News
Palestinians: Swap talks deadlocked over 'heavyweight' prisoners
Ynet
Published: 17.03.09, 08:22
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
14 Talkbacks for this article
1. throughout
ghostq   (03.17.09)
the palestinians history compromisation is non to be found, not just Hamas, they will never learn, never.
2. because..
Daniel ,   LA, CA, USA   (03.17.09)
..they know that one israeli soldier is worth 450 of their top people. scum.
3. Gaza war finished way too early
Leah ,   Israel   (03.17.09)
kadima lost the plot gave away Gaza and now it is a terrorist entity that fires rockets into Israel when ever they like. Resus the cockroaches.
4. #2 Thats their offer:take it or leave it#3gaza war surged..
JayZ ,   Jerusalem   (03.17.09)
#2.. Perhaps shalit is worth 1000 of these prisoners, yet they ask for 450 only, release 1000 and prove that he's worth 1000 men. #3 Its the gaza war that surged this no. of prisoners to be released, before the war, they were asking for less and conditions were easier in negotiations.. But after the war they think to themselves: What worse could possibly happen?
5. Heavyweights?
Sarah ,   New York City, USA   (03.17.09)
Oh, it had nothing to do with whether Israel would release "heavyweight" criminals. It had everything to do with Hamas' inability to meet Israel's quid pro quo; i.e., proving that Gilad Shalit is alive. I really don't care what spin the Palestinian "damage-control" experts are scrambling to put on this. I really don't care what spin the Hamas "damage-control" experts are scrambling to put on this. I really don't care what spin the Egyptian "damage-control" experts are scrambling to put on this. The fact is, Israel issued ONE ... ONE .... quid pro quo. Prove that Shalit is alive. Palestinians couldn't meet the quid pro quo. Hamas couldn't meet the quid pro quo. Egypt couldn't meet the quid pro quo. Hey, folks: you cn fool some of the people some of the time, most of the people most of the time, but you cannot fool all of the people all of the time. Hamas is a lying piece of offal. And now the world knows that. And will not care WHATEVER Israel's response may be. Good riddance to bad (Hamas) rubbish. They've had their fifteen minutes (and then some) of fame. Time to fade into eterniity.
6. Cruelty
Israeli ,   Israel   (03.17.09)
Hamas is playing a real cruel game. It's impossible to do anything with them. Let us all pray that Gilad comes home soon...alive and healthy.
7. to #4 the worse
ghostq   (03.17.09)
thing to them is to declare Gilad Shalit as dead, and close the very narrow opportunity they had.
8. close the Gaza strip complete
eli ,   jerusalem   (03.17.09)
Let them get a desire to send Gilad back. It has to be their only wish, than he will return G-D willing alive.
9. Kidnapped Israeli soldiers.
Robert Bernier ,   Tel Aviv   (03.17.09)
In the war against terror, Human rights, a Judeo-Christian value, should be considered differently. Israel would do well to cancel the visits of Palestinian prisoners' families, no longer allow detainees to complete their studies, and worsen their upgraded imprisonment conditions. Pressure on the part of Palestinian prisoners' families would greatly assist in presenting Hamas as failing to do enough to free its prisoners. This could prompt the group to soften its positions on kidnapped Israeli soldiers. Israel should adapt to the new war as explained at : http://xrl.us/bi3q3
10. If 1 Israeli is later killed by released terros,then the
Alan ,   SA   (03.17.09)
next of kin should sue the State of Israel senseless for negligence and claim big damages in the Supreme Court. I can tell you I would if G-d forbid it affected me or my family . You all see what the Quartet's Guarantees are worth... Hezballah has MORE than re armed and Hamas is back in business with bigger and better weapons . THERE ARE OTHER WAYS TO RELEASE SHALIT without Sayeret Matkal and Entebe Style Acrobatics . Whats wrong with the Israel leadership?I am astounded at the lack of lateral thinking . In any case after Shalit is released by this mad swap ,the Terros will repeat it again and the same process of NATIONAL BLACKMAIL for 3 years will repeat . It is so easy to kidnap any Israeli .They are all over the World in anycase . RELEASE SHALIT but not on those terms .I was one of the first who wrote into Y net with these views and I am still proud of it!
11. everyone Hamas demands
Michael Hessler ,   Ma'ale Adumim   (03.17.09)
Pack up everyone Hamas demands on to transports for the cameras to see. Transport them all to near the Gaza border where the rockets land. Keep them cuffed, shackled and in small groups inside of open air cages with portable toilets. No Red Cross, no telephones, no internet or no visitors within a hundred meters. Let the world press come with cameras to see them. Let everyone wait for Hamas to produce Shalit and show how he has been treated.
12. This shows how Hamas doesn't care about Palestinians.
robert renders ,   belgium   (03.17.09)
The blokkade stays, the people's hardship too. Hamas doensn't give a damn. Bunch of gangsters.
13. To: No. 9
Sarah ,   New York City, USA   (03.17.09)
I am inclined to agree. Throw all Palestinians imprisoned in Israeli jails into solitary confinement and put them on bread and water diets. No visits from family. No human companionship. No one to talk to. Then we'll see.
14. one solution
Israel Israeli ,   Tel Aviv   (03.17.09)
The Olmert/Livni/Barak government has failed in freeing Shalit because they don't understand Hamas interests. Hamas is not critically interested in releasing the murderers. Hamas is interested in defeating, humiliating and demoralizing Israel. Every day Israelis beg for audience with Hamas increases Hamas' popularity in the Arab world and proves that Hamas won "Cast Lead". Thus, Hamas has no interest in finishing the negotiations. There is, however, one solution to defeat Hamas. All Israel has to do is decide that Shalit can't be freed (like it was decided with Baumel, Feldman, Katz, Halabi and Arad) and start building Jewish villages. If Hamas' only achievement in kidnapping Shalit is the construction of more Jewish homes, Hamas will lose power and dissappear.
Back to article