News
Olmert listens to Karnit, and weeps
Roni Sofer
Published: 30.06.08, 01:52
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
81 Talkbacks for this article
61. Olmert wept?
Arie ,   BaGolan   (06.30.08)
The ONLY time olmert weeps is when a withdrawal is made from his swiss bank acct
62. Sorry, I AGREE with Sidney 14. The chances that the ....
Stewart ,   USA   (06.30.08)
soldiers are alive are next to nothing. If the policy is not to bargain with terorist, then one does not bargain with terrorists unless the deal is so good that one suffers essentially no lose or does not encourage the chance of future loses. This is exactly what this will do so we are sacrificing others in the future as well. How can anyone in their right mind offer a deal like this for soildiers with no proof that they are alive? How can anyone in all fairness critcize those harshly who ask for something so reasonable when the safety and live of future soldiers are at stake. THIS IS ONE BIG OLMERT - NO BACKBONE - BLUNDER. What is so difficult about asking them for proof if they want someone living.
63. Regev and Goldwasser were not MIA but were kidnapped
Asher ,   NY, USA   (06.30.08)
in a raid by Hizbollah and as the result they were killed. Hizbullah did it to use them in the bargain but they could not manage to keep them alive. But now they are getting Kuntar back LIVE and his going back safe and sound to his family. Where is justice here? Why should Kuntar goes back alive? He is a criminal in the first place and why should Hizbollah and a criminal get rewarded so highly? Is this a double or triple price Israel is paying for loosing the Lebanon War??!! Hizbollah attacked Israel's soil, kidnapped, killed and demnded Kuntar and is getting him back Alive. God knows what this Olmert is up to and what will happen next? If Olmert Knew they were dead why he did not say so months or weeks ago??? Why the families should found that out through the media just in recent days? If the families of the dead soldiers knew much earlier that their loved ones had been killed maybe they were thinking differently and Kuntar had to be kept in Jail for his crimes and Hizbollah wasn't rewarded so highly!! Did they kept the news hidden to be able to make some hidden deals with Hizbollah as if they were doing favor to the victim families???? I hope Karnit and Regev family are really not taken advantaged by Politics in Olmerts government! not
64. Why didn't he do it in the first place?
Canadian Dude ,   Montreal, Canada   (06.30.08)
So now Olmert is admitting that everything he tried and failed to do in 2006 could have been accomplished without firing a single shot? If Kuntar gets freed anyway, why didn't Olmert just make this deal to begin with and get the world to focus on Hezbollah as a terrorist group, the way they did before Israel went ahead and trashed Lebanon? No, not only did he choose to launch an unnecessary war, but he didn't even finish the job once he started it. And now he's trading live pigs for dead bodies... I really feel bad for you guys that you have to live with this moron in charge.
65. Big mistake in a career of big mistakes...
Davod ,   Hartford USA   (06.30.08)
At the appointed hour of exchange, if the two soldiers are not alive, Kuntar must be executed while he's walking towards his friends and family. A single hollow point round to his head from a sniper. Let his gloating compatriots see his head explode before their eyes. If Kuntar is released for 2 corpses, O-L-B have lost their collective minds and Israel will pay a terrible price in the future for Nasrallah made good on his boast that he would free Kuntar. He will be considered Hezbollah's messiah. No Israeli near any border, in any settlement town, at any bus stop, will be safe. This is what O-L-B have accomplished. As for Shalit, if he truly is alive, exchange 1 for 1. 400 terrorists for 1 soldier? No, it was stupid in the past and it's worse now. Let me repeat this in case OLB didn't get it: if at the place of exchange, if the two soldiers are not alive, then Kuntar cannot leave the site alive either.
66. #18, What to call people who allow Hezzbollah to use them
AK   (06.30.08)
I understand their pain, but now no israeli prisoner has a chance of being returned alive. how many parents will be pleased with this outcome? Will Shalit be returned alived now, or will his dead body surfice for the exchange to go through.
67. Olmert is a part of the problem -- Where're Israelis
AK   (06.30.08)
Where is israeli press. Why aren't Israelis in the streets protesting?
68. #12 HAS THE RIGHT IDEA!
(06.30.08)
69. Karnit-selfish and cruel
Susan ,   Kfar Saba   (06.30.08)
Call me insensitive for saying this, but Karnit Goldwasser is cruel and selfish. Although I sympathisze with her loss, she is cruel to the next soldier who gets kidnapped because of this bad deal, cruel to the victims of the next terror attack that these cold blooded killers commit. If dozens more are murdered by these men, what exactly have we accoomplished? Last night my husband said he can't blame her. I said, what will you say when it's your son who gets kidnapped? These two men are dead and there isn't anything we can do for them. All Jewish martyrs go straight to the World to Come, so if they aren't properly buried it's not these worst thing. It would have been better to name a school or street after Regev and Goldwasser. As for Kuntar, he should have been hanged from the highest tree thirty years ago.
70. A decision that might cost many victims.
Robert Bernier ,   Tel Aviv   (06.30.08)
Who will be responsible for the victims killed and injured ant/or kidnaped by the Arab murderers as the consequence of the released Arab prisoners in exchange for Shalit, and the corpse of Regev and Goldwasser? The Shalit family? The Israeli politicians? What will they have to tell to the families of the victims?... Real leaders have plenty of power in the refusal to bargain. A leader should be strong and courageous! More over the problem of kidnaped soldiers at : http://xrl.us/em3de
71. If Gilad is still alive,
Chatich   (06.30.08)
this criminally shortsighted deal tells hamas we will pay the same price if he's dead.
72. dozens dead Lebanese & cluster bombs maps are Israel's bonus
observer   (06.30.08)
73. If you think they are dead...
Daniel ,   Israel   (06.30.08)
why did you have to go through all that hassle? Instead, you should have insisted on getting some signs of life from across the boarder. Now, do not release a signal prisoner unless our boys are safe in third country. Or prepare for another conflict
74. Olmert is a weak and corrupt leader who is bad for Israel
aaron ,   ra'anana   (06.30.08)
75. Olmert slept in his bed, Nasrallah slept in bunker
observer   (06.30.08)
who weeps now wons humiliation. Have you ever seen Olmert weeping at the wailing wall?
76. You are right, #69 - this is selfishness
Millie ,   Israel   (06.30.08)
That the media openly supported all this public weeping and pleading put pressure on an already weak and capitulating gov't. It is positively scandalous that Olmert made a weepy show of it with Karnit. We can feel sorrow for the pain of the families, but allowing them and the media to "run the show" is a huge mistake that will boomerang and bring pain and suffering on all Israelis for a very long time. Only a complete about-face by the government for a restoration of the tough policy of no negotiations for hostages/POWs/KIAs can put a full stop to this tragic charade.
77. who said theives ai'nt got no heart
Al Capone   (06.30.08)
78. how do u know for sure tthat they r dead?
Phoenix ,   Lebanon   (06.30.08)
bcz olmert said so? didn't he lie to u countless times b4? i'm surprised u still believe him objectively speaking, i really wish they r not dead as i really wish the 1100 victims we lost in 2006 aren't either
79. WHy has YNET altered this aricle 3 times?
Jay3 ,   srael   (06.30.08)
Seems weird that originally there was no mention of Olmerts tears! Now the article has been changed.........i say its all lies.....Olmert has no remorse and cannot shed tears!
80. ohlmert weeped
sas ,   israel   (06.30.08)
i do not believe a word the man says and it is doubful that he even has tears to shed. who knows how much he received to put this deal thru. he does nothing for nothng the man is shrew/a crook/a liar and has no feelings for anything or anyone. he must resign and the sooner the better.
81. Hezbollah kidnapped them alive!
Robert Blum ,   New Albany, U.S.A.   (06.30.08)
Hezbollah never intended to give back living Jews to israel. They captured them alive, tortured them, basked in their misery, then murdered them. Hezbollah knows that even Jewish corpses are very valuable to Israel and so trades them as a commodity. The Muslims are a fifth column in every country they infect and breed in. Lest the liberals allow them to over-run, overwhelm and dominate the west, as in France, England, etc. they must be swept out and in the same way they want to destroy the existence of ALL non-Muslims...By fire and by the sword, to paraphrase their unholy Quran. Unite, be courageous against this politicized paganism, non-religion of Islam and destroy them first!
Previous talkbacks
Back to article