News
Son of terror victim slams decision to free his mother's killer
Roi Mandel
Published: 17.08.08, 23:17
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
34 Talkbacks for this article
1. i hope this time most of the israelis know to vote better
uli ,   jerusalem   (08.17.08)
2. These murderers should be killed.
Keren ,   Israel-SP   (08.17.08)
Israel should have death penalty to deal with these animals. To spend money feeding them in prisons is a waste of resourses and a sin because you keep the seed of evil,which should be eliminated. I wait for the day Israel will have the courage to do the right .
3. Israel NEEDS the death penalty for terrorists, JUSTICE!!!!!!
Bunnie Meyer ,   Los Angeles, CA USA   (08.18.08)
4. Terrorists shouldn't be killed?
Adam Eliyahu Berkowi   (08.18.08)
What kind of twisted amoral disgusting person can open his mouth and say " I feel that terrorists should be set free to roam the streets". I under stand that there are poltiticians who make an obscene amount of money (over and under the table) have a vested interest. But I sincerely doubt that any civilian really agrees with this action. It is about as immoral as a society can get.
5. Olmert, Livni, Barak, Yishai are traitors!
Steve ,   US   (08.18.08)
6. the israeli cabinet now HAVE JEWISH BLOOD on their hands too
(08.18.08)
7. death penalty? to no.3
Zuri ,   Sydney Australia   (08.18.08)
Yes you may be very right that the death penalty should be introduce to terrorists, however I think we jews around the world consider ourselves civil and compassionate, we are not ANIMALS like those terrorists, we are a free nation struggling to put the flames of terrorism out. We as jews should never think that extermination is a way to deal with terrorism I do not supports terrorist attack on innocent civilians and children, I don't care if they are Palis, Jews Muslim, Christians Shia or Sunni, The bottom line my friend is what we as a nation do act, not only with gunfire, but achieve a foreseeable long-term peace Imagine a Pali child in Gaza, what opportunities they have? what option do they have? what family support do they have? what is the future can offer them? We a Israeli society demand justice like Bunnie Meyer, and Karen but I feel this is not going to solve the problem long-term I understand the pain for Kaplan's mother I perhaps would felt the same, and maybe the release of those people responsible for death is the high price we have to pay in order to achieve peace
8. Corrupt citizens vote on corrupt politician
Salomon Mizrahi ,   Sao Carlos SP/Brazil   (08.18.08)
Only little children didn´t know that kadima was formed by a gang of opportunistic corrupt politicians ... Adult mizrahim also know about the money-money-money-shas and still they vote on those politicians... Meretz and Avoda only represent the Israeli nomenklatura... The Knesset composition represents nothing more than the true face of Israeli society ...well if it´s ugly so is Israel on the bulk.
9. Too bad our government doesn't respect us
Ilan ,   Ariel   (08.18.08)
This man speaks with pain and dignity, but people like him are just dust under the feet of our government officials.
10. No One's Never Called Me A Kike in NYC
Dan Friedman ,   NYC USA   (08.18.08)
The last time a terrorist struck my city it was 9/11/01, and my government responded by sending armies abroad and killing thousands of them, capturing some more and never once considering exchanging one of them for a dead or kidnapped US soldier. I'm quite at home here. And I can always hear the NY Philharmonic too.
11. Justifying a release
Arie ,   BaGolan   (08.18.08)
When kuntar was released, the traitors that make up kadima nad labout justified by claiming it was the only way to get the bodies of our dead soldiers back. Their justification in releasing cold-blooded killers now can only be a donation to the olmert re-election fund - oops, I mean the swiss bank accounts
12. Kaplan is part of the problem in Israel.
Steve ,   Fla.   (08.18.08)
Kaplan said: "It won’t really make a difference if the terrorist (who masterminded the murder of my mother) stays in prison or is released; either way it won't help my mother. I have moved on with my life. My daughter is now a mother herself, and I have become a grandfather."
13. Yep, this is going to be the undoing of Olmert & Sharon's
Kadima Party 4 sure. ,   1 pissed off Israeli   (08.18.08)
14. #6 Only NOW they have Israeli blood on their hands? Olmert
has the blood of 136 ,   soldiers on them too   (08.18.08)
15. plmert inviting another holocaust
marcel   (08.18.08)
Olmert releases killers of jews as a gesture, What was the murder of 6 million jews all about. That no jew would be killed without retribution. So this filth olmert descrates the memory of 6 millon dead by releasing killers to abbas. What if the killer had killed Olmert's kids Airel, Shaul, Dana or Livni's kids? Would you then release them? Of course not, you raving hypocrites. Also Livni, since when do west banlk arabs like Queiria's daughter get an israeli ID? You had no business giving the reference. The whole government is a cowardly bunch for the most part. With this group, Israel will be destroyed as Iran says, I have no doubt about it.Israel's only chance is for Yaalon to take over defense and shtienitz, eitam, orlev and eldad to get to work.Barak is a waste of time at defense and I doubt israelis will fight for this arab appeaser.
16. Release of terrorists
kessel ,   canada   (08.18.08)
Infortunately, this government of traitors has not been elected. They are all of them disgusting as all the israeli politicians
17. Sexy Spy Girl Livni is HELLBENT on destroying Israel
Dr. Dave ,   NYC   (08.18.08)
It's amazing how she has the audacity to rationalize these traitorous act. So much for her "security" image, Imagine,...she colluded with the Times of London to portray herself as a sexy Mossad agent traipsing around Europe hunting down terrorists.
18. INJUSTICE reigns supreme in Israel...
David ,   Hartford USA   (08.18.08)
in the name of 'goodwill gestures' to a murdering hypocrit. To the man who 'shot the first bullet towards Israel' Olmert and ilk give goodwill gestures. What exactly has Israel received in return from the mighty Abbas? Dead bodies courtesy of psychopaths driving stolen tractors. Children being indoctrinated with filth about Jews. About how martydom is the greatest glory. Israel has received nothing except death and pain. I think it's high time we demand Abbas to show some goodwill gestures. But he won't, even if he could: he's part of the Arab axis of extermination. He's part of the problem and no one has the courage to say so. As for releasing these prisoners, just more proof that Olmert and his ass-kissing followers don't have clue what they are doing. And all those holier-than-thou 'religious' parties that support the release of killers of Jews? You disgust me. You want to stay in power at all costs to ensure the state keeps throwing money at your yeshivas and 'students.' The government should have a test and keep the 1000 brightest scholars in school and throw the rest of the freeloaders out on their tender behinds to get jobs and help defend the country.
19. I'm against death penalty
YOEL   (08.18.08)
This is in a world made of Justice... Here, death penalty becomes justified; because it is supposed to protect innocents from a terrorist. This "thing" must be killed because he applies death penalty to innocent civilians...
20. "NU" A DIFFERENT KIND OF BLOOD ?
ROLAND SEENER ,   LONDON ENGLAND   (08.18.08)
..(.Q.).. WHO EVER CITES YIGAEL AMIR AS A JEWISH EXAMPLE...(,,A.)..,SOME BLOOD MUST BE REDDER THAN OTHERS...COULD BE BLUE?
21. THINGS HAVE TO GET WORSE BEFORE THEY GET BETTER
ROLAND SEENER ,   LONDON ENGLAND   (08.18.08)
THE LAW IS NOT THE LAW,FOR IT IS CHANGED FOR ACTS OF 'POLITICAL EXPEDIENCY" . THIS WORKS FOR..ARABS ONLY.AND IS AN UNEQUAL ETHNIC PROBLEM .THE MORE VIOLENT,THE MORE PEOPLE KILLED WITH A PRESSURE GROUP OF SUPPORTERS BEHIND YOU,AND YOU WON"T SERVE YOUR FULL TIME !I AM SURPRISED THAT JEWISH GROUPS HAVE NOT SPRUNG INTO EXISTANCE TO PUSH FOR THEIR FAVOURITE SONS RELASE.WILL THE TIME COME WHEN JEWISH BRIGANDSHIP GAINS POWER,OR IS IT THERE ALREADY WITH A MAFIA CORRUPT SYSTEM HEADED BY OLMERT AND THE GOVERNMENT.IT IS NOW "OMERTA" TIME,AS THE SIMPLE CITIZEN IS RENDERED "STUM" .I AM AN OPTIMIST THOUGH..WILL THINGS GET BETTER SOON?...YES WHEN THE "MESSIACH COMES" I HOPE HE IS DOING SOME GOOD LEARNING AT HIS YESHIVA AT THE MOMENT THOUGH!
22. Terrorists murder should be sentenced to death.
Robert Bernier   (08.18.08)
The State Attorney's Office seems not to have been bothered by the fact that terrorists with blood on their hands continue to constitute a grave danger to the civil population. Quite simply, the rarified intellectual and moral universe that Menahem Mazuz and his fellow prosecutors inhabit is not the intellectual and moral universe that most Israelis live in. The prosecutors live in a world in which morality is an abstract issue, best adjudicated by professors, judges and themselves in the name of enlightened humanism. More at : http://xrl.us/kj6sj
23. Parade of Murderers
Reuven ,   New York   (08.18.08)
The release of Sami Kuntar was just the beginning of a parade of murderers released by the weakest government in Israeli history. And for for what purpose? To bolster a Holocaust denier such as Abbas and to set a predecent for the release of other killers. The worst is yet to come.
24. Min 65% of the Israeli pop. wants death penalty 4 Terrorists
Michael Berg ,   Toronto, Canada   (08.18.08)
At least 65%. Why aren't more Terrorists executed? Part of the reason is because absolute representation does not represent the population very well. No party has enough support to risk losing the support of one or two other parties in the Knesset. A second factor, is that leaders today do not lead. If there was a leader with true leadership, he would have a referendum to ask the Israeli public if they think that the legal system should execute those directly responsible for terrorist attacks.
25. To Michael Berg: Israel Is the Laughing Stock
Dave Levy ,   Burbank. CAUSA   (08.18.08)
To Michael Berg: I am an American born Jew, and an ardent Zionist. Here in Calif. we have the death penatly, even though many are alive on appeals. In the last several weeks, several goyim have revealed their anti-Semitism to me. We are told we are smart, but devious, crooks, behind gentile problems. Joe Lieberman parades around with McCain..and Obama has his Jewish donors. As in Israel, we are being fooled. Jews support Darfur activists, while other Jews stand in front of bulldozers in Israel (to protect the poor Palis). Jews are confused all over the world..while rockets land in Sderot and Iran sends up advanced missiles (to hit Tel Aviv). Olmert talks to Abbas about a withdrawal, while the Palis demand the 67 lines, nothing else. Why, after Eichman, wasn't the 12.00 hangman's noose used for Kuntar, Barghouti and others? Israel needs to tighten up..in every area of it's policy. What is Israel thinking by turning the other cheek? An eye for an eye still should dictate. Israel is the laughing stock of the planet.
26. Perhaps the real terrorists are the Israeli government
bernard ross ,   st anns bay, jamaica   (08.18.08)
the israeli government keeps releisng jew killers as if they were the PA. What is the sense of capturing or even fighting the terrorists if the government keps releasing them. Terrorists should not be captured but rathe summarily executed as they donot have the protection of the geneva convention. This will prevent future trading of terrorists by the government.
27. #7 - I wonder - are we responsible for pali kids in Azza?
Arthur ,   SF, CA   (08.18.08)
What a perverted sense of justice you posess...To hell with them! Who cares about them? Let them worry about their own - if if they chose to live their lives like that - sorry, it's not our business.... Let their brothers come to rescue..
28. ban pickle!; it was the only meal offered by Israel to POW
observer   (08.18.08)
29. Chess, the death penalty and #7
Avinoam ,   Tel Aviv, Israel   (08.18.08)
Chess: The Israeli government lives under the delusion that it can control this struggle, manipulating it with gestures of goodwill or with military action. The truth is it cannot. 1) The Israeli government is ineffective. It send mixed messages and it assumes that the world at large is blind to the games it plays. I do not consider myself either left or right. I am practical. When you you take military action don't beat around the bush, have the courage and conviction to follow through in full force. (This does not require human rights violations.) When you make peace have the courage and conviction to pursue your goal despite those that try to derail the process. Fanatic elements in our cabinet should be removed completely. This includes the Arab fifth column (not all Arabs), the loony left and the racist nationalists. 2) Realise that Israel is a central but minor player in a global conflict. I recognise 5 major and independent players: USA, Europe, Russia, China, Islam. World opinion is far more important than local manipulation. News of terror attacks should be reinforced overseas. Israel's position should be uniform and understood. Arab propaganda, in the Middle east and in Europe, should be stopped in its tracks and make the headlines every time. Truth and proportioned representation in journalism is the foundation of a free society. I am against censorship, but I urge serious criticism of the media at all times. The death penalty: This is obvious to me. There are different groups of people to consider and the laws applicable to them should be different: citizens, traitors, foreigners. 1) The death penalty for citizens is a civil debate and ultimately becomes a question of a trade-off between safety and certainty, ethics and the power of government over its citizens. 2) Traitors should be shot. There exists a social contract between a country and its citizens. Treachery resulting in death, or severe consequence to the country as a whole, can be seen as a hostile end of this contract. Mild treachery is also an end of this contract, but should be dealt with by exile. 3) As a rule foreigners should be executed. There exists no social contract between them and the country. The exceptions are if their home countries are allies in which case it becomes a diplomatic issue. If their home countries are not allies just shoot them. #7 By extermination you imply that it is immoral to kill of a group based on their ethnicity, heritage or place of origin. However "terrorist" is neither of these. In modern society it is unacceptable to discriminate based on race, religion or origin, but it is certainly desirable to discriminate based on useful criterion such as danger, hostility and action. There are two things that are necessary to put out the flames of terrorism. 1) snuff the flames 2) cool the embers For some reason people tend to choose one or the other. No wonder we cannot get anywhere.
30. #19
Avinoam ,   Tel Aviv, Israel   (08.18.08)
A terrorist is a human being. Human beings are monsters. This is why we have laws. The laws are not the same for everyone. A country has an obligation first and foremost to its citizens. Death penalty is a term only applicable to state action against ordinary *citizens. (* as opposed to traitors.)
Next talkbacks
Back to article