News
New initiative calls for PA control over Gaza-Egypt border
Ynet
Published: 10.01.09, 08:22
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
8 Talkbacks for this article
1. another plan
Joe ,   US   (01.10.09)
What happens when Fatah loses election and control of PA ? Alos who controls the remainder of the Gaza Egypt border - who will be monitoring the remaindr outside the 'triangle' for arms smugling ? This idea is like Swiss cheese- full of holes
2. UN acts 18 months later
Avinoam ,   Tel Aviv, Israel   (01.10.09)
Obviously this is not in response to Hamas murdering members of a rival political party. The UN does not even have the spine to address Hamas's responsibility in huge documents regarding a ceasefire. This move is simply a "legitimate" way to meddle in Israeli affairs. Can anyone still believe that the UN is unbiased, or even relevant?
3. Turkish and French military?
You gotta be kidding ,   right?   (01.10.09)
Just don't mention the war. OMG - like placing mice in charge of guarding the cheese....
4. No ones going into Gaza to monitor anything.
Ypip ,   Canada   (01.10.09)
until the op is over. If they're so anxious about it, they can always *monitor* where all that 'aid' is going from Iran and the UAE, for the 'poor victims' of Gaza.
5. Boo to those impracticle initiatives !!!
Shira ,   Canada   (01.10.09)
Why wasnt the world as "concerned" and as full of "initiative" when Israel was pounded for 8 years by the Hamas? Why didnt the UN do something when Israel repeatedly COMPLAINED about those rocket attacks?
6. Plan to put PA in power?
Ralph levy ,   USA   (01.10.09)
Plan to put PA in power? Is that why Israeli boys are dyeing in Gaza? Or to protect the South? No to the PA in Gaza. http://ralphsrant1.blogspot.com
7. muslim turks and pro arab french soldiers?
rina   (01.10.09)
just look at the ongoing demographical crisis the un has caused by yealding to the claims of a few arab families and a lots arab nomads that had lived in the gaza area, who had no nation except their affliation with the arab world, when it resolved the gaza area won't be a part of israel in 1948. an ongoing catastrophy for the children who were born there with a conviction that if they got that strip of land, they might eventually get the rest of israel too. this co incides with european pro arab diplomacy ever since, which cared lot for arab oil and arab world opinions, but has caused a lot of suffering to the generations to come. this catastrophy goes on generation after generation, because although israel is such a tiny country, the jews have no other home land, where they can be masters to their fate as a nation. whereas the islam has 22 countries, including jordan, which is the east bank of palestine, inhabitted mostly by palestinians. it is 4 times larger then the west bank and a dozen times less populated. the reason i mention jordan, is because when the world calls to free palestine, it doesn't know that palestine never existed, for if it had existed, then it is mostly jordan, and some 15% israel. they don't know it because of an arab propaganda, which cares very little for facts that occured not long ago. the jews got mostly an arid desert in 1948, which is hard to believe when one sees the ongoing demographical crisis in the west bank today. putting pro arab soldiers, and believing they shall prevent the arab cause to gain domination in the west bank, seems to be a deliberate bad judgement on their part again. hopefully it won't proove to be catastrophical, as was the egyptian watch over arms smuggling through the border.
8. Israel, Go for Your Goals
Menachem ,   Vienna, AT   (01.10.09)
Just don`t listen. Remove those who want to fefeat you... Hamas must be erradicated. Best to closeand take also the southern border of Gaza strip.
Back to article