News
Grandfather confesses to killing Rose
Raanan Ben-Zur
Published: 26.08.08, 11:34
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
49 Talkbacks for this article
31. Poor little Rose, May she find peace in
Joe ,   Ohio, USA   (08.26.08)
the after life that she never found here!
32. # 17 What a Hypocrite
Thomas   (08.26.08)
If a religious person would have done this you would have called them on it. You remind me of the Groucho Marx quote, "These are my principles. If you don't like them, I have others."
33. # 29 Two words for you: honor killing
(08.26.08)
34. #29
Jane   (08.26.08)
In your "society", honor killings are an everyday thing and are accepted. This is, thank G-d, extremely rare in our society and, furthermore, the man will be punished. You cannot say the same.
35. bore him two girls – now aged 18 and 10 months
(08.26.08)
8 month interval between two births; that's a record which forgives all their sins; israeli stylish repentance .
36. Penalty of death for intentionally child killing !!!!
Leo   (08.26.08)
Don´t forget about Ahlam Tamimi, the female terrorist who killed intentionally fifteen innocent people at a pizza restaurant, eight were children.
37. #33 and 34: What are you talking about?
Salameh ,   Gaza, Palestine   (08.26.08)
Honor killing - as much as I oppose it - is a sign of people who have HONOR and hate to see it tarnished, while this loser and your occupation-minded sins are DISHONOR. This man, may he rot in jail until he meets his lord for the big punishment, murdered the child for NO CRIME, and he slept with his daughter-in-law, a crime an animal won't do. It turned out that occupation doesn;t corrupt morals only, but also blinds minds.
38. 37 - LMAO!!! Oh my Allah - you are the LOONIEST yet.
Global Citizen ,   Israel & USA   (08.26.08)
39. Parenting
Marilyn ,   USA   (08.26.08)
As a woman, because of the rash of news reports around the world in which I have seen mothers (and fathers also) who either do not have the skills or the ability or desire to be parents, I think that it might be good for high schools and such to have mandatory parenting training for kids (they can also involve their parents also). This could be so that if they decide to have children they can learn to plan a course for them in which everyone can be happy. It can't be assumed that just because parents can have children that they are going to be decent parents, especially in todays world. Sure perhaps won't reach the really disturbed but a maybe a step forward.
40. Sounds like my dysfunctional, toxic family.
(08.26.08)
41. # 37
(08.26.08)
In your culture, women who are victims of rape are also considered dishonorable and are murdered by their families. That happens more often than a case like this in Israel. You know what else animals don't do? They don't put bombs on their children for money. Another things that exists more commonly in your side of the world. The point is whether there is or isn't an occupation, there would still be bad Jews and Arabs.
42. #37
Jane   (08.26.08)
You kill your daughters if they date someone you don't like. Or if they talk to a boy. Or hold hands. And you call that a crime. Salameh, look at yourselves. You are in no position to say ANYTHING about us. This person is going to pay dearly for what he has done. What you call honor has nothing to do with the meaning of the word. You consider suicide bombs an honor too. You are empty of honor.
43. #29 #17
debbie ,   nola   (08.27.08)
i know you now have an opportunity to spout your political views and religious views and bias....but let me tell you one thing.After yrs of working as a nurse, I assure you that psychopathic behavior can be found EVERYWHERE. That means all religious and secular groups and in occupied and non-occupied areas.Psychopaths are everywhere and this is one family where sick minds tortured that poor baby to death.Smacking her? I bet he did a lot more and why?Because she cried!She was in their way.The "sickness" of these non-humans is very apparent.Please- all of you stop bringing in your personal issues.Call is what it is-
44. It's a good sign
nr ,   los angeles, CA   (08.27.08)
that we all agree this is horrendous. But not the norm. Here in LA, we see trash dumpsters that say "No babies" on it - because that's where they find them. We have a very similar case going on in the US right now - child missing, mother didn't want her, spoke of getting "rid" of her but no body. Yes, this family was messed up and this pure neshamah suffered, and if because of it we become more vigilant and save other children, then Rose's sacrifice will have meaning.
45. about #37
debbie ,   nola   (08.27.08)
well on some level i agree and disagree with this man. I do not agree that you are trying to bring occupation into this. I do however, agree that Honor killings,are reprehensible, this is not quite the same.
46. #41 and 42: You are apparently brainwashed
Salameh ,   Gaza, Palestine   (08.27.08)
Zionist teachings of B'nai birth is making you hallucinate. Honor is a word you and your occupation thugs who shoot blind-folded innocent people do NOT know. We value our children as much as value our land, and 60 years later, we have not given up on neither. So spare me the BS
47. Police fear for life of missing girl
Tim ,   Campbellton CA   (08.27.08)
Very sad, but given what I see on TV as happening in Israel is can't really be described as "one of most shocking ever to occur in Israel."
48. My god!!!
Fernanda ,   Brazil   (08.28.08)
he is a monster!!!!
49. Rose
Silvio Andrade-Erbac ,   Amsterdam   (08.28.08)
Good Bless and confort this poor child, and for all this monsters, DEATH PENALITY NOW FOR THIS MONSTER Silvio
Previous talkbacks
Back to article