Culture  Art&Culture
Carmiel rabbi enraged by erotic show
Galit Perry
Published: 20.03.09, 14:05
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
44 Talkbacks for this article
31. #24 And Whose Brilliant Idea Was It
Lawrence ,   Safed Israel   (03.20.09)
To import multitudes of non-jewish slavs into the jewish state? the Government? the Jewish Agency? Israel did not have enough k.g.b spies and neo-nazis.It must be said,however,that there are many many fine immigrants from the former soviet union who contribute greatly to Israel and are model citizens.The Russian aliyah is a fine one in many respects but also has its problems.
32. #23 Just Keep Studying And Educating
Lawrence ,   Safed Israel   (03.20.09)
yourself,perhaps one day you will be able to understand /appreciate my Talkbacks.
33. Carmiel's Religious Are Enraged
Lawrence ,   Safed Israel   (03.20.09)
Darn it,they say,why do tickets to the show have to be so expensive?
34. #24 You are the problem with Israelis
Aaron ,   SF, USA   (03.20.09)
You intolerant brute. Israel needed those Russian Jews and even if they didn't, you'd think Israelis would be apathetic towards immigrants from russia, no? You are 5th generation Israeli? did you parents come after the pogroms or in the first aliyah? Either way, please remember why the state of Israel exists. And either way, they didn't break any local law - it is not a public event and it is 18+
35. Here we go, another example of overbearing religious
Talula ,   Israel   (03.20.09)
Why do they waste so much energy on trying to preach to people about what is moral and immoral? You don't like the show or its contents, THEN DON'T GO AND SEE IT. Instead, preach to your own community about getting a job and serving your country. Because, what is immoral to me are slobs that skive army service and sponge off the government and make continual demands on a country they do bugger all to contribute to. Morons!
36. Erotic show
NYC Girl   (03.21.09)
Why all the outrage on the part of these rabbis when there are shops and kiosks all over Israel where pornographic magazines are sold right out in the open? I mean you couldn't even put that stuff in the windows of stores in Times Square when it was arguably the porn capital of America. Yet in cities all over Israel there are magazines showing explicit sexual acts on the covers being openly displayed at newsstands, even one where kids were waiting for the bus to go to school. At least, in the case of the erotic show, presumably it's taking place behind closed doors.
37. Religious or not
Yona ,   Israel   (03.21.09)
We should have a high moral standard in the country no matter what religion a person has.
38. You guys are all being had
(03.21.09)
You Talkbackers have fallen into the trap. The rabbi gets some free press for making noise about a non-existent problem: it is a private show so it is perfectly legal. The organizer gets some free press and the Feminists off his back. Face it, the show is a vulgar use of women's bodies, and who knows whether the "actresses" really want to perform. But now the Feminists won't protest because they dont want to side with the rabbi.
39. You don't have to watch it...
Jeremy ,   Boston   (03.22.09)
I don't understand... if the show is being put on in a private, 18+ environment, why does the Rabbi care? If he doesn't like it, he doesn't have to watch it. He can even instruct his congregation not to go.
40. #7's Racist nonsense
Larry ,   Carmiel   (03.22.09)
Instead of yapping from NY, if you would come to Israel, perhaps you would be enlightened to the fact that the big majority of Sephardic Jews are hard-working and productive. Keep your prejudice to yourself. Ynet Talkback editors, I'm surprised you let this goofball's ignorance go through.
41. #40 Larry
Ben ,   Monroe USA   (03.22.09)
Read the posts from Israelis who say the same things as the NY lady. Secondly, if you find the show offensive, JUST DON'T GO.!! There is nobody with a gun to your head forcing you or anyone else to attend. Hey you could always join in the "modesty police" and start beating up women who perform in the show.
42. Hey Alexandr
nr ,   los angeles, usa   (03.22.09)
No doubt the state of California is going into bankruptcy because of the generous welfare payments - to the brain surgeons sitting in the park playing chess. Everyone knows Russians love to live in a welfare state. Dream on about with your visions of glory. BTW, what's BET - I have heard of Snoop Dogg, but never felt the need to watch him. Too busy working a job and paying taxes. Hey, stay in New York - I hear the welfare is good there too.
43. #35 - Guess immorality works for you
nr ,   los angeles, usaq   (03.22.09)
Here in los angeles not too long ago, there was a porno company shooting movies in a private home - and the neighbors got upset. By your logic, it was none of their business. But the courts thought otherwise and stopped it. Pornography and erotic BS bring in unsavory elements - including drugs and other criminal activity. If you haven't figured that out by now you're the moron. So quit falling back on your "the haredi don't serve" to excuse your hatred. It's a lie, as this last incursion into Gaza showed. You sound like a bitter broad who needs to grow up.
44. #21 ever heard of freedom and democracy
Avi ,   Rannana   (03.23.09)
How strange you live in the US enjoy full freedom and democracy and your cushey life style, yet you feel it your right to critisize and tell people how to run their lives in Israel, according to your so called moral ethics. Which is rather rich from jew who chooses to live in LA and not Jerusalem, do you pay taxes in Israel, so you serve in the IDF? so some how i dont think you are in any position to preach to others and deny those who have worked hard for freedom and democracy their democratic rights Bunnie Boy.
Previous talkbacks
Back to article