News
Diskin: Hamas could reach Beersheba
Roni Sofer
Published: 21.12.08, 14:45
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
28 Talkbacks for this article
1. Stupid, stupid "government".
Mike ,   Rishon, Israel   (12.21.08)
All this business could be solved in a very short time if we had a "prime minister" with balls enough to do it. All he has to do is announce that with effect from a specific date about 1 week from now, all rockets which land in Israel will be responded to with 3 larger rockets from Israel, and they will land wherever they land - and that's it. And to hell with the consequences....that will bring peace and quiet to the southern areas as Hamas won't dare to contradict that type of counterthreat. Innocent people would have a week to get the hell out of range and we wouldn't be risking our soldiers lives which is the MOST important thing to us. Stupid, stupid "government".
2. No confidence
Ofer ,   Israel   (12.21.08)
I have zero faith in the intelligence establishment's estimation of what Hamas does or does not want to do, and zero faith in the government's "plan" for Gaza. After the humuliating withdrawl from Gaza and Lebanon and the 2nd Lebanese war I've lost all confidence in the actions of Barak, Olmert and all the rest of the washed-up hacks.
3. The ''New, Improved Lull'' .....
Terry ,   Eilat, Israel   (12.21.08)
Listen to this nonsense double-talk. They want a lull but they don't want a lull. They're ready to continue military operations against us but they're still interested in a lull. In the meantime, now they can target Beersheva. So, of course, let's wait until they can hit Tel Aviv because they're still interested in a lull which they will break whenever they can think of a good pretext or some new demand, but they'll still be interested in a lull but still ready to continue military operations .....blah, blah, blah ... blah, blah, blah ........blah, blah, blah. The only new, improved lull I can see is the lull in Mr Diskin's thinking process.
4. Hamas in Gaza has build up tremendously its firepower
Robert Bernier ,   Tel Aviv   (12.21.08)
Israel does, have the capacity to stop the Gaza build-up by sealing off the Gaza-Sinai border and cleaning up Gaza itself. But its government proclaimed a "ceasefire" whose sole consequences have been (1) to allow Israeli citizens to be shelled at no cost to the aggressors and (2) to allow this build-up to proceed. We should stop them now as explained at : http://xrl.us/biz8x
5. Irmo...The rockets can now hit BeerSheva...
(12.21.08)
You have been faithful in many ways, but unkind in some ways. I have not been provided for by those who should have. Is that going to result in a judgment of a rocket hitting your property in Beersheva? R.
6. So now we know - now we should attack!!!!!
Israel   (12.21.08)
How pathetic!
7. Hamas could reach Beersheba
Susan ,   Israel   (12.21.08)
...AND ISRAEL WILL STILL SIT ON THEIR HANDS favoring opinion from the outside rather than behave like a country in control. How bloody pathetic is that! Furthermore, Hamas can do it because no one has dared to stop them. Israel does not bite with teeth. The west maintains "a dead Jew is not important as making peace with terrorists" In the mean time, our beautiful Shalit, rots.
8. Didn't Hamas get the memo? We Disengaged from Gaza years ago
Besalel ,   Kew Gardens, NY   (12.21.08)
Why is Gaza still in the news? We disengaged from there years ago under Sharon's brilliant plan! What? It didn't work? Well at least we got concession from the USA that we will hold on to large settlement blocks in a peace deal! What? Olmert has already conceded that back without anything in return? Well at least we can now strike at Gaza without fear of hurting settlements there. What? We're afraid of our shadow in Gaza! Oh what a nightmare!
9. Give Gaza a sonic boom for each kassam
JPS ,   Efrat   (12.21.08)
Why not have an F-15 break the sound barrier over Gaza each time the bastards fire a rocket at us? They are trying to kill us, but maybe we can get some popular pressure on Hamas if the Palestinian people get blasted each time we do. Sonic booms don't kill anybody directly, while rockets do. Kassams are a war crime, sonic booms are just there to scare the shit ouf of them on a regular basis. If our people can't live quietly, neither should the enemy in Gaza. Who cares if windows get shattered, it's better than "proportional response" which the politically correct forces think we should use. Few Israeli are in favor of randomly trying to kill Palestinians like they do to us. But giving them a dozen or more powerful sonic explosions a day might help shift pressure onto Hamas from inside Gaza.
10. "work towards getting international legitimization"
(12.21.08)
Really? Seems that Hamas terorists already have international legitimization for an operation against Israel.
11. improved lull?
observer   (12.21.08)
is Israel going to call the concurrent siege blockade?
12. let us all say thanks to the 1% government
Arie ,   BaGolan   (12.21.08)
13. R--I have no control of where the rockest go,but I do trust
in Hashem for pro ,   tection. Irmo   (12.21.08)
14. Extend the Lull and save lives...
Rami of Nazareth ,   Israel   (12.21.08)
Just extend the lull and restore calm..
15. Lull
Brad ,   Us   (12.21.08)
What lull ? Inaction, inaeptness. to hellwithworld opinion. Livni sounds dumber daily: lull proves Hams in control- as if its violent take over last year proved noting. the idea of ridding Hams is fine - but not to hand Gaza to Fata
16. deskin
mike ,   canada   (12.21.08)
what a moron talking to more idiots of the same ilk. WHAT ARE YOU DOING ABOUT IT you fool. They are bombarding you every day. WHAT ARE YOU DOING ABOUT IT. Do something but at the very least stop moving your lips
17. This is war
Leah ,   Israel   (12.21.08)
what are we waiting for mass casualties, Jews covered in blood? the Torah states that if your enemy is coming to kill you, you must kill him first. Use the F15s and tell the rest of the world to mind their own business.
18. #9. In your dreams.
(12.21.08)
Israel will not fight back.
19. # 1 Yours Is A Sensible Idea
Lawrence ,   Safed Israel   (12.21.08)
Makes sense,see how the other side like their own medicine.Israel should have nipped this in the bud but it's not too late.
20. Disengagement Was SUCH A Success
Lawrence ,   Safed Israel   (12.21.08)
Darling...we simply must throw some more of those dreadful Jews from their homes (care of Kadima).
21. Earth To Diskin :Your Government
Lawrence ,   Safed Israel   (12.21.08)
Brought this upon itself,with the immoral eviction of thousands at Gush Katif...enjoy the fruits sucker.
22. My Plan for Gaza
Ralph Levy ,   USA   (12.21.08)
Livni Barak and Olmert will Put Abbas In Charge Israeli boys will die to put Abbas in power and for a failed Peace Treaty. Take Gaza destroy the rockets annex a buffer zone with old settlements and then give the rest of Gaza back to Egypt. The Gazans have more roots to Egypt anyway. Cut all power and water everything to Gaza leave the Egyptian checkpoint at Rafah open also we own nothing to Gaza. http://ralphsrant1.blogspot.com
23. Free Ron Arad, Gilad Shalit
Philippa ,   Johannesburg   (12.21.08)
24. You reap what you sow
Martin Hind ,   Brisbane, Australia   (12.21.08)
If you lock any man in a cage, deny them basic services, deny them regular food supply, deny them decent medical attention, deny them hope; then they will grow to hate you and you will get what you are getting now.
25. To# 24, fool
PatriotUSA ,   Oregon, USA   (12.21.08)
So apparently you think it is justified that the arab/isamofacists that have continually attacked Israel since 1948 is acceptable? You think Israel should retreat back to lines of 1967 and give away all the land they have fought and secured, from REPEATED islamofacist attacks? The arabs have always hated the Jews going back 1350 years at the very least. The Jews were in this land long before the arabs came into the picture. Why should Israel be responsible for the arabs in gazastan? The islamofacist arab states keep the so called "palestinians" in gazastan to perpetuate a continual climate of death and terror. The other arab states could easily asborb the islamofacists and arabs that are in gazastany, but they choose not to. Let Egypt and the other abab countries take care of these losers in gazastan that do not belong there, nor do they deserve to be there. Israel should cut off all aid, utilities etc to gazastan and completey eliminate the islamofacist problems, threats until they are left alone to live in peace, which is all they want. Sadly, this will not happen due to arab hatred of all Jews, wanting them all dead and stealing the land that never was theirs in the first place. Screw your "worldly opinion" and act first, that is what Israel should and needs to do.
26. When Hamas can real Tel Aviv, then something will be done.
(12.22.08)
27. 13 Irmo: You have your trust in the right place.
(12.22.08)
If rockets do hit your property, believe it is for the best. All things work for the good for those who love God and are called according to His purpose. Someday I will understand why it was best for me not to see you Abba and for you not to talk to me when I was in Israel. Someday God will explain and I will understand. R.
28. A talking Clam?
muha ,   London, UK   (12.22.08)
How did the clam prove Hamas was in control of Gaza?
Back to article