Jewish Scene
Prisoner of Zion to head Jewish Agency
Itamar Eichner
Published: 19.04.09, 15:15
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
14 Talkbacks for this article
1. I read about Sharansky
Keren ,   Israel-SP   (04.19.09)
that he encourages goym to make alya.If that's true,he is not going to be good for the post since Israel should make long term plans about its immigrations and think about Israel with the sight of at least 200 years into the future. Wrong decisions and momentaneous decisions have been proven ,since the man is man,a big mistake. Israel cannot think with the same mentally of when it was galut.
2. #1 Instead of posting lies, post references is
(04.19.09)
3. OK, but no more utopian schemes from Mr. Sharansky.
Steve   (04.19.09)
Please, no more pie in the sky, utopian schemes from Mr. Sharanksy about "spreading democracy" throughout the Muslim-Arab world. Haven't we seen enough of this Utopian experiment? Everywhere Sharansky's experiment was tried, we got radical Muslim parties on the increase, Hamas, Hezbollah; Sharia law, repression, rockets, terror and violence. Enough already. Haven't George W. Bush, led by Natan Sharansky's democratic visions, done enough harm in the region?
4. Sharansky supports Muslim-terror state in Israel?
Steve   (04.19.09)
YNet wrote: "Politically Sharansky identifies himself as right-wing. He is willing to see the Palestinians form a state on parts of the West Bank and Gaza, on condition that this state upholds democracy, dismantles the terror groups and ceases the incitement against Israel..." This is meaningless We heard all this before during the Oslo accord years. The only thing the U.S. is seeking now are empty promises from these killers and not even that at this point. They don't even have to recognize Israel as a Jewish state according to the Obama administration! Sharansky claims he identifies with the right but clearly he is hard-core left. Why does Netanyahu place these leftists in positions of power? It only serves to weaken his government.
5. TO MR.SHARANSKY: ALLAH IS WITH YOU,BRING JEWS BACK TO ISRAEL
Mohammed ,   Mecca, Saudi Arabia   (04.19.09)
One truly important fact that is generally overlooked in the Muslim world is the Israeli contribution to Islam. Seventy percent (70%) of the prophets in Islam are all Israeli. All fourteen of the prophets that I have referenced at the bottom were either born in Israel, raised/lived in Israel or passed away in Israel. The Prophet Musa (Moses) was not born or raised in Israel nor did he ever step foot in Israel but he was born into a family of Israelites that were from the tribe of Levi (Levites). Prophet Musa (Moses) is also a descendant of the Prophet Yaqub (Jacob) and if you were to add him as an Israeli that would total the percentage of Israeli prophets in Islam to an astounding seventy-five percent (75%). Since the creation of the State of Israel, as Allah promised in surah 17 verse 104, the kuffar "Palestinians" have gone to all lengths to make sure that information on the Israeli contribution to Islam is not publicized anywhere in the Muslim world. If Muslims were aware that Allah promised the return of Jews to the land of Israel (as stated in the Quran) and that seventy percent of all prophets in Islam were Israeli, real Muslims from around the world would not wage a Jihad against the Israelis but they would wage a Jihad against the fake Muslim "Palestinians" or "The Phillistines". In the Quran, Allah is pro-Israel. The term Israel is a very holy name in the Quran. Creation of a "Palestinian" State on the Holy land of Israel is against the religion of Islam, against the Quran and against Allah. Israel is the second holiest country in Islam. The real Nakba (catastrophy) in Islam will begin once a "Palestinian" State is created. Thoughts of creating a kuffar country named “Palestine” within Holy Israel is a defect in one's mind and thinking. 1. Prophet Ibrahim (Abraham) - Israeli 2. Prophet Ishaq (Isaac) - Israeli 3. Prophet Yaqub (Jacob) - Israeli 4. Prophet Isa (Jesus) - Israeli 5. Prophet Yusef (Joseph) - Israeli 6. Prophet Dawud (King David) - Israeli 7. Prophet Lut (Lot) - Israeli 8. Prophet Haroon (Aaron) - Israeli 9. Prophet Sulayman (King Solomon) - Israeli 10. Prophet Yunus (Jonah) - Israeli 11. Prophet Al-Yasa (Elisha) - Israeli 12. Prophet Zakariya (Zechariah) - Israeli 13. Prophet Yahya ibn Zakariyya (John the Baptist) - Israeli 14. Prophet Ilyas (Elijah) – Israeli Prophet Musa (Moses) - born to family of Israelites
6. Sharansky is the men for the Job!
Jewish Refugee ,   U.S.A.   (04.19.09)
http://israelactnow.blogspot.com/
7. #2- I am not lying.I said that *I read*;I said that
Keren ,   Israel-SP   (04.19.09)
*if that's true...*.Don't you read well? But just clarifying for other readers:I read that Sharansky prevented passing an ammendment to the Law of Return which would limit immigration of non-Jews to Israel. That's it.I didn't check out the information.
8. 5...I sure hope that u clean the hard drive of ur computer
truth   (04.19.09)
often...
9. Sharansky - mistake.
True Zionist ,   Tel Aviv   (04.19.09)
His appointment is another indication of the radicalism of Israel. He was aided in his release by many progressive groups and then in his absorption process into Israel by journalists and writers who saw him as a symbol of morality and honesty. He betrayed most of those who supported him here, especially when he entered politics .He has proved himself to be a reflection of the malaise afflicting our society and of its loss of moral balance. Nowhere is this better understood than in the younger generation of American Jews for whom Israel is not a priority and for which Sharansky represents the same old same old. The Jewish Agency is an anachronism for which he may be very suitable. To make it of value he needs to address whether it has a relevance to both Israel and Diaspora. One way is to make it representative of all the Diaspora, and not just the wealthy. He will have to learn new tricks if he is to succeed in one crucial aspect of his new role - convincing this new American Jewish generation that not only is Israel worthy of their support but also worthy of their money.
10. And besides...
Keren ,   Israel-SPaND   (04.20.09)
Where are the religious who effectively put Netanyahu in the position he is? Wasn't this govt supposed to be more tending to Right and to Religious? Was all just a cheatery? I don't like Livni,but I would be mad as she is by this cheatery. Why Sharansky,a leftist,is being put in such a key post?Why not one of the ones from the elected parties who supported "bibi"? Why?? Cheatery is nasty,and no wonder so many don't like us. Truth should prevail and the will of the people of Israel should prevail. We are not idiots and this govt is treating us as idiots!
11. The right man for the right post
liliane ,   tel aviv   (04.20.09)
No one seems to be more appropriate for this job than Sharansky. He will bring integrety and faith in the fading institution of the Jewish Agency .
12. #11
Keren ,   Israel-SP   (04.20.09)
G'od forbid,I am not judging Sharansky since I know very little about him.I am driven by impressions,few readings and a fact.The fact is that when I visited Beit Hatefutzot for the last time , by the middle to the end of 2007, it was a museum literally falling apart,which is a sin considering the precious information that museum hosts. Thus,yours opinion that "He will bring integrety and faith in the fading institution of the Jewish Agency"is a very doubtfull one.
13. Sharansky
Worried ,   Israel   (04.24.09)
I know that Sharansky suffered for many years in prison for being a Zionist and wanting to make aliyah. On the other hand he seems willing to let non-Jewish Russians continue to make aliyah. I have read that the last several years, the vast majority of olim from the FSU are not Jewish. We do not need them here. Maybe Sharansky won't come out against this because his own brother's wife and kids are not Jewish. They made aliyah years ago and then left for America.Instead of wasting money on non-Jews, use it to help the Jews who already live here. We must keep this country Jewish.
14. Israel leads a kultur kamp against religious Jews 24/7
Al   (04.24.09)
The only bright spot in terms of real aliyah in the past 20 yrs has been Nefesh B Nefesh. Yet you try to resurect a dead horse namely the Jewsih Agency. Hmmm lets see who ran this agency in the past? Avrum the menivel Burg and the last limelight, MR Nothing. Get over it..The Jewish Agency is a mooch fest of worthless schnorrers. Adelson has lost fortnes in Las Vegas and so Sharansky who I demostrated for as a youth in Monteal during the 70's has found himself a jobele. Polease the Jewish Agency is worthless. Get rid of it.
Back to article