News
Pentagon: Israel may attack Iran before 2009
Ynet
Published: 01.07.08, 10:19
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
57 Talkbacks for this article
31. No. 3 Amir
NYC Girl   (07.01.08)
Your comments are very encouraging and most welcome. Years ago, I had several Persian friends, both Muslims and Jews, and I was very fond of all of them. In fact, we used to celebrate Persian New Year together, and so I would love to see a time when perhaps we can all celebrate again.
32. Jimmy Carter, Look What You Have Done
Dave Levy ,   Burbank. CAUSA   (07.01.08)
Bottom LIne: According to latest report by former US Generals, 30m Iranian and 15m Syrians will die in the 1st 3 weeks of an all out Israeli strike. It will be safe on the planet Mars for Iran and Syria. Only 25 nukes will do the job adequately. Israel has thousands of missiles (Jerichos, Popeyes, etc.),, a defense system (Patriots, etc.)..which will ensure success. 1-1.5 Israeli casualties ASSUMING Israel waits for Iran to develop as per this article. So, the time to strike is within the next few weeks in my opinion. Iraqi oil can replace Irans..AND US fleet can reopen the Persian Gulf and Straits. So, Israel go to it..and stop debating.."Strike while the iron is hot" before they (definitely) strike you. At home, we will partrol our neighborhoods for those 40,000 suicide bombers, Iran has threatened to use against Israel and US.
33. May Hashem protect our great pilots!
Efroim ,   Washington DC   (07.01.08)
You have to see this video on youtube about bombing the evil Iran.
34. Unless The Enrichment Stops, Iran Will Be Attacked
David ,   Marietta USA   (07.01.08)
It's simply a question of precisely when, by whom, how many will die, and how can casualties, both civilian and military can be minimized. Bush has the balls but not the political backing to do it, Obama hasn't the political acumen of a chimpanzee (sorry about the racist metaphor, better get used to them), and McCain when he isn't sleep walking is trying to get as many illegal Mexican citizens into the US to do our yard work as possible. Israel's survival depends on Israel, and strangely, Ahmadinejad. But it is coming.
35. WHY CONCENTRATING ON AIR RAID?
MAHMOOD ,   LONDON-UK   (07.01.08)
Didn't we hear about Israeli submarines sailing upto Sea of Oman and releasing their missiles on targets in Iran?Or should we look forward to a combination of both?
36. No.32 Mad Bush has more brain than you idiot!
Mehrdad ,   Tehran, Iran   (07.01.08)
Seems that N0.32 watches Spider man or Super man every night! Wake up! This is real world and REAL IRAN! COME SEE AGAIN AND AGAIN! TEST US AGAIN AND AGAIN! If you're successful in Iraq and Afghanistan then taste Iranian retaliation!! We are ready!
37. #36 Even with all of your bravado,and pompestance you still
off as being small ,   like your leader!!   (07.01.08)
38. Loose lips sink ships
Jake   (07.01.08)
I see the mouths are getting unusually big lately. And,as usual, the media plays along with it.
39. Pentagon Moles
Brod ,   USA   (07.01.08)
Those moles should be locked up for life. They have NO business working in sensitive institutions and serving as Trojan Horse exposing sensitive materials to the world and the enemies.
40. MEDIA HIPE.........................#38
MAHMOOD ,   LONDON-UK   (07.01.08)
It is but obvious that a country planning dangerous,almost impossible and certainly high human loss is not planned and actioned the way we see it.This subject is to ensure oil prices remain high as the true agenda is yet to be floated by vested interest.
41. Probably both, Mahmood.
Ben ,   London, UK   (07.01.08)
Airplanes + missiles! What a damn tragedy! So many people will die and I mean Israelis, Iranians and probably Palestinians and Lebanese people too because the attack may exacerbate the regional tensions. Israel has no other choice and the mollahs know it yet that's what they are looking for! A tragedy!!!
42. #34, don't speak for Israel
Jake   (07.01.08)
You listed the incompetence of American leaders, but you forgot to add Olmert and the Israeli leadership on the list of abject failures. If Olmert is tasked with the job of taking out Iranian nuclear sites, he will more than likely screw it up so badly, not only will the mission not be accomplished, it will lead to nuclear enrichment being sped up, and another war with Hizbullah that Olmert will fail to win. As I recall, Olmert was supposed to get rid of Hizbullah, but he hasn't bagged them yet. Perhaps if Israel had turned Iran's main instrument on its border into pate back in 2006, Ahmedinejad would now be stewing in his own juice. As things stand at the moment, the best bet for stopping Ahmedinejad is that his own people will tear him to shreds. In the meantime, Israel MUST get rid of its weak incompetent leadership, and get a real leader.
43. Israel to attack Iran--Pentagon
robertsgt40 ,   San Antonio--Texas-U   (07.01.08)
Who was the pentagon official? What would happen if The US decides not to help Israel fight their wars any more? Fat chance. Thanx again Israel. Fight your own fights.
44. Garbage media reports just to raise the oil prices
Antonio ,   Haifa   (07.01.08)
45. why?
tom ,   toronto, canada   (07.01.08)
whether or not this story is true, why is the pentagon floating it, and why now? giving iran advance warning of an israeli strike doesn't help israel, and doesn't increase the operation's chances of success. so is the pentagon TRYING to sabotage things?
46. #44 ur right!
Matt ,   USA   (07.01.08)
this is all about oil! the US is leaking this information for the sole reason of driving up oil prices to satisfy the endless greed of the oil puppets Bush Administration. The only people who will benefit from an Israeli strike will be the oil companies, they can then charge $300 a barrel and get rich while the rest of the world, of all religions and nationalities, suffer. The only way to end this standoff is to replace the leadership of Israel, the US and Iran.
47. How can you leak something most people already know?
Stewart ,   USA   (07.01.08)
One way for Israel to pressure on the US is to keep saying it and saying it driving up the price of oil. Obama is a helpless idiot on this one. It is a great opportunity for McCain to pounce on. Who would Israel want in the White House? Obama or McCain. The Pentagon is fairly split. Some would like to see something done about the the Iranian forces acting in Iraq. They'd like to see more than the current covert CIA action. In any leak there is a double message to Iran. Also, how many Iranian are going to get killed since military targets are being targeted? Any at those locations are not much different from someone abetting the terrorist war effort. Also, these leaks serve to put China on notice. If their pipelines to Iran get "accidently" bombed (ooops), they are out of a lot of oil for a month. You know what kind of economic and social unrest that causes. The last time they threatened to dump our bonds, we send an emasary their to tell them that if the US has to bomb Iran, we can't guarentee that their pipeline may not be "accidently" hit. Funny, they caved. No, this whole thing is much, much, more than a Bush conspiracy to raise the price of oil for his friends.
48. SOMETHING HAS TO HAPPEN.....#46
MAHMOOD ,   LONDON-UK   (07.01.08)
Although,Israel will not be able to carry out the air assault on its own.It either,will have to be supported by USA or else a totally different scenerio unrelated to the present speculation will develope.In terms of human loss it can be astounding and very less likelihood of Israeli people approving of such a loss.Iran may have already installed the sophisticated air defence contracted with Russia.If so,the cost is bound to be very heavy. Let us hope nothing happens and countries agree to tolerate the equation balance in the Middle East.
49. BOLTON IS THE FOOL RETURNING TO HIS FOLLY
Arik Silverman ,   MIlwaukee USA   (07.01.08)
Lest anybody forget, Bolton was one of the Neocons predicting the Iraq debacle would be a "cakewalk," so what does he know about Iran? Please read your Bible, Book of Proverbs, Chapter 26, Verse 11: As the dog returns to his vomit, so Bolton repeats his folly. " related interview with the British 'Daily Telegraph,' Bolton said he believed the Arab world would be "pleased" by an Israeli strike. Their reaction, he told the paper "will be positive privately. I think there'll be public denunciations but no action."
50. Israel Iran
Charles R Krueger Jr ,   Kathmandu Nepal   (07.02.08)
Israel is a rogue terrorist state. After viewing the atrocities in Palestine, the Gaza strip and last but not least Lebanon, it would be hard to argue this fact. There is much evidence that shows that the Mossad not only knew about the world trade towers in advance, but they may have even orchestrated this event. How does the zionist punk Lieberman seem to know that the US will be attacked in 2009? If Israel attacks Iran, I hope Iran retaliates and wipes Israel off the map. Charles R Krueger Jr
51. #10 - Brauner - what a great idea!!!
Andy ,   ramat hasharon   (07.02.08)
Replacing the leadership in Tehran! Why didn't I think of that? You need to send an email to the PM and to President Bush right away. Why keep such a great solution to yourself?
52. #4 - No Said, nobody is expecting anything from you...
Andy ,   ramat hasharon   (07.02.08)
except retarded statements on the internet. Go back to Jordan where people are interested in your Israel-hating lies. No wait! You're perfectly at home in London!
53. #3 - Amir - much love back to you, my brother.
Andy ,   ramat hasharon   (07.02.08)
54. To R. Brauner #10. Israel Should NOT Attack Iran !!!
Maansingh ,   The Netherlands   (07.02.08)
Reuven, I agree with your TB at hand, with your line of taught. WHY should Israel be asked to do the DIRTY job for the World ? The problem of the world, i.e. the Iranian facilities, should be solved by USA, EU, Russia and China. IF they (i.e. USA, EU, Russia, China) want to bomb the Iranian facilities -- that is their (i.e. USA, EU, Russia, China) look out, that is their problem. I think Israel should NOT get involved in this MESS, called Iranian facilities. I particularly agree with your idea of “replacing the Iranian regime with a more rational, less hostile leadership“. I think that USA, EU, Russia and China should work dexterously in replacing the Iranian regime. BTW I think that the Arabs, with Saudi Arabia in the forefront, are pushing the Americans to influence Israel into attacking Iran. CONCLUSION : Israel should NOT attack Iranian facilities !!! Israel should NOT make its hands dirty in order to please the world !!!
55. To Yitzchak #26. The ANALYSIS.
Maansingh ,   The Netherlands   (07.02.08)
You write :”America and the West fears Iran ..”. I will disagree with you on this. I think you got the ANALYSIS wrong. The Muslims have two big camps : the Sunnis, comprising more then 75 %, and the Shiites, comprising about 20 % of the Muslims in the world. Saudi Arabia is a Sunni Muslim country, while Iran is a Shiite Muslim country. Saudi Arabia and other Arab countries ARE afraid of a powerful nuclear Iran. There is a STRUGGLE going on between the Sunnis and the Shiites. Although America and its allies WON the war in Iraq in 2003, not long thereafter the war between the Sunnis and the Shiites erupted in Iraq -- comprising the majority of the deaths in Iraq. And this RELIGIOUS war is still going on in Iraq -- with about 1900 deaths a month. SO, I think that Saudi Arabia and the other Sunni Arab states want to USE Israel to stop the further rise of Iran. BTW America and the West are NOT afraid of Iran -- not AT ALL.
56. To R. Brauner #10. Israel Should NOT Attack Iran !!!
Maansingh ,   The Netherlands   (07.02.08)
Reuven, I agree with your TB at hand, with your line of taught. WHY should Israel be asked to do the DIRTY job for the World ? The problem of the world, i.e. the Iranian facilities, should be solved by USA, EU, Russia and China. IF they (i.e. USA, EU, Russia, China) want to bomb the Iranian facilities -- that is their (i.e. USA, EU, Russia, China) look out, that is their problem. I think Israel should NOT get involved in this mess, called Iranian facilities. I particularly agree with your idea of “replacing the Iranian regime with a more rational, less hostile leadership“. I think that USA, EU, Russia and China should work dexterously in replacing the Iranian regime. BTW I think that the Arabs, with Saudi Arabia in the forefront, are pushing the Americans to influence Israel into attacking Iran. CONCLUSION : Israel should NOT attack Iranian facilities !!! Israel should NOT make its hands dirty in order to please the world !!!
57. #42Gee, with all of your knowledge you should be running the
world! NOT!! You are ,   a pompous @ss   (07.02.08)
Previous talkbacks
Back to article