News
Report: Gaza detainees held bound for days
Aviad Glickman
Published: 28.01.09, 13:57
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
66 Talkbacks for this article
1. So Called Human Rights
Warren ,   Israel   (01.28.09)
How does this compare to Hamas treatment of our prisoners. Or even how they treat their own Fatah prisoners, with shaving beards in mild cases. Stripping off clothes and beatings for average cases. And shooting out kneecaps or executions by firing squad in many cases. And they have the audacity to complain about the lesser evil. The have lost their direction, they know they cant sort out their own shit, so they try and make up for it by criticising Israel. All palestinians have it in themselves to behave and Love and live in Peace, so why dont they. Instead they are always looking for someone to blame!
2. Give me a break
Ari ,   Israel   (01.28.09)
Give me a break - this is war. Think of Gilad Shalit, been captive for more than two years and held in worse conditions with no Red Cross access. What a joke of an article.
3. Ask to Shalit if you can rightist are racist indeed
Daniel ,   Amsterdam   (01.28.09)
4. Id rather be a prisoner of Israel than of Hamas.More Garbage
Alan ,   SA   (01.28.09)
5. What? No tea & cookies?
Terry ,   Eilat, Israel   (01.28.09)
I am really shocked! Not even some flowers to brighten up the atmosphere? What's the world coming to when you have to fight a war under such conditions? This constant barrage of propaganda is getting really, really tiresome, don't you think? Isn't it enough we are demonized in all the foreign media, do we have to be subjected to this crap every day in our own media? We all know war sucks. That is the nature of war. Had the residents of Gaza wanted better, they would not have elected Hamas nor continued to support them. In this kind of war where the enemy hides among civilians, when combattants don't wear uniforms, where even women & children can be used as suicide bombers, where civilian houses are rigged with explosives, & the best of all, where the enemy deliberately creates false & misleading ''reports'' for propaganda purposes, why this uncritical reporting & reliance on hostile anti-Israel NGO's that only exist to undermine us? These people have been proven to be liars over & over again. Even if reports are true, that is what war is. Have there ever been any wars anywhere in the world any different? You know, enough is enough with this constant barrage of propaganda. You in the media should try & figure out whose side your on - and if it's NOT our side, you should think of re-locating. You think our self-defense is inhumane? Well, if we ever lose a war & are invaded, you will fast understand what that word really means.
6. Hamas will only grow stronger
fadi ,   lebanon   (01.28.09)
1. now they have the support of 90% of the palestenians 2. The arab and islamic world is all behind Hamas 3. the image of israel was further tarnished and exposed in the world as children and women killers 4. The IDF moron generals now can not fly outside israel 5. The destruction of Gaza will lead to flow of 2 billion dollars of "reconstruction aid" . part of it will be used to purchase of better weapons for round 2 of the war. 6. the israeli front is much more exposed now and all population within a range of 40 km are under the mercy of hamas " missiles of terror" to the hearts of the israeli settlers. should i go further more with this analysis :)
7. Human Rights Groups
Dr John ,   Rechovot Israel   (01.28.09)
These sanctamonious, self righteous idiots make me sick to my stomach. Where have they been for the last 2+ years? Have they ever said a word about the treatment & mental torture of one Gilad Shalit!! & his family. No Sir, but to them he is not as important as those Hamas thugs who were released almost immedietly & do not seem to any the worse for wear. Anything they can do to harm Israel & it's people they do with pleasure! Shame on them!!
8. yeah, what about Shalit?
eliezer ,   jerusalem   (01.28.09)
oh my gosh, we tied up their hands for a few days. nothing like our boys in their hands. did they go back in a casket? tell us how you treat shalit?
9. So how did Samir Kuntar get a college degree?
Another BS story!   (01.28.09)
10. Is Gilad Shalit in the Hilton hotel? Where is Ron Arad?
Has anyone seen him?   (01.28.09)
11. they donn't have rights of POW because they r civilians?
observer   (01.28.09)
some of them were being held near tanks and in war zones
12. Why is Shalit not seen by red cross?
I. Barr ,   USA   (01.28.09)
The audacity of "Rights" groups to file complaints against IDF while ignoring the plight of the Israeli POW is reflection of double standards. These rights groups know that they cannot file complaints against Hamas. If they even think about doing so Haniye will die laughing. Where are the human rights people with the Hamas human shields, using schools, residential areas to launch attacks? These rights groups did not demonstrate against Sudan where 1000-5000 are killed daily in Darfur. Moral decadence seems to be a problem that Israel will have to deal with.
13. When these so called 'human rights' groups
Arie ,   BaGolan   (01.28.09)
seek any access to Gilad Shalit to see how he is doing, perhaps then they will gain some credibility. Until then, the hell with them. And shame on Ynet for even printing this article
14. fadi - you analysis by the numbers
Arie ,   BaGolan   (01.28.09)
1. 90%? According to hezbullah and hamass. Seem the writers that interview palis privately (since they will be executed as collaborators otherwise) want peace with us and an end to hamasstan 2. the islamonazi world has always wanted our extermination. that is why you fought with hitler 3. the "tarnished" image changes as the truth of hamass murders and its leadership still in roach holes shows up 4.gnerals cannot fly out of Israel.:At least they are not in hiding.nazirallah and haniyeh are afraid to exit their roach holes knowing a missile with their names on it are waiting 5. I'm glad the islamonazis ADMIT the "humanitarian aid" is actually used for weapons 6.Do you really think the new government will be as restrained asour current appeasement government? should I go further with the analysis? ;-}~
15. Did they kneecap you?
meir elazar   (01.28.09)
16. rights
Ilana   (01.28.09)
As much as we hate the terrorists POWs must receive correct treatment according to our laws as well as intl ones. Especially if thisis prior to investigation. I think we should be above such treatment. And of course, anyone would rather be a POW in Israel than anywhere else!!
17. Why print this in our Papers.
Moshe ,   Israel   (01.28.09)
MOST that is written is not true! This article only gives Israel a bad name.
18. YES! YES! THEY KEEP US BOUND!
oi givalt   (01.28.09)
DAYS AND DAYS THEY KEEP US BOUND! OUR WOMEN AND CHILDREN! THEY KILL OUR WOMEN AND CHILDREN! They just don't give up do they? Trying a new angle I see...
19. Human rights groups. I wish
Sagi ,   Israel   (01.28.09)
they would print what I think of you, but they won't.
20. "held inside holes in the ground "
Talula ,   Israel   (01.28.09)
They have GOT to be kidding?!?!?!?! These animals are used to living in holes in the ground. They spend their lives digging holes and then hiding in them when the IDF comes knocking - so they should have felt at home. These men are liars and they cannot be trusted. I shudder to think what would have happened if it was OUR soldiers they captured. They need to thank Allah they got it so good. Filth!
21. international humanitarian law??
Talula seeing red ,   Israel   (01.28.09)
How DARE they!!!!! These men were firing from schools and civilian roof tops!!! But because THEY were captured, they want their human rights and all of a sudden international humanitarian law means something. Pity it meant squat while they were violating every single clause. They should have been shot and not captured.
22. #6 FADI - LEBANON
Talula ,   Israel   (01.28.09)
1. 90% of the Palestinians? The starving, sick and rock bottom Palestinians? Yep! that should help them. Hamas abused them, so don't count on the Palestinians for help. 2. ONLY the Islamic world is behind them. Everyone else HATES them. 3. Meanwhile, no one said stop bombing. They sat back with popcorn and enjoyed the show 4. Boo Hooo!!! We have nice beaches here. And you are wrong, they CAN travel. Who knows, they may bump into Fatso Nasrallah at Frankfurt airport LOL!!! Talk about can’t travel? At least our generals don’t live in fear of their lives in underground caves. 5. Gaza is going to look like this for the next hundred million years - no-one is going to rebuild it - and you know it. 6. We have nukes. You stopped in the right place with your pathetic analysis. What you've written is stupid ridiculous and you are clutching at straws. Get a life.
23. "human rights" WHAT A JOKE
adi   (01.28.09)
TO THE SO CALLED HUMAN RIGHTS,, PLS GO AND INQUIRE ABOUT GILAD SHALIT IF YOU HAVE GUTS.. AND EVERYTHING IS VALID IN WAR.. EVEN WE ARE TORTURED, EVEN WE FEEL THE PAIN, EVEN WE ARE HUMANS.. SO PLEASE,,,,,
24. The real option
Alin ,   Bucharest,Romania   (01.28.09)
Israel is in a state of war. Technically speaking, those acting against Israel are traitors. And traitors should be executed due to the state of war. On sight. Military rules applies to the case.Long live Israel!
25. HAMAS EXECUTED FATAH PRO ACTIVISTS
(01.28.09)
26. SHALIT HAS NEVER SEEN HUMAN RIGHTS ORGANIZATIONS
(01.28.09)
27. BOOHOO WAHAA !!!
DAVID ,   JUDEA   (01.28.09)
They are right they should have let them kill our soldiers and shoot more rockets at our civilians. This was totally unfair they should have been put up in the Tel Aviv hilton with easy acces to the dolphinarium. Whta were they thinking we are not enemies with our Pallies., what a relieve to have such moral elevated souls among us.
28. Fadi
Yaron ,   USA   (01.28.09)
Your analysis is ridiculous and not believeable....let's examine; 1. now they have the support of 90% of the palestenians -WHICH CONTINUES TO PROVE THAT THE PALS ARE A BLOODTHIRSTY GANG WITH NO CONNECTION TO ONE ANOTHER OTHER THAN ARAB. 2. The arab and islamic world is all behind Hamas - WHAT HAS THE WHOLE ARAB WORLD EVER DONE FOR THE PALS....THAT ONE MADE ME LAUGH 3. the image of israel was further tarnished and exposed in the world as children and women killers - WORNG AGAIN. HAMAS HAVE BEEN EXPOSED AS A DANGEROUS REGIME THAT CAN AND WILL NOT BE ALLOWED TO RE-ARM DUE TO THE DESTRUCTION THEY INVITED ON THE INHABITANTS OF GAZA. CLEAR CONSCIOUS PEOPLE UNDERSTAND THAT EQUATION. 4. The IDF moron generals now can not fly outside israel - NEVER HAVE BEEN BUT THEN AGAIN HONOR IS WORTH MORE THAN ANY TRIP TO LONDON OR PARIS. 5. The destruction of Gaza will lead to flow of 2 billion dollars of "reconstruction aid" . part of it will be used to purchase of better weapons for round 2 of the war. - AND THAT WILL RAISE THE LEVEL OF DESTRUCTION THAT IT BRINGS WITH IT ON THE INHABITANTS OF GAZA...AGAIN 6. the israeli front is much more exposed now and all population within a range of 40 km are under the mercy of hamas " missiles of terror" to the hearts of the israeli settlers. - WHICH IS WHY THE ISRAELIS ARE JUSTIFIED IN THEIR RETALIATION WHEN WOMEN AND CHILDREN ARE UNFORTUNATELY HARMED AND KILLED. The mentality seems to be going no-where....don't you think? Interestingly, Hizbullah have been pretty quiet since the war they "won". How does S Lebanon look to you? Was it worth the "grand victory"? When will the Arab world contribute back to civilization again.....other than violence and hatred that is.
29. ask shalit when he is released, how was the treatment, you w
mohannad   (01.28.09)
will be surprised
30. #6 Was that an "analysis"? More like a load of crap.
Australian Guy   (01.28.09)
Next talkbacks
Back to article