News
Sad end: Rose's body identified
Tal Rabinovsky
Published: 12.09.08, 18:40
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
38 Talkbacks for this article
1. Angel Rose!
Bandar ,   Beirut, Lebanon   (09.12.08)
Its very sad, my heart aches for this little angel. The very people that are supposed to protect her are guilty of this terrible crime. If there any justice in this world, the guilty must pay the ultimate price.
2. This was definitely murder
Paula Stern   (09.12.08)
the only question, probably is if it was premeditated and whether the police can prove the mother's involvement. At least, she can be charged with negligence - incredible, criminal negligence for failing to report her daughter missing.
3. Israelis flock to area to say goodbye to young child who 'ha
Bandar ,   Beirut, Lebanon   (09.12.08)
Wrong! Jews, Christians, Muslims and Hindus all over the world are mourning Rose. Rest in peace little princess. We love you.
4. R.I.P. little girl
Mohammed ,   Syria   (09.12.08)
5. Whoever murdered little Rose must be
(09.12.08)
sentenced to death !
6. Bandar - very very nicely put
Amir - Tel Aviv   (09.12.08)
7. No-one to mourn over her?
Talula ,   Israel   (09.12.08)
There's over 5 million people who didn't even know her and in their own quiet way mourn for her. The sad thing is, we can't even celebrate her life, it was taunted and sad and violent. I hope she is now in a place where there are only good happy things. Goodbye little one.
8. We all mourn little Rose
Stephanie ,   Israel   (09.12.08)
Little Rose you never had a chance born to such a terrible family. if only we had known, so many people would have opened their hearts and homes to you. So many childless couples would have made you a wonderful home. We promice that this will never happen again in our little country. We will all be aware of little children who are like you.
9. I agree with #1
Leah ,   Israel   (09.12.08)
For once Israelis and lebanese agree, that the people who did this terrible crime should indeed pay for it. To take such a sweet little girls life like that no words can express how we feel.
10. Must follow proper legal procedure
Arie ,   BaGolan   (09.12.08)
1. Identify the body 2. Formally charge defendants 3.Hold trial 4. If convicted, death penalty 5. Cremate the guilty 6. Spread ashes over gaza where they would be more welcome
11. So desperately sad.
(09.12.08)
12. Farewell Roase
Nice Bloke ,   Rochdale   (09.12.08)
Thou wert the morning star among the living, Ere thy fair light had fled; Now, having died, thou art as Hesperus, giving New splendor to the dead.
13. reply to #10 Arie
Bandar ,   Beirut, Lebanon   (09.12.08)
Arie, this is a tragedy that transcends hatred. What does Gazza have to do with it. Stop being an idiot and show some respect to this little angel.
14. May she rest in Peace...
Michael ,   Tel aviv Israel   (09.12.08)
I'm So sorry for her.... how people can do such things.....?
15. All the country is mourning the tragedy of sweet Rose
gabriela ben ari ,   Jerusalem   (09.12.08)
16. #3 bandar
debbie ,   nola   (09.12.08)
I agree with you.When it comes to this tragic end, there is no group that cares more or less. we all mourn this terrible act of cruelty and inhumanity by sociopaths.I totally agree with you!
17. #10
debbie ,   nola   (09.12.08)
I agree with lebanon - what the hell does Gaza have to do with this?stop bringing in irrelevant issues. call it what it is- pure evil!!!leave Gaza out of it.
18. some praise for Israeli divers
Mike ,   New York   (09.12.08)
it is a hellish task to be doing multiple dives in a murky river, day in, day out. that they found the girl's body is a testament to the skill and bravery of the Navy and Police divers that performed this grueling job. Kudos to them.
19. My middle name is Rose......
(09.12.08)
R.I.P Rose. I wish you could have been one of my babies:-(
20. Bandar , Beirut, Lebanon & Mohammed
Joe ,   Ohio, USA   (09.12.08)
Syria . Thank you for leaving politics out of this tragedy. You've shown yourselves to be better people than some on this page. Let's not compound this senseless tragedy with another by name calling here.
21. #1, I agree with you.
Jake   (09.12.08)
Just like the murderer of Einat Haran and her father, who is now a free man.
22. This a day of mourning for Rose, of blessed memory
Jake   (09.12.08)
The perpetrators must be punished severely. But even so, it will be of little consolation for such a terrible and senseless loss.
23. Rose
Millicent ,   Israel   (09.12.08)
A little angel taken before her time,may you find the peace and love in GDS arms that you never felt here on earth. An entire World Weeps for this little flower picked before she had the chance to blossom. May Gd Bless you Rose, I am sorry that we as a Nation failed you!
24. Say a prayer. A monument should be built for her.
Efroim ,   Washington DC   (09.12.08)
1.Who knows who the red suitcase belonged to? Was its Rose's or another persons? 2. I want to invite all to leave a prayer at the kotel via internet. Here is the link: Simply enter your prayer in the box. Thank You. http://www.aish.com/wallcam/Place_a_Note_in_the_Wall.asp
25. no one to mourn Rose???
Ziad ,   Beirut, Lebanon   (09.12.08)
It hurts so much to look at the eyes of this little girl in the picture knowing that she was denied her basic human right to life. We mourn this little girl and pray to God that she is in a better place today; a place where she can find the love and happiness that she so desperetaly needed yet lacked on this earth.
26. Shame!
Ali ,   Beirut, Lebanon   (09.12.08)
Humanity failed you little angel. May your soul rest in peace.
27. Shocked by murder, where were social services?
Nevena Gueorguieva ,   Paris, France   (09.12.08)
As a mother of two living in France who has had to deal with mental violence, marital problems and postnatal depression I understand how overwhelmed Rose's mother felt. Having to deal with her own problems and tormented overactive children is not easy. Rose's murder is a disgrace, a monstrous act and a shame to whoever did it and whatever for. Rose's life was a misery, a painfull existence that came to a brutal end. Where were social services? Why did they not act? Rest in peace, dear Rose!
28. #27
Kiwi ,   Auckland   (09.13.08)
I see the French are like Kiwis- blame social services instead of the perpetrators themselves. The man who did this violated the basic rules of religion and civilised society; he betrayed his own son, she took up with the father and then he killed Rose because she was in the way. No social services would have protected Rose against this couple's total immorality. They are a selfish pair who only thought of themselves and even her letter is a self serving example of that.
29. Bandar , Beirut, Lebanon
Ginette ,   Toronto   (09.13.08)
You are absolutely right and kind. Arie # 10 is a moron who does not know how to mourn. Gazza has nothing to do with the death of this little angel. PEACE!
30. How can any human be so ruthless?
Daniel ,   ISRAEL   (09.13.08)
First, he snatched his own son's wife! (She was equivalent to his own daughter!) Second, he coolly murdered his own granddaughter Such a person should not have place in our community.
Next talkbacks
Back to article