News
IDF: Shots fired from doctor's home
Hanan Greenberg
Published: 17.01.09, 18:54
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
60 Talkbacks for this article
31. #2 Faraz ! Think About It ?
Gad ben Shalom ,   Jerusalem Israel   (01.17.09)
It is all over youtube of Hamas killing Arabs in Gaza . The "Good" Dr. was absolutely going against the Hamas Doctrine . It is very very sad that his family was used when he was not Home . But unless you are part of the Muslims that think he should have been executed a long time ago for befriending Israeli's , you have got to know he was a target by Hamas . I guarantee you it was Hamas that was shooting from his home to draw fire . Exactly like they do in the UNWRA Schools , which Faraz is on YouTube , if you care , go look for yourself . The Enemy here is not Israel , its Hamas. G-d Bless these special children and their father . Now maybe he will leave that place and work for peace where his children are not at risk of assasination by Hamas. He Was Freinds of Israel's Defense Minister , Think Faraz
32. #29 Another self hating Jew heard from
Alex ,   US   (01.17.09)
33.  If there were no civilians present in Gaza
Maria ,   MD   (01.17.09)
during this conflict,Israel could have flattened Gaza strip in just one day.But Israel's hands and feet are tied up by the UN and the Arab world and of course the people all over the world who have won the hearts of Palestinians[thanks to the Arab media for only showing Palestinian victims].
34. To #29 Arik Speak for yourself
Levi ,   Rifle, Colorado /   (01.17.09)
Most of us from the WEST SUPPORT ISRAEL AND ALLWAYS WILL !!! Don't know whos polls your looking at.
35. #29 Ah we in the west DO believe Israels credibility.Hamass
is ALWAYS guilty. ,   ALWAYS!! JP,USA   (01.17.09)
36. Why is a pali doctor working in an Israeli
jason white ,   afula,israel   (01.17.09)
hospital? Not enough Israeli drs?
37. Yeah sure
Ava ,   New York, USA   (01.17.09)
Yeah sure the army was fired on - just like it was from the UN school. Man does a lot of things to cover his tracks but this is downright dirty.
38. Answer to #6
Ava ,   New York, USA   (01.17.09)
Wow. Do you realize that if anyone said all these things that you just said about Muslims to Jews instead, they would be called "anti-semetic"? You poor people - so brainwashed by your state's media. Maybe you should see/read what the rest of the world thinks about you.
39. blah blah blah. yes the same BS you said about the UN school
son of yaffa ,   yaffa   (01.17.09)
your hunger for spilling blood is never ending
40. #2: Israel should finish all of Hamas anyway!
Jack ,   San Diego, USA   (01.17.09)
41. SHAME IS ONLY ISRAELS. MY CONDALANCE FOR THE DOCTOR.
ATİLLA KARAGÖZOĞLU   (01.17.09)
42. to 29: If Israel has no credibility ...
Hans ,   Germany   (01.17.09)
so have you as you are part of Israel. Tough luck my dear.
43. Dr. wins on every side!
fertiledirt ,   US   (01.17.09)
He enjoys the benefits of living in Israel, probably without the taxes, (how many Israeli drs. allowed in Gaza?), gets to work for jihad, and gets out of the dowry payments for his daughters, before he has to slaughter them for dishonor. Then, hey, call a PR meeting and act like the victim! Win-Win! Now he only has to wait for his share in the more than 200 million dollars already pledged in aid. Yes, it's been proven that martyrs families are paid.
44. THIS IS NOT A WAR. AND HAMAS IS JUST DEFENDING HIS PEOPLE.
ATİLLA KARAGÖZOĞLU   (01.17.09)
45. #37: Ava, photographic evidence abounds that this is
Global Citizen ,   Israel & USA   (01.17.09)
Hamas' modus operandi. If you don't want to believe it, that is your problem. It is a BIG problem, because then no-one can take seriously anything else you post.
46. Who works for the UN in Gaza ???
Sobieski   (01.18.09)
Who works for the UN in Gaza ?? Hypothesis: Moslems and european leftists like Mats Gilbert are the only ones who would be motivated enough to work there. Therefore info from Gaza is biased.
47. to #29-"arik silverman" You are just upset
Arie ,   BaGolan   (01.18.09)
That we, the Jewish people, have finally said enough is enough to muslim terrorism! I realize that your people, followers of the vatican and the profit, DEMAND that Jews accept any attempts to eradicate us you thrust on us:from the crusades, to the Inquisition, to the pogroms, to the Shoah, you sure did try. Well, whatever your real name is, the sheepish Jew died in the Shoah! Today, hit us and we will hit you back twice! By the way abdul, check your states: the VAST majority of American CITIZENS support us, even according to the arab Zogby poll!
48. mark in USA: yet you accept all claims against us
Arie ,   BaGolan   (01.18.09)
You claim there is no proof that snipers were using the building. So, permit me to ask:Why do you so quickly accept that '400 children were killed' without any real proof? All the sources quoted are by a "hamas source" or a "plaestinian source affiliated with hamas" or my favourite - "UN officials quoting 'reliable paletsinian sources' "! Or is it simply good old fashioned anti-Semitism that allows you to believe canards against us but not believe any response we provide? By the way, we DO appreciate the FACT that even the Arab Zogby poll identifies that the majority of Americans support us and state that the arabs started this war
49. #8 the only lies are coming from the Arabs
Pallywood ,   Pallywood   (01.18.09)
Time and again doctoring photographs and setting up shots and blaming Israel for their own "work accidents". Pallywood is in full swing!
50. Arab doctors and terrorism
AK   (01.18.09)
I don't know what it is about Arab doctors but saving lives doesn't seem to be for them a high priority. osama's #2, Hamas, the terrorists at Glasgow airport.... the list is unusually long. Arab doctors must have modeled themselves on Dr. Mengele.
51. All Gazans are legitimate targets
Meir ,   Tel Aviv   (01.18.09)
The Gazans opened a war on Israel, they launched terrorist attacks against the Israelis therefore Israel has the right to attack back Gaza and its people. Any other country would have nuked Gaza completely and that's what Israel should do in order to achieve peace.
52. inhuman
dilhoo ,   Mauritius   (01.18.09)
This is all insane!!!How can a mother of three accuse a father who has just lost his daughters of propaganda!No conflict has never had any human considerations but this one beats all. A lame excuse from Tsahal to bomb a building. And again what a disproportionnate response!! This is all making me sick.A proper genocide is happening. I am an atheist, and so glad i don't believe in any of these god. It spares me from many arguments.
53. # 42 ... Hans
Sderot   (01.18.09)
We could say the same thing about you ... Haaaannnnnssss from Germany. Does that mean you're a Natzi? since you're German? Get your stupid point?!
54. have Mercy on Him
amazed ,   cleveland /ohio   (01.18.09)
the DOC just lost 3 daughters ...and here you are calling him spy among other names . you are raising Hell about Shalit ..?? how about this poor man . like usual ..you kill innocent people and you say ...you were just returning the fire .......been there .
55. Duh, meir, in tel aviv
jack ,   Richmond, va   (01.18.09)
OK, just so you know. If you nuke gaza, not only are you committing genocied, but you are also committing suicide. It is not possible for Israel to use nukes against the palestinains, the jordanians, lebaneses, or most of the syrians or Egyptians. You simply live to close to them. Duh.
56. #17 "ben, world", you are beneath contempt
Ben Alofs ,   Bangor, UK   (01.18.09)
"reality - 3 less suicide bombers to worry about". I cannot believe the viciousness of this hateful statement after three young Palestinian girls were killed in their home by Israeli bombs.
57. # 41 you're a jerk
alan ,   texas   (01.18.09)
I you fire at Israel, the IDF will fire back. What don't you understand about that? If a girl fires a gun, you are just as dead as if a man fires the gun. can I make it any simpler for you?
58. Excuses
Jerrold Cohen ,   Seal Beach, USA   (01.18.09)
I tell you Israel comes up with excuses a mile a minute. PROVE IT. SHOW ME THE PHOTOS. TIME STAMPED. DATE STAMPED. PHOTOS THAT I KNOW WEREN'T RIGGED.
59. And so the lie is exposed - no shots from house.
daveza ,   za   (01.18.09)
http://www.jpost.com/servlet/Satellite?cid=1232100170518&pagename=JPost%2FJPArticle%2FShowFull The IDF Spokesman said soldiers "opened fire in the direction of the home of the Palestinian doctor... A preliminary probe by the IDF revealed that shots had been fired at Israeli forces from an apartment near Abuelaish's home. The troops returned fire and accidentally hit Abuelaish's home."
60. Have you lost your sense of humanity?
Vitor Vieira ,   Porto, Portugal   (01.19.09)
It's shameful: a man loose two daughters, another one is severely injured, and you spend time suggesting that "maybe" the guy shot the troops? In this case, it's clear he could't have done that. But you know something? If my country was invaded, I'd join the resistance. Would that make me a "terrorist"? Remember the maquisards on WWII: how many of them were jews? Would you label them "terrorists" when they killed german soldiers? Grow up, will you?
Previous talkbacks
Back to article