News
IDF probes Palestinian boy's death
Ali Waked
Published: 30.07.08, 00:37
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
90 Talkbacks for this article
1. children
invicta ,   europa   (07.29.08)
That makes 61 children killed by the IDF this year. What other civilised (or despotic for that matter) has such a record?
2. Murder
Solmon ,   Tel-Aviv   (07.29.08)
I was at the demo. The soldiers for no reason had a order to get rid of the totally peaceful protest. And then they chassed every nilin person and friends into the village. 100% Murder!
4. THE NEW MUHAMMAD AL DURA MARTYR
m   (07.29.08)
Only it was not true the first time
5. #1-It's another Al-Dura like Pallywood myth.
Allan ,   US   (07.29.08)
Where do you get you figures of 61 children killed? The credible and respectable Palestinian press no doubt.
6. Stop Shedding Children's Blood!!!!!!!
Mohammed ,   PalestinianAuthority   (07.29.08)
We need peace and its time to support a Two State solution as much as i hate Mahmoud Abbas and Ehud Olmert If they can make a peace deal lets support them for now then get them out of office
7. incivta
israeli ,   israel   (07.29.08)
In just one month, under UN auspices and right under the noses of the Dutch peace keeping forces ,8,000 (eight thousand) Muslims were massacred in Srebrenica, located, I believe, in Europa. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Srebrenica_massacre
8. SOLMON you are an IDIOT
EG ,   UAS   (07.29.08)
ENOUGH already stop going to protests that encourage the ENEMY a suggestion.. Better use of time - go pay a shiva call at the home of those murdered by blood thirsty arab terrorists go pay a visit at a hospital where the victims of blood thirsty arab terrorists are recuperating STOP aiding and abetting the enemy you fifth columnist
9. When can you believe a "palestinian"?
Bunnie Meyer ,   Los Angeles, CA USA   (07.29.08)
10. To Solmon and Invicta
Ricardo Macher ,   KarneiShomron Israel   (07.29.08)
Dear friends, I t is absolutely clear to me and any clever person here in Israel or in "Europe" what your game is. You Invicta, are looking things from abroad and don't even have the guts to say were from, so I understand your info is blatantly one sided. As per Solmon, you are of course sitting in Tel-Aviv, working against your country and the army that is defending you and is the only reason your arab friends have not killed you yet. So, please, if you don't like us, if you "love" your arab friends, why don't you move to Ramallah?
11. The Whole World Is Watching!
World Citizen ,   the world   (07.29.08)
And as far as the comments by #3 Naro. I would like to thank him for making my point so clearly. What is wrong with Israeli culture and society? Have you all gone mad?
12. Kid supposedly killed
DENNIS GREENSTEIN ,   MARLTON USA   (07.29.08)
1. has anyone autopside the body? 2. why wasn't the kid in school? 3.why didnt responsible adults keep kids away from these protects where the supposedly Bloodthirsty Israeli Killers are known to seek out kids to murder??? no tears here for the parents. It sounds harsh, but the kids had no reason to be in the area, except to serve the propoganda interests of their "handlers"
13. Story sounds shaky
Adam Eliyahu Berkowi   (07.29.08)
Inital reports were of two inured. WHere is the second injured arab? Also, the arabs refuse to let the body be examined. And the protests were not peaceful. SO lets get our facts straight. Actually, this story, though reproted by an arab, was a lot better than those written by
14. #1&#11 Was the world watching last week...
Cynic ,   USA   (07.29.08)
in Gaza when the arabs killed a girl last week when they set off a bomb.
15. Ynet Why are you covering up the daily rocks the Arabs throw
Miriam ,   Israel   (07.29.08)
at Israeli civilians, injuring people including children? And why don't we hear about these violent anti-fence protests from the radical Leftists and Arabs where several police were severly injured?
16. #2 - You have probably been in London all week.
(07.29.08)
17. This war is primitive
Gary ,   Los Angeles   (07.29.08)
Until the Arabs give up on the idea that they will dismantle Israel these ugly incidents will continue on both sides. Will Hamas sit down with Jews to reach a formal peace agreement? Or is the dynamic behind Islam regarding Jews impossible to change?
18. I live right near Naalin
TOWN NEARBY ,   TOWN NEARBY   (07.29.08)
EVERYBODY SHOULD COME TO SEE THE TRUTH OF WHAT REALLY HAPPENS and this is not what happens. The arab villagers and "peaceniks" come there everyday to incite violence. The soilders only respond back with rubber when they are attacked. I personally was there when the "MAGAD" told the soilders not to shoot anything unless the arabs are throwing rocks and hitting them.
19. Who cares to even attempt to believe such a story?
Johnny ,   Stockholm Sweden   (07.29.08)
The palestinian agenda, and that of most so called "peace organizations" is to use desinformation taken to the extreme. It's almost always a lie if it comes from these organizations.
20. "Sitting under a tree" during a violent Arab riot?
MF ,   Israel   (07.29.08)
Liars.
21. Palestinian reports - always Palestinian reports
Rebecca ,   Modiin   (07.29.08)
Palestinian report mean nothing. They lie constantly, with Peace now's support, like Solomon. Solomon, what were you doing there? dont you have a job, or does Europe pay you to cause trouble. Never will I ever believe that soldiers like my son will just pull up in a car and shoot children. I know what my son has ignored at check points etc, and not reacted at all. Get some valid reports
22. # 1 - 61 children in a year
Bill ,   US   (07.29.08)
Many civilized (by your definition I'm sure) and depotic peoples/governments have achieved this in a day. Since you list your homeland as the entire continent of Europe your homeland is beyond reproach. How cowardly.
23. the story smells funny
jared ,   orlando   (07.29.08)
the BS detector is going off like crazy while the propaganda meter is in overload Lets get teh facts before we draw any conclusions If the soldier is responsible, he should be held to account If not, or there are other matters at work here, which i suspect, then lets deal with it accordingly. The pal auth have lied many times regarding these cases, lets see if this pans out
24. #1 invicta
Cynthia ,   USA   (07.29.08)
What type of people cross into Israel to murder Israeli children, then protest a security fence built to save lives? What type of people send their children to throw rocks at soldiers and provoke a confrontation while they hide behind a protest? And if you're going to inaccurately claim 61 deaths of children, shouldn't you point out the majority of these minors died while involved in hostilities? This information is posted on the btselem website. You need to ask Palestinian parents why they don't do a better job protecting their children and Israel should make these useless protests illegal.
25. 11 year olds?!
GUH   (07.29.08)
But that "trooper" didn't mean to hurt them, did he? No, because Israelis would never harm a soul, let alone a Palestinian one.
26. Headline should of read: IDF officer hurt, may loose eye
dave ,   uk   (07.29.08)
Why do the palys get preference
27. solomon - the TA leftist-amswer the questions
Arie ,   BaGolan   (07.29.08)
Another TA leftie looking for an excuse to dismantle the Jewish State. How about you answer a few questions: what was a 9 year old (age dependent on which of his relatives you ask) doing at a violent demonstration?; If it was peaceful as you claim, why is a Border Officer fighting to retain his sight after being attacked by you and your cohorts?; Is it considered "peaceful" only when Jews are hurt?; Would you be willing, along with your cohorts, to be exchanged to your motherland (gaza) in exchange for Gilad? I know most Israelis would cherish that thought
28. #20..
Natan   (07.29.08)
Yes, and probably reading a book about peace....Gimme a break . Those palis lie the moment they open their mouth!!!
29. Palestinian's most effective weapon against Israel: Lies
Jake   (07.29.08)
and smokescreen. I will bet that the real events were nothing like these Palestinian "witnesses" claim. Remember Mohammed al-Durra and the Jenin "massacre".
30. #1: There is 0% chance these claims can be accepted
Jake   (07.29.08)
at face value. Accept them at your own ridicule. Your "scorecard" is also bogus. You seem willing to swallow LIES and HEARSAY whole, but are unphased by the mass civilian carnage reaked by female Islamic suicide bombers in Iraq yesterday. You are beyond pathetic; you are laughing stock, a satire, the practical joke of this website.
Next talkbacks
Back to article