News
Israeli accused of relaying information to Iran
Vered Luvitch
Published: 25.05.08, 15:05
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
37 Talkbacks for this article
1. ynet,stop putting pictures of this monkey! thank you.
stephane ,   france   (05.25.08)
2. death penalty for collaberators of the enemy!
Elmer Fudd   (05.25.08)
3. to israel
evangelist ,   israel supporter   (05.25.08)
can u please hang this traitor? like eichmann? ok?
4. spying
Edithann ,   USA   (05.25.08)
So what should the US do with those two traitores giving secrets to Israel through AIPAC? Should the US hang Pollard and these two Bozos too?
5. And still no death penalty?
Arie ,   BaGolan   (05.25.08)
6. Hang him.
Talula ,   Israel   (05.25.08)
7. #4- Key words: Enemy State
LEE ,   NY, USA   (05.25.08)
8. he is only following example of suicidal leadership
Marcel ,   Florida   (05.25.08)
Is it really any surprise that under the weak and defeatist leadership of Olmert who only knows three words ,retreat,surrender appease that we see major cracks across the foundations of Israel. Why fight and give ones life for Israel when her cowardly leaders give it up for no peace ? What else is happening that they are hiding from us ?
9. Don't forget to place a HUGE KIPPAH
dosiya   (05.25.08)
on his head, as usual.
10. to the evangelist...we don't have the death penalty...
(05.25.08)
We have a really good security system backed up by the mighty Hand of G-d! He takes care of Israel just fine without the death penalty. You do of course remember that the Almighty gave us the 10 commandments which include "Thou Shalt NOT kill!"
11. EdithAnn good question 4 the extremist TBers here!
(05.25.08)
of course they won't answer because they are all twisted up in their wierd philosophical views
12. Cleared for publication but as clear as mud.
Persian CAT   (05.25.08)
Since the "source" of this news is Israeli intel and military, I doubt it's true at all - even the guy's face is blurred while pictures of other alleged "spies" are not altered when published! My guess is either this guy was an Israeli agent but was "turned" by the Iranian intel, or the whole thing is a harassment campaign of the Iranian Jews who live in Israel because too many of them have maintained ties with the families in their ancestral land, Iran. Besides, a lot of Iranian Jews have openly opposed Zionism and its crimes against humanity. That alone is reason to invoke the wrath of the Apartheid regime.
13. #7. Friends don't spy on each other!
Persian CAT   (05.25.08)
Why does Israel have the need to spy against the US?
14. Anon. 11 and edithann
bar ,   israel   (05.25.08)
Iran is an ENEMY state , not only of us , but also for all the democratic countries . Israel is not an enemy state for the USA . That's the difference .
15. Prision
Tomas ,   Bsas, Argentina   (05.25.08)
Death sentences or hanging in public places, maybe Rabin Square? What are you talking about? are you people serious??? THAT IS WHAT THE NAZIS DO, AND THE IRANIANS DO, and what the Afgans did.... do you think a Democracy can do the same??? amazing.. just put him behind bars for the rest of his life. long live israel
16. cremation
observer   (05.25.08)
Eichman was hanged to death in Israel and his remains cremated and disposed in the sea outside Israel's territories. Is cremation Okay for a Jewish spy? but what about the ash, will it pose any ecological problem? time has changed!
17. scat! persian cat! we don't want u here!
(05.25.08)
18. #14 a spy is a spy is a spy! Pollard is a spy just like...
(05.25.08)
this guy. Being a traitor against your country is being a traitor against your country. Pollard was a traitor against his country and that's why he's in jail.
19. Death to this spy but freedom for Polard!
Al ,   US   (05.25.08)
You guys are hypocrites!
20. Re: 12
Israeli LION   (05.25.08)
What is a Persian CAT doing in an Israeli lair? Trying to demoralize Israelis and Jews by spreading Iranian propaganda and laughable self-delusions? Trying to satisfy an abiding interest in Israel?
21. #13
your judge   (05.25.08)
consider it "checking" on them for continuous loyalty. israel's is still allive because its trust comes with safe distance. people like u for example are considered enemy (to human kind), look out the window, maybe we're already spying on you?
22. # 12 Why Are You Here?
(05.25.08)
If you don't trust Israeli sources why would you come to an Israeli news site. Why get yourself upset reading things you know you won't believe. Hence, I don't read Arab (including "Persians") publications.
23. No. 13
(05.25.08)
Since you seem to be so obsessed with everything that goes on in Israel, it's surprising to find out you haven't got a clue as to why Jonathan Pollard felt compelled to do what he did. And as far as friends not spying on each other, I have a news flash for you. EVERYBODY spies on everybody else, and allies spy on each other all the time. But, for some reason, the Jonathan Pollard affair was made into more of a goddamn big deal than even the cases involving Robert Hanssen and Aldrich Ames, who did irrevocable damage to the U.S. when they were spying for the Soviets.
24. Persian CAT needs something
Persian TARSIER ,   Tuhran   (05.25.08)
Persian CAT needs zybi fertyzi ASAP. Anyone not squeamish.
25. aw, poor widdle pwersian pudi-tat
Tweeti-Pie   (05.25.08)
wotsup feline, you think we dont know of the outrage so many decent Iranians are reeling in, in Iran, while AhMADijamonkeywanker continues to drag your once great nation into complete isolation, and possible (& very probable) oblivion? Yes, flea-bitten one, you really should lerk in the TBs of your local sites, and piss off from here!
26. To all who responded to my post, the reason why...
Persian CAT   (05.25.08)
I read Israeli media is because the Iranian media is worthless. The media in Iran is either government controlled or closed for not toeing the official line. Even the "progressive" ones have not tradition of talkback! I have always said I think Israel must be recognized once it limit itself to its 1967 borders and compensate the Palestinians for the properties taken from them by terrorizing them or otherwise. The ME will not see peace unless both Zionism and Islamism, which are two sides of the same coin are ERADICATED. Jews and Moslems have live with one anther in peace before, they can do it again. Can anyone tell me why the identity of this "spy" cannot be shown even after to more than two weeks of incarceration?! Israeli military has not been shy before to release the unadulterated picture of other people accused of "spying" for Iran before. Why this time, if harassment is not the only objective?!
27. To Persian CAT,
Roman ,   Lod, Israel   (05.25.08)
Friendly states spy on each other - it's been a fact of life since the dawn of time, because each state will always look to its own interest first, and to its friend's interest second. Sometimes that creates a conflict of interests - quite apparent when the US Navy Intel didn't bother to pass on information to Israel regarding Syria's cheamical weapon stockpiles, or when Israel sold technology to China that didn't quite fit with what the US wanted witheld from the People's Republic. As for your claims regarding Shin Bet and the army - bullshit. As is your "evidence", as I've seen many blurred faces in the press when it's in the initial phases of the investigation. It's done so the press doesn't become judge and jury, and also for security reasons - when you don't want certain friends or family to see the suspect's face. Oh and please, read up on what Apartheid is. When we put our Arab, Bedoin, Druze, Circeccean, Baha'i etc. population into special zones, refuse them the vote, and push them out of being judges, members of parliament etc, *then* you may call us an Apartheid state. Oh, and how are the Baha'i in *your* country doing? Still treated like dirt, beaten up, and officially discriminated against at every state institute, and their graveyards torn down by the Islamist youths? And how are the gays, eh? Still being hanged at the nearest crane?
28. # 26
(05.25.08)
His identity may be concealed to protect his family who can't be held liable.They may have shown pictures of spies before but was it before or after their conviction? And did revealing their images to the public cause problems that they decided not to do it again? I don't know. But I don't see pixelating a face as harrassment. "Jews and Moslems have live with one anther in peace before, they can do it again." From what I've read Jews in Persia were happier before Islam came to their country. As for living peacefully together, do you really need me to cut and paste the dates of the periodic porgrams that occured in the Muslim world against Jews throughout every century that Islam's been around. Neded I write out the apartheid like Pact of Umar? Give me a break. ps. Not trusting the Iranian media is not a good explanation as to why you come to an Israeli site. Especially when the source for alot of Israeli news is the government and the IDF - two groups you said you don't trust
29. At the minimum he should rot in jail for life like Pollard
David Cohen ,   NY, NY USA   (05.26.08)
A traitor is a traitor, and if he does not get the death penalty, he should at least rot in jail for the rest of his life just like Johathan Pollard shall for betraying my country.
30. Roman, et al. The diff is the Iranian regime has never...
Persian CAT   (05.26.08)
claimed it is a democracy. At least the Iranian regime is an equal opportunity oppressor that does not persecute solely based on ethnic and religious backgrounds of the people it does not like - Bahais are an exception. Israel on the other hand, even discriminates among the Jews. The Sephardi Jews are treated as the second class comparing to the Ashkenazis and the Arab/Muslims are officially at the bottom of the social strata despite all the Zionist claims of "democracy" and human rights. Iran has not been receiving millions of dollars of the hapless and increasing impoverished American tax payers money for "sharing democratic and human right values" of the West! The charades are coming to an end and you guys know it. The world without Zionism and Islamism will be a much better place for all.
Next talkbacks
Back to article