News
Ahmadinejad: Zionism has nothing to do with Jewish people
Reuters
Published: 26.09.08, 10:07
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
22 Talkbacks for this article
1. Move UN to iran, they deserve each other.
Bunnie Meyer ,   Los Angeles, CA USA   (09.26.08)
2. and ahmadenijad has nothing to do with intelligence
mike ,   israel (formerly usa   (09.26.08)
the more he talks, the dumber we discover he is. keep it up, persia boy.
3. We'll see if he changes his views.
Dan ,   Californi   (09.26.08)
4. Nonsense. Dialogue is meaningless.
Avinoam ,   Tel Aviv, Israel   (09.26.08)
I am not a Zionist. I do not think that it is an ideology fitting the modern age and a modern Israel. However, to claim that it has nothing to do with the Jewish people is preposterous. It was an ideology that was absolutely necessary for the survival of the Jewish people. Some may argue that it still is. (Though I would disagree.) This is all a game of distraction using classic anti-semetic rhetoric. There is absolutely no point in any discussion with Ahmadinejad. His basic premises will never change. They are fundamental to his political position. The purpose of this distraction is to buy time for his nuclear program. Iran has brought much death and destruction to Israel, and in fact has little genuine concern for the Palestinian problem, but merely uses them as a pawn and aggravates any potential peace with their propaganda. and investment in terrorism. He should be brought up on charges of crimes against humanity, and not wined and dined like some celebrity. To treat him as such only validates his point of view.
5. disccusion
Elizabeth ,   Australia   (09.26.08)
I believe that Iran's president wants to make a peace for everybody. He has to intolerantly follow whole space tolerance to be sure the world wants to speak about problems, politic violence and corruptions. I believe in change. Here is a challenge.
6. A-jad is just another Goliath.Soon he will get a smooth
stone between the ,   eyes.   (09.26.08)
7. annoying
Ketsia   (09.26.08)
Why dont we invite the Devil over for dinner while we r at it?
8. When will we learn?
Oleg ,   Canada   (09.26.08)
Look at these nice Jewish people..they have asked for understanding!!!! wow...we really need this understanding thing with Ahmanidajad ! when will Jewish people get rid off of such idiots amongst us , when will we learn?
9. score one more for mahmoud
Doron   (09.26.08)
duh people, this is obviously a publicity stunt. the guy loves the attention and also can get away with saying that he was having a dialogue when he was really just enjoying the humus. this is the same as sitting down with hitler (really, i'm not kidding, compare mein kampf with mahmouds blog and you will find eerie similarities...) and should not be done.
10. He does not need understanding....
Andy ,   ramat hasharon   (09.26.08)
He needs to be killed. And, btw YNET please do not censor my opinion here.
11. disgraceful
(09.26.08)
barbaric and unbelievable thaqt here in our land of freedom, this beast of a hateful man is given respect and a podium for his vile theories and lies.
12. Ode to Stalin
Michael ,   Moscow, USA   (09.26.08)
Joseph (Osip) Mandelshtam once wrote a poem called ‘Ode to Stalin’. He did it out of desperation. Hounded by GPU agents, being poverty-stricken and seeing most of his friends and loved-ones sent to GuLag he wrote that piece. But even then he could not overcome a poetic truth within and wrote about Stalin’s fat fingers and sleazy demeanor. Infuriated Stalin got him arrested and killed in exile. Why am I talking about it today? It’s because some extravagant Californian woman calling herself a ‘rabbi’ wrote an ‘Ode to Iran’ and to mr. Achmadinejad by proxy. The link can be found here: http://shomershalom.org/blog/2008/06/11/ode-to-iran-by-rabbi-lynn-gottieb/ For her publicity has no shame
13. how fascinating & not 1 guest brought in a gun or bomb!
(09.27.08)
Can you just imagine what it would have been like if this were a dinner with an Israeli leader and there were Shite Moslems invited?
14. #2 Actually he does. He is proof that you can teach a monkey
to do anything!!!!!   (09.27.08)
15. Ahmadinejad
Mark ,   Minnesota   (09.27.08)
How convenient to separate "zionism" and the jews. You cannot. How can a man who says he wants to push Israel into the sea be taken seriously? There is evil in this world and this man is EVIL.
16. Get a grip
Mike Coakley ,   Halifax, Canada   (09.27.08)
This guy is insane... #9 you're right he loves all the attention he is probably laffing at the fact that the Americans tolerate him spouting his verbal garbage while he is a clear enemy of the west and would attack Israel immediatley is she didn't have the backing of America (even though Israel has proven it can handle itself with anyone)... its like Hitler with Britain and France... give me czechoslovakia and ill be happy and boom they did it as he was laffing at their stupidity. As they helped him acheive his goals before pouncing on them too.
17. Interfaith Dinner
Bob ,   Clarksburg, WV, USA   (09.27.08)
I see that Islam has its own "useful idiots" in the religious community. These people are simply enabling evil by their own lack of spiritual discernment, naivete', and downright stupidity. Anti-semitism takes many guises.
18. Ah-my-dinner-jacket
Rachel ,   S.Africa   (09.27.08)
What I find hard to understand is why these people are given publicity. Why are their puerile donkey-brayings put out there for the world to read?. All it does is give them legitimacy in the eyes of the many global ignorants. They are read and quoted by millions - all of this is just grist to their mill and it spreads their insane ideologies round the globe. I say there should be a blanket of media silence when it comes to people like this. Don't give them airspace.
19. What does it mean...?
grandee ,   chapel hill , TN   (09.28.08)
to love an enemy? What does it mean?? What does Christ mean in Matthew 5:44?? What did it mean for Christ to love the enemy of His Father--we who are at emnity with God?? We are that enemy whom Christ loved. What does it mean to love an enemy?? What does it mean??
20. He is not dumb and should be taken very seriously
Kurtlane ,   Orange County, CA   (09.30.08)
He is not dumb and should be taken very seriously. Hitler wasn't taken seriously in time, and we all paid for it. This man is new Hitler.
21. Re: Love your enemy
Kurtlane ,   Orange County, CA   (09.30.08)
You can love your enemy or hate him, but in some cases you have to kill him. This is just the case.
22. About others at that dinner
Kurtlane ,   Orange County, CA   (09.30.08)
About others at that dinner: Those who sell their dignity for peace deserve neither.
Back to article