Jewish Scene
Why do they hate us?
Haim Navon
Published: 30.01.09, 09:19
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
219 Talkbacks for this article
121. the the Iraqi
Asaf Golan ,   Sugar Land   (01.30.09)
You claim you hate us because we "took your land" But it was Muhammad who took the Yathrib from us Jews. Do we blow up our kids to kill your Muslims for stealing Al Madina from us? You Arabs invaded the land of Israel in 700CE when Jews were still living in Israel and occupied our sacred land. Did we murder your kin? Of course not! You Arabs have rioted in bloodlust against us in Bagdad 1950, and 1929 in Hebron and 1920 in Jerusalem. Did we murder you? My family came from Arab lands. You are just butchers. You Arabs are the Germans of the Near East.
122. why do they hate us?
steven rosenfeld ,   L.A. USA   (01.30.09)
Why do you care? I'd rather be hated and alive that loved and dead. The rest of the world loves the Jew as victim, but hates the Jew as equal. I wouldn't worry too much about what the world thinks.
123. #66 - ahmad
tsedek ,   ramat-gan, israel   (01.30.09)
the link you gave... in jenin in 2002 there were NOT 'thousands killed'. why do people keep hanging on to lies that have been disclosed so many years already?
124. Hate
Muhammet ,   Istanbul   (01.30.09)
We turks do not hate Jews apart from a a few percent little minority who hate Israel State. But if you drop bombs rather than chasing terrorists and kill civillians of course this is not acceptable.
125. They hate Israel because...
leo ,   Bklyn   (01.30.09)
...Israel does not follow the stereotype 18th and 19th century Jew that the world could push around and kill at a whim. They can't take the 'new' Jew that stands up to the oppressor and fights back. Let them hate us. This way we know who the enemy is.
126. Alexander Israel: 114
Fadi ,   USA   (01.30.09)
you are not realistic you want to kick out all the Palestinians from Israel? Thats Genocide. No matter what you claim your history books say.
127. Why do tehy hate us.
Victor Vergara ,   ConcepciĆ³n, Chile   (01.31.09)
I speak only on behalf of myself. I used to have a lot of good feelings about Israel from the very onset. I mean I thought the Jews had every right to have a home State of their own, and so on. I believed everything the western media, Hollywood included, had to say about the sorrounding arab peoples wanted to erase you from the planet and I knew nothing about any atrocities commited by the israelis against some arabs. I still know very little, but some. Then, I was shown by the same western media the infamous Sabra and Shatila mess and Ariel Sharon. It felt horrible to see jews abusing to the extent of extintion a large group or human beings with no good discerning. It felt worse to see much later Ariel Sharon becoming Israel Prime Minister. Nowadays, I'd say I'm skeptical about how to believe what reality shows. You had a real problem with Hamas sending you missiles for too long a time while you were warning them? Well, I guess you had the right to defend your people and your land. Did you have to do that with an invasion which meant killing, again, without discerning the innocent from the ones who deseved the rataliation? People in this planet, with all their hypocrisy, do hate to see images of bloody dead babies, kids, women and old people, In their eyes, maybe, you are now the bully because a long time ago you ceased to be regarded as the victims. I do not hate jews nor Israel, but I have a lot of questions in my scarcely informed mind. I hope I could help a bit to answer your terrible question. Sincerely.
128. Change lane
Oved hazadok ,   Isratine   (01.30.09)
My dear Jewish friends, You have to change lane and you will see that the world will not only stop hating you but will also love you because I am sure that the Lord gave you special gift which other peoples in the world don't have.. You have a mission and I am afraid that you are betraying it.. if really God chose you it is not to be feel that you are better than the others.. but the carry a mission of salvation not a one of injustice like you are doing now in the name of the Lord
129. It is a Battle between Light and Darkness
Brod ,   USA   (01.30.09)
It is better to be loved by the GOD of Israel than to be contaminated by the dark forces let by Satan.
130. who wasJewish?
Honest Abe   (01.31.09)
Abraham was Jewish. Jesus was Jewish. . The fact that we still have the Jewish religion as Abraham andJesusand not another ireligion drives the moslems and many christians insane! It was away for them to differentiate their religion from ours when they began their religion. Otherwise who wouldf ollow them? So they made up lies in the quran, in the vatican. They passed it on and it grew and grew, until nobody knew the real truth. The hatred grew as well. The jealousy grew,too. Hatred and jealous are the most lethal.
131. Did the Rabbi read the news last week?
redbourn ,   tel aviv   (01.30.09)
All in the last week BBC blocks program EU blames Hamas The UN blames Hamas. Egypt stops ship from Iran Foreign Minister Miguel Moratinos, "'We'll amend law to prevent such probes". Cyprus searches ship bringing arms from Iran. I was delighted with all of the above! Mike
132. #73 JEWISH WAY OF LIFE HAS NOTHING TO DO WITH WHAT U INVENT
(01.30.09)
133. Why do they hate us?
Semprof ,   Boise, Idaho, USA   (01.30.09)
Re-read Ezekiel 36-39. Even though we have caused the nations to blaspheme the holy name of the L-rd, He will vindicate his holy name at the expense of all nations when they mount a huge, world-wide jihad against us. "It is not for your sake, O Israel, but for the sake of my holy name." . . . "the nations shall know that I am the L-RD, the Holy One in Israel" (Ezek 39:7). It is because the nations hate G-d that they attack the bearers of His revelation to the world. For further development of this argument, see the monograph: J. Ruthven, The Prophecy That Is Shaping History (www.jon-ruthven.org/rosh.pdf)
134. #124
Len ,   USA   (01.30.09)
Like Tthe way the Turks deal with their friends the Kurds, Armenians and Greeks. Just let a goup of these people strke your civilians and let us see your restraint. You should only have Jews as your enemy because only Jews would show you mercy.
135. #4 The Occupation is the reason?????
Len ,   USA   (01.31.09)
Jews left Gaza--why the rockets? Gazans need to build. They are taught hate instead--that is the only occupation they are trained for. They need to be taught a real occupation---not hate, not racism and not sexism. They should be taught to create--not to destroy.
136. Why the hatred for Jewish people and Israel
Leon ,   Adelaide Australia   (01.31.09)
This hatred is absolutely tragic and wrongly placed. I like reading the Torah and the Prophets.. I think the answer is found in the Prophets, also accordingly the Prophets speak of a soon coming time when all nations will serve Israel, This may be why , perhaps. Blessed be Israel.
137. Hatred of Israel
Leif ,   Gothenburg - Sweden   (01.31.09)
This a comment from a non Jewish Swedish observer of the Israel Palestinian conflict. Let it be known that You are not hated by every one. Israel is the only democracy and the only civilized island in a sea of Barbary in the Middle East. Israel has every right to defend itself from terrorism.
138. Why Do They Hate Us?
Gary Anderson ,   Butler, Missouri USA   (01.31.09)
Dear Rabbi Novan, I would love to correspond with you on your very sincere and correct question you posed in your recent article. I for one love the Jewish nation of Israel and embrace your culture and your history. I believe the answer to your question can only come from the God of Abraham, Issac and Jacob whom your forefathers worshipped from the beginning. And from the beginning He has written the answer to your question in the Holy Scripture for all generations to see and read for themselves. Take a look and ask God if it is true as it was written so many years ago. With respect, Gary Anderson
139. Why do they hate us?
Ahron ,   Toronto, Canada   (01.31.09)
I belive that they hate Israel because it is a Jewish country and not because Israel is doing anything wrong. The world is just waiting for Israel to do somthing so they can show their hate against the jews but they will blame Israel. If any other country would do what Israel did, you would hear NOTHING!
140. WHY?
Neal ,   LA USA   (01.31.09)
Its strange and I dont think anyone will ever figure it out. Meanwhile let the world hate us and we will carry on like always. Please fellow Jews dont cry over this stupid stuff
141. #4
Knightarm ,   New York, USA   (01.31.09)
So let's see...Jews were persecuted and condemned by the Spanish in the 15th century because of the "occupation" of Palestine in the 20tth century. Two thousand years of European Christian anti-semitism also occurred because of Jewish "occupation" of Palestine in the 20th century. Hundreds of years of Eastern European persecution of Jews also occurred because of the aforementioned "occupation". Organizations in the US such as KKK are anti-semitic because of the same "occupation". Relegation of Jews to second class citizenship in the Middle East for centuried occurred because of the same "occupation". Now I've got it. You're right. Anti-semitism throughout the ages occurred because of "occupation" of Palestine (you probably mean "occupation" since 1948 don't you?). Here is something for you and your Palestinian friends to remember: "NEVER AGAIN!!!". "NEVER EVER AGAIN!!!". Good luck to all you Palestinians in whatever Arab country you end up.
142. Why they hate us - no big mystery there
Ofir Paz ,   Lampedusa, Italy   (01.31.09)
1) Deep inside all men fear G_d's judgment which is going to come on them, and they associate us Jews with G_d. 2) Jews represent a moral condemnation of all men, not because we are better but because we were created as examples. 3) The Satan especially hates Jews and whispers slanders about them into mens' minds, because the existence of Jews to the present day is a proof that the G_d of the Scriptures is true to His word.
143. 135 complaints and whines and no insight what so ever!
Edithann ,   USA   (01.31.09)
3000 years you've been doing same thing with the same attitude of contempt for 'others'.!.. You're lied to yourselves until you don't know what the truth is anymore , and this forum proves that point... Had the world wanted to be rid of Jews, they'd have done it two thousands of years ago..but they let you move on..does that even tell you reprobates anything at all? Now why should the Palestinians turn their homes and lands over to Jews without a damn good fight? TATA
144. The Jewish People
Kevin McAllen ,   Chicago,IL   (01.31.09)
As a proud Irish Catholic, God bless the Jews, the toughest, most resilient, moral, successful and generous people the world has ever produced. Is it simple jealousy? I'm proud to count several Jews among my friends and closest friends.
145. #21 Amr
shmulke ,   w coast, USA   (01.31.09)
You MORON, there IS NO "greater Israel"! If Israel craves all the land from the Nile to the Euphrates as the hate-crazed imams will tell you, why did they return the Sinai Peninsula (an area many times larger than its present boundaries) to Egypt?? Answer: because Israel craves peace and will do what it takes to achieve it. Only problem is, rabid Islamists' idea of peace is the destruction of Israel and world domination of Islam, which is unacceptable to Israelis. Despite their slogans and their frothing at the mouth, the Islamists have not been able to make the mideast Jew-free though they've been trying for hundreds of years, and they're not going to succeed now. Israel will defend itself by whatever means it deems necessary.
146. Why they hate you?
Abe ,   Detroit, USA   (01.31.09)
They hate you because you are a master of deception and injustice, they hate you because you are getting even with the wrong people, they hate you because you show no mercy in killing children that you have the nerve to call them terrorists, deep down you know why they hate you. you have to worru about what the future will state about the state of Israel in the history books.
147. # 4 Because of Jealousy
Maria ,   MD   (01.31.09)
Have you read Hamas Charter? It mentioned about the Jews all over the world control finances,media,etc.The Jews used to live in ghettos in Europe centuries ago or thousand years ago,they were hated every where they went,they went on with their lives.They were not taught to hate,but to love other people.But now,they're the most successful people in the world.They contribute a lot to our civilization more than anybody else.They're hated also because they're Chosen or Special people,the apple of God's eye.
148. #9 Charles...that's true also.
Maria ,   MD   (01.31.09)
I'm Asian,I have a Filipino friend who asked me why did God choose Jews to be His chosen people.You know what she said, it's unfair. I think the rest of the world think the same way also.The Arab world has started boycotting Israel's products.I didn't even know that Disney is owned by a Jew.Most well-known Hollywood celebrities [past and present]were/are Jews including Howard Morris[Earnest T. Bass].Frank Oz[Miss Piggy].That's why the world hates Jews and love the Palestininians[that's their excuse to hate you].Because Israel killed a lot of innocent Palestinians[really?] The Arab world has fooled a lot of people for using propaganda[Palestinians].
149. These people who hate Jews were not taught right
Maria ,   MD   (01.31.09)
when they're young. My daughter has a friend,she told my daughter that Christians were chosen one and not the Jews.My 13 year old daughter rebuked her for saying that.Some children her age never heard of the Holocaust or Anne Frank.We showed her the Holocaust Museum in DC and VA, she needs to learn all about this while she's young. I told her not to hate Muslims either.
150. The world hate you; loves the Palestinians
Maria ,   MD   (01.31.09)
You're on the right track! God is on your side.I'd rather be hated by the world rather than be hated by God.Long live Israel!!!!!!
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article