Opinion
Tzipi's race to the top
Attila Somfalvi
Published: 31.05.08, 11:39
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
31 Talkbacks for this article
1. Israel needs a LEADER - not Livni
Caroline ,   Israel   (05.31.08)
Tzipi Livni is where she is now only by the strange turn of fate. The fate which pushed her to jump first after Olmert into Arik Sharon's Kadima wagon. Apart of this quick move and her presumably clean hands she has nothing to justify her aspirations for the Prime Minister's chair. Her "clean hands" reputation is oversized by those who intend to pull on the puppet PM strings in future. Do we need a puppet PM after a crook PM? I certainly don't! We should look for a LEADER with strong personnality and strong views - not a cautious yesman or yeswoman who, it seems to me, is moving forward only when pushed from behind by interested people.
2. Ms Livni - clever, clean and charismatic
sheila ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (05.31.08)
Having heard Ms Livni speak at the president's Conference I understood that she was the only leader to speak on the subject given,(Bibi, Barak and Yishai were the others) to keep to the time limit and to keep her audence enthralled. I was convinced that she is the only one who can "do it"
3. "Olmert is not going anywhere" ? - what drivel!
redmiike ,   TA - LA - London   (05.31.08)
I thought that maybe this article was written a few days ago but the date at the top is today's. So one can only imagine that Attila Somfalvi spends little time reading or watching the news. Ramon announced yesterday, "elections by November" and Mazuz made it clear 3 days ago that he expects to charge Olmert with money laundering very shortly. Mazuz separated the money laundering from the other offenses that will be add later because of the political instability that is being caused. I am still suprised by the ignorance that is shown by almost all of ynets supposed journalists. I shouldn't be of course, because the expression 'if you pay peanuts you get monkeys" obviously but sadly applies. Mike
4. Livni is totally inept
Jay3 ,   Israel   (05.31.08)
Her track record is proof. She has done absolutely NOTHING! I distinctly remember her poor performance during the last Lebanese war. She only went in front of the cameras twice and hardly defended Israels situation. She never refuted any Hezbollah false claims of atrocities. Also she disgracefully refuses to speak to the kidnapped soldiers parents and has no regard for anyone but herself.. I have no problem with a woman PM, but Livni is no Golda and we need strength through deterrence.....not the foolish weak appeasing stance Livni supports!
5. She's no good. Wants to give away "land for peace" too
DOOMHAM   (05.31.08)
6. here not a man in israel?
augustine e johnson ,   Birmingham-usa   (05.31.08)
here not a man in israel? == cant you elect a man from the likud? have you never heard of netanyahu =============shalom===========augustine e johnson-usa
7. Tzipi rethink
alex   (05.31.08)
She could be good if she rethought the whole oslo which is bunk and discredited. s well she needs to work out with weights to toughen her will. Last year's manoever was weak and pathetic on her part.Olmert clearly has some sway because Liberman did not call him the coward on the inside. Even when he left he simply said it is a government of wimps but not attack olmert. Right now, israel should look at the whole arab issue as one of truces. forget about peace. As for demorgraphics which drives the peace agenda s o much, stop being hysterical. Programs should be encouraged to have arabs move to jordan. Face facts, the only reason why arabs came to palestine and now israel is to follow the jews for jobs and the good life. The hypocrites in east jerusalem say they want a PLO state yet they want to remain israeli so they can collect benefits. In the meantime, the education system on the west bank shoul be forcibly changed to say the truth and good things about israel.
8. #6 Are you serious? A man? Bibi?
Sheila ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (05.31.08)
Oh Number 6, you are clearly a long long way from israel because if you were here you would know that emancipation ofwomen has been in place for some time!!! If someone has balls to run this incredible country and stop the infighting which worsens the outfighting then we do not check if they are actual! Maggie Thatcher was more of a man than any male in her cabinet - Ms. Livni too!!!
9. to those who support livni
fad egypt   (05.31.08)
the problem is not man or woman the problem that livni is nothing except of a weak woman who doesnt deserve to be called leader do you thing that she will bring end to kassams sharon failed to do so will livni successed ?!! will she successed in facing iran and prevent it from aquiring nuclear weapons livni which surrendered to the un in 2006 in which she agreed to cease fire without at least bringing home the soldiers will she successed ?? and will she succeded in what she is doing now with the talking with the palestinian the answer is NO NO NO because she is weak she is no golda or tatcher or even a chrismatic leader and also all kadima leaders are the same like her the only solution is BIBI and the likud and if limor livnat is strong enough and is leading the likud i will say the solution is the likud and livnat so the problem is not man or woman the problem is in kadima livni labor barak they are the same i think that if livni continued with talking with the palistinians regardless of the fighting of terror the intifada will break out abbas has said that if talks fail he will try somthing else !!!!!!!!!!!!!!! shalom vote likud please for the sake of israel i would like to say that olmert is stronger than livni and she is also corrupted she wants him to resign while she sitting the coalition to replace him without election and now when the polls begin to be in favor of her she wants election she is political oppertunist while BIBI is not corrupted if he is so he would be in jail now i ve read before that BIBI refused high salary in the US during 1970s and prefered to return to israel to the money he is a real leader shalom
10. Amen to Livni
Tikva   (05.31.08)
Hooray Sheila! I totally agree with you. At this moment, if anyone can do this job, it's Livni. Bibi and Barak had their chance and failed.
11. #8 It's ridiculous to compare Livni to Thatcher!
Caroline ,   Israel   (05.31.08)
12. Will she be as strong as Golda?
Daniel ,   Israel   (05.31.08)
13. It's about leadership , not sex
efi ,   jerusalem   (05.31.08)
Although many women may want to see Livni as the new PM (look how many women vote for Hillary Clinton just because she is not a man), Livni is no leader. Unfortunately, neither are Barak, Netanyahu or any other candidate in these parties. Whoever becomes our next PM will be as bad or worse than Olmert , who was worse than Sharon. Livni's record may be cleaner, but she has no solution to our country's problems. She will never reach an agreement with the Palestinians. She is indifferent to our captives, our brothers and sisters in Sderot and Ashkelon, the homeless of Gush Katif, and the countless Jews who want to make aliyah from countries like Ethiopia, Mexico, Afghanistan etc.
14. #11 I know both of them and it is quite logical!!!!
sheila ,   Jerusalem   (05.31.08)
15. #14 If you know Thatcher, than you know she would NEVER give
your land away!! ,   Manchester, England!   (05.31.08)
16. Tzipi's race to the top
(05.31.08)
# 14 sheila do us all a favor go home to australia
17. livni
sas ,   israel   (05.31.08)
A BiG MISTAKE. THE WOMAN IS NOT HONEST AND IS GOOD FOR NOTHING.
18. Livni is nothing Sheila, less than a minus zero
chanan ,   usa   (05.31.08)
can you detail what are her achievements to qualify her as prime minister for Israel especially during such trying times? Nice talk talk is not enough but even her talking is very confusing. I watched her in one hour long interviews in the US and she could bring herself to make a clear statement why Israel has the right to exist, all in extremely poor English, all the while leaning her head 90 degrees to the right like a mentally disabled person.
19. vote Livni & you get olmert dont be fooled by the dress
zionist forever   (06.01.08)
A vote for Livni is no difference than a vote for Olmert. We wont have the coruption scandals but policy wise she has been backing Olmert all the way on everything from security issues to selling the Golan and dividing Jeruslalem. She is simply Olmert in a dress at the very least we will have an Olmert clone politicily at worst she will be even more left wing and egotistical than Olmert and we are going to be wishing for the good old days when we had a strong PM named Ehud Olmert. She has seen for over a year now that Olmerts living on borrowed time and so she has been playing smart politics. Support Olmerts contrversal policies when it comes to taking votes in the Knesset but dont , now and again criticise the boss to get noticed by the right in Israel and hope they will see you as primeminister material. and make yourself look like a woman withe her own ideas but dont try to look to right wing so the left like you and dont push Olmert to far to ensure you dont get pushed asside. Olmert has been the public face of all the contreversial and unpopular policies while she has said nothing publicly let him be the scapegoat for poilces she supports. While he is still PM let Olmert create a situation on the ground by making all the unpopular decisions but she can later cpme along say this is the reality as it stands its not my decision so dont blame me if its not good for Israel. What she wants most now is Olmert gone but without early ellections, kadima will allmost certainly choose her as the new leader and she can have an entire year as PM to create a power base make herself look like the kind of PM Israel needs. Dont do anything to contreversial ( save that till after the ellection ), clean up Kadima make it look like a part of government, criticise Barak & Natanyahu both former PMS who have made their mistakes while in office. Come ellection time Livni is going to be running a pparty that doesnt stand for coruption, she is whiter than white because she kept a low profile under Olmert and didnt do anything to contrversial before the ellection. The people have a short memory and they will ellect her with a clear majority ... this woman is no fool when it comes to politcal ambision. She might be exactly what we dont need but she wants the job and knows how to sell herself and once she has the job we are going to have to put up with her just like we have had to put up with Olmert because we voted for him.
20. 2
zionist forever   (06.01.08)
Its because she doesnt say or do anything in public that she looks ellectable. Say nothing and there is nothing to criticise... Barak & Natanyahu have both had their time as PM and both made some good decisions and some bad ones but they do have a history and when you have a history the opposition has something to use against you. Livni is a newcomer, she has kept her nose clean and head down what can the opposition say its Olmert who was PM not her... behind the scenes though she just happened to support all the contreversial and damaginf policies Olmert was the public face of making. Let Olmert take all the blame in public while I stay behind the scenes supporting all his policies and prepare for power. Once she is ellected politicly we will get another Olmert who will sell off the entire country cheap for a legacy or if possible a woman who will make Olmert look like the kind of leader Israel needs.
21. Livni: The final nail in Israel's coffin
Dr. Dave ,   USA   (06.01.08)
Intern of Foreign Affairs & Queen of Surrender will destroy Israel beyond recognition.
22. chanan #18: What you do not understand.
Steve ,   Fla.   (06.01.08)
Sheila speaks for the vast majority of the Jews in Israel. Don't you understand Ehud Olmert was popularly elected by the Jews in Israel? Sheila is tired of fighting. She is tired of winning. She is tired of being courageous, etc.
23. #14 Livni is climbing to the top of Mount NO-WHERE!!
Shlomo ,   Israel   (06.01.08)
24. livni
sad ,   israel   (06.01.08)
she lacks everything that it takes to be prime minister. she is dull., dumb, has no courage to do anything, no vision to think of the future. she is not corrupt......... (so far) but will totally ruin the state of israel. she has no personalllity and we have seen what she has done to the ministry of foreign affairs. why don't people open up their eyes??????she basically lacks everything that it takes to be a real leader. to make it short she is GOOD FOR NOTHING. Can someone write me what she did as Minister of Justice and as Foreign Minister?????? Everytime there was a problem she kept her mouth shut or said the wrong thing.
25. #16
Jay3 ,   Israel   (06.01.08)
Maybe shes in Israel because Australia doesnt want her.
26. No to Livni, No to the leftists!
nachum ,   golan   (06.01.08)
If our people are going to be dumb enough to elect leftists again, then our country is going to be in grave danger of destruction. Livni has the same exact corrupt, treasonous agenda as Olmert. And that is to give Israel away piece by piece until the Palestinians stop attacking. And that point can only come when there is no Israel. Giving land to enemies brings worthless peace. Just look at Egypt! It was a complete failure. We should have held onto Sinai. Look at Gaza! Another failure! Look at the PA in Judea and Samaria, FAILURE. There cannot be peace unless we work to remove the Arab terror from Jewish land. SAY NO TO THE LEFTISTS! SAY YES TO LIKUD!
27. What qualifications does she have?
Rami ,   London   (06.01.08)
What has she ever accomplished? Has an IQ test ever been administered to her? What were the results?
28. Only diference between her and olmert are boobs and PMS.
Bunnie Meyer ,   Santa Monica,CA USA   (06.01.08)
29. Question for Attila or anybody
Haim ,   New York   (06.02.08)
Did Livni knew about Olmert's cash, pens, houses, and other dealings? Bill Clinton's wife never knew that Bill had a girlfriend (s).
30. Livni is a corrupt, substandard Drekess
The Historian ,   Raananana   (06.02.08)
Next talkbacks
Back to article