Jewish Scene
Vatican finds Holocaust-denying bishop's apology lacking
Associated Press
Published: 27.02.09, 16:59
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
25 Talkbacks for this article
1. OH PLEASE SPARE US
Arie ,   BaGolan   (02.27.09)
His 'apology' was hand-written for him by the vatican. Looks like it was a trial balloon on their part to have us forget their insipid anti-Jew theology. They see that we saw through the veil of hatred and will now try a new comment. Please stand by:the vatican media office is preparing a new comment
2. sounds like a palestinian apology
mike ,   israel (formerly usa   (02.27.09)
you know, "we're sorry because of the problems it has caused for us", ie a non-apology. he's not sorry. but he is a sorry excuse for a religious man.
3. What should be done to this disgusting man...
David Hersch ,   Cape Town, S Africa   (02.27.09)
Politely, it would be phrased as castrating him. In normal English, cut his b....s off. He doesn't need them anyway and he is a disgrace!
4. just the facts, ma'am..
tom ,   toronto, canada   (02.27.09)
1) his "ordination" was done without the consent of the vatican, so why is the vatican even considering "his return to episcopal functions"? he was never legitimately a bishop, excommunicated or otherwise. logically, it would seem that he needs the church more than the church needs him, so what's really going on? 2) it is clear that his "apology" is not a recantation of his holocaust denial. in fact, it is anything but. 3) it is doubtful that germany really wants to prosecute him, but a warrant for his arrest would bar him from entering the eu, and possibly prevent further mischief. good. unfortunately, britain has yet to show any such inclination toward moral conviction 4) jewish groups using words like "penance" sound strange and foolish. it is sufficient to call him what he is, a fool and a nazi apologist, and ask the vatican to demonstrate their good faith by distancing themselves from his opinions.
5. Time To Stop Bashing The Bishop
Lawrence ,   Safed Israel   (02.27.09)
Let him sink into well-deserved oblivion/anonymity.
6. What difference does it make?
NYC Girl   (02.27.09)
Williamson has already made his views on the Holocaust very clear. Any statements he might issue now are just a lot of b.s. designed to minimize the penalties he's facing.
7. bishop
nabil ,   isreal   (02.27.09)
What happened to free speech?
8. #1 Oh, please spare us
aramkr ,   nyc   (02.27.09)
If you knew anything about Catholic theology, your opinion might be worth something but then you wouldn't have called it "anti-Jew".
9. who cares protestant bigger problem
AY_Lamb ,   USA   (02.27.09)
Von den Juden und ihren Lügen - ML whata guy. Robertson, Hagee, Brikner, and Phelps and the rest of those schmucks are more hateful a regular bunch o dudes.
10. the bigger problem is protestants
AY_Lamb ,   USA   (02.27.09)
Von den Juden und ihren Lügen. ML whata guy - Robertson, Hagee, Brikner they are real dude as well.
11. #3-But what would the Choirboys say?
(02.27.09)
12. Finally we see meaningful respose. The BBC and the Guardian
Harry   (02.27.09)
however will be pleased to employ the man, won't they?
13. Hopefuly......
Galut ,   Selah   (02.27.09)
even though this man has opended societies pandoras box of bitterness that is virtualy impossible to close...whether it is him honestly owning up to his mistake....and/or those holding thier cup of bitterness poision and learning how to turn it into constructive forgivness..... we as a society will not be served well if we refuse to come to grips with our own evil....whether it be bishop williamsons denial or those that hold him to a standard that they would not accept even if he honestly met all the requirements of that standard.... Cynicism to me equals bitterness that drives a unrealistic expectation that never can be met and always will be suspect no matter how honest the effort on the part of the offending party..... Bitterness unresloved becomes the festering fodder for future conflict... that is why the lord Jesus emphsised the concept of forgiveness.. forgiveness does not mean there is no accountability on the part of the forgiven person. he or she is still accountable to societies laws. Remembering the atrocities of the holocaust is an important safeguard marker for all society....but it should driven by venemous bitterness.
14. you are afraid from him
(02.28.09)
Why not one Jew has the courage to discuss with him his opinion and prove that he is wrong ..... no one of you dares to take such step because you are all afraid that you can not or your evedinces is not strong enough ... easy to accuse him with anti-simitism than you go in an uncounted adventure can change the world or your world .
15. #8-OK,let's review Catholic 'theology'
Arie ,   BaGolan   (02.27.09)
The vatican promotes the annual 'passion play' advocating the belief that the Jews committed 'deicide'; the vatican theology led to the crusades leaving 9 million Jews and Muslims dead; the vatican theology led to the inquisition leaving millions dead; the vatican theology promoted the belief that the Jews cause the Black Plague; the vatican theology caused popes to order kidnappings of little Jewish boys;the vatican theology led to the Shoah;and today the vatican promotes the beatification of hitler's pope and the inquisition queen, all concluded with groups of priests openly denying the Shoah ever existed. I do believe that falls under the category of "anti-Jew!"
16. 13 correction
Galut ,   Selah   (02.28.09)
Quote : but it should driven by venemous bitterness. shoud say - but it should not be driven by venemous bitterness.
17. IN HIS OWN WORDS - THE VIDEO - WATCH
Andrew ,   Miami,FL   (02.28.09)
HERE IT IS ;-( http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gHwDF65CDto&feature=related
18. #7 THERE'S A DIFFERENCE BETWEEN SATIRE AND EXTERMINATION OF
RINA FROM ISRAEL   (02.28.09)
TWO THIRDS OF A RACE JUST FOR THEIR RELIGION A LOT OF PEOPLE AROUND US LOST RELATIVES IN HOLOCAUST, IT DIDN'T HAPPEN THAT LONG AGO U KNOW, SOME SURVIVORS R STILL ALIVE
19. Catholics should clean Vatican upper ranks from Judaic conve
Tayfun_Turkey ,   Istanbul   (02.28.09)
Catholics should clean Vatican upper ranks from Judaic converted clergyman Some Catholics clergyman converted to Judaism secretly during their tenure and serve Zionism rather than their catholic belief This recent example showed how upper ranks in Vatican was occupied by Secret Judaic converts.
20. #12 - You are confused about the BBC
P ,   Philadelphia   (02.28.09)
The BBC is not anti-semitic, and I doubt it has among its ranks people who deny the Shoah. It does have a history of not being supportive of Zionism or Israel as it is now, but that is not anti-semitism. There are many jews who are not ashamed to be jewish who feel that the idea of a national homeland that discriminates against others and act as Israel has is morally offensive. From Charedi to seculars, there are many jews who do not buy the Zionist program, and this is the case both now and in its controversial beginnings. Confusing Zionism and Jewishness is a mistake.
21. Re#19 Yea, Right ..Jews Who Control ALL
Christy ,   Boston, US   (03.01.09)
... even the upper echelons of the Catholic Church! Does anyone really believe this, or is this just spouted as the normal anti-Jewish propaganda. FYI: - The group this so-called Bishop is a member of had broken away from the Catholic Church. They didn't/don't recognize anything the Catholic Church had done post-Vatican II... this includes all the post-Vatican II popes. The current Pope wants to 'mend the wounds' of this fissure. Why would Jews, or any other non-Catholic, care if this wound was mended or not? Doesn't make any sense. What do Jews, or any other non-Catholic, gain by this reunion?
22. To #19 Tay Fun Turkey
T. Traub ,   Phoenix, Arizona USA   (03.01.09)
Now that was funny! Not only do we Jews control the media, the top corporations and governments, but we also are the puppeteers behind the Vatican! As the old joke goes, if we're so in control, how come I'm not rich yet??
23. Whoship Richard Williamson
Ralph Branham ,   Norman , Oklahoma   (03.01.09)
I do not beleive that there is a padded cell with enough padding for the poor excuse of a Human .They need to figure out where he received his degree from and close that assylem down before they infect others with this desease .
24. vatican theology
azerty ,   France   (03.01.09)
"he vatican theology led to the inquisition leaving millions dead;" i understand that you do not appreciate the catholic church , but the fact is that the inquisition (french and spanish combined) caused approximatively 20 000 death , (in which 1 out 9 was sent to jail and 1 out of 15 was burnt) "vatican promotes the beatification of hitler's pope" Rabbi David Dalin would not disagree with that
25. I Have Been Bashing The Bishop For So
Lawrence ,   Safed Israel   (03.01.09)
Long,my hand is calloused.
Back to article