News
Gaza: 5 family members killed by IDF shell; Hamas commander hurt
Hanan Greenberg
Published: 04.01.09, 17:29
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
59 Talkbacks for this article
1. these arent civilians they are the enemy
shmu ,   unholyland   (01.04.09)
There are no civilians in Gaza, only the enemy. Anyone who does not stand against Hamas is Hamas and so far I know of none in Gaza that have ever stood against Hamass
2. u play with fire u get burnt and b careful what u ask 4
dr ,   southern, US   (01.04.09)
http://www.knoxnews.com/news/2009/jan/03/crowd-protests-gaza-violence/ Note the amount of comments against the protestors and mention of a related article(same day)about the vandalism of 2 synagogues. I would advice them not to protest in TN anymore. We are keenly aware that our christian roots are Jewish!
3. The bravery and moral standards of the IDF
GUH   (01.04.09)
Is displayed once again!
4. The war will end
Ze'ev ,   Haifa   (01.04.09)
When Arabs will love their children more than they hate us
5. thanks for the crying kid pic Ynet; it helps boost moral for
you idiots!   (01.04.09)
the enemy!
6. Why are you reporting this stuff
Doesn't matter ,   Canada   (01.04.09)
Seriously, why do you guys report this stuff in the middle of a war? You're not sure if this is true to begin with and on top of that, you're adding fuel to the flames already that are ignited against your own people!!! Put the faces of children crying in the Gaza on more of your reporting and ignore your own people!
7. That baby face crying doesn't impress me at all!
Keren ,   Israel-SP   (01.04.09)
Their parents,their community asked for what is happening now. It is not Israel's fault their suffering :it is their own fault. They just don't care for suffering because hatred is their fuel.Israel must be cold enough and put an end in ITS OWN SUFFERING,even if the price is the hypocrit suffering of them. The sooner Israel RESOLVES this matter ,the best,because then we will not suffer anymore nor will have to stand with that circus suffering of them. They get what they ask and what they like!
8. 82 children KILLED hundreds injured
Davis   (01.04.09)
thousands traumatised ...why they born from Gazan parents they can deside to be swis or chinees this is there mistake they must pay the price IDF condemn them to deth
9. #3, I am sure Muhammad Shalfuach
Danny   (01.04.09)
was just dropping his family off. Must be a take your kids to work day, wierd I don't remember any of my colleagues bringing their kids on military operations....
10. Terrorists trained from age of 3 - civilians?
Common Sense ,   Katar   (01.04.09)
Look at that - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gi-c6lbFGC4 Few generations of killers are grown in this way - what do you expect from such people - could they turn to be peaceful?
11. craziness and journalistic incompetence
Phil ,   US   (01.04.09)
Do any of the editors at YNET, let alone the writer of this article know how many French civilians were killed by the allied bombing of France prior to the D-Day invasion? I wonder how many real newspapers in the allied countries had the American and British caused French casualty figures as front page news when this occurred in 1945. Obviously, in those primitive days, people understood that the most important goal of the invasion of France was to establish a beachhead for allied troops to fight against and eventually destroy hitler's third reich. Can you imagine an international organization, if there had been one, demanding an immediate ceasefire prior to the D-Day invasion because of civilian casualties. The only thing that has changed is the jounalistic and hypocritical international pressure that prevents the bad guys from losing. These people care nothing of the beseiged residents of Sderot , Ashkelon, and other Negev communities. They are only interested in appearing to be moral by condemning the victim.
12. No. 5
NYC Girl   (01.04.09)
You're absolutely right. These photographs, which are displayed with no context , are handing a propaganda victory to the terrorists. If civilians are dying it's the result of the fact that Hamas thugs deliberately embed themselves among civilians knowing the Israelis are loathe to inflict casualties on non-combatants.
13. bad journalism
Mark Katzman ,   San Francisco, USA   (01.04.09)
what's with the picture of the crying child? Is that supposed to tug at our heartstrings? What a cheap bit of photo journalism. Maybe it's a picture of a kid who didn't get his milk and is crying-how do we know? That's just bad propaganda. Shame on you guys.
14. This war will end
GUH   (01.04.09)
When you stop killing Arabic Palestinian Children! Recent and similar story: http://www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7340,L-3649308,00.html For the full list, see: http://www.rememberthesechildren.com/remember2008.html FREE PALESTINE! SAVE BABIES FROM ISRAELI TROOPS!
15. A POEM FOR THE DEAD PALESTINIANS
Atilla Karagözoğlu ,   To my homesick birds   (01.04.09)
now you are free on the skies of your own land. feel free my HOMESICK birds. feel free to fly ... THE TIME COMES ! YOU GET DONE AND LEAVE HAPPYLY.
16. I welcome my Palestinian brothers and sisters
King Abdullah ,   Palestine/Jordan   (01.04.09)
to come home where you belong
17. I feel very sorry for Leftists
Yoel ,   Ra'nana   (01.04.09)
They must be very sad, but I have no compassion for those palestinians. They were always happy while some terror attacks "succeded". Time has come to stop feeling guilty. Israel has the full right of defending his citizens. Palestinian civilians could try to escape combat zone instead of beeing human shields. People who remained there are Hamas supporters. We should not endanger our soldiers' lives just because we think about "innocent palestinians". Our children are more innocent, and most of them didn't wish entering into the Gaza Strip.
18. A traumatized Israeli girl not good enough for you?
Laura ,   Israel   (01.04.09)
Ynet - Your priorities and loyalties are pretty screwed up. We're at war with a genocidal enemy. Please decide which side you're on.
19. Maybe the girl is crying because...
Millie ,   Israel   (01.04.09)
the evil, bad Israelis took Farfur the Genocidal Mouse off the TV when they took over Hamas TV broadcasting.
20. Shahids
Conker ,   Israel   (01.04.09)
Good for them ! More are coming hopefully.
21. #3
Yaron ,   USA   (01.04.09)
Hey retard....what don't you get? Your hero Pals are the true cowards much like yourself....making abnoxious comments. Why don't you move to Gaza so they can shoot at you too?
22. you all are Unbelievable
a free man ,   USA   (01.04.09)
Come on you all say they are not civilians they are the enemy you all sound just like them that what they say about you all are no different than them you also become the monster. Those people used to live where they are shooting the rockets to that used to be there home that is there X home that you all took. I mean come do you all remember when you all used to be refuges during the NAZI time you all become the monster you all trying to fight you all are no different than they are . You all have no respect to humanity at all... 1st you all said get rid of Arafat we will do peace then you all said that the Palestinians need to do election then they did and got Hamas which Hamas was created by Israel for Israel and now it backed fired on its creator. I just want to say that they are HUMANS and they have to live FREE and without OCUPATION the OCUPATIONS is the root cause of all problems. In my eyes the problems are not the rockets that Hamas is firing is the KILLER OCUPATIONS
23. typical of ali waked
Arie ,   BaGolan   (01.04.09)
The strikes killed two of the senior hamass terrorists. The question, that waked conveniently avoids, is why did they surround themselves with innocent civilians if not for a predilection for the use of human shields
24. responsibility for casualties
aramkr ,   NYC   (01.04.09)
Why has the IAF avoided hitting the Hamas "prime minister"? The only casualties that should be laid at Israel's door are the ones that will most certainly follow (on both sides)if Hamas is left standing because of this kind of punch pulling.
25. #1
Ash   (01.04.09)
There are no civilians in israel as well. All the civilians killed inside israel are just soldiers of the IDF and enemies.
26. Morally, Israel has already lost the war
Imad ,   Germany   (01.04.09)
...by just looking the picture of this innocent child crying!!
27. #14 War will end
Cynthia ,   USA   (01.04.09)
When Palestinians use their money to build a state and a future for their children instead of using it to terrorize Israel. You can post your propaganda but it will not change the facts on the ground. The armed struggle and use of terror against Israel has gotten the Palestinians nowhere. This conflict is a perfect example.
28. #7 You'd know all about hatred
Israel   (01.04.09)
You spew enough of it out in every talkback. You are sick and you make me puke.
29. #4 As said by Golda Meir.
Talula ,   Israel   (01.04.09)
30. #3 Airhead
Talula ,   Israel   (01.04.09)
So, what you are essentially saying, is that you expect us NOT to kill civilians, because you expect more from our moral army, but it's OK for Hamas to fire rockets into southern Israeli towns, with the hope of causing maximum deaths? Do you have any idea, any idea at all of what a brainless asshole you really are?
Next talkbacks
Back to article