News
UN report accuses Israel of using human shields
Associated Press
Published: 23.03.09, 18:57
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
37 Talkbacks for this article
1. As long as there are Jews to attack and debase
Arie ,   BaGolan   (03.23.09)
no need to conduct a truly objective investigation.
2. US & Europe uses Israel as a human shield
Darren ,   Oakland, CA   (03.23.09)
Want accusations with only a very slight basis in logic and international law? I've got plenty!
3. SO WHO ACTUALLY WERE THE WITNESSES REPORTING THESE STORIES??
stude ham   (03.23.09)
was it the idf troops alledged to have commandeered the youth? in other words... since when have any UN reports against Israel truly been reliable? moshiach will appear well before such UN reliability.
4. it's funny
yoyo   (03.23.09)
no matter how cruel world terrorists will be, the UN and humas rights group will always try to link it to jews. it's just pure hate and jealousy...
5. How about some sort of proof?
Gee ,   Zikron Yaakov   (03.23.09)
The UN has continually made these type of blood-libel claims all without a single piece of proof. Radhika Coomaraswamy you are a racist liar and murder and I have as much proof of that as you do that there was any human shields used by the IDF.
6. Proof?
Mike ,   USA   (03.23.09)
the proof are the stories of YOU OWN soldiers who are coming out and admitting what the have done in there...
7. "Atrocities" is a bit strong
TK ,   USA   (03.23.09)
Especially since no one was injured in the alleged incident with the teen. In all of these cases, the accusers had better come up with better proof than an "eyewitness" - who is nearly always eventually proved a gross liar.
8. Always in denial
Nick ,   USA   (03.23.09)
Always, your response to any report against IDF is denial, and immediate jump to accusation to everybody else to be a Jew hater, anti Semite..pla ..pla..An unheard of bullshit statements that make people sick to their stomach. Well, let’s ask, were you there to prove that didn’t happened, or is this a racist assumption that this report must be incorrect because incent that a Jew did something wrong, Oh my God, how could this happened..There are no Jews in jail anywhere in the world and certainly not in Israel for stealing nor for killing their own kind even. And how about those IDF soldiers that admitted receiving orders to performing genocide in Gaza in the name of religion, those statements were published by Haaretz Newspaper, were those guys not there too, or are those guys Jews haters too. Come on, wake up and be honest with yourselves and your children maybe that will reduce the hatred going around and maybe allow you to live in piece, if not with neighbors but at least with your own conscience.
9. LOL, they're mad because we're turning into them.
Nick Sporek ,   Jerusalem Israel   (03.23.09)
10. ICC
Mark Wilson ,   USA   (03.24.09)
Why is it taking so long to begin issuing arrest warrants?
11. Interesting comparison Darren # 2
Mongo ,   PARIS   (03.24.09)
12. #8 Always in Denial
Nick Nikora ,   Gisborne New Zealand   (03.24.09)
As in all conflicts there will always be allegations of abusive behaviour committed against innocent civilains. In this recent conflict between Israel and Hamas 1,400 Palestinians died 960 of them civilians and 13 Israelis. A disproportionate number of civilian deaths. Allegations made by a number of soldiers from the Golani Infantry Bde have recently been made public both in Israel and internationally. In one instance it has been alledged by an IDF soldier that a Palestinian woman and her child were killed by an IDF sniper. If Israel and the IDF are ever to gain the moral high ground in this conflict these allegations must be acknowledged and investigated. Otherwise, if left unchecked the IDF risks being torn apart from within.
13. They're mad because they're turning into
(03.24.09)
their interpretation of us me thinks.
14. #6 That's definitely not proof.
jv ,   LA, USA   (03.24.09)
That's multiple levels of hearsay by unnamed sources. Proof is testimony given under oath and tested by cross-examination.
15. HAMMAS USED 1.5 MILLION PALESTINIANS AS HUMAN SHIELDS
Jorge ,   Tegucigalpa   (03.24.09)
I did not hear even a whisper from the U.N. about that documented atrocity, but then, what can you expect from the U.N. when the so called Human rights commision has Cuba, Iran and the likes as members
16. Using Human Shieilds is wrong- However...
Galut ,   Selah   (03.24.09)
it would be interesting to see the documentation on this ... it sounds apparent that launching qassams from school yards is not high on the list of those investigating violations.... particularly since the qassams are being used as a harrasment device to draw israeli fire....fire that some times produces colateral civilian casualties
17. has to be a lie
raji ,   santa monica   (03.24.09)
jews are perfect.
18. #8 denial
Tamir ,   Los Angeles   (03.24.09)
the issue here isnt whether or not jews commit bad acts because there are definately those that do. The issue here is the double standard that comes to the reporting of israeli conflicts vs. arab conflicts. If a jew targets a civilian (intentionally or not) he is a villian, but if an arab targets a civilian he is either a hero or a victim that was "forced" to do so because of the "occupation" There is no questions in my mind that there were some unfortanate circumstances resulting from this operation in Gaza but to be so one sided against Jews in this regard is what creates this feeling of anti-semitism amongst jews. Let's be real here, as a country Israel is one of the freeist and most moral entities not only in the middle east but in the world. It's about time people like you started to question the motives and the actions of the other side before you go off on these rants
19. UN human rights experts? Oxymoron.
(03.24.09)
20. to is unbased and...
ghostq   (03.24.09)
the double standard of the UN cause when the palis r doing it it's ok, so transperant, so again save the trees and throw this report to the local recycling bin.
21. Illogical
Rina   (03.24.09)
How would using a human shield help the IDF when we all know that Hamas itself uses its own people as human shields? The supposed human shield would have no deferance value. But good tactic for Hamas: Make a claim that is not true. By the time it's proven to be false, everyone has already formed their impression and it doesn't matter that it was a lie.
22. Journalists
hakim ,   usa   (03.24.09)
If they would have allowed them in during operation last dead you would have all kinds of proof on video as well.The IDF did not allow them in because they knew exactly what they were going to do and it was all planned. P.S even if caught on video they would DENY IT!!!!!
23. #15 Very True
Cynthia ,   USA   (03.24.09)
The UN doesn't care if the Palestinians shot 3000 missiles at Israel or killed Israeli children. I doubt they even listen to the issues. They have an automatic blame Israel button which they push arbitrarily. Only problem, the UN now has absolutely no credibility and they've become a bloated, useless organization.
24. israel is a strong country
hakim, ,   usa   (03.24.09)
G-d bless Israel, hamas is lying and making others lie for them, this is a corrupt organisation led by the likes of the un.
25. #24 NICE TRY
THE REAL hakim ,   usa   (03.24.09)
these dirty games are what is getting you in trouble..
26. Hamas uses population as a human shield
Maks ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (03.24.09)
27. More megaphone diplomacy from the UN
Talula ,   Israel   (03.24.09)
The UN should disband. They are hopeless unprofessional misfits who, when 300,000 Iraqi Kurds, men, women and children were being gassed to death and left dead on the streets by Saddam Hussein’s brutal regime, they were no-where in sight - they kept quiet and did nothing to help. It seems they approve of Arabs killing Arabs but Israelis are not allowed to do so, even if Israel has been under constant rocket attack for years and years……………for no reason. We shouldn’t let these useless Plebs into our country – they are biased, hate Jews and will do anything to keep us pinned to the firing squad. When they start paying attention to brutal murders, rapes and other horrors that take place daily in other countries – and bring it to the forefront with as much zest as the Israeli issues, then maybe their word would actually mean something. Until then, they just need to shut up, pack up and go stand in line for welfare.
28. gaza
joe ,   saugerties usa   (03.24.09)
israel is on the road to self destruction
29. #8 so you saying the UN isn't anti-Israeli?
I say your the ,   queen of denial   (03.24.09)
30. The UN blames the Jews when the Arabs do this
Steve from Raleigh   (03.24.09)
To their own people. So it's axiomatic that they'd eventually blame the Jews for doing something else.
Next talkbacks
Back to article