Jewish Scene
Neo-Nazis for Israel
Eldad Beck
Published: 04.06.08, 12:35
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
56 Talkbacks for this article
31. whats the problem?
Ephraim ,   NYC/Kfar Tapuah   (06.05.08)
If they are honest and don't hate Jews, i don't see a problem accepting their support.
32. To Jake #21. I agree with you.
Maansingh ,   The Netherlands   (06.05.08)
Jake, I agree with you. To propagate racial purity is the most STUPID idea ever preached in the world. There NEVER was a country with a pure race in the PAST ; at the PRESENT moment there is NO country with a pure race ; NOR will there EVER be a country consisting of a pure race in the FUTURE !!! TO yearn for a country of pure race -- is just PURE stupidity, it is just PURE pie in the sky. The preachers of pure race have committed the MOST heinous, MOST abominable crimes against humanity EVER in history !!! Preachers of pure race are NOT pure persons themselves !!! They are the MOST obnoxious persons walking on the surface of the earth !!!
33. The joke's on you
Kyle ,   Southpark, CO, USA   (06.05.08)
My sometimes "friend" Eric Cartman created this website and you people fell for it.
34. 31 That's Sad
Thomas   (06.05.08)
You don't see a problem with allying yourself with Neo-Nazis as long as they don't hate us? There's a Swedish Christian living in Jaffa, who changed his name to Israel Shamir who has spent his whole life writing anti-Jewish propaghanda. Two members of the PLO told him that they don't appreciate his support because they feel their cause is just and don't want to associate with a racist. You should have such principles.
35. If hatred could power turbines
Kevin ,   England   (06.05.08)
this talkback column alone could put a dent in the world energy crisis. Pity it can only power war and revenge.
36. #26 - Johnny
Michael ,   Belgium   (06.05.08)
Johnny, with this logic commies are right wing, because North Korea has "democratic" word in it's name.
37. You do their work for them.
LuFri ,   USA   (06.05.08)
Can you see no simularities between the current situations; increase in anti-Jew feelings, seperation wall, etc., etc., etc. and the Warsaw ghetto? No simularities at all?
38. Pure Blooded
Red Sonja ,   Beijing   (06.05.08)
The Chinese ARE the most pure blooded race in the world today - this is why they all look the same - FACT
39. # 37 Nope. No Simularities
Thomas   (06.05.08)
Germany didn't put Jews in ghettos to prevent terror attacks. Jews didn't have 22 countries of their own to go to. The Warsaw ghetto didn't have more NGOs than all of Africa and Asia put together.
40. #39, RE #37, "Simularities", LOL, that's a good one
Jake   (06.05.08)
41. 39
LuFri   (06.05.08)
By building the wall are you not putting yourselves in the ghetto?
42. Welcome friends!
Moysh ,   USA   (06.05.08)
WE must accept all those who wish to be our friends. The left is our real enemy.
43. Racial Purity
Mike ,   USA   (06.05.08)
Racial, national, or ethnic purity are not rational goals. In light of the wars and millions of deaths caused by this nonsense, you would think people should have learned. In nature mutts fare better than the pedigreed. Multi-racial and multi-cultural is better than "in-bred". Too shallow a gene pool leads to nasty diseases like Tay-Sachs, sickel cell anemia, or the many diseases of the Amish. Barak Obama is a robust symbol of what diverse "bloodlines" can produce. Sign me "post-religious" Russian Jew intermarried to "post-religious" woman of German/Irish extraction. Our story is pretty common these days.
44. To Sonja #38. Red Blood.
Maansingh ,   The Netherlands   (06.05.08)
China became conquered by the Mongols -- and they melted. (BTW the Mongols had the BIGGEST empire in history covering over 33 million sq. km., or 22% of the Earth's total land area). Later on the Mantsjoe people conquered China -- and they melted. To a lesser extent the Koreans also mixed with the Chinese. And more recently the Japanese conquered a big chunk of China in the 30s and 40s -- and also left behind their DNA in China. SO Sonja, you ARE wrong about the Chinese !! BTW regarding blood. Caucasian people have the same blood like the African people, the same blood like the Mongol people. ALL of them, without exception, have red blood. NONE of them has green, blue, or any other colour, blood. Sonja, I hope you have some biology knowledge.
45. Flirting with the "lesser evil"
Valery Novoselsky ,   Brussels, Belgium   (06.05.08)
It simply means that Islam and ethnic Muslims for the extreme rights in Germany became much more "dangerous", then the Jews. That`s why they have recently started to flirt with the idea of support to Zionizm.
46. # 40 Don't Be So Easily Amused
Thomas   (06.06.08)
47. No. 34 Thomas
NYC Girl   (06.06.08)
There's something you should know about groups like the PLO. The only reason they would eschew the support of somebody like this "Israel Shamir" is because they were afraid it might make them look bad. Believe me, they have no problem with Nazis. It's the same reason why they'll publicly (and never in Arabic, by the way) decry acts of terrorism against Israeli civilians. It's not because they find it morally repugnant to slaughter innocent Israelis. Their only concern is that committing such such atrocities might hurt their cause.
48. Racial purity eh?
Golani ,   canada   (06.06.08)
Gee ive got Native blood and white man blood and raised jewish so where does that leave me?DO i follow the hebrews?The natives ?or the white man?No i follow the law of G-d and justice.I help the meek and poor not put myself on a pedastel and declare myself superior to others by race.My home is Earth.My blood is red.My cause is justice for all.I will fight for the jews,the natives and fight INJUSTICE where ever it may be.As a native i know all too well about broken promises and peace treaties.I also know what happens when people do nothing in the face of dictators and those who promote "racial purity", terror on innocents or dhimmitude.I will not bow to Islam just because some kooky cleric says so?Lebanese Cleric Abd Al-Karim Fadhlallah claims natives spoke to columbus in arabic.What a crock!Natives have there a own language!No the bullsheet stops here and now!
49. This was inevitable
Alon ,   Canada   (06.06.08)
In today's Europe Muslims are a much more prominent minority than Jews ever were and they are not integrating. It was inevitable that the main target of hatred would be Muslims and not Jews. This is furthered by the fact that most neo-Nazis come from poorer social backgrounds and likely encounter more competition in the work place from immigrants. It's inevitable that these idiots would eventually warm up to Israel because its at the forefront of the fight against radical Islam. Does any of that justify blind hatred? (Note: I write hatred not racism because the Muslims are not a race) No.
50. The enemy of my enemy is my friend?
watchinlistenin ,   USA   (06.06.08)
My sentiment exactly.
51. Actually-Listen to them carefully
watchinglistening ,   USA   (06.06.08)
I agree with some of your points. I don't know about Europe exploding but there are quite a few problems brewing in America as it pertains to racial issues and tensions. These people are slimy to even try to play up to the Jews now but I believe they have a motive and it is based in continued hate and their believed entitlement to have this society that preserves them and squats on everyone else.
52. New Enemy Replaces Jews (Re#45)
Christy ,   Boston, US   (06.09.08)
It seems they are fine with Jews being out of Europe and in Israel. They support the Jewish state because Jews can leave Europe and go to their own country. Also, Jews may be helpful in their fight against their perceived 'New Enemy'.... the Muslims. A 'New Enemy' has replaced the Jews. The Muslims that live in Europe, and are immigrating to Europe, are perceived as THE threat now. There is some concern that demographics will give Muslims the political upper hand in about 10 years or so. Many Europeans believe they are losing their culture NOW because of Muslims. Neo-Nazis seem pretty much as always .. haters of all but the 'pure'. They've just changed a bit of their window-dressing.
53. first of april was a long time ago , nazis....
Ariel ,   Brazil   (06.10.08)
the nazis are trying to make the jewish community more relaxed about the extreme right....but dont be fooled by those retards. By the way, it is ridiculous the fact that the extreme right still exists, it will only create instability among a continent that is already fine
54. Is this April fools day?
rachel ,   usa   (06.14.08)
55. #32 The japaneese are pretty pure
(06.14.08)
56. #37 no , no similarities at all. What a joke of a question
rachel ,   usa   (06.14.08)
Previous talkbacks
Back to article