News
Arabs slam 'racist' Israel Railways policy
Sharon Roffe-Ofir
Published: 18.03.09, 19:07
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
50 Talkbacks for this article
31. The Jews will give them anything they want
frank ,   usa   (03.18.09)
..so that they continue to challenge the Jewishness of the state, play backgammon, socialize and procreate without risking their lives in Gaza or Hebron. If the Jews are so insecure they deserved to be challenged. Nobody in the US would challenge the veterans benefits. Only in Israel.....
32. I agree it is not racism
IRAN#1   (03.18.09)
That is precisely why jewish complain that they don't get high security jobs in Iran is also totally rubbish. It is common sense.
33. Throwing Jews out of gaza is racist
dave ,   uk   (03.18.09)
34. Arabs slam 'racist' Israel Railways policy
ISSY DYKMAN ,   ISRAEL   (03.19.09)
WELCOME TO CHELM. WHY NOT USE SECURITY PRISONERS AS SECURITY FOR OUR RAILWAYS ? THEY CAN ALSO BE PAID LESS AND JUST THINK HOW MUCH WE SAVE AND ALSO WE WON'T BE CALLED RACISTS ! ! !
35. Oh come on -security is racist???
Jo   (03.19.09)
It makes sense and is necessary. As to this racist slogan the Arabs keep giving us - let us return it to them. We have plenty of proof - quote after quote on record - to prove the racism of some Arab Mks. We should all talk Arab, it is the only way to fight this sillyness
36. Racist is Arabs not serving in IDF and Jews protecting Arabs
David ,   Boston, USA   (03.19.09)
Thats racist. The Arabs should serve in the IDF also and protect ALL Israeli citizens. Jewish, Druze, Beduin, and a small number of others serve in the IDF protecting ALL citizens, including ALL the Arabs who dont. Maybe these Arab Railroad employees should have joined the IDF, hmm?
37. Tibi,to stir the pot,again sticking his nose in
Sorcey ,   UK   (03.19.09)
38. duh!
david ,   new york   (03.19.09)
if you don't trust someone to carry an m-16, why should you trust them with the safety of 1000 tons of metal going 60 miles per hour?? the railway is a prime opportunity for terrorists
39. Saftey Inspector
Shaul ,   Sheboygan   (03.19.09)
Okay, can somebody please list the job duties for this position? The title "Saftey Inspector" makes me think of someone who: - prevents drunks from sleeping on the tracks, - keeps pedestrians enraptured with their cell phones from blindly walking in front of trains, - rescues children who trip when laying sheckels on the tracks, - herding unblemished red heifers away from a non-kosher death.
40. prove your loyalty before whining
Mongo ,   Paris   (03.19.09)
learn to becomne a true mensch!
41. It is a VETERANS perk, they didn't defend Israel.
Bunnie Meyer ,   Los Angeles, CA USA   (03.19.09)
42. When it comes to safety, err on conservative side
William ,   Israel   (03.19.09)
Sorry, Arabs. I wouldn't really trust you with the key to my apartment building let alone the very safety issues on my transportation systems. Call Israel racist all you want. It was YOUR practices to led to these type of restrictions. Things like calling Jewish firefighters and police to fake alarms just to stone them. Or killing a Jewish Bezeq repairman in Umm Al-Faqm. When the train is 95% Israeli-Arab passengers, then I *might* be inclined to trust you to do a decent job.... but knowing Israeli Arabs...they would just demand the tracks be moved closer to their villages, at expense to Jewish taxpayers, so they didn't have to travel so far to work.
43. Tibi is the Arab Al Sharpton
William ,   Israel   (03.19.09)
Ready to scream racism about any thing involving Arabs, whether legitimate or not. Al Sharpton would travel the country instigating people with his charges of racism against Blacks, even those involved in violent criminal activities. Tibi is just another Al Sharpton knowing a democracy cringes when faced with the "R" card. The best thing to do is sideline him and make sure you're covered legally Israel. If his followers feel a fair shake from Israel (must be tied to national service and paying taxes) Tibi becomes worthless.
44. Re#5-Agreed - NOT racist!
Christy ,   Boston, US   (03.19.09)
I believe Israeli Arabs can join the IDF ... no discrimination here. As #5 pointed out, it's been a longstanding (since WWII?) law in the US that former soldiers (veterans ..vets) get preferential status for government jobs. They also have education, health, and mortgage benefits... that non-vets are NOT entitled to. Seems very reasonable to me that a country give some preferential treatment to people who put their lives on the line to defend their country. As far as the US goes, I'd like to see *more* benefits given to vets. It's thanks to the vets that we have a free country. => This applies to Israel too.
45. The Arabs of Israel spit in the well from which they drink.
Robert Bernier ,   Tel Aviv   (03.19.09)
We have been fooling ourselves all these years. We are ignoring the participation of Arabs with Israeli citizenship in terrorist attacks, and we refuse to recognize that most of the property crimes in Israel are carried out by Arabs. We also don't want to know about the systematic Arab takeover of Jewish neighborhoods in Israeli cities, significant centers of unrest exist, just like in Akko, in Lod, Ramle, Yaffo, Carmiel, Upper Nazareth, and Haifa as well. There, too, Arab riots and destruction of Jewish property are just a matter of time. More about the Arabs in Israel at : http://xrl.us/bi3hx
46. Racism?
Art ,   New City, NY   (03.19.09)
There are ARAB soldiers in the Israeli Army as well, Bedouin and Druze. So where is the racism?
47. Set aside positions for Arabs who have not done IDF service
Kyle ,   Southpark, CO, USA   (03.19.09)
What about setting aside jobs for haredim?
48. Racist?!
Heather Czerniak ,   Milwaukee, WI   (03.19.09)
The only people I'd trust guarding me on an Israeli train are ex-IDF soldiers. I wouldn't trust anyone else. I can't afford to.
49. You know NOTHING about racism.
rebecca ,   modiin   (03.19.09)
Ask the Jews from Arab countries, or Jews from Nazi Germany. Or Ex-South Africans, or the Matabele in Zimbabwe, or our Sudanese refugees. There are lots of people who know racism 1st hand. Israeli Arabs only know the racism their elected leaders practice, and even that is watered down
50. Racism? You mean preferential treatment
Yosi M. ,   GiloJerusalem Israel   (03.19.09)
If there were equal treatment, these arabs wouldn't have half of the jobs that they have. Tibi the racist calling Jews racist? Why does he want all areas where arabs live completely free of Jews? Why does he say to his arab constituants, in arabic, that they will eliminate all Jews from Israel? Racist my arse.
Previous talkbacks
Back to article