News
UN: 25% of those killed in Gaza civilians
AFP
Published: 31.12.08, 13:28
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
48 Talkbacks for this article
31. Palestinian #8
Gee ,   Zikron Yaakov   (12.31.08)
With your logic then we have yet to kill a civilian. Just how many of those 'civilian' were killed by Hamas munitions going off? I'll bet a majority. So this is our fault? Not hardly terrorists storing weapons and hiding among civilians renders those areas as military targets
32. this is israel
ali ,   egypt   (12.31.08)
Hamas has no nuclear weapons,no airforce of F-16,s, F-15, Apache gunships,tanks,navy and dolphin nuclear submarines...as israel does... Hamas has water pipes cutup and filled with crude dynamite...these are not eaxcatly ICBM's=intercontinetel ballistic missiles...these are the weapons of the desperate bseiged Palestinians... 75 % rpt 75% of the Gaza population are refugees-those who were ethnically cleanesed by jewish terrorist gangs such as Hagnah,Palmac,Shtern and Irgun.. Like apartheid nuclear armed white south africa,isreal is a passing phenomenon and will vanish into oblivion...oppression and injustice are ultimately short-lived...
33. good for pools
marcellaurent ,   montreal, canada   (12.31.08)
34. good for polls
marcellaurent ,   montreal, canada   (12.31.08)
with such disgusting comments from some people, I guess barrack and Livni are doing quite well in the polls for the election. what was this war about anyways?
35. Ali from Egypt
Ehud ,   TA   (12.31.08)
The fact that Hamas is weake doesn't mean they are right. We waited for 7 years before doing waht needs to be done. How patient would Egypt have been, 7 days, 7 hours? Even your government and half the Arab world is fed up with Hamas, and pays only lip service to the "Arab streeet". So don't blame us!
36. 25% Civilian Casualties
Rivkah Rybak ,   Israel   (12.31.08)
100% casualties of Israelies are civilian. www.yeshabulletin.com
37. Civilians in Gaza being hurt
Grant Thomas ,   Brookfield, WI, USA   (12.31.08)
It's a favorite ploy of the media to whine about "civilians" being hurt, but the reality is that the people of Gaza support the terrorists and therefore have to bear the consequences of their hatred of Israel. Sadly, the only way this can end is if every Palestinian is killed, driven out of the land, or Israel is eliminated. I'm in favor of the first two options!
38. #26 is right. 75% terrorist in uniform and 25%
Rehavam ,   Israel   (12.31.08)
same terrorists without uniform. Col haKavod le TZAHAL!
39. so in other words...
mordechai ,   Brooklyn, NY   (12.31.08)
75% of the rockets hit at the precise target they were fired at. Contrast that to the Kassams that are indiscriminatly fired at Israel 100% kill non-combatants. So i ask the UN, do the math, who more ruthless, killers?
40. They only have Hamas to blame
Lioness ,   Israel   (12.31.08)
Did they expect that Israel would not defend herself? Too bad they should not have voted into power a terrorist regime. where has all the money gone that the US, EU,and Russia given them. Money has gone into buying rockets, weapons and explosives instead of feeding their people or on infrastucture. They can not expect sympathy for every one of those Gazans have never turned around to Hamas and demanded they stop rocketing Israel.
41. This is the same guy who lied about cluster bombs
Danny   (12.31.08)
in Lebanon. I guess lying is just too natural for him.
42. #8, whereas your PR turns warriors into civilians
Danny   (12.31.08)
43. To those foreigners (mainly UK)condemniing Tzahal
Arie ,   BaGolan   (12.31.08)
You should really post at haaretz where your ilk is definitiely welcome! haaretz, since it s purchase by the German company that got its start as the propaganda office for the nazis in the 30s, has gotten rid of ALL writers that support the state and maintains a full editorial and writing staff that seeks out any opportunity to chastise and condemn all things Jewish and/or Israeli! It's much like posting on al jazeera, the BBC, guardian, or CNN
44. Palestinians
TheAre ,   Brooklyn NY.   (12.31.08)
Israel made a big mistake that they did not get rid of all the arabs in gaza and the west bank during the first wars (6 day war & war of 1973) Israel would have total peace today if they secured the boarders around them and created buffer zones before the boarders too.
45. AP, AFP, 90% of media +leftist, antiIsrael LIARS!
jj ,   USA   (12.31.08)
46. Hebraic Jihad
Frankie Littlehammer ,   New Herstal, TX, US   (12.31.08)
The Israeli Armed Forces should just rename (re-christen?) themselves 'Hebraic Jihad' and pretend to take orders from no one, and the UN will immediately stop criticizing. Or do they have different rules for different people?
47. civilians killed as targets
lawrence ,   Philadelphia, USA   (12.31.08)
Israel targets the terrorists and some civilians are killed because the terrorists use them as human shields. Hamas targets civilians and some IDF are killed mostly because they use themself as shields to protect civilians. HUM! Is their a moral and philosophical difference here that need to be examined?
48. own goals
La Cumparsita ,   London UK   (12.31.08)
and how many of these civiilans have been hit by Hamas' own weaponry misfiring when the IAF hits their launchpads?
49. UN are Morons
Jah ,   Los Angeles, USA   (12.31.08)
The UN are a bunch of anti-semtic morons. Where was the UN for the last few months as the Qassam rockets were landing in Israel? But, when Israel retaliates is when the UN decides to open their mouths. It is unfortunate that civilian deaths are happpening, but Israel is not targeting them, they are targeting the cowards (Hamas) that are hiding amongst them. And, I wouldn't doubt that some of these kids are affiliated with Hamas and are being counted as Civilians. I am sure the causality of Hamas rats are greater but they are not reporting it to make themselves seem strong. Israel needs to go in with ground troops and clean out these filthy rats once and for all.
Previous talkbacks
Back to article