News
IDF officer killed in Gaza
Hanan Greenberg
Published: 08.01.09, 19:07
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
48 Talkbacks for this article
31. #7 Cynthia
Dave Wilson ,   usa   (01.08.09)
Sorry to disagree with you Cynthia. The IDF is a murderous group. The leaders of Israel should face trial at the Hague. In Kana, Israel hit a united nations compound where civilians were taking shelter. Hundreds of women and children were killed. Israel claimed that Hezbollah was firing from the vicinity of the compound. A claim that was denied by the U.N peace keepers. Kana 2, same story. In the case of the Gaza School where around fourty women and children were massacred, again Israel claimed that Hamas gunmen were firing from within the school compound. A claim which the U.N denies. The U.N made arrangements with the IDF to ensure the safe passage of U.N trucks loaded with humanitarian aid, and over and over again the trucks are hit by the IDF which led the U.N to halt its humanitarian aid to Gaza. Cynthia, how can you sleep with a clear conscience at night when you defend murderers of women and children? Have you seen the images of the infants and children torn to pieces? Have you seen the fear in the eyes of the very young ones? Its obvious that this is an Israeli policy to create fear and panic among the civilian population in order to drive a wedge between the Palestinians and Hamas. If this does not constitute war crimes, then I do not know what does! I know that I will get a lot of replies accusing me of being anti semitic. If saying the truth is anti semitic, then I will always be proud to be anti semitic. I hope that YNET does not censor my post because Israel should not alianate the free world. Israel should not behave like a terrorist organization.
32. To #4 What are you talking about,you ass wipe?
jason white ,   afula,israel   (01.08.09)
When moslim armies fight each other both sides lose. You all are as big a bunch of losers as shimon peres!
33. Condolences from a Muslim
Madiha ,   USA   (01.08.09)
As a Muslim in the US, the news of any casualties, weather on the Palestinian or Israeli side deeply saddens and concerns me. I am positive that this is not what my Allah wanted for his people. I offer my sincere and deepest condolences to the family and loved ones of Rosner, but also to all of those who have lost their loved ones in this tragic but in my opinion unnecessary "battle." I feel that Israel has stooped down to the level of those that it says is their enemy.
34. Frank, My 100% Muslim heart agrees with you
Madiha ,   USA   (01.08.09)
May God enlighten all of us to get past this tragedy and to be able to look forward to a world of peace and tolerance.
35. 23# Rabbi Eckstein should have prayed more effectively
observer   (01.08.09)
to pounce the rocket back to its origin.
36. # 3 as Iranian let me ask some question from you?
sam ,   tehran,iran   (01.08.09)
Why do you judging unilaterally about actual of the disasters, don't forget that Israelis has right to living in peace as you have right to live, but at this time people of both side lose their life because some ignoramus Hemas leader (terrorist) so every body think that Hamas should be punishment so what do you think ?could you tell me that why Hamas leader hid their self and putted innocent people in out side any shelter ? Could you tell me that why terrorist group like Hamas launch missile from mosque(Masajed) or could you give me reasonable answer that why do they launch the missile from roof of hospital or school court ? Could you tell me that why they didn't import food and first aid instead of smuggling weapon since years ago? And last question Why do you think that Israelis media tricking people ?here even Iranian could put their comment with out any censorship what do you think ?
37. ALON#17 YOU ARE SO RIGHT
Orly ,   Toronto/NJ   (01.08.09)
Alon, I could not agree with you more. My heart goes out to the families of our falled hero's. Am Israel Chai
38. MADIHA WERE THERE MORE
PEACE ,   TO US ALL   (01.08.09)
PEOPLE LIKE U THE WORLD WOULD BE A BETTER PLACE TO LIVE, U WORDED IT PERFECTLY...SHUKRAN AND SALAM..
39. libyan guy a fool?or just brainwashed?
alon ,   toronto,canada   (01.08.09)
uh how does one argue with your knowledge?????of nothing!p.s. been to arab countries..shit holes and backwards,everyone of them and who runs most of them?. dictators!
40. #19 Frank, Los Angeles
Bandar ,   Beirut, Lebanon   (01.08.09)
Frank, your post is the most sensible post I have read anywhere. If there are more people like you on both sides of this conflict, there would be no reason for anyone to be mourning, and peace would prevail. I salute you and admire your courage.
41. #33 Madiha
Mike ,   usa   (01.08.09)
You are such a stupid idiot. Have you felt sorry for the innocent Palestinian children torn to pieces by F16s and by tank shells? You are a disgrace to humanity. When the whole world condemns Israel as evidenced by the massive demonstrations all over the world, you are shedding your lousy tears on a baby killer. Idiot!
42. #28 Thank you
Libyan Guy ,   Italy   (01.08.09)
most appreciated and praying that no more innocents and children die from anyside ... love & peace
43. #29 Facts that people try to ignor
Libyan Guy ,   Italy   (01.08.09)
history books are open and to add, your america in the 80's wanted to get rid of Gheddafi the mad dog that bombed the panam and label discotech, saying that you wanted freedom and human rights to come back to Libya, pitty that your slogans are only crap for pubblic opinion use and your mad dog is the wise guy friend of Bush and the united states while he is still leading the country as the oldest dictatorship after Castro's Cuba ... Thank you America for the freedom, human rights and the tohe PETRODOLLARS that made you change mind and buy the blood of your own citizen's for CASHMONEY ... shame on America.
44. #8
Libyan Guy ,   Italy   (01.08.09)
Ghandi in India got indipendence not firing a shot ... You in Israel need to kill all arab children to guarantee you indipendence but you did not realise that you lost the most important war, the war of hearts. Israel suxs
45. give peace
ines ,   tunisia   (01.09.09)
I'am a muslim, and i don't see any reason to have all this killer from people of gaza and people of israel. I don't hate juif, but if israel want to be accepted by arab world, she must give peace
46. Mike
Madiha ,   USA   (01.09.09)
Just because I feel bad about the loss of life of another human does NOT mean I dont condemn Israel's actions. My heart breaks every time I think of those who were killed in these attacks and what their loved ones must be going through. However, that does not mean that I am going to stoop down to the level of all the savages in this world and say that a Palestinians blood is more worth than an Israeli's. Both are God's children and both have the right to live. I pray and grieve deeply for all of my brothers and sisters in Gaza day and night. To all of those who just want to kill and hate each other based on our differeces, I would like to say that God is watching all of us, and I can pretty certainly say that he is NOT happy.
47. 35 Observer: Rabbi Eckstein prays defensively, it
Rivkah   (01.09.09)
appears. I am quite different in that I pray for God to protect and defend me, but also for God to avenge me. Most people who love the Lord do not think of the Lord as an avenger, but the Bible says vengeance belongs to God. So I ask God to avenge me and He does. So many people have died or been in horrific accidents or gotten cancer after mistreating me to the point that I ask the Lord to avenge me. Rabbi Eckstein probably is not into asking for revenge from the Lord, but I ask every day for all the vengeance the Lord will allow. King David was comforted when the Lord showed him the fate of his enemies which was eternal death for them.
48. #47 from where Israel got it, offense is the best defense?
observer   (01.09.09)
do Zionists work separately from their Rabbis?
Previous talkbacks
Back to article