News
Doctor who lost daughters in Gaza war: We were created to live together
The Media Line
Published: 19.02.09, 14:13
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
42 Talkbacks for this article
1. He Was Warned To Get His Family Out Of The House!!
Adina Kutnicki ,   Israel, new olah   (02.19.09)
What other nation WARNS an enemy population to leave before a strike, regardless of him being a doctor in Israel? The fact that he was even allowed to practice in Israel is lost on the bleeding left and their Israel haters.
2. How about the ammunition found hidden in his home?
m   (02.19.09)
3. Doctors lie. FACT!
israel   (02.19.09)
4. Why is he working in Israel?
Judah ,   Golan Heights,ISRAEL   (02.19.09)
I am sorry for his loss and he probally is an excellent Doctor yet why is he allowed to work in Israel and bring his family to live here? He does not qualify for the right of return unless he has Jewish parents or grandparents.
5. My Comment...
Jerusalem - ISRAEL   (02.19.09)
The tragedy that befell this Palestinian medical doctor is a personal,individual case only.I simply wish some media organization provides countless Palestinians with the opportunity to speak out and air their grievances. Personally I have realized that so many circles have blocked my way to stifle me that I ultimately had no choice but air my grievances with a flavor of bitter grudges,pitch-dark hatred,and poisonous rancor. Nothing is worse for the human being than losing all hope because in such a case life becomes meaningless and worthless and suicidal death among others becomes extremely valuable. If I don't fuss or make a big row about my own grievances nobody would bother to think of me.People would simply think " he is silent...it seems everything is fine with him " !
6. You are an inspiration
Zoe ,   Israel   (02.19.09)
I SO want to believe there are more like him, because we need people like this to have some hope.
7. Dr. Abu Something is a member of Hamas
Genuine Tosefta ,   Tveria   (02.19.09)
He is using his Nom De Guerre in this interview which is typical of membership in Hamas, Fatah, Al Qaida, Hizbullah and other Terror Arb Mafia Gangs
8. ONE DAY ! ISRAEL AND ITS SUPPORTERS WILL PAY BACK.
ATİLLA KARAGÖZOĞLU   (02.19.09)
9. " I fully believe in the benefits that come from education"
Sagi ,   Israel   (02.19.09)
Educate to love and not to hate. Educate to preserve not to destroy. Educate to live not to die. Educate to let live not to kill. Educate to educate not read Koran. Love others as you love yourself is the highest education to which man can aspire. Hating others and wishing them dead is the lowest of valleys to which man can descend. Only when the Palestinians decide it is time to leave the depths of that valley, where the air is putrid, and decide to ascend the mountain of humanity, will they breath the clean and fresh air of enlightenment. They will find it so precious that they will never again want to be back in the Stygian depths of that foul valley of death. Yes,education brings enlightenment and with enlightenment man is like a bird on the wing soaring to unimaginable heights.
10. #1 Adina
Marco ,   Spain   (02.19.09)
How do you know that he was warned to leave his house? Were you there? Did you deliver the warning? Stop your propaganda and your lies. The man himslef is denying that he was warned in very clear unequivical terms. He is even challlenging the press to investigate this point. Admit the fact that your leaders will amount to nothing more than war criminals who are good at nothing more than killing babies.
11. Talkbacks
surprised american ,   Bethesda, MD   (02.19.09)
Wow--what people you are. You still trash the doctor after killing his 3 daughters. Back in the day, I used to feel much sympathy for the Israelis and was proud to help. Now I think you might as well have the same doctrine as Hamas. You are no different from them, judging from these talkbacks. Congrats on being proud of yourselves for creating 2 more generations of terrorists. It amazes me of how proud you are of killing people and creating more hatred--at least you and the Palestinians are truly on the same mentality level now. And the nasty talkbacks to follow only prove my point more. You are all one in the same. Please give back my taxpayer money and fight amongst yourselves to the bitter end--just leave the rest of the world and our money out of it.
12. Regarding # 5
Abdel Karim Salim ,   Jerusalem - ISRAEL   (02.19.09)
I wrote comment number 5. Normally I boldly write down my name in full, and this time I simply forgot to fill out the name space before I submitted my comment... Abdel Karim Salim Sharif stalingrad_43@yahoo.com Jerusalem - ISRAEL
13. #1 adina
atmleb ,   Ottawa   (02.19.09)
warning someone does not relieve Israel from the responsibility of its soldier's action. and secondly civilians had nowhere because all the borders were closed.
14. marco
bentzy ,   canada   (02.19.09)
you ask why we should trust the idf that the doctor was warned and also had arms stockpiled in his home, and you call it propaganda. let me ask you, why should we trust the doctor who obviously has nothing to lose and everything to gain - including media attention - by lying. at least the idf has its credibility to lose. while these palis have time and time again turned out to be liars (see jenin massacre), and fools such as yourself believe them for no other reason then that its fun to blame the jews, while the idf usually turns out right (see u.n. school). i must say though i had a hearty laugh from the irony ,reading how you call israeli leaders war criminals when i see after your name that your from Spain a country which tortured Jews for hundreds of years. at least we know a anti semite never changes
15. to suprised american
bentzy ,   canada   (02.19.09)
i also am a american (dual citisen) but unlike you i have spent considerable time in israel. while i understand your concern , you must relise that the story you are hearing is almost always a twisted one. let me paint you a diffrent picture, after israel left gaza instead of palestinians trying to create a normal democracy, they elected terrorists (hamas) as their goverment who started fyring rockets into israels southern citisens for no other reason but to terrify isrealis. so Israel after trying and being snubbed in diplomacy, did as any sane country would do including the USA and attacked the terrorist group while trying its hardest not to kill civilians . this doctor was warned numerous times (i explain in my previous post why i trust the idf more than the doctor) but didn't listen and though its sad, its hardly fair to blame israel and its leaders for his stupidity.
16. #11 Surprised American
Ofer ,   Kfar Saba   (02.19.09)
Most of the talkbacks here and other Israeli online newspaper sites are of the most extreme nature whether pro or anti Israel. They are not representative of Israeli society at all and for that matter often originate out of the country just like your talkback. Now you (in branding all Israelis as no different than Hamas based on what you read here) have proven yourself just as hateful as the other talkbackers and equally as ignorant as some of them.
17. What's up Doc? U're a Hamas collaborator n informer
Zohan ,   Tel Aviv   (02.19.09)
18. Marco is lying as well
Ben ,   London, UK   (02.19.09)
Adina may be wrong. At least I also want to believe the Doctor. I am sure that no army is perfect and that include the Israeli or the Spanish armies. However, your comments about the Israeli leaders being baby killers are despicable. No Israeli leaders has plans to kill civilians. On the other hand, every major Palestinian organizations has plans regarding killing Israeli civilians. Fatah, Hamas, Islamic Djihad, FPLP, ... all carried missions to purposely kill civilians in Israel and abroad. Palestinians have killed enough non Israelis. They have killed enough Jews around the world (babies or not babies). Whether you have the honesty to admit it or not, Israel is a democracy and act as one. Hamas hides among the population of Gaza. I don't blame them maybe I would as well if someone is determined to get me. But Hamas instead of just hiding, it attacks Israeli soldiers from civilian location hoping that the fire hits the civilians so that idiots like you (with either subjective minds or with total incapacity of understandings) may start pointing the finger at Israel. And again this is not based on Zionist propaganda, it is based on countless Palestinian accounts. You are an absolute waste of time to all of us who wish peace in that region. Keep up the good work you for sure have been a great deal of help. Get lost loser.
19. #11
Logic ,   Israeli   (02.19.09)
Last time I checked, seven talkbacks on a non-Hebrew news site is not enough to represent the opinions of an entire nation.
20. Sorrow, Sin, & Salvation
Volubrjotr ,   St Paul USA   (02.19.09)
It breaks my heart to see such sorrow and I pray his family is now in Heaven. That said, we are made to live together and the world is not ideologic. It is ideologic to think a bomb is perfectly discriminative, it is ideologic to think that the nation protecting itself from evil can itself be perfect in all things...only God is perfect. Again, this man truly wanted to be a bridge to healing, yet sin must be confronted, it is one's duty as well. My deepest sympathy to everyone involved.
21. #14 bentzy, canada
Marco ,   Spain   (02.19.09)
The problem wth you people, is that your lies intertwine so much with your propaganda that you tend to loose track of where facts end and fiction begins. If this doctor had stock piles of weapons in his house, why has he not been arrested by the IDF until now? Spare me your B.S about this doctor seeking publicity. I am sure he would rather have his daughters alive, dont you think? Judging by the talk backs I have read so far, I believe that Israel has lost its moral sense. You have become a nation with no conscience. Shame on you.
22. Hey marco, keep your big mouth shut
Zohan ,   Tel Aviv   (02.19.09)
23. compassion
Ilana   (02.19.09)
How is it that so many Israeli feel compassion for the innocent victims in Gaza, including myself, even though I fully understand the whole and not half of the story, while none of the Gazans or their supporters feel any compassion for the innocent victims in Israel?? All Jewish Israelis deserve to die? They are all so guilty that death is their punishment? Not one foreign tb or arab has said they are so sad about Israeli victims of terror and missiles. And: I am curious, why would some of you repeatedly read this news in Israel and repeatedly write tbs against Israel? I mean, I don;t even know about an Arab online news or a spain one and if I did, I cannot imagine myself constantly insulted them with accusations, cruel words and lackof knowledge blatantly thrown at them to incite anger and frustration. Why the hang up with this tiny country? Whynot with Tibet? Why not with Sudan? Why not Myanamar? It goes on and on. Do you guys write tbs on Tibet issues? Really a phenomenon!
24. #2, how about the ammunition found in your brain?
GUH   (02.19.09)
25. #22 Zohan
Marco ,   Spain   (02.19.09)
Keep my mouth shut????? Why Zohan, cant you handle the truth?
26. We don't give a monkey what you say, that's the truth
Zohan ,   Tel Aviv   (02.19.09)
27. Doctor, your story is sad - war makes many innocent victims
Avi ,   Geneva   (02.19.09)
Sincere condolences for your daughters. Sincerely. But Israel was pushed to the wall by Hamas (or Palestinian) violence. They were (and still are) spoiling for a fight. Blame them 100% for the collateral damage.
28. Shame
berlonski ,   berlin   (02.19.09)
That an interview like that provokes such a cynical, hateful discussion like the one in these talkbacks here, is a shame.
29. #24, what a comeback
Danny   (02.19.09)
I assume you are in primary school. you going call his momma fat too?
30. Ynet, what's wrong with you?
YOEL   (02.19.09)
Even our next PM Netanyahu never had such a long tribune. Even Rabin Za"l didn't get such place for pleading. I don't mind of this doctor, I give priority to my family in the South who were under Grads' threat, and all those soldiers who risked their lives for our safety.
Next talkbacks
Back to article