News
Sakhnin protest: IDF op a war crime
Sharon Roffe-Ofir
Published: 03.01.09, 16:18
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
51 Talkbacks for this article
31. #20 Daniel - Do you get out much??
William ,   Israel   (01.03.09)
"therefore making it the only country in the world in which citizenship is based on religion." Take a walk around the Arab Middle East. You'll find many more. And those who do provide citizenship (although) not freely to other religions will still place them under the laws of the major religion (Islam). Do you know as a Christian in the Arab world you can be arrested and beaten up if you are seen eating during Ramadan? But in Israel you can eat during Yom Kippur and nothing happens. I think THIS is what the founding fathers had in mind regarding coexistence. The point is Israel is a place for Jews to be Jews, and why not? Everyone else gets to practice their own religion in peace...is that not why B'hais continue to run to Israel? And Samaritans, considered illegal in Arab countries, flourishes here? Get out more.
32. #17: Don't most liberals agree with these protesters?
(01.03.09)
Don't most liberals agree with these thousands of killers and potential killers? Don't liberals agree that Jews have no right of self-defense? That for Jews to defend themselves, this constitute war crimes?
33. war crimes
Miriam ,   Canada   (01.03.09)
do I get this right? Israel defending itself is called war crime? Terrorist thugs lopping rockets into civilian neighborhoods is what? a tea party? Is there anybody on the 'other' side that is still sane? Palestinians must be totally brainwashed to swallow this crud....
34. Agree with all that is said
Jimmy ,   Raanana   (01.03.09)
I am a centrist - I have no respect for Lieberman nor Bibi. I have no respect for Zippi or Barak. But this war is late in coming. Fortunately all sides left and right are joining in the war effort. Bibi and his excellent method of PR is doing well. Bibi must be the head of Israel's PR
35. To #20
M. Hartley ,   Atlanta, US   (01.03.09)
What you say sounds great on the surface, but look at what’s happening in other countries where there’s a large influx of Muslims. As long as you have fanatics who can’t or won’t separate politics from religion or God from Caesar, sooner or later you’ll end up with the same mess. I’m not Jewish nor do I believe in any religion. I have, however, chosen to be a citizen of the US and as such I am expected to comply with the laws of this country, as weird as some of them may be. If I have a beef, I am allowed to demonstrate peacefully, avail myself of judicial means for redress, or get the hell out and find a place more to my liking. If Israel were to disappear tomorrow, the same people who now lob rockets at you would find some other target.
36. "israeli arabs": "We, the people of Palestine"!
GET REAL ,   USA   (01.03.09)
"isreali arab leader": ""Long live Palestine, whose capital is Jerusalem, and long live the shahids (martyrs)."" ISRAEL GOVERNMENT IS BRAIN DEAD NOT TO ROUND UP THESE TRAITORS AND CHARGE THEM WITH SEDITION AND TREASON IN A TIME OF WAR! NATIONALIST JEWS ARE ARRESTED FOR SEDITION FOR SPEAKING ON ISRAEL JEWISH NATIONHOOD! ANY JEW IS ISRAEL THAT STATES ARABS MUST GO IS ARRESTED FOR RACISM!
37. GO ahed Palestinians inside (Israel)
Khaled ,   Tehran   (01.03.09)
You are our ammo inside the enemy body, the time bomb that will blow off at the right time!!
38. They Must Go!
shmujew ,   unholyland   (01.03.09)
There is no reason for the existence of Arabs in Israel, Jews need to start to do the jobs that these foreigners are doing and create a real jewish State.
39. Protest
Mark Watkins ,   East Bernstadt , USA   (01.03.09)
So what , These People are Hate Mongers , and want to see Israel wiped off The Map , They need to read Psalms 83 to see where they are Headed .. G-d Bless The Great Nation of Israel !
40. The lines ahve been drawn by the Israeli Palestinians
We the People ,   Galiliee, Israel   (01.03.09)
Now the people of Israel, those who believe in the right of the Jewish People to exist in our country, after thousands of years of persecution by the Greeks, The Romans, the Church, the Crusaders, the Spanish, the English, the Czars of Russia and the Stalinists to rise up to the threat the of our own Arabs whose actions are treasonable and seditious and to effect a total boycott on Arab businesses and professional services. The Arabs have chosen sides with the terrorists who have terrorized and traumatized our people in Sderot and the Negev and now in Ashqelon, Ashdod and other towns and settlements in the south and who have kidnapped our child, Gilad Shalit, and hold him hostage as would common thugs. We cannot allow the hand that feeds to be bitten by a rabid 5th column who would side with those who would massacre every man, woman and child who calls himself or herself an Israeli! START THE BOYCOTT NOW!
41. To #20: Daniel: Jewsish State or not
David ,   Karmiel, Israel   (01.03.09)
OK, I too am a totally secular Jew and totally for separation of Synagogue and State. Also, there are many "not so educated" Israelis who are also secular and your discriminatory comment is a bit out of line. However, you are losing site of the reason for the creation of the State of Israel. The land was created as a home for the Jewish people who had been decimated by the Holocaust and who have been persecuted through the ages. If the country was just "a country" with no affiliation to our beliefs and traditions then why have a State of Israel at all? We cannot allow ourselves to forget what has been done to us in the past and to protect ourselves from from it even happening again. Yes, a Secular Jewish State would be the best but regrettable will probably never happen. Having worked with many Arabs over the last 20 years I cannot agree with you on the Arabs not "feeling connected". They have adapted very well and use and abuse the welfare that this country hands out just as well as their loyal Israeli counterparts. What is unforgivable regarding the Israeli Arab community is that they side with the very people who would destroy us and take away the democratic nature and the basic freedoms that do NOT exist in most of the Arab world.
42. T0 #21: Very well said!
David ,   Karmiel, Israel   (01.03.09)
The only thing to add is that Russia, a member of the "Quartet", is arming Hamas, Hezbollah, Iran and probably Al Qaeda with the rockets fired at our people. Putin's Russia is resembling more and more every day that of the Stalinist/Communist regimes and the "West" is too stupid to see this and have made themselves into a laughing stock of the Georgia Russian aggression!
43. #37 A voice from terror state of Iran
Cynthia ,   USA   (01.03.09)
You should hang your head low just like Ahmadinejad is now doing. He's afraid people will realize all roads of terror lead back to Iran. Once they realize this, no country in the world will want to conduct business or have any association with you. Your dying, irreparable economy is a sign this process is already quite advanced.
44. To the protestors: SHUT YOUR STUPID MOUTHS!
David ,   Hartford USA   (01.03.09)
You didn't say a peep all this time that your 'brothers' from Gaza were shooting rockets and mortars into Israel. As long as it was only Jews being maimed and killed it didn't concern you. And now the tables are turned and you've found your voice. Well, NOBODY CARES! Cry as you may, the IDF will do what it has to do. Hamas has launched rockets into Israel for years- so the IDF has every right to do exactly the same thing. So to all the bleeding hearts who only cry for Arab victims, the real world doesn't hear you anymore. GO IDF!
45. Arab protests
Arie ,   Tel-Aviv   (01.03.09)
Guys, Instead of complaining we should implement boycott of the traitors: No shopping No employment No communication These measures will drive the message home real fast.
46. Terry and Marcel (#17 and #21)
Imperator ,   USA   (01.03.09)
Kol HaKavod!. Agree with both your postings 100%. Lamentably, Israel's Hasbara is puny and ineffective. Alas, we Jews in the Galut are no better... Am Israel Chai!
47. God bless IDF
Jonathan ,   London   (01.03.09)
48. Eh bien, dansez maintenant
Jan   (01.03.09)
Dear arabs ; allah's gift to humanity and it's scourge as well. YOU danced on roofs when YOUR FU...NG Saddam ( now Satan's guest ) lobbded rockets on Israel. How about a little " Hava Nagila " NOW.!!
49. To Natan #2. I second your TB.
Maansingh ,   The Netherlands   (01.04.09)
50. I strongly suggest for Daniel (#20) to read #19.
Tahl ,   Ashdod, Israel   (01.04.09)
How ironic it is, that post #19 is by a non-Jewish Lebanese, and post #20 is by an Israeli Jew! Daniel, read what botros has to say and maybe you'd sober up to the sad reality of "integration".
51. What was happening before hamas?
Fred ,   San Fransisco, CA   (01.06.09)
Do you ever stop to think what was going on before Hamas? Here's a few for you; 1)Years of oppresion, 2)Economic blockade for god knows how many years.. You turned Gaza into LIVING HELL for Palestinians long before there ever was any kind of terrorist organization among Arabs. Israel's actions are only inspiring more suicide bombers and all kinds of hell.. Learn how to COEXIST!! for humanity's sake!! Thank you, Fred
Previous talkbacks
Back to article