News
Russia giving Iran only defensive weapons
Associated Press
Published: 22.12.08, 13:35
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
11 Talkbacks for this article
1. WHAT ELSE WOULD S-300
MAHMOOD ,   LONDON-UK   (12.22.08)
Protect??? Downtown restaurant in Tehran?
2. Israel had better understand: Russia is not our friend
Laura ,   Israel   (12.22.08)
Olmert, Gilad, others go like fools, on their knees, begging Russia not to sell arms to Iran, Syria and Lebanon. They say, "We'll think about it" and laugh behind our backs. This foolish, passive Israeli government has lost all its credibility. It lost our deterrent capabilities. The entire cabinet should be committed to a psychiatric institution for the criminally insane.
3. The Georgian test case has provided Putin with all the ...
Robert Bernier ,   Tel Aviv   (12.22.08)
The Georgian test case has provided Putin with all the incentive that he needs. Putin will not suffice himself with Georgia. The Georgian test case has provided him with all the incentive that he needs. We do not yet know exactly where or when the next eruption will occur. But if the process of disintegration in the West continues, the new Russian bully will feel confident enough to initiate more wars. Does Russia present a direct threat to Israel? It is possible that Russia will begin to expand in our direction. That is a most undesirable eventuality – but if it happens, it will not be the first time. Israeli pilots have already waged air skirmishes against Soviet pilots who defended Egyptian skies during the War of Attrition. The Israeli pilots even downed a number of Russian piloted planes. Israel is not Georgia and the Russians know that. More about Russian politics and the Middle East at : http://xrl.us/oq2y9
4. Russia giving Iran weapons
DT ,   TA Isr   (12.22.08)
Don't understand ! I thought Stealth was undectable by radar ?
5. #3 Robert
Felix ,   tel aviv   (12.22.08)
Hi Robert, Israel is not Georia by any stretch of the imagination, but do not let that cloud our judgment. The enemies that Israel fights, collectively, do not represent 1% of Russia's capabilites. If Heaven forbid Russia and Israel were on a direct collision course, Israel would have 0 hope without direct involvement of the US.
6. And yet some considering selling them UAVs
Raymond in DC ,   Washington, DC USA   (12.22.08)
This report is consistent with others confirming that Russia IS supplying Iran with advanced weaponry, including the S-300. It's clear Russia is no friend. Yet, in a stunning display of denial and irresponsibility, some in Israel are considering Russia's request to buy advanced UAVs. Perhaps not since the days of the Hellenists have so many in positions of leadership promoted the interests of others against their own people.
7. S-300's Will Only Help Preserve ME Peace
Boris Badenough   (12.22.08)
If the sale of S-300's prevent Israeli aggression towards Iran, then Russia should be applauded and given a Nobel Peace prize. Israel actually started to think it was in the position to dictate to other nations on matters such as how they choose to defend themselves from aggression and needed a reality check in the worst way.
8. A NEW DIMENSION AND AN OUTRAGE !!
Arik Silverman ,   Milwaukee USA   (12.22.08)
So now Israel and the US are thinking of attacking Iran's PEACEFUL nuclear power plant? What an outrage! That's a long way from attacking the uranium enrichment facilities. If they attack an Iranian power plant, what about a plant of another country that might get a reactor? Many countries in the area are looking for nuclear power plants. Will Israel launch an attack on Egypt if it gets a nuclear power plant?
9. Russia is the danger behind Iran
ROXY ,   Israel   (12.22.08)
General Patton recognized the dangers posed by Russia after WW II He tried to warn the US,he accurately accesed the sift of the balence of world power which the war produced and forsaw the enormous danger of Russian aggression against the west. Alone among the US Leaders he WARNED that the US should act immediately,while her supremacy was unchallenged to end that danger,but unfortunately his warning went unheeded, and he was silenced by a convienant"accident" some say by the for runner to the KGB with the blessing of the US President who feared Patton would inniate WWIII! Patton felt it was better to face them then while America was strong andd unchallenged because from then on Russia would grow stronger while the US would weaken. This is exactly what is happening now as Patton predicted...Russia is supplying the enemies of freedom with Nuclear plants, arms to be used against the West,Middle East, and the non radical Islamic regimes . It is Russia that is the big danger even bigger than Iran,the Russian bear thinks it can control Iran but it can't and we will all pay a steep price in our blood in the end if the Nukes aren't stopped before they are created!
10. Lets be realistic here.
Avi ,   telaviv   (12.22.08)
Does the U.S need anyones permission to sell Israel weapons? Why should Russia be any different? Lets be realistic here. Its a jungle out there. In the end, Iran will get its nuclear bomb. We might be able to delay it for a while but we cant stop it for ever.
11. YOU ARE RIGHT,IN A WAY..........#7
MAHMOOD ,   LONDON-UK   (12.22.08)
Suggesting that the acquisition of missile defence shield will bring about a serious reconsideration on the part of Israel to attack Iranian nuclear sites.We should,however,not forget that even without these missiles being installed,the repurcussion that Iran can offer should also not be disregarded.Keeping in line with their periodical statements emanating from different military personnell,it is easy to write on the talk-back coloumn and treat such statements as being rhetorics on the part of the Iranians.However, when you read the DEBKA column and other military sites,there has always been a cause of concern even without these S-300.
Back to article