Jewish Scene  Rabbi Levi Brackman
Al-Jazeera shown the door by local US democracy
Rabbi Levi Brackman
Published: 22.08.08, 11:13
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
25 Talkbacks for this article
1. Patheric double standards
Said ,   London, UK   (08.22.08)
So its alright for Western media to demonise the Arabs and stereotype them, but when its the other way around, suddenly it becomes a matter of "morals". Pathetic! The West has been pillaging , raping and plundering the East for centuries and now suddenly they think they're morally superior?
2. yes suddenly
Ben ,   USA   (08.22.08)
As of lately ("suddenly", per your description), parts of the "East" are crying "victim" when they are not totally collectively innocent themselves. Cries of "throw the Jews into the sea" are not the cries of victims ... One "Eastern" entity, the Islamic Ottomon Empire, attempted conquest of large parts of Europe only a few hundred years ago. As recently as the 20th century, they supported the Germans in World War I. Were those Germans brave liberal defenders of poor victimized natives of non-Western cultures? Not all Easterners are such poor victimized underdogs as you insinuate, and they do not necessarily descend from poor, victimized, brutalized peoples themselves. Remember that when you try to appeal to collective guilt amongst liberals in the West.
3. That is the worst piece of journalism I have come across.
rani ,   lebanon   (08.22.08)
Seriously people. When articles are written on the pretext "we are good, they are bad" and supported only by ones selfish perception, it really speaks about the author.
4. Double standards, Said? (#1)
Tahl ,   Israel   (08.22.08)
Said, what the hell are you talking about?... "Double standards"?... "alright for Western media to demonise the Arabs"?... Have you seen the virulent anti-Israel incitement in the Arab media? Go read some newspapers in Syria, Saudi Arabia or the "moderate" gulf states. Go read newspapers in Egypt, with whom Israel has "peace". You'd find vicious antisemetic caricatures, showing Shylock-like, hook-nosed Jews, Israeli Prime Ministers as Dracula drinking Palestinian children's blood, stacks of Palestinian bodies next to a smiling IDF soldier, ludicrous stories about Israel poisoning Egyptian food, a TV series about a vicious Israeli ambassador, a #1-hit song called "I hate Israel", the Protocols of the Zion Elderlies, and so forth, hard-core stuff that even puts Der Sturmer (look it up) to shame. Or how about Farfur, the friendly Palestinian Mickey Mouse, that encourages kids to become martyrs by killing Jews? Or the Palestinian summer camps, which teach Palestinian kids wonderful, useful skills, such as how to fire an RPG? You Arabs, are the KINGS or double-standards! It is acceptable to incite such unbelievable antisemetic hate on a daily basis, it is ok to call for a Jihad against the kafirs, but G-d forbid, if someone puts a mirror to your face and shows Muhammad strapped with explosive belt? One stupid caricature is enough to light up the entire Arab world in riots, violence, and threats of terror attacks. You don't like being portrayed as violent, and if someone does portray you like that - you'd bomb the living c**p out of him! How ironic is that? Oh no, we're no hypocrite, we're not violent... Just teaching 'em a lesson for badmouthing us... Tell me, have you ever seen the Jews riot and threaten with violence, over your ugly propeganda? Have you seen the Jews threaten Mel Gibson with violence and terror, after his Passion movie came out? This is the difference between the religion of Moses, and "the religion of peace"... You want more examples of double standards? No problem... How about the Palestinian crying out for every incident where Israelis supposedly "oppressed" them, yet no one utters a word when Hamas and Fatah massacre each other's peoples? As I said, Said, you Arabs are the absolute kings of double standards.
5. THANK YOU RABBI, You are a true AMERICAN and a Jew.
Bunnie Meyer ,   Los Angeles, CA USA   (08.22.08)
6. Rabbi Brackman
Iamashamed ,   UK   (08.22.08)
This just goes to show that the citizens of Golden are, just like you Rabbi, xenophobic, anti-Islam and intolerant.
7. You speak the truth
Christy ,   Boston, US   (08.22.08)
"Despite what some on Left may want us to believe, average working class, right-leaning American is neither xenophobic, anti-Semitic or intolerant." The Left hate anyone who is not themselves; at times they even seem to hate themselves! Your observations about right-leaning working class folk in the US are very accurate. You'll find the same thing in thousands of cities and towns across the US.
8. Anti Islam?
GZLives   (08.22.08)
I sure am if Ayaan Hirsi Ali's book has any truth to it. Why wouldn't I and everyone else in the civilized world be anti Islam. From female gental mutilation to the homophobia to the point of stoning gays to death to the refusal to allow any interpretation of the Quran which plainly calls for the murder of non believers. Islam is evil and I haven't seen any attempt to take it out of the 7th century. Just more excuses and deflections. You Muslims don't want to be hated - then stand up against your radicals and throw them out of your faith. But you won't because most of you secretly believe all the garbage as well. So from this former liberal, I think Islam should be banned from civilized countries.
9. #3 Why? Because he is good and you are bad?
Hypocritical ,   lebonese.   (08.22.08)
10. #1 Superior? Damn straight we are.
US Marine Corp. ,   USA   (08.22.08)
11. Now only if we Israelis can use this to stand up to our govt
and our enemies. ,   Maurie, Israel   (08.22.08)
12. no need to red carpet or parpique
hanna ,   jerusalem   (08.23.08)
she met me infront of her house .invited me to a party at satarday .i said yes .... my girl 3 years old said that she is thirsty want a glass of water . the woman do not care and said that she is in hurry and like to see me at satarday ... my girlasked me if i want to go .. i asked her openion ... the girl said .no mother please no need to her juice and cake
13. A bad loser
john ,   bristow   (08.23.08)
The Rabbai is just a bad loser...
14. #4
(08.23.08)
i really believe you left said from the uk speechless. good for you. everything yhou say is the truth christian arab from lubnan
15. #1 said
(08.23.08)
it is not this rabbi and great person that has made or caused the people to throw out al jazira. it is the entire people present who know what islam and what arabs are like since they have been on ample tours in iraq and have first hand experience with the muslim mentality. the truth hurts. however, as an arab myself, i invite you to look at all the world and all the muslim nations in the globe and see that wherever there is blodshed, trouble, murder, violence...it is in muslim countries. americans do not have to convince us of where the trouble is. you open a newspaper and see that all the murders and all the bloodshed is caused by muslim on muslim and muslim on anyone else that doesn't agree with their ideology and belief system. said, from one brother to another, i as an arab moderate know that our behavior doesn't portray us in good light. our governments do not help us to enlighten and progress. they supress us. our people are tools for al jazira, for mullahs and clerics that are enticing and using us and our children to destroy others and to fight with them. our arab mentality was never one of peace. we fought amongst each other for generations and please do not blame the west for thinking about our nature in a negative way. when have we as arabs ever given them the opportunity to see otherwise? it is sad, but we also must endure the burden of multitudes of our brothers that have shown the west we cannot be peceful, cannot be trusted, cannot be relied on to be civilized and modern in thought. our book stores and news stands reek of antisemitism, anti west, anti democracy and pro violence. the rabbi is right to feel pride. the menorah is a peace symbol and the jews are smart and peace loving people. they are asdmired in the usa and everywhere in the world and we are not. that hurts, but we have to look into our heart and mind to see where we went wrong, not where they went wrong and we have to stop blaming everyone for doing things to arabs. without the west, we couldn;t even take oil out of the ground. the west technology helped arabs become rich. do you hear me? could saudi arabia get so rich by refusing the west help? no! before you complain, look into your heart brother and think what we have to do differently. salam! and also shalom.
16. I'm sick of Islam
Polly ,   Poplar Bluff Mo   (08.23.08)
I get sick everytime some idiot says that Muslims worship the same G-D as me. I am a Bible believing Pentecostal Christian and their isn't anyway that my G-D is the same as theirs. Only Christians and Jews worship the same G-D. I personally back Israel 100%. It makes me very proud to hear that many other Americans do as well.
17. #1 "Raping the East"?
Thomas   (08.23.08)
All we did, in regards to Arabia, is for private oil companies to buy land to develop oil refineries which were later stolen back by the Arabs once they saw how much money they were making. Sorry we made you the rich people on earth. Is that what you call rape? The West has done much worse to people in the East and they weren't made rich by it.
18. intolerance
jerusalem   (08.23.08)
i dont know about xenophobic, but you would be calling them anti-semetic, or at least hinting at it if they were against your minora idea. intolerance on the other hand, i see evidence of in your article. with the clear facts that you have reported at that meeting, i dont understand why you would declare that there is no intolerance. the towns people just excluded a body out of an event. i would understand if the stations were hizbulla sponsored "al manar," hamas sponsored "al aqsa," or even PA's "falasteen" reporters (thats if they can even get out of the country; or entrance visas in the US) all aljazeera wanted in the first place was to meet and interview residents. there is no need for a special barbecue celebration, though how else is the manager to assemble the residents ? sheer intorlorance. there are other ways to interview the residence than a barbecue anyway. they are not going to let some heated intolerant people get in their way of reporting.
19. jerrywhi@innova.net
Jerry Whitmire ,   United States   (08.23.08)
Dear Mr. Brackman, My wife and I recently returned from an extended stay in Italy. Our only English language newscasts were BBC World News and Aljazeera World News in English. We had assumed that the Aljazeera newscasts would have a lot of anti-US and anti-Jewish content. While we cannot speak to the Arabic language broadcasts, we were forced to change our opinions regarding Aljazeera's English language newscasts. We are educated and patriotic Americans, but we were unable to detect any anti-Americanism or anti-Jewish content in their newscasts. They actually seemed to cover U.S. news more thoroughly than our friends at BBC. They are a bit heavier on mid-eastern and African news than BBC or, certainly, CNN. But if there was bias in their reporting we were unable to detect it. We felt their English language newscasts were on a par with BBC. Thanks for your consideration. Jerry and Barbara Whitmire Pittsboro, North Carolina
20. Jerry and Barbara Whitmire
dennisw ,   USA/Florida   (08.24.08)
Hello Al Jazeera might be mild and acceptable in English. This is called successful marketing. But the Arabic Al Jazeera is a great friend of Jihad and the Veterans who spoke up know this. Al Jazeera is Arabic is much much larger than what you say
21. umber 19, Jerry & Barbara were you aware that
kate b ,   uk   (08.24.08)
The English version is not the same as the even more anti-semitic Arabic version, however, you are correct with it being on par with the BBC which is biased towards the oil producers i.e. Arabs. If you are unaware of the bias in the BBC then you won't have noticed it in Al-Jazeera. Have a look at Memri, UNWatch, Honestreporting.com PMW for a grounding of the facts.
22. to 20 and 21
kami ,   jerusalem   (08.24.08)
aljazeera tell its best to the frieners and its best to the arabs .. it is part of its success
23. #1 - you are mixing apples and oranges ..
redmike ,   Tel Aviv   (08.24.08)
It seems you failed to understand the thrust of the article. The townspeople were against al-Jazeera and not Arabs. Israel recently had to take action against al-Jazeera as well as it gave a hero's welcome to a child killer that was released from prison. There are always reactions to actions and al-Jazeera like all of us must weigh its actions and it words and decide if it is willing to pay the cost. Mike
24. #13 - what did he lose?
redmike ,   Tel Aviv   (08.24.08)
25. Thank you and do it again and again
Petra ,   usa   (08.27.08)
until this trash called Al Jazeera disappears like a thief in the night. They are NOT welcome here. They are the enemy.
Back to article