so her other 2 children are not mamzerim. I knew she couldn't be Jewish, as she was too cruel to her children and committed too many crimes to have a Jewish heart. And I WAS RIGHT ALL ALONG when I blamed the mother or both for committing this crime. As I said, “A G-dless person who commits incest (and brings mamzerim into the world if she’s Jewish) is liable for the most criminal and hideous act as she takes no responsibility for anything. She is not to be trusted at all! It might be difficult … to understand it, but wait and see that I’ll be right.” http://www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7340,L-3588875,00.html

I agree with Miriam but lets not forget there is a little girl missing or murdered here and whatever her religion is she must found and if she is dead she deserves a funeral. I followed the Madeline McCann case and so much wanted little Maddie to be found alive and well. In Europe these terrible cases are quite normal but here is Israel it is very unusual and there has been three cases in so many weeks. Child abuse must be a top priority here so that we can prevent any more cases like these.

The grandfather is the murderer and he is as Jewish as YOU are. It is people like you who cause this world to be such a mess.

I feel sorry for you. You are ridiculous and I am sure that you don't even know why !!!!!!

guaranteed NOT TO BE inscribed in the Book of Life. You are pathetic and utterly so.

have a much bigger incidents of everything, let alone child abuse and murder. Take your holier than thou attitude lady and stuff it.

You sound as if you are on the side of the child abuser. What is your name. or maybe you dont want us to know for some reason.

Will you be inscribbed in the Book of Life. Miriam will I have no doubts about that. She is proud to be Jewish and tries her best to keep the commandments. How about you are you another selfhating Jew? You probably do not any laws in Judaism. One of the Ten commandments is thou shalt not kill. We are talking about a little girl who was viviously abused and her non-Jewish mother who must of seen it all.

I do not know your name but you obviously need help. What is wrong in demanding an end to child abuse and more to be done to help these children. i am beginning to wonder about you, what sort of person are you. Can you identify with little Rose.

I would like the country I live in to be a little more Jewish with a lot more Jewish passion and morals. and # 8 & 9 you dont have to be religious to be a good Jew. You just have to be decent.

The erev rav are worse. Olmert killed hundreds recently with his whorishness and caused the displacement and depression of tens of thousands not to mention the seeds of future terro. Barak caused all the suffering of 10 years ago with thousands murdered and 10's of thousands maimed. Yes a purely theoretical non-jew is often on the animal level - BUT an erev rav who embraces animal and evil behavior IS MUCH WORSE AND MORE DANGEROUS! Look at all the zionists who controlled the murderous judenrats and jewish gestapo fully collaborating with the evil devilish non-jewish filth only a few decades ago in europe. Look at the leftistt sewage and filth collaborating with arab terrorist murderers now. Arabfart could not have done anything without them. Primakov the commie director of arab terrorism is an amalekite JEW yimach shemam! GOD wants our prayers for OUR repentance AND OUR SEPARATION from the satanic erev rav now !!!! Thankfully God is about to make his entrance !!!!!!

Do you live in israel and why, are you Jewish and if so do you believe in Hashem and try to follow His ways? Israel is a country, not perfect by all means. but as a Jew I am trying to be a good person and follow the law to the best of mu ability that is why I live in Israel. Israel is supposed to be a light unto the world, if that is so we must condemn child murder, infact all murder, we must protect the most vulnerable in society and YES we in Israel should strive to be better than anyone else by keeping the Mitzvaot. You sond to be a self loathing person. I am sorry for you.

What is the point of this article? Whe does "charedi" have to appear in the headline? I find it amazing that I have been following this story from the beginning and this is the first mention of the non-jewishness of the mother and Rose. That seemed irrelevant. But what does it add to the story that her father tried to enroll her in school AFTER she disappeared. And yet you imply the charedi school was to blame. It seems implicit that the school was to blame for not taking her in, either because they were evil charedi or because she wasn't Jewish. Actually, the school didn't deny her entrance. The grandfather never co ntacted them again. Enpugh grasping at every chance to charedi bash. It's getting tiresome.

Why did Y-Net bring up this story about the school. Was it to start a whole lot of talkbacks that would create a religious-nonreligius argument. It seems to me that Y-net are part of the establishment, leftwing establishment, like our government that wants to give 1000 guns to the enemy and will be used G-d forbid agaist Jews, whether they are religious, non religious, Sephardim or Ashkanazim. It is too bad the people who talkback fall into this hatred trap.

Your racist comments Miriam # 2 DISGUST ME almost as much as Rose's mother and grandfather. The irony of your stupidity is that her grandfather - i.e., the actual murderer in this case is JEWISH - so to blame the mother because she is not Jewish is not only racist, but ignorant of the facts, which speak for themselves. In this case, both a Jew and a non-Jew are to blame - unless new facts come to light at trial. And family violence tragically crosses all faiths, races,and socio-economic classes, or haven't you read .... If anything, this should be but one of the lessons learned from this case. To make this an issue about one's religious background is as despicable as it would be for a non-Jew in France to blame Rose's death on the fact that she went to live with a Jew (her grandfather). And your attitude only adds to the disrespect Rose was shown in her brief life.