News
Yaalon: Withdrawals must end
Amnon Meranda
Published: 18.11.08, 19:54
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
29 Talkbacks for this article
1. land for no peace must not end
Marcel ,   Florida   (11.18.08)
This is how we defeat Israel without a war so Israel must continue it's surrender and appeasment for our peace of Islam. If you don't continue to surender your land to us we will declare war on you. Signed; Moderate Moslems
2. Bogie is the man
Frank ,   Canada   (11.18.08)
Bogie will work at defeating Arabs and at creating winning strategies based on ground realities and threats instead of wishful thinking and empty dreams.
3. Ya’alon is one of the few politicians who really gets it
Mladen Andrijasevic ,   Be'er Sheva, Israel   (11.18.08)
A New Strategy for the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict Lt.-Gen. (ret.) Moshe Yaalon http://www.jcpa.org/Templates/ShowPage.asp?DRIT=1&DBID=1&LNGID=1&TMID=111&FID=442&PID=0&IID=2515&TTL=A_New_Strategy_for_the_Israeli-Palestinian_Conflict
4. Finally a sane Israeli leader.
Yacov ,   Chicago   (11.18.08)
With all the left-wing lunacy of giving away territory and getting terror in return, it is wonderful to see one Israeli leader not afflicted with Oslo Psychosis. We have places in America for people like Olmert and Beilin....they are called insane asylums.
5. marcel, you have far too much time on your hands mate
(11.18.08)
6. Dont confuse Yaalon with the other leftist one
JAy ,   Israel   (11.18.08)
You know, the colonel Klink look alike, without the monocle, that is starting his own party and wants to give the Golan and Israel away to our enemies.
7. #5
Marcel ,   Florida   (11.18.08)
Thanks for the compliment. IT'S AN HONOR I guess bringing to light the game plan of Israel's enemies and phony friends bothers you ? And by the way I'm not your mate ,dude afraid to leave his name because it is probally mohammed.
8. for Israel to get peace it must return ALL the land
Joseph ,   Hull Canada   (11.18.08)
if you someone owe you 1000$ will you stop requesting him to repay you if he give you 10$??? why should the Arabs give you peace if you return a very small portion of the land??
9. Yaalon would be Israel's greatest Defense Minister.
LEE ,   NY, USA   (11.18.08)
10. Do we have another option?
Jewish Refugee ,   U.S.A.   (11.18.08)
Likud is our last chance to revive Israel. If this party fails Israel will pay a heavy price. We have to follow the actions of all the parties not only before the elections and after so we don't have another Ehud Olmert and Company as our leaders. Please Join the New Blog, you finally can make your voices heard without any sensoring, and let everyone know what you think. JOIN http://israelactnow.blogspot.com/
11. #8 CRUSH is the word
CIA ,   NYC   (11.18.08)
First of all "It is OUR land! Second: We are NOT asking for Arab peace! If they want peace we will have peace! If they want WAR (which they do), We want to CRUSH them! (not talk)
12. To Marcel:
Boaz ,   Haifa   (11.18.08)
Quit being such a sour pickle. Just because no one in America trusts Arabs anymore (and for good reason), doesn't mean you have to take your anger out on us. And a vote for Likud is the right choice! They will quit licking America's %&^@ and start thinking for whats good for ISRAEL!!
13. #8, Olny if you give your house to Indians first.
Yoni ,   Chiloquin   (11.18.08)
#8 you are operating on a false assumption that the murderous arabs owned that land. I believe in Land For Peace but not the direction the arabs want. When a suicide bomber or rocket strikes Israel the town that it originated from should be leveled and turned into a nice new Jewish peace center with nice new homes for Jews. This is war not negotiations. The only stipulation ever put on any accord with the arabs was the sensation of violence. The arabs killed Jews before 1948 and they have never stopped , this is not about land. This is a lesson in how to train a barbaric culture not to hate and kill, you have to use a huge stick to train them. The problem is that every other barbaric arab nation around Israel wants to also kill Jews. So to hell with those who's simplistic views only show their deep rooted anti-Semitism. Your European Jew bashing has never given Jews their rightful property, you have stolen from Jews and now you want arabs to take Jewish land away. Israel is Jewish land, let the arabs make painful concessions for a change.
14. beware of Bibi's tough friends ...
avi   (11.18.08)
they might be too with Iran and start the irreparable ... WAR.
15. #12 Boaz
Marcel ,   Florida   (11.19.08)
I'll quit being a sour pickle when Am Yisrael stop acting like grasshoppers and annexes Judea and Samaria and turns Gaza into grazing land for sheep and goats according to Hashems peace plan of Exodus 23:27-33. Deal ?
16. Peace (really lack of war) comes from strenght, not from
Bunnie Meyer ,   Los Angeles, CA USA   (11.19.08)
sucking up the the terrorists.
17. Geneva convention
zechariah   (11.19.08)
IF the arabs adopt the Geneva convention with iran they can have an autonomous security state protected the the us israeli missile manhatten nuclear shields . The arabs who adopt in their hearts and souls the un human rights charters can stay but the islamists who are against the one hundred year truce must be expelled.
18. #5 With all the time he has on his HANDS, his nickmame is
Marcel Jackov!!! ,   MATE!!!!   (11.19.08)
19. olmert offers more concession
alexi   (11.19.08)
i don't care what the weakling mazzuzz says about's olmert status-the IDF, barak and ashkenazi MUST NOT do any more withdrawals as Olmert wants in Gandjar. Olmert is desperate and vengeful against israel. Hezbollah will spin it as israeli weakness. Barak and IDF- no more withdrawals-no more releases with Olmert. He is cancer to israel-all he has brought is death and losses and lack of will, the coward that he is. Do not endorese his move to giv e up gandjar. Winograd has condemned as a loser who has no judgment. You can say no. Beside he will soon be indicted. Don't be taken in.Olmert confused sharon with the gaza withdrawal and then misled israel as to rabin's moves. He is cancer to israel!!!!
20. Yaalon is right if U.S.A and Europe’s will not interfere to
e.m.Jordan is Palest ,   s.f   (11.19.08)
21. Vote People, Vote!
Ginette ,   Toronto, Canada   (11.19.08)
Marcel in Florida...I sense you are starting to shake in your boots, are you? No? Then maybe you should as Yaalon was ousted not in disgrace but rather due to warped politics and most of all jealousy. He is made of that special cloth (guts and pride) only your Arab friends can dream of. I for one am very happy he finally "woke up" and decided this can't go on, Israel needs its pride and its strength restored. Bogie was the best, the toughest IDF chief of staff this tiny country ever had. Bibi is a smart man who is now making the right choice. He is (was) a statesman so let him be P.M.; however the real foot soldier who will save him and Israel is Bogie and no one else. Take that to the bank and go vote. Bye-bye Livni, bye-bye Kadima, hoping to never hear from you again!
22. joining Likud
zee ,   denver, usa   (11.19.08)
a loser joining another loser.
23. but yes ! retreat must halt beginning today in hebron !!!
avi   (11.19.08)
24. Wow, what an addition!!
Meir ,   Beit Shemesh   (11.19.08)
The Likud looks so impressive now. With the team of Netanyahu, Begin, Chefetz, Yaalon, Dayan, it's a winner, and I'm sure we can rely on these guys to look after Israel's interests.
25. 21
Israel   (11.19.08)
Why dont' you vote? oh, that's right - you don't live here and are not entitled to vote - so why stick your nose in?
26. Must end? (When?) Or no more? Which?
Paqid Yirmeyahu ,   Ra'anana, Israel   (11.19.08)
27. # 25 Israel
Ginette ,   Toronto, Canada   (11.19.08)
Wrong again! I am the female version of James Bond. I hold an Israeli passport, a Canadian passport and a French passport and all of them up to date. So there, my voice can be heard and counted in three countries.
28. so yaalon ignores mortars, qassams, and terrorist tunnels?
mike ,   israel (formerly usa   (11.19.08)
if israeli settlements were still in gaza, there would be not only unprecedented pounding of israelis there, not to mention terrorists popping out of every place in the ground to kill/capture jews that it would be stunning. he's a great military leader, but not so good as a politician.
29. #28 you have it wrong
Yossi ,   New York, NY   (11.23.08)
because Israel is no longer in Gaza do we hear of mortars, qassams and terrorist tunnels. If they were there they would control most of that (like they did before the disengagement). Boogi is right: no point giving an inch back and no point talking to them until they recognize our right to live. Period.
Back to article