News
Holy Land Christians urge pope to call off visit
Associated Press
Published: 22.02.09, 21:30
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
86 Talkbacks for this article
61. #44 Palestinian Christians and Israel
Palestinian   (02.23.09)
I'll tell who mistreated us: Israeli governments for decades. Why don't you just google BEIT SAHOUR for a start, you will see who were oppressing and mistreating us for decades, it was Israeli government and Rabin who used force against non-violent Christians. Then check out how much land of ours are taken by Israel under the mask of security fence. Israeli governments give us occupation, oppression, steal our lands, ban us from visiting our holy places Jerusalem and Nazareth, kill and jail us. Stop trying to whitewash Israel's wrongdoings by blaiming Muslims, all Palestinians suffer from Israeli oppressive policies. Your lies and low style are only a reflection of how corrupt Israel has become because of occupation.
62. #42
Palestinian   (02.23.09)
You should go back and read my post, you will see how respectfully I talk. Then read your post, you will see how hostile and disrespectful you become in your post. Thanks for displaying your discriminative attitude in your posts, so people can see that clearly. Before knowing anything about Palestinian Christians, you keep judging us and using abusive language in a hostile way. None of these are Christian values.
63.  Plaszow
Galut ,   Selah   (02.23.09)
Sarah I now understand your bitterness .... though I see it as a poision that harms the one holding it more than it harms the object of the bitterness.... loosing a large portion of ones family to a Evil political system is not something that can be treated lightly. the society that spawned that system must come to terms with how it enabled it to come into being. each societal organization religious and secular must examin its role in that enablement and work toward not allowing it to happen again. The catholic church which found itself in a landlocked position ,I suspect felt quite threaten with a potential take over of the vatican by the nazis. thus probably thought it necesary to do a delicate tap dance diplomaticly.... Not a good thing if you want to uphold a high moral standard.... Pope John paul essentualy recognized this.... I expect indivdual priest and bishops may or maynot have sucumbed to the vaticans policy...as in your case the preist for whatever reason betrayed your families trust ....(they will have to account for thier actions before the Lord .... and so will the pope that was over them...) not all catholics turn a blind eye to the jewish perscution infact there were thousands of catholics that died at Plaszow alongside the jews monument at Plaszow http://www.scrapbookpages.com/poland/Plaszow/Plaszow06.html ============================================== THE RIGHTEOUS GENTILES http://southerninstitute.info/holocaust_education/slguide.html ============================= 1944, a 24-year-old Catholic farmer is arrested for being a member of the Polish resistance http://www.ilab.org/db/book1502_40165-001.html ======================== I my self am not catholic ....but Protestant with a baptist /methodist background Though my last name betrays a possible Jewish heiritage ( Galut ia ) so maybe in one of those persequtions you site ...one of my family members may have converted to being a protestant - my family came to america in the mid 1600s Form the Is of Jersey of the french coast.... He was a Huguenot.... My Prayers are for you.... And I pray your bitterness turns into understanding and love.
64. Hmmm. Sarah blames perpetrators. Charles blames G-d
(02.23.09)
65. Hate between christians and jews.
sanna ,   sweden   (02.23.09)
I can only speak from my point of wiew, but if christians started to read the bible for them selves, they (we) would see that we are obligated to bless Israel and Gods chosen people. There wouldn´t have been any massacre on the jews if we just followed Gods word, but we have through the history been jealous on the jews and made our own traditions mixed with paganism and you can´t serve two Gods. We christians have a lot to ask for forgivnes for, to the jews.
66. stupid suggestion
jerusalem   (02.23.09)
pope should come. hope he doesnt listen to foolish call and pass up the opportunity.
67. Palestinian Christians #23, 32, 61, etc.
Tahl ,   Ashdod, Israel   (02.23.09)
It boggles my mind how quickly and instinctively you blame Israel for all your hardships, yet completely condone the suffering you get from you Muslim "brothers". In all your posts, I've seen plenty of whining against Israel, yet not one word about the siege of the Nativity church by Palestinian Muslims, just a fews years ago - where they savegely murdered Christians believers. I also haven't read a single word about what Hizbollah has been doing to Christians in Lebanon - which is a thousand-fold worse than what Israel has ever done to you. I suggest you'd google Brigitte Gabrielle to learn more about who's on your good side and who's on your bad side. But deep down, I believe you actually KNOW you're better off living with Jews than with Muslims. Not that you'd admit it though.
68. To: Charles
Sarah ,   New York City, USA   (02.23.09)
Pope John XXIII started the CANONIZATION process for Pius XII. The current pope started the BEATIFICATION process for Pius XII. I do believe I referenced only BEATIFICATION in my post, did I not? (I'll save you the trouble of re-reading it: I did.) Care to apologize for accusing me of error? Of course you won't ....
69. Sarah , AGAIN WRONG , you ! apologise !
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (02.23.09)
The beatification of a person is the THIRD stage before the final one , canonisation . The beatification process of pius XII was begon by Paul Vi . Jews feared the the current pope would accelerate the canonisation of pius XII . [ wikipedia as main source others tell the same ] canonisation is the LAST stage , not done yet for pius XII And this was not your first error . SO WHO IS WRONG ? YOU !!! but you have an excuse , you are not smart . You showed your true face : a vulgar person behind a nice mask .
70. Sarah , had you written canonisation
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (02.23.09)
of pius XII by the current pope there woul'nt be any error . But as you wrote beatification , you were wrong . Will you apologise for your INSULTS ?
71. Sarah , another source tell's me YOU must apologise
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (02.23.09)
this writes : the cause for beatification of pope pius XII opened in october 1967 . one -nine-six-seven , around a 40 years before the current pope was named . I have learned something . the beatification precedes the canonisation .
72. To: Charles
Sarah ,   New York City, USA   (02.23.09)
Canonization Veneration Beatification Sainthood
73. #65 Sanna
USABorn   (02.23.09)
With all due respect, why would any Christaian need foregiveness from the Jews. I do not hate the Jews or the Arabs, but the Bible says that God will act on Israels' behalf, not because they deserve it, but so that they will know he is God. Ezekiel 22 talks about the Regathering of the Jews. Ezk 22, 32 says: It is not for your sake I will act, says the Lord God; let that be known to you. Be ashamed and confounded for your ways, O house of Israel. I know the Jewish people of the past brought us the scriptures, and for that I am grateful, but many have also denied Christ. While God will act on Israels' behalf, it is not because they are better or more Godly than anyone else, it is so they will know he is God.
74. Canonization Veneration eatification Sainthood to me is....
Galut ,   Selah   (02.23.09)
mans attemp at speculating where someone we hold in high esteem will be in the eyes of God.... I would sugest that those that follow this type of process will have a rude awakening... as God who Knows every speck and event in our lives will be the real judge ...those who we may think of as first may be last in the kingdom and visa versa... our petty attempt to elevate someone to sainthood maybe burnt as straw before our eyes.... and that is not saying that some may not deserve sainthood ... but from what I see in scripture that is in G-ds hands.....the important thing for us christians and Jews is to be about G-ds business of making sure peoples spiriual and Physical needs are taken care of... those that don't will face some hard questions when they stand before thier lord.
75. Sarah , ALWAYS WRONG
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (02.23.09)
www.catholic-pages.com/saints/explained.asp DO some research if you , a not smart person , as you said , can . You are not only WRONG but stupid by NOT accepting it .
76. To: Charles at No. 75
Sarah ,   New York City, USA   (02.23.09)
Charles -- I have a confession to make. When I said I was not smart, I lied. I am very, very smart (so much for false modesty). It will be a cold, snowy day in August before I look at the website you provided, but thanks for the link, anyway.
77. Crazy weather
Galut ,   Selah   (02.23.09)
careful Sarah with crazy weather patterns we are having ...we may have that cold snowy day in august...
78. To: Galut at No. 77
Sarah ,   New York City, USA   (02.23.09)
You're right .... perhaps I should have said "cold, snowy day in August in Riyadh ...." @--->---->--
79. To: Charles at No. 70
Sarah ,   New York City, USA   (02.24.09)
I don't know how I missed this one. I have one small question: do you know what it means to separate the wheat from the chaff?
80. Sarah NYC and Charles
Mark ,   Lodz, Poland   (02.24.09)
Sarah, It's really sad what happened to your family and I can understand you much better now for sharing that. I spend a lot of time reading articles and TBs here on YNET . I like Raymond in DC, Terry in Eilat, Gideon Reader, Andy in Ramat Hasharon, Lawrence in Safed, Arie BaGolan, Robert Bernier and other posters including Charles in PetachTikva who, dare I say, is NOT your enemy
81. Sarah , I'm SURE
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (02.24.09)
That this day in August , you had it some hours ago . But you can't accept it . Better don't write anymore , so you won't write stupidities , errors [ unvoluntarely or not ] This was NOT your only error , you made more . You know : on enleve la peinture , et la salete apparait . You take off the mask , and the ugly face appears . Not better as MY ISRAEL"s worst enemies , they throw stone , you venom . A last point . I did'nt need a Israeli woman to live here .
82. sarah , from now on , i will
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (02.24.09)
tell those who insult people : don't be so vulgar as this woman called sarah .
83. Just visit Palestine
Syd Walker ,   Queensland, Australi   (02.25.09)
The Pope should visit Palestine, where he is welcome, instead of Israel, where he is not.
84. The Question is
Shimon   (02.25.09)
Why would Israel allow any pope to visit Israel after all they have repeatedly refused to return the holy artifacts from the sacking of the temple as depicted in the arch of Titus and this particular pope given the fact he was in charge of the modern version of the spanish inqusition should have known better then to reistate a reknowned holacaust denier. Where is Israel's intestinal fortitude or backbone or are they now a feel good society that lets anyone wipe their feet on them because they might hurt public opinion....I got news for you they dont like us anyway so why try....Really it is rediculous....
85. Nice try Sarah.
Bob ,   NYC, USA   (02.27.09)
An ad hominem attack is what I expect from you. You know I'm right. You can sense, it can't you. You almost lost in 1973 if it weren't for US aid. Now that aid may dry up. Good luck fighting 1 billion Muslims. Not to mention the influx of Muslim and Hispanic Catholics in the US. We'll soon see who "runs the show".
86. One law for everyone - you shall not favor
Josh   (03.07.09)
Christianity is not founded on fullfullment of a single messiah prophecy. That makes it fraud. So the Rabbinical and the secular government should treat all vistors alike. People involved in illegal activity such as fraud or menatlly unstable as to protect peodophiles, should not be allowed to visit.
Previous talkbacks
Back to article