Opinion
Media war on 'Nazi' Israel
Roee Nahmias
Published: 11.01.09, 09:22
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
56 Talkbacks for this article
31. why
Jennie ,   NYC   (01.12.09)
I can't get the purpose of this article...If it isn't enough yet what lies the enemie is circulating about us(Jews), Nachmias is publicizing it and adding another drop of poison to a pot full of it....A Jewish journalist who knows the truth should have add his analisys to the situation.... And the truth is, that all around the world, wherever Jews lived for almost 2 Thousand years, they were always the scape goats, the subjects of pogroms and brutal mass murders..they were hated, expelled from the countries they were born in and were loyal citizens to. The arab countries expelld over 600,000 Thousand Jews in the in the 60's, confiscating all their assets and hoping to kill them with all the Israeli people in an all out war against Israel .Why is it, that when finally most Jews left the countries they were so unwelcome and established their own tiny country, the whole world is focused to destroy it..Why do Jews obsetting the world so much ?!What is wrong with this world ? This is in general what I would write the above article about if I was a writer/correspondent.....
32. To Ahmed #9. Israel is Defending Itself Against Terror.
Maansingh ,   The Netherlands   (01.12.09)
You say :” why wont these dumb palestinians understand.” Ahmed, this is NOT a fight between Israel and the Palestinians, but one where Israel is defending itself against terror. The Israeli action in Gaza Strip will STOP when Hamas agrees to STOP firing rockets at Israel, and when it STOPS receiving arms from Syria and Iran.
33. Ironic. It was the Palestinian that fought with the Nazis
Jo   (01.11.09)
It is a history that they can not escape. The mufti is pictured with Hitler. There was even a muslim unit. The Mufti of Jerusalem aligned themselves with the Nazis, fought against the British. No matter how they would like to change history, there is so much documentation out there that tells it as it is. The Jews of that time fought with the British against the Nazis.
34. Forget the arabs, look at BBC, CNN, C4
Danny   (01.12.09)
35. To BP #28. I second your TB. It is NEEDED.
Maansingh ,   The Netherlands   (01.12.09)
36. Baal temple nowdays
Siul ,   madrid sefarad   (01.12.09)
The world is annoyed ok. do not worry, now is the time to be brave and please to the Lord and so to win his favour . I imagine that he is not happy when he see a transformation of Baal temple in moriat hill nowdays, in JERUSALEM!!!.
37. The Truth hurts
Macker ,   Edinburgh, Scotland   (01.12.09)
I fail to see anywhere in the article where the reports on the 'arabic' stations are incorrect. And its not only the arabic stations that are showing these type of images, its also CNN, BBC & ITV. Maybe because these images are true, isnt that what really should be the thrust of this article. That no matter how you try to block the truth, it will evantually come out, limited at first, but you can no longer operate a war in silence with todays technology and expect the world to believe your version, we also know that the IDF have blocked access to the strip to all outside journalists because you fear what will be shown.
38. Clips like these should be broadcast by the MSM
redbourn ,   Tel Aviv   (01.12.09)
http://tinypic.com/player.php?v=2euj0r6&s=5 Most of the world including the Muslim one have no idea how Hamas treats Gazans! http://tiny.cc/rulebyhamas1 The narration at the front ends after a minute or so and then we see Hamas in action. Mike
39. You protest against these images?
Endeavour ,   European-wide   (01.12.09)
they are just showing the reality of the conflict! I wonder if you wait that Arab media will depict Israel during this was as a peace-loving and a pacifist country while perpetrating mass killing of civilians and children in Gaza.
40. Its OK Jews wont have to suffer this long.. 9 days at most
RJBH ,   Methil   (01.12.09)
41. Gaza images
Debra ,   UK   (01.12.09)
Gaza images are the inevitable consequence of the WORLD condoning human shields and ignorantly focus on the effect and blaming those who fight it instead of attacking the cause. Inverse morality.
42. For Christians in the world
Marcos David ,   Sao Paulo, Brazil   (01.12.09)
A Christian theology deficient with respect to "Holy Land" has contributed to the tragic cross cruelty of the Middle Ages. Unfortunately, this Christian theology deficient is, today, giving the Israel secular a divine mandate to conquer and take possession of Palestine, with the consequence that the Palestinian people is marginalized and regarded as "virtual canaanites". This doctrine is both contrary to the teaching of the New Testament as a violation of the mandate of the Gospel of God in Jesus Christ. In addition, this theology puts those Christians who encourage the violent attack on and occupation of the earth Palestine in moral hazard of guilt in shedding of blood Palestinian.As Christians we are not called to pray and work for peace, warning both parts of this conflict that those who live by the sword shall die by the sword? Who hath ears, listen...
43. Solution?
nancy ,   Philadelphia USA   (01.12.09)
..does this article advocate siffling the press? ignoring reality? ooh...don't mind the dead children..there is a mission to accomplish! Get REAL! The Red Cross. Human Right Watch. There are impartial organisations that lambaste all nations who murder and torture and lie. they criticized the USA, Canada, Israel, as well as China and Cuba, and Darfur and Somalia. None are spared the wrath of truth; life is life, children lost are children lost no matter that nation. Are you so pompous as to be advocating stifling of the press for Israel's atrocities?
44. Press
Joel Shurkin ,   US   (01.12.09)
Israel bans the international press from covering the war and then complains about the coverage. Good luck.
45. Not only arabs, nazis do too...
annoyed ,   germany   (01.12.09)
Greetings from Germany. I've seen one or two natives here say the same thing about Israel and jews in general. Then you ask them a few choice questions and suddenly "concentration camps never happened" and "jews killed their economy". If a person who wants to exterminate all jews, calls you a nazi for attacking someone, who also wants to exterminate all jews, it's not really something an intelligent person should be taking seriously. Not to mention that you cannot seriously compare the kind of considerate self defense Israel is showing here with genocide. Of course, that doesn't mean you shouldn't try to point out the wrongness of such an accusation to others, there are a lot of less than intelligent people in this world, after all.
46. Media bias
Douglas Miller ,   Detroit, USA   (01.12.09)
If visitors arrived here from Mars and relied only on the mainstream media they would think that Israel was attacking Boy Scouts in Gaza. The media has so irresponsibly, and in many cases, intentionally butchered the reporting on the war in Southern Israel and Gaza that they are guilty of interplanetary journalistic malpractice. It's barely mentioned that Hamas and their buddies in other terrorist gangs have fired over 10,000 missiles, rockets and mortars into Israel from Gaza over the past 8 years, the majority since all Jews left & turned control of Gaza over to the Arab settlers 3 years ago. There is barely a mention that Hamas targets innocent civilians: men, women and children, schools, shops, apartments, businesses, homes, synagogues and hospitals. We have not, and still don't, hear about the many deaths, hundreds of injuries, widespread destruction and the constant fear suffered by hundreds of thousands of Israeli citizens who are frightened for the safety of their loved ones. Little mention that 750,000 people are now in range of Hamas missiles that have been supplied by the mullahs in Iran and smuggled into Gaza Our Martian friends would have to hunt far and wide to discover that Hamas has received billions in aide but has squandered it all on weapons acquisition to further it's sole aim which is the annihilation of Israel and the extermination of the Jewish people. And they would never know that Hamas uses human shields to protect their cowardly gunmen, cynically hoping for civilian casualties to promote their propaganda offensive. Hopefully our Martian friends will find out what many of our fellow earthlings don't yet know that the media, for some inexplicable reason, is supporting the terrorists in their war against the Jews.
47. Christians
Jeroen Kesteloot ,   Kortrijk Belgium   (01.12.09)
"Christians we are not called to pray and work for peace, warning both parts of this conflict that those who live by the sword shall die by the sword? Who hath ears, listen... " I feel the same way. Hamas wanted war, now hell has come over them. Let them learn.
48. The media in Europe
Janus Hansen ,   Copenhagen, Denmark   (01.12.09)
Many of us in the West who unconditionally supports Israel's right to self defense of this war. The Western press has different views and are running a propaganda war in favor of Hamas is frightening. In Europe we have lots of problems with Muslim immigrants who will not adapt to European culture, but living in isolated enclaves. First, the days of a war between Muslims and European pears, Europe and its population will understand Israel. My best wishes to Israel and the Israeli population.
49. DONT STOP THE IMAGES OF DEAD 'FREEDOM FIGHTERS' I LOVE IT
..............DACON9   (01.12.09)
50. #42
(01.13.09)
Ponder the welcome Christians will receive in the holy land if the Palestinians, who call for destruction of Israel and world domination succeed. If Israel dies by the sword, next will be Christianity and then every other non-Muslim in the world. Destruction of Israel is only its first objective.
51. French TV Faked Footage in Gaza, again
Ibrahim ,   S. Arabia   (01.13.09)
This was published a couple of hours ago on Fox News.com http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,479485,00.html "Media analysts are feeling a sense of déjà vu as reports of doctored and staged footage, which critics say creates propaganda for terrorists, begin surfacing from Gaza again. France 2 Public Television aired video showing the purported aftermath of an Israel Air Force strike in the Palestinian territory, which has been under siege by the Israeli military for more than two weeks. But the footage was actually amateur video shot during a 2005 incident involving Gaza civilians killed in an explosion caused by militants. The footage shows dozens of bodies, including Hamas gunmen and civilians. In the report, the.....
52. Al Quds al Arabi
Gabi Gold ,   Tel Aviv, Israel   (01.13.09)
It amazes me whenever I see Abd Al-Bari Atwan on BBC News or Sky extolling the virtues of peace between Israel & The Palestinians, when I know first hand while serving him in my family restaurant ,in London prior to making Aliyah. He dined with a woman and it was fairly late in the evening and they were the only guests dining. I made it clear that I recognized him and asked him his opinion on whether there will ever be peace in the middle east; I also asked him what he thought of Osama Bin Laden. To my disbelief he and his female guest started saying that all jews should be killed and that there is no such thing as an Israeli. As far as he was concerned, Osama was a hero for masterminding 9/11 and America deserved it. Although I was incensed I did not make my ethnicity known and as it was a Greek restaurant (Long story), he was none the wiser. I did not fancy having the restaurant firebombed or maybe worse. This is the man called on by all the news agencies whenever they are looking for an objective analysis of the middle east. So, with that in mind what is your opinion on peace in the middle east?
53. To Macker #37. War is NOT A Child-Play.
Maansingh ,   The Netherlands   (01.13.09)
You say :”.. the IDF have blocked access to the strip to all outside journalists (also to all Israeli journalists) because you fear what will be shown.” The IDF did that in order to avoid journalists coming in the crossfire, in order to avoid journalists getting killed. AFTER the war all journalists will be ALLOWED to enter Gaza Strip -- to do their investigations and research, take interviews of ALL the civilians. BTW journalists craving for live-reporting straight from the battlefield while the battle is going on -- is sheer STUPIDITY. Why is it stupidity ? Because war is NOT a child-play, war is NOT a dancing-party, war is NOT a theatrical performance. War is a killing business (between Israeli Army and Hamas et al operatives) -- so, journalists should NOT be eager to stand in the crossfire.
54. Do You Wonder Why?!
Edd Yerburgh ,   United Kingdom   (01.13.09)
Do you really wonder why? I hate to see Hamas using terror tactics on ISrael, but there are reasons. If you retreated to your originally intneded borders then Hamas will accept a ceasefire. This website makes me sick with the way you present Hamas. You know why their so upset? maybe because you stole their lands, split up the west bank adn gaza, put continuous sanctions and blockades, built ilegal settlements on their land, built a WALL between you and their land and then started developing on THEIR land! Hamas, terrorists? bah. They are desperate people and only terror tactics, although sad and discusting, can work against you. For some reason no countries have backed them up, talked to them, given them any help. You have the 4th biggest army in the world and are bombarding Gaza YET again. From what I understand from the start you have both been in the wrong, but to present Hamas as terrorist and you as the good guys? A little one sided I think. Obviously this is an Israeli site and I'm sure its just as one sided on Hamas' site, but you will never kill terror with violence, only insight more hatred and reason to use terror tactics. Do you think you;re going to acheive ANYTHING except the hate of the world and of HAmas by doing this? IF this is published then I am very grateful and would like to receive emails as I'm sure I don't know half the story. Thankyou Peace and Love.
55. To nr 9 - the pathetic Jew hater Ahmed
Alexander ,   Herzliya, Israel   (01.15.09)
Anti-Semitism is hatred for Jews.This hatred is characterized by: 1)Demonization of Jews. 2) Double standards deployed against Jews 3.) Discrimination of Jews 4) Delegitimization of Jews and Israel and 5.) False accusations. Further on: a Jew spewing hatred against Jews and Israel does not justify hatred and racism against Israel. If an African spreads hatred and racism against Africans, does it mean that it is okay to hate and spread racism against Africans? Further on: the Arab world is the biggest producer and consumer of Nazi Literature such as Mein Kampf. The Arab world cooperated with Hitler and Nazi Germany and sent many North African Jews to a certain death in European Nazi German concentration camps. The Baath Parties of Iraq and Syria are based on fascism and communism. The Arabs of today are not the original Arabians of the 600s AD. Arabs of today are Africans, Asians, Berbers, Kurds, Mongols, Turks, Persians, Assyrians and South Europeans and Yugoslav people speaking the Arabic tongue and upholding the culture of Greece, Rome and Persia. Dozens of civilizations including Jews, lived in the Middle East before Arabs. 90% of the population in most Arab countries: 1) Deny or glorify the Holocaust 2.) Thinks that killing Jews because they are Jews is okay. 3.) Thinks that Israel has no right to exist. Interestingly enough: an Israelite/Jewish nation has existed for the past 4000 years but no "Palestinian" nation or people has ever existed in recorded human history - no archaeological evidence speaks of a "Palestinian" civilization and no ancient culture ever mentions or refers to any "Palestinians" but most ancient cultures and civilizations refer to Jews/Hebrews/Israelites and Israel. The Bible and the Koran never mention "Palestinians" or "Palestine" once. War is ugly. Civilians are always victims of war. If civilian losses is so terrible, its strange that Arabs had no problem killing 12 million Arabs since WW2, and its strange that Arab parents and Hamas members use their Arab kids as human shields. And yes, Hizbollah did use kids and civilians as human shields in Lebanon. UN is not reliable. It consists almost exclusively of despotic, militaristic and theocratic states and governments. Democracy, freedom, liberty and truth are not chief components of UN. Yes, Israel is fighting terrorism. Terrorists never bring with them freedom and democracy and terrorists never fight for independence and national liberation. Terrorists bring death and destruction and despotism and that is exactly what Arabs of Gaza, Judea and Samaria are doing.
56. #13 marti
Stefan ,   Germany   (01.15.09)
Please spare me the...I feel so ashamed...line. To start with, there are far more than just one Holocaust, human history is full of them, there is no country or people without some dark history...including the Jews. Second, the Jewish Holocaust is not unique, if there is one Holocaust that is unique or comes close to one, than that would be the Native American Holocaust, 40,000,000 is the conservative estimate, it is also the most successful Holocaust. Oh Btw, I have no shame, remorse or guilt, I didn't kill anyone, never have condoned killing anyone, nor have I ever seen a person killed. I am a German, and damn proud of it, I fly my flag day and night high. So please....zip it with the "I feels so guilty!!!
Previous talkbacks
Back to article