Culture  Music
Noa cancels appearance at Gaza fundraiser
Merav Yudilovitch
Published: 23.01.09, 09:05
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
66 Talkbacks for this article
1. I believe only loosers will come to this so-called concert
Alex   (01.23.09)
BTW, who are those "actors" ? Does anybody know them?
2. Can you imagine a benefit for Berlin in 1944 London?
AK   (01.23.09)
I don't. The Israeli Arabs participating in this affair are traitors who don't even have 'divided' loyalties -- their loyalties are with Israel's enemies 1000%. But what can one say about the Israeli Jews who do the same? They are far worse than merely traitors. No country ever in history allowed open treason and subversion at the time of war. Those Israeli Jews are beneath contempt. Noa, go and sing to collect money for the people of Sderot. You take pride in being Mizrahi Jew? Well, the majority of the people in Sderot are working-class Mizrahi Jews. You have who to help.
3. What about gay Palestinians who are injured?
Yaakov Sullivan ,   NYC   (01.23.09)
There are some palestinians from our community who are in need. We have sent them our blood donations by UPS. We also collected $18000 at our annual nude salsa contest ( I won the first place) We hope you can make a difference in their life.
4. Noa
Josie ,   Israel   (01.23.09)
Kol Hakavod to you! I stand with you. Be strong in your conviction for it is the truth. Let the organizers bury their head in the sand like the ostrich. More power and success to you!
5. artists and managers
fish tel-aviv   (01.23.09)
I'd urge the manager of Mira Awd to sue the "artists" who signed this letter, demanding her withdrawal from Eurovision, citing harassment, giving a delicate situation, attempts to ruin her career through political means. Levontin 7 has a capacity of 100-200 places most. The money they may raise will probably be enough to but a couple of rounds of beer for all this circus, not to help their beloved Gazans, but of course this event must in their idea boost their popularity. Disgusting. Noa was right to withdraw from this event.
6. They're right
Ofer ,   Israel   (01.23.09)
It's not proper to infantilize the Palestinans. They made a choice to elect leaders who are more interested in killing Jews than taking care of their people. They are responsible aduluts who should live with the consequences of their actions.
7. Noa's letter was right
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (01.23.09)
Hamas whit his social work had attracted much votes . Other parties also act this way , social work , schools , religion are the reasons of Shas's succes here too .
8. You did the right thing!!!
Esther ,   Israel   (01.23.09)
Noa, I'm a huge fan of yours even though I don't always agree with your political views. In this case, I think you did the right thing!
9. Only Jews can You can kill the Gazans and cry over them to
Eric ,   Tel Aviv   (01.23.09)
Apparently the hypocritical writers of the protest letter do not understand the concept of compassion. For them it is black and white - join us or die. Israel did everything it could to prevent the loss of lives in Gaza, it was not our troops that rigged schools to blowup, that set up launch pads next to schools of hospitals in order to force reprisals, that put munitions under people's homes so they would blowup without warning. Hamas may have started out as an elected party, but when they started to forcibly remove the rest of the government and staging a military coupe then they lost legitimacy. Good for Noa, her letter was correct and her actions now both in offering to help raise money and then in canceling her support for a concert with the wrong message was right.
10. I totally agree with Josie! Kol hakavod Noa!
Alejandro Rodriguez ,   Berlin, Germany   (01.23.09)
Seeking peace does not mean ignoring reality! If there is something ugly at sight, you should take care of it instead of looking in the other direction!
11. Shame, we had planned to go and donate beyond
Aviva ,   Tel Aviv   (01.23.09)
When we first read about this, the organizers said it was to be an a-political event. I, along with family and friends, were planning to attend and to give a donation of nearly $10,000. We were planning to go largely because Noa and Miri would be performing. Noa's letter reflected perfectly the situation and the way the vast majority of Israelis feel. Well, we'll donate elsewhere.
12. Stick to your guns Noa!
Ram ,   London   (01.23.09)
While your kind heart intends to help those injured as a consequence of their black hearted leaders' actions, you can see that even some of your own people are turning against you and insist on bending you to follow their twisted beliefs even when you are intentions are to contribute out of pure kindness. Remain steadfast on your beliefs and and direct your energy and talent to help those wounded on the Israeli side. Israel has so many enemies from without and within that the Palestinians will always find backing. Always remember the valid saying "my enemies enemy is my friend". Shabbat shalom
14. No regrets
Isaac ,   Brazil   (01.23.09)
It's amazing how naive the self hating jews are.Noa has nothing to apologize.She wrote a wonderful letter which express by the way a deep commitment to peace between Israel and the Palestinians.
15. #2 Right on!
Debbie   (01.23.09)
The Leftists got us into this mess in the first place. Now, instead of APOLOGIZING to the residents of the South, they are spitting in their faces by collecting money for the next generation of terrorists in Gaza. You think they'll love you if you send them shekels for blankets? No, they'll just get stronger to fight you better. WAKE UP ALREADY!!!!!!!! And if you hate this country so much, LEAVE!!!!
16. Noa, Keep Writing!!! Write More!!!
Brana Lobel ,   Israel   (01.23.09)
17. Leftists have trouble accepting the ugly truth
JPS ,   Efrat   (01.23.09)
There they go again bleating about how the Pals "have freely elected one political movement". So what? Hamas is guilty of crimes against humanity and war crimes. Their stated goal and policy is to attack civilians. Yet the Left is silent about this fact. It makes them liars by omission and negates their efforts. Instead of confronting the ugly truth, the radical Left embraces the Hamas war crimes and bleats out "legitimate resistance to the occupation". It is not legitimate. It is not resistance. It is a stated policy of war crimes. That's why the left is dying out and is on the verge of disappearing from the Knesset. They are supposed to be pursuing peace. Instead they are supporting Hamas - whose stated goal is war and death.
18. Achinoam Nini is actually kind . . .
vered ,   israel   (01.23.09)
The Palestinians freely elected a political party that espouses the destruction of Israel. If they had been winning, what would their response be? And if all the Gazans in their heart of hearts wished to see all of Israel destroyed, well, if you can't take the heat get out of the kitchen, or rather, who are the real crybabies?
19. to 11
tFighterPilot   (01.23.09)
There are enough people around the world who donate to the Palestinians (or in other words, buying weapons for Hamas) If you want to donate, why won't you donate to the people of Sderot who lost their homes?
20. Hipocracy of terror
Ben ,   Binyamina, Israel   (01.23.09)
According to the organizers, you can't accidentally kill children and then send blankets and other humanitarian aid. But the Hamas can train children to blindly hate us, teach them to be suicide terrorists, use civilians as human shields as they target our children and then they make a dramatic show of their tears when the reap the fruit they have sown.
21. Go out and buy Noa's albums
Alexander ,   Ramat Gan, Israel   (01.23.09)
Noa may be naive, but she is a very genuine peace-loving person, perhaps too much so. She is also a terrific and famous singer, whose presence at the concert could attract a lot of people and money. The fundraiser organizers' position shows that they are not nearly as interested in the plight of the wounded and dispossessed Gazans than they are in furthering their anti-Israeli political agenda. I call upon all commenters here, including those who, like myself, disagree with Noa's naive take on politics yet realize that she means well, to go out and buy Noa's music. This way, you will both support a good person against a hypocritical bunch of terror supporters and you will also get to enjoy her wonderful music and powerful lyrics.
22. "Systematic intentional brutality"
S.   (01.23.09)
those words belong to Hamas and not Israel. Noa is right!
23. #13
Ethan ,   Eilat   (01.23.09)
Whoever put that together is a sick person with a sick warped imagination,
24. Noa is a good one
Bernd ,   Germany   (01.23.09)
Noa, I have been on many of your concerts both in Germany and in Israel. I believe you are a good person and a kind person. Therefore, I tend to rather follow your position than that of the arab and proarab hatemongers. Keep on rocking, keep on trucking, keep the faith! Bernd
25. Aviva, Tel Aviv #11
m   (01.23.09)
Aviva, there is an idea: how about donating your 10.000 to Sderot kids?
26. How about childred in Sderod??
Texas ,   US   (01.23.09)
Half-brained idiot. Collecting money for the enemy is treason.
27. Have a Sderot/Gaza thingy and split it
Mea   (01.23.09)
They are trying to use your good name and turn your words against you. Don't believe for a second they would not. Looks like your hope for them refuting Hamas was futile. Also believe that the organized boiler room pro-Hamas flunkies are behind this so called pressure. Have a conceet in Israel and split the proceeds between Sderot and Gaza children.
28. Ms. Nini's letter told it like it is.
LA Jew ,   los angeles   (01.23.09)
Told the truth, all the truth, and nothing but the truth. Thank you Ms. Nini for your letter, for defending the State of Israel with your writing skill, with your pen.
29. #1. #1 They are the actors who took apart in...
Kev ,   London   (01.23.09)
...the Mohammed Al Dura movie.
30. to #19
Aviva ,   Tel Aviv   (01.23.09)
We not only already donate to causes in Sderot related to the situation but have family living in Sderot.
Next talkbacks
Back to article