News
UN rep: Evidence Israel committed war crimes
Reuters
Published: 22.01.09, 20:51
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
82 Talkbacks for this article
1. are about this guy
David ben Yaakov ,   Toronto, Canada   (01.22.09)
2. How would you know?
David ben Yaakov ,   Toronto, Ont   (01.22.09)
This guy Falk should be utterly ashamed of himself. Not only is he a self-hating Jew, but he is promoting his conclusions from the confines of his cushy living room in California. Maybe some Mexican cartels should start lobbing rockets over the USA-Mexico fence, and with G-D's help, he'll learn what it is like to live in such a situation!
3. by his logic every Israeli dead or alive is a casualty
L. Rose ,   L.A., USA   (01.22.09)
If the entire population of Gaza counts as a 'casualty' then by his logic the traumatizing of Israeli citizens since the Arab countries declared war on it in '48 means its entire population is a 'casualty'. The fact that he feels it's okay for Israeli's to have rockets that kill falling on them for years, but he won't acknowledge their right to self defense is as prejudiced as an African American being lynched in pre-civil rights movement USA and not having the right to defend himself. There is no justice for Israel in the UN - once again there is one rule of law for others - and a demonizing rule of anti-law applied to Israel.
4. Investigate corruption at theUntied Nation
rachel ,   usa   (01.22.09)
5. Cry me a freaking river
J K ,   NYC, USA   (01.22.09)
Phonecalls, announcement, flyers being dropped in neighborhoods. nothing will ever be enough for the UN and their reflexive need to bring up 'war crimes' against Israel. Wars are MEANT to inflict harm on another population. Do you think Russia called everyone in Georgia to let them know there would be bombings? Have you heard about Russia being brought on up on war crimes? I sure haven't. Next time, maybe look to Hamas for their 8 years of war crimes against Israel, shooting rockets into population centers. For the UN, it seems, history starts only after Israel defends itself. The precipitating circumstances don't count.
6. Falk
Ben Hur ,   Manhattan, USA   (01.22.09)
Is Ynet not aware of who Richard Falk is?
7. Where is UN rep: Evidence Hamas committed war crimes
Maria ,   MD   (01.22.09)
The UN never condemned the Hamas or the Arab world.Oil talks.Iffff you,youuu condemned usss,we wooon't sell youuu ouuur oooil. The children in the picture are not malnourished at all.Who said that they're starving?
8. moving gazans to southern israel
israel   (01.22.09)
"There could have been temporary provision at least made for children, disabled, sick civilians to leave, even if where they left to was southern Israel," the US professor said. if they were allowed to come to southern israel they could have been rocketed by the hamas like the rest of the people in the south of the country - sounds to me like a fair trade. why stay in a war zone, when you can move to a war zone???
9. Dropping phosphorus bombs over a besieged population
The Hague   (01.22.09)
and causing indiscriminate death of hundreds of civilians is way beyond self-defence. Hamas rocket fire looks like peanuts in light of those heavy weight war crimes that Israel comitted.
10. No wonder Israel did not want to have the media there
Gadi   (01.22.09)
Far to often it is the free press that witnessed war crimes in areas of conflict. Of course, they are always welcome to visit Sderot but looking from the other side is not permitted.
11. UNHRC claims Israel committed war crimes
Ger ,   Raanana, Israel`   (01.22.09)
Why do you keep giving valuable space to the ravings of this anti-semite? He has never said a good word about Israel, and lives only to discredit it.
12. War crimes
Hal ,   usa   (01.22.09)
So will Egypt join Israel on the docket? The Egyptians used machine guns on Gazans that tried to cross into Egypt. I doubt it.
13. Background of Falk
Arie ,   BaGolan   (01.22.09)
In 2000, when he was with the OHCHR, he claimed the palis had a 'right' to attack Israelis!; John Bolton, in defining Falk last year, stated falk's goal was the removal of a Jewish State; EVEN BEFORE the incursion, he was DEMANDING Israeli government leaders be arrested and tried; In 2004, he accused the US Government of staging the 9/11 massacre; http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Richard_Falk
14. It's just Richard Falk again...
Joe ,   Ramat Gan   (01.22.09)
... spouting his double standards and ignoring both the reality on the ground and international law. Is there any way to sue the UN, or at least charge it with crimes against humanity: namely against the Jews?
15. Strange...
Efrat ,   Washington, DC   (01.22.09)
I have to wonder why no one is accusing Egypt of war crimes for closing the border crossings. Hamas is not a sworn enemy of Egypt or its people, so food and innocent civilians should be able to move freely across the Egyptian border. It is exceedingly strange to me that Israel is expected to do what no other country is expected to do- open its borders, provide safe haven, and deliver food, water, and power to a nation that refuses to recognize the right of Israel to exist or the right of her people to live. This kind of bizarre demand is precisely as insane as asking France to politely allow the German army to cross its borders during WWII. Only Israel is considered "criminal" if it denies freedom of movement within its borders to those affiliated with an enemy organization, and I have to wonder what, if not sheer anti-Semitism, this could possibly be fueled by?
16. Who is this UN rep
Michael ,   NY NY   (01.22.09)
In 2004, Falk wrote a preface to David Ray Griffin's book The New Pearl Harbor: Disturbing Questions About the Bush Administration and 9/11 which presents evidence that the George W. Bush administration was complicit in the September 11 attacks On February 16, 1979, two weeks after the Iranian revolution returned religious leader Ruhollah Khomeini to Iran, and nine months before student followers of Khomeini took American diplomats hostage at the US Embassy in Tehran, Falk wrote an op-ed for the New York Times entitled "Trusting Khomeini." Believing that Khomeini had been judged unfairly, he concluded "the depiction of Khomeini as fanatical, reactionary and the bearer of crude prejudices seems certainly and happily false ... To suppose that Ayatollah Khomeini is dissembling seems almost beyond belief. ... Having created a new model of popular revolution based, for the most part, on nonviolent tactics, Iran may yet provide us with a desperately-needed model of humane governance for a third-world country."[
17. Be not troubled; Richard Falk is a joke
Ben ,   USA   (01.22.09)
.... and a jihadi sympathizer. For example, his insight about Khomeini, was as follows: "The depiction of Khomeini as fanatical, reactionary and the bearer of crude prejudices seems certainly and happily false ... To suppose that Ayatollah Khomeini is dissembling seems almost beyond belief. ... Having created a new model of popular revolution based, for the most part, on nonviolent tactics, Iran may yet provide us with a desperately-needed model of humane governance for a third-world country."
18. where are is articles on the pa's
jewish girl ,   israel   (01.22.09)
shooting rockets into israel. he should care more for his own people. jews against jews. we will bring another holocaust on ourselves.
19. Mentally scarred for life
NoraTel Aviv ,   Tel Aviv   (01.22.09)
Show me one war in history that people were not mentally scarred, be it for the attacked or the attackers.
20. Israel:
Bernie ,   Paris   (01.22.09)
PLEASE FALK HIM!
21. who commited war crimes?
Israel Israeli ,   Tel Aviv   (01.22.09)
Mr. Falk should actually be accusing Mubarak and not Israel. Mubarak allowed Hamas to receive rockets which it used to attack Israel. Mubarak armed Hamas and is therefore criminally liable for the damage caused to innocent Arabs by the Israeli defensive action. Even more, Mr. Falk notes that "locking up" the Arabs was the cause of their trauma. Clearly, the Arabs could not be moved North or East which were Israeli military staging areas and legitimate targets for Hamas attacks. The only escape route available was south but throughout the war, Mubarak prohibited any passage of refugees into Sinai. Indeed Mubarak should be tried for his crimes.
22. Falk Can Go Falk Himself
Lawrence ,   Safed Israel   (01.22.09)
23. Palestinians commit war crimes
Ita ,   Israel   (01.22.09)
Maybe the ppl of Sderot and the rest of southern israel can claim the same.. The live in fear EVERY DAY of those rockets.. The rest of the country of israel too who have to live in fear as to where the rockets would land. OMG , what a lack of brains and an extreme anti-semite. THIS IS WAR! Holy Cow! I want to prosecute for the war crimes against me as a citizen of Israel.. Woah!
24. Richard Falk will talk about the Warsaw ghetto
hilonia   (01.22.09)
evev if Israel woul d have sent flowers to the Gazans
25. Falk,go complain with Egypt and with your UN friends
Keren ,   Israel-SP   (01.22.09)
Egypt closed their doors to their "brothers"to run from war zone.Israel is just fed up of years and years of terror and is just naturally reacting. UN feeds this hell.If they wanted it would be finished long ago and that population would not suffer nor would Israel. Offer to the pali population land to live and farm or make business among their own in one of the arab countries,and I bet they will be happy and go.It is your likes who keep this hell alight to after complain.It is mentally ill men like you who do this. Israel did very well to not let you in :you are not a Jew but an abortion!
26. The UN has disqualified itself from any investigation.
Cynic ,   USA   (01.22.09)
No unbiased, impartial and objective body would ever indict anybody before conducting the investigation. This bozo has already found war crimes were committed before he has even stepped foot in Gaza.
27. Talk of war crimes is just proof that Hamas was defeated.
Cynic ,   USA   (01.22.09)
28. NEXT TIME
LARRY ,   USA   (01.22.09)
MAKE IT OFFICIAL A DECLERATION OF WAR . BECAUSE NO MATTER WHAT ISRAEL DOES OR DOES NOT DO IT WILL BE CONDEMED .TOTAL WAR ON ALL TERROR GROUPS AND COUNTRIES ALLIED WITH THEM JUST AS THE AMERICAN RUSSIAN AND BRITISH DID IN WW2
29. With Jews like you, who needs Hamas!
A proud Israeli Jew! ,   Haifa, Israel   (01.22.09)
Falk, Shame on you! For unjustifiably attacking Israel, a country the size of NJ which finally acted after 8 years of terror from Hamas. An ongoing daily terror that ruined the lives and property of ten of thousands of Jews in Israel, that hypocrites like you the UN, obviously did little to stop. I am not sure what is the exact title for Jews like you, but as far as I am concerned your are an anti-Semite, Jew or not! You are not welcome in Israel!
30. Proof of UN racism is right here, read and weep:
JPS ,   Efrat   (01.22.09)
Amnesty International produced the following conclusion in 2002. We can only conclude that the UN has actively ignored Palestinian war crimes for the past 7 years and is obviously and clearly pursuing a racist vendetta against Israel: "The attacks against civilians by Palestinian armed groups are widespread, systematic and in pursuit of an explicit policy to attack civilians. They therefore constitute crimes against humanity under international law. They may also constitute war crimes" http://www.amnesty.org/en/library/info/MDE02/003/2002 This does nothing but prove the uselessness of the corrupt UN and its bloated, graft-ridden bureaucracy.
Next talkbacks
Back to article