Opinion
Presidential demagoguery
B. Michael
Published: 15.05.09, 13:42
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
25 Talkbacks for this article
1. NO JEWS CAN LIVE WITHOUT DEMAGOGY ! ...
.THIS IS MY KNOW-HOW ,   Atilla Karagözoğlu   (05.15.09)
sorry I cant talk much ! I am not a demagog as you guys :)
3. #1 No. I think you're just retarded.
Etoile ,   Montreal, Canada   (05.15.09)
4. 'natural growth'
moron ,   galut   (05.15.09)
no excuse is needed for jews to live anywhere in the region--especially if arabs live in israel
5. this article
MC ,   UK   (05.15.09)
This article is total rubbish. Why is it given space on ynet? The land of Israel belongs to the Jewish people and they can settle anywhere they like in it!! Can we please have some sanity?!
6. i really enjoy reading B. Michael opinion
Avi ,   Herzilya   (05.15.09)
too bad his opinion hasnt been posted in the hebrew ynet in recent times. in many cases it looks like he is actually the boy from the famous story "the emperor new clothes".
7. Peres is right
s.c.   (05.15.09)
Peres is right. Should allow settlements to grow, especially humanitarian reasons. There are families who want to expand their home because of family growth. Negotiations with the Palestinians give up must be mutual. To this day, Palestinians did not gave up on anything, so stuck in the negotiations.
8. What Horse Manure !!!
Yisrael ,   Jeruslaem, Israel   (05.15.09)
Let's see, tearing down illegal Arab houses is a crime, because, after all, they only want to live near their families, but if Jews want the same thing, it's also a crime ! When you are are pro-Arab, you can do no wrong and make no sense, apparently.
9. Room for Jews is a problem in all of Palestine
dmgold ,   Pardes Channa Israel   (05.15.09)
B Michael doesnt want those nasty breeding Jews in the West Bank the Israeli Arabs dont want them next to Jaffo, they dont want them in the Negev nor in the Galil. Sorry B Michael, but according to your narrative and that of Israels Arabs, Jews should go back to where they came from. Oh I forgot the %50-60 % o0f Israeli jews who are descendant from Arab countries and Iran arent welcome back there. B Michael join your self hating jew freinds at J street and enjoy Obama's america because neither you nor your opinion is wanted here in Israel.
10. Property rights= human rights
Shlomo ,   LA   (05.15.09)
how can you tell one group of people they cannot own property somewhere, whether it is Israel, US, Canada, or any place in the world. Why don't we stick to this basic fact, it isn't about Judaism, or Arab, it is a basic human right that can not be taken away.
11. how stupid can you possibly be?
izzy ,   san francisco CA   (05.16.09)
There is no debut in my mind that you are writing out of hate to the settlers and the religious community. You say it says no were that children do have to live near the parents. But it was only 4 day ago that residents of "ramat aviv" Who had a problem with religious ppl moving in... Let me Guess, you would love to have X settlers as your next door neighbor right? So do all of us a big favor and keep your stupid comments to your self.
12. You are correct. You did waste your time writing this.
Bunnie Meyer ,   Los Angeles, CA USA   (05.16.09)
13. It is "a foolish excuse." No excuse is needed.
Len ,   NYC   (05.16.09)
Think of how much more room for "natural growth" we'll have when the Palestinians exercise their "right of return" to Jordan.
14. Hatred of religious a lame excuse for settlement destroction
Daniel ,   Formerly Israel   (05.16.09)
15. B. Michael is a righteous man, He is my personal Chist
Yaakov Sullivan ,   NYC   (05.16.09)
No doubt that B. Michael is my role model. I would definitely stop be at his eatery in Israel. I am sure his hummus is a world class.
16. Why is B. Michael's opinion piece
Robert Haymond ,   Ashdod + Edmonton   (05.16.09)
highlighted by YNet? Why do you use him at all? His opinion pieces are simplistic at best and the Israel bashing quality of current and past statements more clearly deserve publication in their natural outlet, Haaretz. I really wish YNet editors reconsider investing in this ignoramus.
17. #16 .Michael is not an intellectual but he
Yaakov Sullivan ,   NYC   (05.16.09)
is a very smart man and he owns his own business. His restaurant is located in TA and I was told he has a pretty good hummus there. Even Jesus was''t an intellectual. He was a simple man with simple wisdom. How intellectual is love your neighbor as yourself? B. Michael is a simple and beautiful man and I admire his ideas.
18. Cancer is also a natural growth!
Chanalau, Tova ,   London, UK   (05.16.09)
And may the settlers have as much as they deserve!
19. In all cities homes are built to allow for population growth
Esther ,   Netherlands   (05.16.09)
20. Sure - just do the same to the Israeli Arabs
Ralph Haglund ,   Lund, Sweden   (05.16.09)
Apply it to the Arab minority in Israel if you want to apply it to the Jewish minority (7-8%) in Judea/Samaria. Tell those Arabs that UN, EU, USA has decided that their children have to be deported in the name of piece.
21. # 17 Yaakov the gay: Jesus isn't G-d in Israel.
petra ,   uSA   (05.16.09)
you must have him confused in your catholic teachings. Is being gay okay w/ the vatican? Somehow when you post, it begins to smell. Jesus is not a favorite subject w/ the Jews and not w/ gays either. Silly boy/girl.
22. # 18 Chanalangadingdong Londonstan
petra ,   uSA   (05.16.09)
If population growth rates count, the muslims have everyone beat. They breed like rats and are not as clean, and they eat their own. Lovely publicity for anti muslims. Did you mean to be funny? laughed my ass off. Thanx pal.
23. anti-settler tripe!
tom ,   toronto, canada   (05.17.09)
for once shimon peres is actually trying not to harm israel, so now you complain? do jews really need a publicity campaign to justify living in their own homeland? do frenchmen or russians? are we going to equate arab terrorism with jewish settlement, and then condemn the "settlers'? this cuckoo-cloudland talk is more suited to the arab media than to a rational israeli newspaper.
24. #18 Actually, Chanalau, cancer is not a natural growth.
Roman ,   Lod, Israel   (05.17.09)
It's a mutation of a kind that the host body is incapable of handling, and thus ends up killing the host body. So it's a lot more like your unnatural hatred for all things Israeli and Jewish - only harmful, and eventually disastrous.
25. B. Michael, why don't you pack it in already
Debbie ,   Jerusalem   (05.17.09)
You know very well that the future of Israel is CHAREDI. Just do the math. Ten children to your leftist/atheist 1.5 children. Why don't you and your leftist pals leave now, before your neighborhood becomes a sea of black hats and coats?
26. It is interesting why - when peres brings up
Vardina   (05.17.09)
this argument to justify extension of jewish settlements it is considered a stupid excuse wherease the same argument stated by arabs to justify illegal construction has been accepted as natural. What is the conclusion?
Back to article