News
Report: Israel gearing to bomb Iran's nuclear sites
Ynet
Published: 18.04.09, 09:22
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
65 Talkbacks for this article
31. ISRAEL IS IN EVERY ZIONIST AND JEWISH HEART
shu ,   UK   (04.18.09)
the land and the people of israel will win,ISRAEL IS OUR HEART AND SOUL. WE DO THE OUT MOST TO PROTECT IT.am yisrael hay
32. #9 Mike Cato- naive at best
Tif ,   Monmouth, NJ USA   (04.18.09)
Have you ever heard of keeping your friends close but your enemies closer? Barack Obama is a very smart man and he knows exactly what needs to be done to change the tone of these people. Getting close to them is exactly what he should be doing if we are ever to have a dynamic of de-escalating tyranny and terrorism. The only way to stop a bully is to listen to him, not tolerate him and take his toys away....and do it in a way that he doesn't even see it happening. Tif USA
33. IRAN, DONOT WAIT ,STRIKE ISRAEL PREEMPTIVELY!!!
Tayfun_Turkey ,   Istanbul   (04.18.09)
They are preparing for raid, Irand should act faster and strike Israel preemptively BOMB BOMB BOMB.... At least Iranian army should announce they elaborate a possible preemtive strike!
34. No possible concession to Iran will prevent military action
Joe ,   Canada   (04.18.09)
Given the fanatical long term aim of the ayatollahs to dominate & impose their brand of Shiite Islam to the majority Arab Sunni world using Israel's destruction as an enticement & pretext for Arab cooperation, there is no concession acceptable to the West that can be offered to satisfy Iran & to deter them. The US cannot even offer Irak to Iran, since Irak will be anyway dominated by Shiites & Iran once the G.I,'s leave. And it is not plausible that the West would give Syria & Iran more say in the affairs of Lebanon that they already have with the dominant military power of their Hizbollah proxy which has veto power in the government even though it is a minority player. So, whatever path the diplomatic negotiations (& weak carrot & stick measures) take, they will end in failure since there is no sign of internal upwheal to threaten the regime of the religious leaders who control the electoral process & the petrodollars of the economy. In the end resorting to military action to prevent or delay the acquisition of nuclear weapons by Iran will be the only recourse left as Russia & China are preventing complete economic isolation of Iran which had a small chance of bringing Iran to negotiate a more peaceful resolution of the nuclear & terrorist proxies threat. Even if Iran would show public sign of mollifying its stance it would still use undercover means to provoke troubles & terrorist actions outside its borders as on the past (remember Argentina, Egypt, Saudi Arabia....)
35. It's a matter of timing
cas reader   (04.18.09)
As for now, the diplomatic approach is taken to resolve Iran's nuclear issue. However, time will come when action is necessary to protect Israel and her citizens. Israel is waiting for the green light from USA which will only be given if all diplomatic avenues have failed.
36. JUST DO IT!! THE SOONER, THE BETTER!!
Tom ,   San Francisco   (04.18.09)
Personally, I doubt very much that Netanyahu will have the courage to do the necessary strike on Iran. I hope I am wrong. In any case, there is no more time to waste. It is now or it will be simply too late!! And please Israel, do NOT wait for the USA to give you the go ahead, Israel is not the valet of the USA and therefore Israel does not need the go ahead from anybody!!
37. military action
tom ,   toronto, canada   (04.18.09)
a military attack on iran's nuclear facilities is a high-risk tactic with only a limited chance of success. even assuming that the raid is 100% successful, destroying iran's nuclear toys will delay, but not stop, their development programme, simply because iran can afford to replace them. and there are plenty of reasons why it won't be successful against dispersed and hardened targets, and possibly due to imperfect intelligence. iran's nuclear programme is primarily a "people problem", consisting of a political leadership obsessed with national suicide (such as threatening nuclear war against the united states, or even israel), and relying on a very small number of nuclear physicists and engineers (probably speaking russian or korean). removing either element will stop the programme. hopefully, covert operations to achieve this won't be making headlines in the "london times".
38. ALL SITES DESTROYED
MAHMOOD ,   LONDON-UK   (04.18.09)
All aircrafts returned safely to bases.No more talks about Iran for 20 years.:)
39. No options available
John ,   Boise, ID   (04.18.09)
The time to strike is long overdue. Of course, there are options. The "little hitler" that wants to draw attention to himself, can be put out of his misery by one of their local citizens. This would generate freedom for the common citizen who wants to get on with his life like the rest of us and direct their energies toward their families and more important issues at hand. The Iranian common people need to find their voice.
40. to Nour
nate ,   canada   (04.18.09)
I hope you're in shock when the successful mission takes place. I also hope Iran's retaliatory strikes hit you in the face in so-called "palestine".
41.  Obvious analysis
Pedro ,   Brazil   (04.18.09)
Israel simply cannot accept Iran to possess nuclear weapons and at the same time to continue financing Hezbollah, Hamas and other terrorist groups against Israel. Israel don't have other alternative that act.
42. #20 We know how you luv the Palestinians
Cynthia ,   USA   (04.18.09)
Train and arm them to do your dirty work against Israel. When they die like the Lebanese in a conflict, just label them as martyrs, use them for your propaganda, then forget about them. Hizbullah does squat for the Palestinians except use them for jihad. The last thing you want is for them to be independent. Save the BS for your rallies.
43. Israel would not reviele its plans
maxim ,   Eilat,Israel   (04.18.09)
Israel would never reveal its true plans or intentions and most certianly never in a news paper
44. Jeremiah the Prophet:
The 11th Man ,   London   (04.18.09)
Thus saith the L-rd of hosts; Behold, I will break the bow of Iran (Elam), the chief of their might. And upon Iran will I bring the four winds from the four quarters of heaven, and will scatter them toward all those winds; and there shall be no nation whither the outcasts of Iran shall not come. For I will cause Iran to be dismayed before their enemies, and before them that seek their life: and I will bring evil upon them, even my fierce anger, saith the Lord; and I will send the sword after them , till I have consumed them: And I will set my throne in Iran, and will destroy from thence the king and the princes, SAITH THE L-RD. Jeremiah 49:35-38.
45. #30 Thank Israel, Marco
Cynthia ,   USA   (04.18.09)
Israel made the world a safer place in 1981 when Israel destroyed the Osirak nuclear reactor. They even scheduled the attack on Sunday when the plant was closed and before the plant went live to minimize casualties. Iran initially attacked and damaged the Osirak plant in 1980 but Israel came back to destroy it. Living under threat of nuclear Iran is more dangerous, particularly for Israel when the President of Iran openly threatens to wipe Israel off the map.
46. #29 X'
Yasser ,   Lebanon   (04.18.09)
Are our nukes giving birth? Last week there were only 200 and now they are at 500+???? Look, Iran will get nukes which means that Hezbollah will get them too. Israel's strategic depth is no depth at all. One is enough! As far as we are concerned, we welcome death if it means dignity. We do not mind as long as we take you with us!
47. #40 nate
Marco ,   Spain   (04.18.09)
Nate, its a two way street. I would pay anything to see your stupid face when Israel fails miserably with Iranian and Hezbollah missiles raining all over Israel. I would like to see your stupid face when the price of a barrel of oild jumps to 300$ with you freezing your a$$ in winter because you cannot afford your heating bill.
48. Why is it important for Israel to be the first to strike?
Dave Ronen ,   Haifa   (04.18.09)
Iran only needs one nuclear-tipped missile to get through and Tel Aviv, along with most of Israel’s west coast with 70% of her population, most of her industry and her international airport will be obliterated or eventually killed by radiation. I suspect that only then would Washington move and send body bags and food to the survivors - or something like Georgia. And if there will be one nuclear-tipped missile striking Israel, Iran will not hesitate to strike immediately also the rest of the world as can be understand by reading : http://xrl.us/orpxu
49. #45 Cynthia, USA
Marco ,   Spain   (04.18.09)
Cynthia, what the president of Iran said was that Israel will cease to exist. He did not say that he will physically destroy Israel by bombing it. What he meant was that in a one state with equal rights for Jews and Palestinians, Jews will be outnumbered in a few decades and therefore Israel as we know it today will cease to exist.
50. #49 Marco, Full of Bullah
Cynthia ,   USA   (04.18.09)
Marco, that's your job title for your new business card. Congratulations on being promoted from spokesperson for Hizbullah to Ahmadinejad's English translator. We know what he said and we know what he means.
51. bombing iran same as bombing wall street!
Issa Yacoub ,   USA   (04.18.09)
i guess the israeli defence ministry has a financial stake with the gas station up the street from my house,every other day gas price jumps up 2 cents,think what would happen if israel bomb,oil prices would double stock market will nose dive by 1500 points and the world will go crazy,Obama wont allow it period.iranians are aware of this game,anyway i filled up my gas tank just in case..
52. no you wrong 6
me   (04.18.09)
if iran were stronger then they were destroy israel but they can't do this
53. THAT IS EXACTLY WHAT IRAN.....#43
(04.18.09)
Is also very certain not to reveal.If you or any of the readers is under the impression that the attempted or partially succesful raid on the Iranian Nuclear site will demonstrate a one-sided scenerio for people to enjoy,might as well abondon your thoughts.Iran is ready with numerous contigency plans and one has only to look at few to believe why the USA is finding it difficult to give consent to the Israelis.Mind you Maxim,Iran has numerous options than Israel has.Dont you ever doubt or wonder. Since nothing has happened so far,let us write and enjoy what we feel will happen or not happen
54. WHAT ABOUT THE IRANIAN PLANT,CYNTHIA......#45
MAHMOOD ,   LONDON-UK   (04.18.09)
It runs day and night.When will you stop dreaming?
55. DETER IRAN - WHAT A JOKE !!!.
ORAO STRANKA. ,   TSARIGRAD U SRBIA.   (04.18.09)
“Many of the leaks or statements made by Israeli leaders and military commanders are meant for deterrence. ARE THERE ONLY ATEISTIC FOOLS AND IDIOTS IN ISRAELI LEADERS AND MILITARY COMMANDERS. YOU CAN NOT DETER RELIGIOUS CONVICTIONS AND BELIEVES. The message to Iran is that the threat is not just words,” the report quoted a senior defense establishment official as saying. YES GIVE DETRERING WORDS AND FORWARN THEM YEARS IN ADVANCE FOR THE COMING MILITARYT STRIKE. WHAT FOLISHNES AND IDIOTY. “We would not make the threat (against Iran) without the force to back it. There has been a recent move, a number of on-the-ground preparations, that indicate Israel's willingness to act,” said another official from Israel's intelligence community. YES NOW IRAN HAS BEEN FORWARNED AND PREPERED FOR THIS MILITARY STRIKE FOR SEVEAL YEARS. VERY SMART THIS FORWARNINGS. “Many of the leaks or statements made by Israeli leaders and military commanders are meant for deterrence. The message is that if (the international community) is unable to solve the problem they need to take into account that we will solve it our way,” he added. THANK YOU !!!. “Israel has made it clear that it will not tolerate the threat of a nuclear Iran. According to Israeli Intelligence they will have the bomb within two years ... Once they have a bomb it will be too late, and Israel will have no choice to strike – with or without America,” an official from the Israeli Defense Ministry said. IRAN IS CERTAINLY VERY IMPRESSED OF THE ISRAELI AND US OFFICIALLY DETERING THREATHS, THANK YOU JERKS !!!. Orao.
56. TALKBACK 44 IS AN ERROR !!!.
ORAO STRANKA. ,   TSARIGRAD U SRBIA.   (04.18.09)
THE ELAMITES IS A SEMITIC PEOPLE, ITS TODAY CALLED ARABISTAN. THE IRANIANS IS AN INDOEUROPEAN PEOPLE, OF MEDIAN ORIGIN. Orao.
57. Bomb Iran!
will ,   dallas tx usa   (04.18.09)
Blow Iran back in to the stone age. Turn it in to Baney's rubble where there is nothing left but flintstones. Keep on...wave after wave til nothing remains larger then a matzah box. That's my suggestion
58. #53 what Iran has...
will ,   dallas tx usa   (04.18.09)
Iran has outdated russian and US military machines and technology. They are decades behind Israel and the West. They are the largest military machine in the region, but they don't stand a chance against a solid carpet bombing by superior forces. They count on indecisiveness by greedy cowards in the US Congress and state departments as well as the current exacerbations concerning Palestine etc in Israel. Iran has been an over estimated bully since the hostage thing in the 70's. Things are different now Iran... Our pity for you has run out. NO ONE believes what you say.
59. So, it's official, the US just gave Iran permission to fly
Danny ,   I'm out of here!   (04.18.09)
over Iraq, and we thought it was going to be the other way around.
60. Orao #56 I take your point.
The 11th Man ,   London   (04.18.09)
You are absolutely correct, the Elamites were a Semitic people and the modern Iranians are not. However, the text from Jeremiah refers to the LAND of Elam not the people called Elamites. I therefore understand the passage to be saying the following: WHOEVER IS INHABITING THE LAND ORIGINALLY KNOWN AS ELAM WILL BE SUBJECT TO THE JUDGMENT DESCRIBED. And, as S.W.Iran is the location of ancient Elam, this means the Iranians. I appreciate your having taken time to respond to my talkback and, if you aren't convinced, time alone will tell.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article