News
Chabad centers in India heighten alert
Yael Levy
Published: 01.12.08, 00:26
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
18 Talkbacks for this article
1. Give every Chabad staff a Glock, teach them to use it.
Bunnie Meyer ,   Los Angeles, CA USA   (12.01.08)
2. What do they do there?
Edithann ,   USA   (12.01.08)
What does a Chabad Outreach group do? ..Are they something like Mother Theresa only Jewish? Just asking.. TATA
3. There is no mitzvah in staying there
Al   (12.01.08)
Its a place of death much like Germany and Poland. Chabad, I understand your akshonos but this is insanity. The Yidden belong in Eretz Yisroel. Thats where you have to concentrate your efforts. Israel needs to become a Jewish country. The very lives of 5 M yidden lies in the balance. There is no mitzvah in staying in these g-d forsaken hell holes. This is not mesiras nefesh. This is a narisha geiva. These kedoshim have the zhus of being buried in Eretz Yisroel. My garndparents along with millions of other kedoshim didnt have that Zhus. They died al kiddush hashem and I their grandson have no need whatsoever to ever step into that toma called Europe. Mumbai after this horror is toma..It is not a place for yidden ever.
4. Negotiating with the Terrorists
Zalman ,   Paris, France   (12.01.08)
Lubavitch blogger, Leah Kleim is reporting that she was negotiating with the terrorists up until the Indian forces burst in. She claims she had made a deal with them to transfer $100m US into a Pakistani bank account and was attempting to secure safe passage for the terrorists to Afghanistan. Has anyone else heard this?
5. People in foreign countries should return home until after
Rivkah   (12.01.08)
events expected to unfold next February are past. This attack is a drop in the bucket of what is expected to happen when the US dollar is declared a non-currency when the interest on the national debt can no longer be paid and the economies of the world collapse. Bob Trefz and Hal Turner and others believe there will be roundups of millions of people before martial law is declared in America, most likely in February 2009. First the electricity will go out, then roundups from midnight to 4 AM. When martial law is declared after a national emergency is declared, the plan under P.D.D. 51 is to seal off the cities that are expected to erupt into civil war. No one will be allowed into or out of the cities after two hours. Food trucks will not go into cities. When enough people have killed each other off and/or starved to death, that it is safe for the troops to go in and haul off the dead, the government officials will come out of hiding in bunkers. That is how scared they are of getting killed when the good life ends in America and communism begins. Bob Trefz has been in hiding for years after attempts on his life, like being shot at by snipers when he walked to his mailbox on his property. His 5 DVD lecture "Meltdown!" which is about 7 hours of listening is scary. I had to take a medicine to calm my heart and call a girlfriend to share my grief at it all after listening to the lectures which took a few days because it is so painful to contemplate. Revelation chapter 18 discusses the collapse of Babylon the Great which might be the collapse of the world economies that may come in February. Hal Turner thinks the dollar will be replaced with an Amero currency for North America. Bob Trefz thinks it will be a world currency, called the Phoenix.
6. Chabad Houses and all hotels need armed guards at the front
Rivkah   (12.01.08)
door and metal detectors, like hotels in Israel. Costs too much? It will take a year for the Taj Mahal Hotel to get any revenue again because of needed repairs after the terrorist attacks. A few guards with guns and metal detectors in retrospect is less costly. Of course, the reports that Indian guards with guns would not use them to deter the terrorists, is unsettling.
7. Assume your choices...
EYS ,   Montreal Canada   (12.01.08)
Ok, so stay there and don't complain if something similar is happening again in a couple of months. And it will happen, because India has a big potential of being targeted by muslim terrorism once again. Some people will never understand.
8. come on boys ! you fear Elohim don't you ?
avi   (12.01.08)
Didn't it strike you that this terror over Chabad Jews happened just after the Chabad Conference in NY ??? Come home, there is much more to do here, don't comfort our brothers to travel outside Israel for no reason, come and let's our land bloom with our efforts, your great wisdom is much welcomed here in Sderot for instance 'cause you say not afraid of bombs are you ???
9. Israel should follow Chabad’s Example!
Jewish Refugee ,   U.S.A.   (12.01.08)
Every time there is a threat to Israel the present government of Israel capitulates. We have seen this in Lebanon 2000, Gaza, Lebanon 2006, recently the government was discussing the withdrawal from North Israeli border with Lebanon that should fall under U.N. supervision. Soon we going to see Jerusalem and Golan Heights surrounded if the government is not voted out the office. But here we have small group Chabad that has more will to spread light and protect its rights than the whole country of Israel does. Go Chabad!!!! Please join our new pro-Israeli blog where you can finally voice your opinion, write your own article to be published on the blog, vote, and above all show how we support Israel. All this at http://israelactnow.blogspot.com/.
10. For every gross act of barbarism
Joe ,   Ohio, USA   (12.01.08)
countless acts of humanity are expressed. May the people in the Chabad centers continue to do good things in the world,. It has to make a difference at some point
11. #8 Avi, there's already a Chabad Rabbi in Sderot
Roman ,   Lod, Israel   (12.01.08)
So your point? Or do you simply prefer to make somewhat amusing insinuations about who got "punished" and for what?
12. Bush is sending Condi to India
David ,   USA   (12.01.08)
Will she tell India to give land to the terrorists and relax security at the border? It works wonders for Israel.
13. #2 - Edithann
Chaya ,   Bat Yam   (12.01.08)
Chabad Houses all over the world - especially in far-flung places - provide a temporary "Jewish home" for - mainly - Israeli travelers who love to travel the world right after army service. Chabad centers provide kosher food, Shabbat hospitality, Torah study and - in the case of the Mumbai center - drug rehabilitation. Most of the visitors are not religious at all. Many have come to India to get some 'spirituality.' And Chabad helps to fight against this searching for spirituality in other places.
14. to edithann
(12.01.08)
chabad's purpose is to make jews more observant. along the way they also help with drug addiction, serve hot meals and generally provide a warm family like atmosphere for jews wherever they are travelling. since so many jews (israelis) travel to india there are quite a few chabad houses there, but there are in almost every country in the world as well.
15. #14 deliberately nasty maybe?
bad taste   (12.01.08)
nobody 'makes' anybody observant. They 'make' them feel they have a home away fron home, but you know this don't you. Send them a donation as a way of apologising. All parents of those that Chabad have helped should send a donation, such as the parents of the drugged, lost, imprisoned and suicidal that these shlichim have saved. It's the leat you can do. Yes, our family has sent a donation and did so when our children and grandchildren were holidaying in Thailand and spent a Shabbat with them.
16. Huckleberries in season
Gideon Reader   (12.01.08)
Miss Bunny, Why not give them a 60mm mortar. They will not/cannot use either one, Golck or Mortar, and the mortar is more effective. Presentation of a firearm does NOT confer on the giftee the needed mindset, and practical skills needed to make the cost and presentation effective. I can give you a Glock(the Model of your choice)and make you a skilled and confident shootist, but it would take a time and personal committment and effort on your part. Chabadnikim are more committed towards their mission of religion than towards becoming CCW holders and skilled shooters. By the way. It would take a consolidated course of about eight weeks to give you the mechanical shooting skills, IF you had reasonable hand-eye coordination. Teaching you to be an adequate gunfighter? Maybe never. It's all midset.
17. My opinion, stay out of India NOW
AlbertoGa ,   St. George UT, USA   (12.01.08)
It is a soft target to terrorist muslim gangs. It is clear that India did nothing to protect the center. It is time to stay out of tourism in the area for the moment. Plenty to do in Israel.
18. # 17
arjun hardas ,   new delhi, india   (12.01.08)
I think it is you should never enter india EVER. You talk like a typical a** who loves to talk without having a clue what's going on and and what the facts are. stay in the US, where yr druggies and serial killers make life a far safer place for yr kids
Back to article