News
Livni in Brussels: Gaza crisis won’t end until Shalit returned
Roni Sofer
Published: 22.01.09, 01:33
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
43 Talkbacks for this article
1. LIVNI is a fraud! She wanted to "WITHDRAW" without SHALIT!
BMT ,   USA   (01.22.09)
2. Serious questions that must be addressed before exchanges...
Robert Bernier ,   Tel Aviv   (01.22.09)
Serious questions that must be addressed before exchanges of prisoners are considered. The prisoner exchanges harms Israeli deterrence, creates an appalling precedent that encourages further kidnappings, increases the possibility that our captured soldiers will be mistreated or even murdered in custody, and rewards imprisoned terrorists by releasing them early to claim new victims. While the return of the soldiers, regardless of their condition, fulfills an important central value of Israeli society – that the State of Israel will do its utmost to recover soldiers behind enemy lines – nonetheless, it poses serious questions that must be addressed before such exchanges are considered in the future. More at : http://xrl.us/kj6sj
3. obama's first call as president was to abbas.
debra ,   usa   (01.22.09)
4. YOU dictate the rules THE ISRAELI IDF WON
LARRY ,   USA   (01.22.09)
FOR EVERY TUNNEL RECONSTRUCTED DROP A WARNING 10 MINUTES PRIOR TO A BOMB ON TARGET IF YOU EXPECT THE EU TO KEEP YOU SAFE GOOD LUCK ISRAEL
5. Livni is right
Brod ,   USA   (01.22.09)
regarding Shallit. Unfortunately, Hamas, the Butchers, might have already butchered Shallit. Israel should capture Hamas political leaders because they are the ones that give life to Hamas terrorism.
6. Preconditions!
Daniel ,   San Jose, CA   (01.22.09)
I fail to see where any preconditions exist. If they are rearming, boarders open or not they are in violation. This whole cease fire defies the imagination. We are trying to deal with terrorists! We should be laying Gaza to waist until Hamas waves the white flag. I want Gilad back, I want the smuggling to stop. There is no precondition to that. Anything else gives legitimacy to the 9 years of bombing Israel and terrorism in general.
7. No Peace with out Gilad.
Daniel ,   San Jose, CA   (01.22.09)
they should get a week then we go into phase 3 if they don't hand of Gilad. Period.
8. On 2/10 she will be gone!
Arie ,   BaGolan   (01.22.09)
Along with her fellow 1%ers that have absolutely no concept on how to run a country and protect its citizens! They finished the war before achieving all its goals simply to appease the far left and foreign countries that have histories of hostility to Jews! We shant forget and we won't miss you!
9. Is he even alive?
Arie ,   BaGolan   (01.22.09)
Since 2006 no one has seen him or heard from him! The ICRC, as its tradition, abdicated its mandate where Jews are concerned and has refused to intercede even thought it is the executor of the Geneva Convention. Yet, in response, our appeasement government allow full access to hamass prisoners.
10. Hamas - you have come a long way baby
2nd observer ,   worldwide   (01.22.09)
you been holding shalit for 2 years and counting....
11. The tunnels PRECEDED the closed crossings
Zvi   (01.22.09)
This is because their original aim was to smuggle WEAPONS that were not allowed through the open crossings. Swedish Foreign Minister Carl Bildt is full of it.
12. If you want talk talk, if you want shot, shot
Itay Yahel   (01.22.09)
But never let down your people. Why? why did you go to fight and now all smuggle return to the terror lane? here is some of the web addresses which could make clear that truce with Hams without Gilad Shalit is bad decision. we lost the war from beginning, just because no Gilad, smuggling no ended, so what's going to be it all we had in the past, and we lost the media war too I hope I'm who is the wrong one http://www.facebook.com/video/video.php?v=1068867007308&oid=36976484493 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KKjcySXjhWg http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=59C17RJoyVU&feature=related http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7_OGhj43GAE
13. Ynet shows model pics of Livni
Respect for Gilad ,   USA   (01.22.09)
Ynet, why u show this. Gilad Shalit is waiting to come home. You are tainting the memory of a brave young soldier.
14. So sad to see Israel failed to exploit that changed equation
Raymond in DC ,   Washington, DC USA   (01.22.09)
So, after all the IDF did for the them and the country, Olmert and Barak believe Israel will have "no other choice" but to release Hamas prisoners. Has anyone ever so quickly thrown away their stronger position? They are shameless; They really need to leave the scene.
15. Swap livni for shalit, she is useless
bernard ross ,   st anns bay jamaica   (01.22.09)
She abandoned him to the animals. a real leader would tell the euros to not even think of anything for gaza until shalit is released. She should tell them if harm comes to shalit every gazan will pay
16. Did Livni take that photo at Glamour Shots. Boy She is ugly.
(01.22.09)
17. Border Crossings
jayemmay ,   Detroit, Michigan   (01.22.09)
I constantly read and hear about the border crossings. It is clear that the meaning is crossing points between Israel and Gaza. Why is the border between Gaza and Egypt ignored. It is as if goods can only reach Gaza from Israel. Why does Israel have such an obligation? When goods come from Egypt, they are smuggled in tunnels. Does Egypt refuse to have any commercial dealings with Gaza?
18. they choose Hamas
Israel   (01.22.09)
They are not digging tunnels out of desperation, they are digging tunnels to smuggle guns to attack Israel. I am not feeling sorry for them only the children. I think Israel should continue until Hamas doesn´t exist anymore. Hamas is not a nation, they are terrorist and there is not way to negociate with them because they are not reasonable.
19. IRANIAN ARMS SMUGGLING
Simple Yid ,   Israel   (01.22.09)
Bomb Iranian vessels, or tell the Somali pirates that the ships contain hidden treasure.
20. Livni should take into account....
Free Goliad   (01.22.09)
that Gilad possibly already evaporated under Israeli phosphorous bombs.
21. before & during the war Livni disnt care about Gilad
zionist forever   (01.22.09)
Now she does .. hints of typical Kadima coruption to me but it couldn't be because she is claiming to be honest isn't she? I am sure it couldn't have anything to do with the fact that there is an election in 19 days. About two weeks before the war she gave a speech to some students and told them we cant always bring our guys back ( Gilad ) During the war she never mentioned his name once. When we were talking with Egypt before the unilateral ceasefire all she wanted was a Red Cross visit. Now the voters think that she has abandoned him suddenly his release is a top priority. This is the woman who wants to be PM Gilad only matters to her as long as there are votes to be gained from his release. Any Israeli who cares about the security of the country will punish Livni and Barak on election day make sure they not only loose but loose by a landslide teach all potential governments both now and in future that if they dont satisfy the public then they will be punished.
22. Livni
Leonard ,   LA usa   (01.22.09)
Livni is a good looking woman. I'd vote for her.
23. smuggling
Lee ,   Canada   (01.22.09)
Who will stop the arm's smuggling into Isreal? Seems to me we are chasing the wrong terrorists here?
24. #22..Leonard from La
Malone ,   Hfx   (01.22.09)
Not that it has anything to do with anything,but if that's your opinion,it doesn't say a whole hell of a lot for the women where you come from.
25. it is evil
sarah ,   jerusalem   (01.22.09)
yesterday here one man in palastinian authoroty said .hamass do not make only to kill the innuscent of gazans .what is the stratigy of this war they are still lhke a mouse in a trap . how evil from the start till now . i said people in gaza do not say that and you are sit on your ass . oh how evil to let any prisoner in a prison for the stupidity of leaders
26. trade livni/olmer/barak for Shalit!!! Hamass can have em'!
Yid with brain ,   Israyoli   (01.22.09)
27. no peace for livni without schalit
elliot ,   usa   (01.22.09)
proof operation's limited success --now livni will pay pals for what she should have taken
28. #3 yes Obama is real American not zionist like Bush.
(01.22.09)
29. Hamas managed to expose your ugly faces to the whole world.
(01.22.09)
Obama is going to screw you soon.
30. You should ask yourself why Shalit was kidnapped in
(01.22.09)
the first place,BITCH !
Next talkbacks
Back to article