreaming. You only excel in murdering Jews, but that's hardly a basis for having your own state from the JEWS. Ref kidnapping - you're your own worst enemies. You stole future from your children and yourselves alike.
25. #23
Hani ,   Palestine   (05.17.08)
We Palestinians aren't going anywhere. But you, go back to Russia, New York, and Poland. You are NOT welcome here. celebrate your 60th birthday and colony here, while it lasts! We all know what happened to the crusades. Yours, history will prove, will last a few more years.
26. Ali , ..........Gaza "prison"
Charles   (05.17.08)
and I thought you would sit on candleight without elecricity for months now stupid me
27. Ali , ....Ramallah-Falasteen
Charles   (05.17.08)
is ok, no Pali "state" whatsoever. Hope dumb Kadima and Barak donĀ“t capitulate to your Saudi Bush buddies.
28. hopes for Shalit's return..
Alex ,   UK   (05.17.08)
..might be over. It looks like no sign of life was given despite repeated requests through mediators. The same story with two soldiers captured in Lebanon. No sign of life. Give 'em hell.
29. To 6 , don't watch too much sincefiction movies ...LOL
(05.17.08)
30. To The Doc: Israel Must Wake Up
Dave Levy ,   Burbank. CAUSA   (05.17.08)
To: The Doc:: This is partly Israel's fault by giving the Arabs an in. I have been advocating for years, since the 1st Intifada, that Israel incorporate capital punishment, an "Eye for an eye". Since the Orthodox rule Israel's marriage, divorce, conversions, why don't they pressure the gov't for hanging this Pals scum, the ones who murder, and are accomplices to murder. A failed attempt is 25 to life..so no chance of 72 virgins. Eichmann was the last and ONLY enemy of Israel punished this way for his crime. When Jews are made captive, from their own land, Israel should have carpet bomb 24/7 until released...if killed, then it's all out war. At this rate, with docile Livni, and Barak and Olmert acquiescing to Bush (Condi) and hearing nice speeches which mean nothing, except fodder for Obama and the US media, Israel will lose this war. Now we learn that thousands of rockets WILL in deed hit Israel's civilian population centers..in any new war. Israel wake up for G-ds sake.It's your necks on the line. You have the power, but not the will.
Next talkbacks
Back to article