News
Tank and infantry operations in Gaza investigated
Hanan Greenberg
Published: 06.01.09, 12:41
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
36 Talkbacks for this article
1. Notice how many religious soldiers are being killed/ wounded
Dani ,   Tel Aviv   (01.06.09)
And so many from Judea and Samaria- the "settlements". They are our hope and future; those who protect the nation selflessly. May G-d protect them.
2. To Dani
Indigenous ,   statless   (01.06.09)
Yeah sure...Yosef was very religious Druze Muslim...
3. Questionable
Jeremy ,   UK   (01.06.09)
Your account is questionable. It seems as if Tsahal soldiers cannot be killed by Hamas fire. B ydenying war casualties, your are loosing credibility and making Hamas killings more potent !
4. To Indigenous
Dani ,   Tel Aviv   (01.06.09)
True- there have been 2 Druze casualties too, but watch the news and see how many of the soldiers are religious jews-kippot srugot. See how many of the wounded are, of those killed are. And how many of them come from Judea and Samaria. Like it or not, it's a fact.
5. Same way civilians are killed
JA ,   Nowhere   (01.06.09)
The same way civilians are killed because they are mistaken with the hamas men. Stop this war now.
6. WE ARE IN A WARFATE
(01.06.09)
Nothing would happen if the buildings were the soldiers have hided, would have been destroyed in advance. It is about the time to face the fact that we are in warfare, and we have to behave as such.
7. IDF credebility in question!
Dave Wilson ,   usa   (01.06.09)
Its funny that Israeli casualties should come only from friendly fire according to IDF accounts. Be real people because you are losing credebility fast.
8. I wonder how many more incidents before the war is over?
Mark ,   USA   (01.06.09)
If i were living in Israel id be offended by all these lies the government keeps spitting out, your telling me 10,000 troops went in to fight 25,000 militants and only 5 died? 4 as a result of friendly fire? COME ON PPL, GET REAL.
9. Never been to war ...
Hiram ,   Piz Gloria . Schweiz   (01.06.09)
Interesting to see how many of the post come from people who apparently have never seen fire , driven an armoured vehicle in battle times or manned a communication station. In an urban war , the biggest difficulty is to make the right decision in the fastest possible way . In an open field, although decision speed is also critical, the risks are lesser as fewer options are available to the ennemy. I do believe that any military operation will yield infortunate " collateral damages" and that friendly fire issues have been a part of war since the ancient times. Taking more time in cross-checking information is certainly wishful thinking. Tsahal is not a trigger happy army . Let's honor the dead soldiers who gave their life , willingly or not, to the nation. Internal Religious considerations have no place on these posts.
10. to #5
Ale ,   Haifa,Israel   (01.06.09)
Stop saying "stop the war"...mefager
11. How redicilous u r israelis
mohammed ,   Dubai   (01.06.09)
I really feel sorry for ur army Till now they are not telling u the truth i can confirm that tens of ur men are killed till now and i feel sorry for their execuses about those who were killed mistaken In the coming future, you will be shocked with a video in which Hamas men will show u a new Shalit in their hand and then tell me how strong ur army is
12. #6
Jamil ,   UAE   (01.06.09)
Funny, if the house was destroyed before the soldiers enter inside, they wouldn't then find a place to hide, hence they would have been killed by HAMAS
13. #11
SBK ,   Hong Kong   (01.06.09)
What credibility do you have for saying that "tens" of Israeli soldiers were killed? Can you prove it? Your statement is not valid until proven.
14. israelies have to learn how to behave
ziad ,   lebanon   (01.06.09)
because too much arogance is going to lead to the destruction of israel so behave and learn how to live in peace with other nations or face the end .behave ..behave shalom
15. Blessings to Israel
Petr ,   Karlovy Vary, CZ   (01.06.09)
May your soldiers hit those responsible, miss the innocent and return safely home. We are with you, stay tough.
16. two out of 5 are Israeli-Arabs
Rami of Nazareth ,   Israel   (01.06.09)
two out of the 5 Israeli soldiers killed so far defending the jewish state are israeli-Arabs. Please remmember this fact when posting your typical racist inciting remarks about Israeli-Arabs.
17. do yourself a faver
Mohammed ,   USA   (01.06.09)
that was a breaking news at aljazeera yesterday ...Hamas gunmen directed those idiots to a building ..and then ...they killed some and injured the rest ..few kidnapped . that was not friendly fire .. all of this is irrelevant infront of the civilian casuality . this must stop.
18. IDF can't recognize their own soldiers? What about civils?
Reailst   (01.06.09)
Just confirms that IDF shoots on anything moving. IDF has no more respect for civilianz than Hamas. Death figures confirm that even more.
19. Our enemy wears no specific uniform
Zion   (01.06.09)
Gaza terrorists can easily dress up in IDF uniforms, or civilian clothes, or take off a uniform before appearing on camera. We are dealing with transuniformed terrorists.
20. Lyers
Mary ,   Israel   (01.06.09)
Why don't you confess that Hamas fighters are the ones who killed these soldiers? Why do you lie to us? War of 2006 taught us not to believe you!!!!!!!!!!
21. # 14 Ali Baba in Lebanon
(01.06.09)
we say NO to Dhimitude. Now back into the cave,fool.
22. investigations' objectives: are they really tank & infantry?
observer   (01.06.09)
Hass said: "Where does the IDF Chief of Staff sit when he draws up war plans? Not in the Sahara, or even in the Negev. What would happen if someone blew themselves up at the entrance to Tel Aviv's Cinematheque movie theater, and those who sent him said sorry, but he was headed for the Defense Ministry down the street?". In the mean time, the IDF Chief of Staff is waiting Hamas to to express sorry and sorrow for the incident!
23. a prelude fro retreat
observer   (01.06.09)
Olmert: We'll end Gaza op if arms smuggling, rocket attacks cease Barak: We knew it would be difficult
24. #13 Right on!
Edithann ,   USA   (01.06.09)
With no outside media to substantiate it..you expect the world to take your word? You're contempt for the reader is overwhelming .. And you prove you're not trustworthy..even to tell the truth.. TATA
25. Stealing The Fighter's Glory
Dirk Diggler ,   Paterson NJ USA   (01.06.09)
This is more lying on the part of the IDF. These soldiers died at the hands of the resistance. you can be sure that the invaders have suffered dozens of casualties. As they were warned before they started this adventure, Gaza is swiftly becoming a graveyard for the Zionists.
26. We have lost 1 soilder in battle we have killed the rest
zionist forever   (01.06.09)
This is unacceptable and we need to investgate and decide if extra training is needed by the men who control these tanks. How do you tell a parent their son is dead because we killed him through negligence not in combat? There must be no more friendly fire incidents Now though is the time to pray that there are no more of these accidents and for the souls of the men who died.
27. to #10
JA ,   Nowhere   (01.06.09)
Sorry....you'r right. We can't say stop the war. We should rather say: stop this massacre.
28. #14
John ,   NY Us   (01.06.09)
Oh... we have have learned...and the response is... you are next !!!
29. #11, just like Hizbollah sank two ships
Danny   (01.06.09)
and destroyed dozens of tanks? And who turned out to be lying?
30. HAHAH! This must be divine justice!
IRAN#1   (01.06.09)
G_d is telling you you are doing the wrong thing!
Next talkbacks
Back to article