News
Rightists say all IDF soldiers 'should become Gilad Shalit'
Efrat Weiss
Published: 26.10.08, 12:58
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
51 Talkbacks for this article
1. we need a 3 state solution
Avi ,   Ramat Gan   (10.26.08)
one state for secular people with tel aviv as its capital another state for the Palestinian people with East Jerusalem as their capital and a third state for the religious right wing fanatics including the charideem. Now can we get on with our lives please?
2. I love this.
Bandar ,   Beirut, Lebanon   (10.26.08)
Its the beginning of a beautiful day.
3. Ramon is wagging his tongue again!
Pete ,   Bat Yam   (10.26.08)
"Ramon said that "had an Arab called for a terror attack on the radio, he would have been arrested a long time ago. " Every Friday Arab Muezzins incite against the Jews and the IDF from the loudspeakers of the Mosques and are allowed to get away with it Ramon needs to get sex out of his head and pay attention to other things than female bodies! He needs to be aware of what is going on in the world. The only thing he knows about the IDF is the quickest way to get into a chayelet's pants!
4. obviously talking about those who destroyed jewish homes
Avi   (10.26.08)
5. israelis and jews
nomis ,   cape rsa   (10.26.08)
once again the leftists drive the wedge between israelis and jews,what seems to be a growing difference.israelis, wake up out of your coma,arabs will never like you,jews know this,fact.may the wild crops grow strong, as the other crop has been taken over by weeds and seeks to become like them.
6. No words to describe these sick animals
Talula ,   Israel   (10.26.08)
These people are simply too vile for words. I have nothing but hatred and contempt for them. Fanatic Morons without brains and no direction in their lives. I hope only BAD things happen to them for saying something so vile. I also hope they all go to hell, very soon.
7. #6
g ,   eli   (10.26.08)
For a person who thinks they are above these people you sure know how to go down to their level. Alternative approach perhaps... What they said was very inappropriate. If these comments were made at a time of rage I hope they will come down and see what they said was wrong. I wish them to do tschuva for what they say.
8. You reap what you sow
Mani ,   Birmingham, UK   (10.26.08)
And don't act like you never saw what pampering the religious fanatics would leade to. Egypt: President assassinated by a religious fanatic in 1981. Afghanistan: Government overthrown by a group of ignorant religious fanatics calling them the Talebans. Israel: Prime minister assassinated by a religious empty-head. Keep pampering them and you will reap what you sow.
9. Real "Right-wingers"...
El-Nakam ,   Tel Aviv, Israel   (10.26.08)
...don't use the term "Palestinians." They say "Arabs." They don't call for slaughter of IDF soldiers. And they don't run around masked and shirtless. Shabak incitement, anyone?
10. Where are you going?
Dorothea Killus ,   Germany   (10.26.08)
Israel - where are you going? Your self-destruction as a state - in the year when we celebrate your 60-years-of-existence! - seem s to know no limit. The photo of the destroyed Federman "Illegal outpost" is a witness against you before the world and shows utter blindness for God's purposes. We who are watching the ongoing events after the Gaza expulsion from afar and with a deply heavy heart, ful mourn with you, the Federmans, and pray to the LORD of Lords, the God of Israel, to step in. For Israel's self-destruction is clear rebellion against HaShem. He will surely not suffer his holy nanme to be trampled down by his own people.
11. stick to killing leftists pleeeease - thisstory is bs
petoius ,   salonika   (10.26.08)
continued shinbit incitement.
12. Talula
thomas ,   England   (10.26.08)
I notice that you have 'nothing but hatred and contempt' for many individuals and groups. You must have a lot of hatred stored up in you to be able to shower it out so generously! P.s i didn't think you believed in hell
13. Shabbak or leftist media incitement
Patriot ,   formerly gush katif   (10.26.08)
Sounds like shabbak , or leftist media incitement against "settlers". I've lived in Judea, Samaria and Gaza - I've never heard a Jew call for the death of Israeli soldiers. The "settlers" all serve themselves in miluim (reserves) and send their sons to the IDF. Why would these same "settlers" call for their own or their sons' death?
14. #7 - what is "tschuva"?
israeli   (10.26.08)
never heard of that word here in Israel.
15. Dorothea Killus , Germany
DR ,   Israel   (10.26.08)
Rest assured Dorthea that every thing you said rings strong in the heart of all believing Jews. We have always had a harder time struggling with our brother Jews than we ever had with an external enemy. Never fear. In the end we will win this struggle with ourselves and become the stronger for it, living in a Jewish State and not an Israeli one.
16. NO to Ravaging Jewish homes
Brod ,   USA   (10.26.08)
This is a despicable act against Jews living in their liberated biblical and historic homeland. The fact is Jews have all the rights in the world to live anywhere in the Land of Israel-the Land of their Ancestors. GOD has restored Modern Israel in Ancient Israel in the 20th century as a Fulfillment of His Covenant to Israel 2500 years ago. Jeremiah 31:1-17, Ezekiell 36:24-38, Ezekiel 37:21-28, Ezekiel 39:27-29, Amos 9:14-15. The Leftists who do not know the GOD of Israel should stop playing god on Israel. Ravaging Jewish homes as they did in Ghush Khatif is playing right into the hands of Israel's pernicious enemies. It is time the government of Israel protects its people instead of hurting them who are the bastion of Israel's survival and existence. GOD, the Holy Bible and History are on the side of these brave patriotic Jews whose homes have been ravaged. It is time to stop this madness.
17. Propaganda
Marty ,   USA   (10.26.08)
You don't even mention part of what actually happened till the end of the story. Is this because you wanted the reader's mind to be outraged from the start. Had you mentioned in the beginning of the story that a Mother, Father and their nine children were attacked in the middle of the night without warning in a Gestapo type manner and that the broken glass fell all over the children, your reader may have had a chance to make up his own mind. Shame on Ynet.
18. olmert and disengagement
alexi   (10.26.08)
Who is olmert to spit at israeli settlers when his sons Ariel ran away from the IDf duty and the other son sits at nicklolodean in New York having protested idf activities. Who is Ehud, who because of some earlier injuries did no idf combat duty. Who is aliza, from a holocaust family who allows her husband to incite against jews rather than talk moderately about what to do. Who is ehud whose decisons killed 200 soliders for nothing, a big fat nothing. This imbecile ouught to be indicted but for the hapless, appeasing Mazzuzz who shares olmert's gutless ideology. Mazzuzz never spent a day in real court and that's why he is even now investigating olmert after allof the work had been done. Olmert belongs in jail along with araB RAPISTS. The whole olmert family is corrupt and gutless to the core.
19. NUTS
eddie ,   london, UK   (10.26.08)
whoever said this is crazy but, why is it Ok to transfer Jews, yet brand the Kahanists as fascists if they wish to transfer the Palis?
20. #12
Talula ,   Israel   (10.26.08)
Are your sons in the IDF? Are they both in combat units? Do you worry so much about them that you find it hard to breath sometimes? No, I didn't think so. So shut your gob and don't stick your nose in.
21. Olmert, Peres, Barak need......
Fortune ,   Brooklyn NY   (10.26.08)
To makae Aliyah to Saudi Arabia. There they can sit in luxury and smoke a Hukkah all day and complain about Israel politics. WAKE UP ISRAEL......Your land is being taken away under your eyes. Tel Aviv is next!!!!
22. Police with no hearts
Meira ,   Yesha   (10.26.08)
How can anyone have the nerve to go and demolish ones home at 1:30 in the morning without any notice? The kids were fast asleep and all of a sudden the police come marching right up to their house and start smashing the windows. The glass went all over the beds. They threw all of the books off the shelves. They broke all the dishes. The poor family doesn't even have any clothes or shoes left. Everything is in the rubble.
23. Olmert wants civil war in order to stay capo
Ariel Ben Yochanan ,   Kfar Tapuah   (10.26.08)
24. ISRAEL GOVERMENT AGAIST JEW, THEN SOON G'D AGAINST ISRAEL
THEN MASHIACH ,   ..............DACON9   (10.26.08)
25. Islamic incitement ALLOWED
Marcel ,   Florida   (10.26.08)
When the leader of the Islamic movement in Nazareth Sheikh Saleh openly called incitement against Israel saying much worse things the cowards Olmert and Pamon did nothing .They have lied time and again and said he woul;d be 'investigated' for incitiement. These COWARDS have done nothing but lie and make excuses for the Islamic jihadists. They do have great courage to go after fellow Jews and talk big when it comes to removing this non existent threat while helping the real threat to grow as they have done with Gaza. The real enemy are these cowards.
26. TALULA, WHATS THE DIFFERENCE, INNOCENT CITIZENS OR IDF,NONE.
ITS EVIL GOVERMENT ,   ,,,,,,,,,,....DACON9   (10.26.08)
27. #1 enjoy it
observer   (10.26.08)
at least the three states are seemingly independent; unlike you neighbors who have state within state.
28. Sad truth - no civil rights in Israel, nor good journalism
JPS ,   Efrat   (10.26.08)
As much as I have revulsion for any from the lunatic fringe who open their mouths and have diarhea come out, this article simply does not reflect the facts of what happened. Buried waaaaay down in the article is "Shortly after 1:30 am on Saturday night, massive police, Border Guard and IDF forces arrived near the Federman home." No matter what stupid things his followers said (and they are NOT :"the settlers", the vast majority of whom are law abiding citizens), this guy's home was bulldozed in the middle of the night and his kids hauled out of their beds in their bedclothes. I may not agree with Federman and his allies, but the police and army were waaaay out of line and he had the right to defend himself when assaulted in the middle of the night. If citizens are supposed to obey the law and follow due process, the authorities are obligated to do so even more. That the press in Israel is concentrating on the reaction to the story, rather than the story itself, is simply a sign of the low standard of journalism the world has come to.
29. God
Israel   (10.26.08)
I'm wondering what God is thinking when he hears them talk like that. Bet he's none to pleased. I'd strike them all down with a bolt of lightening if I was him.
30. illegal outpost?
observer   (10.26.08)
how can somebody build a legal construction on illegal ground? what's built on illegally occupied ground can't acquire the legality regardless of whatever legal procedures followed?
Next talkbacks
Back to article