News
Did Revolutionary Guards doctor missile photos?
Ynet
Published: 10.07.08, 21:47
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
52 Talkbacks for this article
1. What the Iranians are lying ?
Simon ,   TA Israel   (07.10.08)
Well duh !
2. but the far right rocket's 'tailstream' looks unique . .
Dr. Feelgood   (07.10.08)
3. It's irrelevant whether they doctored or not.
(07.10.08)
what's relevant is that they have motivation and capabilities to send nuclear missiles to Israel and the region. That's the REAL problem.
4. Another coup for Photoshop!
(07.10.08)
5. fake? why is AFP publishing thes pics?
Jacob ,   munich,Germany   (07.10.08)
6. And who are the biggest liars in the middle east ...
Chanalau, Tova ,   London, UK   (07.10.08)
...the ones that promised not to be the first to introduce nuclear weapons into the region ... can someone remind me, I forget which country that was, you know the one that built the textile factory in Dimona.
7. believe me i know for a fact that they are not lying
rashid ,   palistinian   (07.10.08)
i was there and i see the missile go up and up towards allah believe me that was great i am still covered with dust from what you can see in the picture but no worry believe me i will have a bath once i come back to gaza if the israil not cut off the water.
8. Stupid Persians
Chemi, TEL AVIV   (07.10.08)
damn, even my kid brother (8) saw that, he said, "how come the smoke produced by the rockets could have the identicle pattern" and thats coming from an 8 year old Iran, you will have to try a bit harder to pull the wool over our eyes - you are dealing with bright - clever Jews here, not Arabs, you donkeys... Maybe you need Stephen Speilberg to help you (i doubt he will agree)
9. Rashid
Phil Hert   (07.10.08)
Rashid you soppy Palestinian if the bombs fall on Israel, then you are dead too, deeerrrrrrr
10. What are the odds...
US citizen ,   Atlanta, US   (07.10.08)
of an Iranian missile hitting a target? The contrails looked like a fire in a firework factory. They're foolish if they think they'll be able to launch more than a few before we are on them.
11. Rashid
hemi   (07.10.08)
Rashid - we love you... when you travel bewteen Gaza City and Tehran, do you take El Al's new service - Gaza/Tehran - LY999? By the way, I tasted the water in Gaza and it was very nice,
12. Signs of desperation
Red Temple ,   White Mtns.   (07.10.08)
The IRGC - *was* - somewhat unified over its policies. Taking the confrontational stance over the reconciliatory one is merely a significant sign that the regime is becoming more adversely impacted by its own deranged policies.
13. Classic
Chocko ,   NY, USA   (07.10.08)
Im still laughing..... Oh... Dear .... Lord. Well anyway, now you have nothing to fear except fear itself....Or do you? But Chanalau Tova's comments about the 'Textile Factory' in Dimona is correct. It was always denied and even sworn that no such factory would be built, until it suited you to imply that there might be such a factory somewhere and then you jailed the guy who tried to warn the world.
14. Im a Photoshop expert.....definate fake
Jay3 ,   Israel   (07.10.08)
Obvious clone tool use. Exactly like the Rueters pics! If they wanted a professional job they should of contacted me....lol
15. monkey
jes   (07.10.08)
i want to see monkey boy in an israeli jail eating cous cous
16. To # 6 Lo Tova
Voice of Reason ,   Here & Now   (07.10.08)
What a pleasure to hear from you again. Another perfect self hating specimen. You never cease to amaze us with your bright and witty ramblings against Israel. One begins to wonder how and or why you were given your name Tova unless of course it is a pseudo- name. HK”BH of course will repay you by having your children make aliyah. Wishing you a Shabbat Shalom.
17. Dearest Rashid
Voice of Reason ,   Here & Now   (07.10.08)
Good for you and may the dust cover you and yours completely. May you and yours be worthy to see Allah up close and the sooner the better.
18. It is obvious the The Chanalau Phenomenon biggest liar in ME
Genuine Tosefta ,   Tveria   (07.10.08)
in how she covers up for all Arab and Muslim lies and deceptions called Al-Takiya
19. #7 Rashid my friend you are a hoot!! Be safe over there ok?
jan ,   usa   (07.10.08)
20. Well, duh...
Canadian Dude ,   Montreal, Canada   (07.10.08)
Anyone with half a brain knows Iran can barely match what US technology already accomplished half a century ago. It's all bluster with no substance to back it up. Without human shields, none of these middle eastern states would last 5 minutes in a real war with the west, and I'm sure they know it too. These types of tests are probably conducted more for domestic consumption than for international attention. Let Iran spend hundreds of millions on its missile program; armed with conventional explosives, their missiles are glorified scuds good for blowing up sand in the desert but not much else.
21. That's why they're testing.
Persian CAT   (07.10.08)
To fix any problems to make them as accurate and deadly. Sure the pictures are doctored but mainly to cover the launch vehicles and pads. I'm sure the US and others have a lot of data to shows the real effectiveness of Iran's missiles. The pictures are only for show. But Iran's defensive and strike back capabilities are real. Israel would have attacked by now if it could. Israel has never been shy to attack others.
22. Is Ahmadinejad afraid ?
Robert Bernier ,   Tel Aviv   (07.10.08)
The economic situation of the Iranian population is dreadful. Ahmadinejad cannot afford the risk of an Israeli attack on the Iranian nuclear installations and/or other vital targets – he might face a popular revolution supported by a part of the Iranian army. That could be the beginning of the end of the fanatical Islamic regime. Would Ahmadinejad take such a risk ? More about Iran today at : http://xrl.us/biz87
23. The Chanalau Penomenon admits that Iranian photos are fake
Genuine Tosefta ,   Tveria   (07.10.08)
while she takes a cheap shot at Israel too
24. #7 Rashid
Canadian Dude ,   Montreal, Canada   (07.10.08)
Bahahaha! Up and towards allah, eh? Yeah, he tends to reside at about 40 000 feet last I checked. I have an idea for you, load those Iranian missiles with bath water and send 'em flying towards Gaza, that's pretty much the only use you'll have for 'em.
25. Photo
Elianah ,   London, UK   (07.10.08)
Apparently, it's been removed by the Associated Press. However, a comparison of the original image and the doctored one is here: http://www.nationalpost.com/645632.bin
26. to #17
ami ,   ny,usa   (07.10.08)
well said. shabat shalom
27. A good opportunity as any other for The Chanalau Phenomenon
Genuine Tosefta ,   Tveria   (07.10.08)
to aim a cheap shot at Israel that has nothing to do with Iranian tests or doctored photos by Revolutionary Guards Now, please tell us who is the biggest liar about the Middle East, The Chanalau Phenomenon?
28. #25 That figures nicely...thanks.
Red Temple ,   White Mtns.   (07.10.08)
29. yes......sure,sure,thay have problems......X-)))))))))
Siad ,   muslim world   (07.10.08)
hahahahahhaa stupid think. X-)
30. Hahaha... Lets hit Iran allready!
Efroim ,   Washington DC   (07.10.08)
Lets put the ugly Mullahs out of their misery and move on with business. Israel is the smartest land in the area as the others dont posess the ability to work with thoroughness or precise. Its a BALAGAN state. Let em have it allready. Take out the bully and the other muslims will shut up alltogether!
Next talkbacks
Back to article