News
Dichter: Attack on professor Jewish terror
Raanan Ben-Zur
Published: 25.09.08, 21:51
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
27 Talkbacks for this article
1. This reminds me of
moriah ,   sacramento, USA   (09.25.08)
the black professor who got busted plagerizing a former students paper and to throw of the accusers she hung a noose on her office door. The left are devious and not above hurting one of their own to vilify the religious/ nationalistic land loving Jew. The Peace Now et al Left wing groups want to destroy Israel starting with the Rightwing. Their SICKNESS runs deep. If they want so bad to be loved by Edom let them go to Edom....
2. South end of mule talking
Gee ,   Zikron Yaakov   (09.25.08)
Internal Security Minister Dichter is inciting against an entire community without any proof. How do you know if it was Jew? Anything at all? Come on you have stated something without any evidence to support it. Just as the security services incited the attack against Rabin, did they do this as well?
3. ONE NOTCH UP
DAVID ,   JUDEA   (09.25.08)
As was just written before in the article about "a threat to democracy ", the media sharks turn the incitement up another notch. While Dichter sits on his but and let daily attacks take place in Judea, the Shomron and Jerusalem, we can expect and read this clearly" the Jewish section of the shabak "( there was also a Jewish section in the Gestappo) go in and do some serious damage to anything they perceive as a threat , meaning against the political secular agenda. Rabin's murder was used to further the luny left agenda, so this will be used to justify some more progroms from our Herzelist hencemen.
4. Sorry to say it
Fontelle ,   Los Angeles   (09.25.08)
I am sorry to say it but Israel is not a country like any other and the leftist are a cancer to Israel that weakens it. Sternell is very respectable and was not the right target.
5. It is hard to understand what MK Dichter says
Meir Weinstein ,   Toronto, Canada   (09.25.08)
It is a dispicable act, to go out and attack someone that does not share your view. I understand that. But when the professor states his view that the Arabs should use violence against women and children that live in the settlements, that is also dispicable. And I would expect any MK to see this no other way. This professor should not receive the Israel prize because he supports violence.
6. Dupes
Ben ,   Monroe, USA   (09.25.08)
The rebbunim rant and the dupes react. Just as the murderer of rabin still believes he acted in the name of G-D since the rebbunim raved, so do the religious maniacs act now. Religion is the cause of murder in the name of G-d. No surprise that atheists numbers grow.
7. Is there evidence and proof
Meir ,   Raanana   (09.25.08)
that it was done by Jews? Given the facts that there have been NUMEROUS terror attacks in Jerusalem and it has been PROVEN that they were done by "Islamic Activists" and given the fact that many of the victims were not religious Jews or Likudniks or Mafdalniks but in fact also included leftists, and given the fact that many pipe-bombs have been found among the "Islamic Activists" it is logical to presume till proven otherwise that this pipe-bomb used in this act of terror against a Jew in Jerusalem living on occubied land was also perpetrated by "Islamic Activists" Any attack is non democratic, and intolerable, the murders in Merkaz HaRav were undemocratic, so were the two tractor and the BMW attacks, so were the kassam attacks on Sderot, so why is Prof. Sternhell being made MORE of a victim than the others????That is undemocratic too!
8. Shabak Shalom
J Hartman ,   Israel   (09.25.08)
An excellent presentation of what is going through everyone's mind can be found at http://www.israelnationalnews.com/Blogs/Blog.aspx/9#3042 Sternhell should know his friends would have no ethical qualms about giving up his life for the greater cause.
9. jewish terrorism!
czech republic   (09.25.08)
Speaks for itself
10. Is Dichter high on crack-cocaine?
Avraham ,   NYC   (09.25.08)
What Jewish terror? Israel is not doing enough at all to wage a war against the Arab terror that's real and tangible!!!
11. typical mainstream media article
Rami   (09.25.08)
characterised by: (1) lack of the basic info what, who, when, where, how why. (2) gossip, slurs, unproven statements, leftist passion and (3) sows confusion, mistrust, miscommunication
12. Time to get rid of dichter!
jason white ,   afula,israel   (09.25.08)
Arab terrorists killing Jews and he sits back and does nothing. Someone wounding an enemy of Israel and he cries out about terrorism. To go after organized crime, rapists, child molesters, thieves, drug dealers, white slavers and terrorists is nothing. We have to get whoever did this and nothing else is important! Who cares about this professor? Why provide him and the other enemies of the state with security. We need the police to prevent crimes to citizens and not traitors!
13. Ummm
Galut ,   Selah   (09.25.08)
Proof> , right? ,left? ,Ruze to diminish ? maybe there should be an independant invetigation ? Who Knows ?
14. Step 1: Deny there is Arab Terrorism.
Progressive Agitator ,   Dickter   (09.26.08)
Step 2: Invent Jewish Terrorism Step 3: Lock up the dissidents. Step 4: ????? Step 5: Profit!
15. It's not Terror. It's Freedom Fighting.
Menashe ,   NY   (09.25.08)
If Islamic Terrorism is freedom fighting according to Sternheil - this is Super Uber Ultra Freedom fighting.
16. wheres all the tough talk....
(09.25.08)
on arab terrorism? Arab runs over soldiers and the press writes about how he was rejected by his cousin.
17. The extreme left believes in "The end justifies the means."
Michael Berg ,   Toronto, Canada   (09.26.08)
It is far more likely that this was committed by the extreme-left. Read this: http://www.israelnationalnews.com/Blogs/Blog.aspx/9#3042
18. Right-wing, left-wing or Shabak-instigated Jewish terror?
Prof. Reuven Bar-On ,   Israel   (09.26.08)
Although a thorough and impartial investigation has not yet been completed let alone begun, Dichter has reached the conclusion that this is an act of "Jewish" terrorism. IF, in fact, he is right that it is an act of Jewish terrorism, it must be determined if it is an act of right-wing or left-wing Jewish terrorism, or an act of terrorism instigated by the Security Service (“Shabak”) for example. It's still open, everything is possible, and all forms of Jewish and non-Jewish terrorism have happened in the past.
19. DICHTER KNOWS ABOUT PROVOCATIONS
(09.26.08)
20. right wing persecution
paul ,   ranana   (09.26.08)
starts whenever the left and the governing elite feel Bibi Natanyahu is getting close to become PM
21. Anyone STOP to consider...
rachel ,   chutz4now   (09.26.08)
that the bombs are from PA? I mean after all....all they need to get the bug to kill, is a simple break up with a girl. "Jewish terrorism" is like saying "Jumbo shrimp" it makes no logical sense.
22. It sounds like the usual lefty crying-out for sympathy to me
EGW ,   vancouver canada   (09.26.08)
Dichter and his "Rabib" crap. Has anybody considered how utterly INEPT the Jewish "terrorist" efforts are, and that included the poor guy who got 15 years ( and they won't allow any normal privileges) for trying to scare the Arabs with the school bomb, in which NOBODY was hurt, it being OUTSIDE the school, and at a time when no one was there. Considwering the huge amount of IDF talent in the religious sector, especially in YESHA, if they REALLY wanted to kill someone, why can't they?? Guns are plentiful, explosives are chancy and complicated.........A FAKE.
23. Do they have any proof?
Matt C ,   Canada   (09.26.08)
Do they have any proof that this is "Jewish terror"? Because if they do not it is grossly irresponsible to rush to assign blame. Perhaps they are simply assuming that Sternhell is such a supporter of the Arabs over the Jews that they would never harm him.
24. Where is the Outcry
Ralph Levy ,   USA   (09.26.08)
Where is the outcry by the Israeli government against the Left Wing groups and them taking foreign government money. Who is protecting these groups from scrutiny. http://ralphsrant1.blogspot.com/
25. Based on the talkbacks, methinks that Dichter got caught
David ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (09.26.08)
with his hand in the cookie jar. After all, we know that he specializes in anti-right wing arrest and instigations. How many Jews have been arrest because of him? How many investigated on false charges of crime or tax evasion? How many 10-16 years old Jewish boys and girls were held for months at his behest? Dichter, you've been outed!
26. Dichter and honesty
(09.26.08)
Margalit Har-Shefi was imprisoned because the court decided that she knew what Yigal Amir was planning. Years later, Dichter admitted that he and the SHABAK knew all along that she was innocent. Is it surprising that a man who let an innocent rot in jail to support his political beliefs would join this wild incitement?
27. Jewish intimidation?Harrassment?yeah, but 'terror'?hell no
shneerhere ,   USA   (09.26.08)
Tell me, please, how many Leftist or Arab restaurants have been blown to smithereens? How many Arab and Leftist buses been blown up? How many Leftist and Arab little schoolgirls have been intentionally shot at point-blank range repeatedly? Yeah, pipe bombs are violent, criminal, etc. Don't call it terror. You insult all the blind, deaf and limbless among us with your sweeping, hysterical denunciations!
Back to article